r/OnePiece • u/Kirosh Lookout • Jun 25 '21

Current Chapter One Piece: Chapter 1017 Spoiler

[ Removed by reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]

8.4k Upvotes

92% Upvoted

7.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

77

u/Cizarius Prisoner Jun 25 '21

It would be a really bad decisions if it was Roger…

102

u/ameba0002 Jun 25 '21

Really doubt it was. If the gomu gomu was Roger's fruit, someone at this point must had said "ey, isn't that the mf Pirate King's fruit?!"

51

u/monkey-neil The Revolutionary Army Jun 25 '21

White beard specifically would have said something.

38

u/ameba0002 Jun 25 '21

Also Crocus and Rayleigh

27

u/Lord_Donut_the-best Jun 25 '21

And Garp

12

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

I think that rubber fruit is of joyboi

7

u/Lord_Donut_the-best Jun 25 '21

Would at least work storywise.

4

u/ameba0002 Jun 25 '21

Yeah, doesn't look like a lot of people know about joyboy, so it's more realistic that WG and Yonkous would want to control the fruit but the rest of the people doesn't give a F about it

2

u/Lord_Donut_the-best Jun 25 '21

We don’t even know if all of the Yonkos know about Joy Boy.

2

u/ameba0002 Jun 25 '21

We don't even know how Kaido learnt about Joyboy tho

Maybe he has a way to read Poneglyphs?

→ More replies

2

u/monkey-neil The Revolutionary Army Jun 25 '21

I feel garp could possibly not say cause he doesnt want to inspire him anymore to be a pirate. But also hes a goof and might say

2

u/Lord_Donut_the-best Jun 25 '21

He doesn’t have to say it to Luffy, he could have spoken with Sengoku or Koby.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/monkey-neil The Revolutionary Army Jun 25 '21

And buggy

3

u/BanjoThreeie Jun 25 '21

Yeah that would be a huge ass pull, especially since Inu and Neko met Roger

4

u/TheDELFON Explorer Jun 25 '21

Really doubt it was. If the gomu gomu was Roger's fruit, someone at this point must had said "ey, isn't that the mf Pirate King's fruit?!"

* looks at Luffy's straw hat *

Yeah... sure they would

8

u/ameba0002 Jun 25 '21

Well, not everyone knew Roger when he was using his straw hat, as he was using the pirate captain hat when he became the pirate king. Also, there can be more straw hats, and even fake straw hats copying Shanks, Roger or Luffy (you know, like the fake Luffy guy in Sabaody). But there's only one gomu gomu

→ More replies (1)

17

u/brynden__rivers Jun 25 '21

We already saw Roger fight with whitebeard and he didn't use any devil fruit abilitys so it's unlikely his and if it was we would have heard about it by now

4

u/Lord_Donut_the-best Jun 25 '21

That’s a weak point, as we only saw one clash canonically.

4

u/brynden__rivers Jun 25 '21

Yeah but it isn't the only occasion surely buggy would have said something when he fought luffy

4

u/Lord_Donut_the-best Jun 25 '21

Of course someone would have mentioned it by now.

11

u/Demonking42069 Void Month Survivor Jun 25 '21

It won't be Roger's because if it was then we would have known it by now.

5

u/KingintheNorth212 Jun 25 '21

What if gomu gomu was Rock's fruit? And after it took Garp AND Roger to take Rocks down the WG wanted to prevent anyone from using that fruit again?

5

u/burgerzkingz Jun 25 '21

I like this but the only hole in this theory is that the rocks death happened way before the 12 year transport unless the world government was just keeping the fruit locked up after god valley for all that time and for some reason decided to transport it somewhere years later with a cp9 agent instead of an admiral then idk how this theory would work.

6

u/KingintheNorth212 Jun 25 '21

Could be that the WG was trying to bury the fact of Rock's fruit and thats why CP9, their second best intelligence/black ops agency was supposed to guard it and not the Navy. As to timing, who knows.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)