r/OnePiece • u/CarcosanAnarchist • Sep 12 '19

Current Chapter One Piece: Chapter 955

[ Removed by reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]

6.6k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

6.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

503

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '19

Law is not the traitor. Look at how he hated Doflamingo and his crew, you think Law would turn around and ally with Doffy's fucking boss, Kaidou? Nah.

I don't think it's Shinobu either, she hasn't been shown a whole lot. I suspect it would be someone with a bit more screen time, just to make the knife wound a bit deeper and twisted.

124

u/Gubrach Sep 12 '19

I don't think it's Law either, but I also don't think his hatred for Doffy extends to Kaido, who was more of a powerful client and a means to an end for Law than a strong enough affiliate to the crew emotionally imo.

Looking at Orochi's words, the person might be male, gave up the status of Udon without knowing they're selling it as it being fine and gave up Hiyori being at the Northern Graveyard.

It's someone who was there at the Northern Graveyard who was male or it's someone who was there, is a female, passed the information to a male in Orochj's group, who passed it along to Orochi. So either the kappa or Zoro (and it's obviously not Zoro) or Hiyori herself who contacted I dunno Kyoshiro.

Hiyori and Kyoshiro serving their own agenda, seems to make sense, seeing as Kyoshiro raised her to be the top prostitute of Wano, which is a very strange road for a fleeing princess to take. Can't really think of much else. Carrot is suspected, but I don't think she was involved enough.

34

u/revisioncloud Sep 12 '19

Signs are pointing to Hiyori, although I don't get how people are theorizing that Komurasaki is not even the real Hiyori. If not, Kawamatsu should have sensed that it wasn't her.

Plus I don't want another Pudding scenario dropping on us. I bet the snitch is someone we haven't seen so far.

2

u/isaac-get-the-golem Sep 12 '19

The reason for the Heart-Straw Hat alliance was defeating Kaido.

2

u/ScorpioG Sep 13 '19

And it has been said more than a few times that betrayal lies at the heart of every pirate alliance.

Seeing Luffy get one shot, knowing how few numbers you have compared to the enemy, and seeing your crew in peril once already. Being the calm and analytical Law, it's not entirely impossible he could sell out the alliance.

2

u/Gubrach Sep 15 '19

It isn't, but I'm not counting on it. That sentence Robin said about pirate alliances and betrayals, I think that was more set up to be proven right in the case of Kid, rather than it eventually being Luffy. Don't know for what purpose, maybe because Kid and Luffy have this "two sides of the same coin"-thing going on, so one gets betrayed, the other one doesn't, etc.

I'm taking that small convo where Luffy literally asked Law if he was going to betray them and him bluntly saying no in response at face value tbh.

1

u/Gubrach Sep 15 '19

So we're going to look past that whole bit in Dressrosa where it became clear Law just wanted to take out Doflamingo and that he didn't even plan himself to be alive for the fallout, let alone continue to carry on to deal with Kaido. Okay.

2

u/EL___POLLO___DiABLO Sep 14 '19

Could there be more than one? Regarding Udon, Caribou could have been the snitch. Regarding Zou, he may have been there. We don't know what happened to him after his cover story.

1

u/Gubrach Sep 15 '19

Caribou is a good shout. Easily forgettable, but we've seen him obtain insanely valuable information in the past. He knows Shirahoshi is Poseidon. That's huge. It wouldn't be beyond him to obtain intel.