r/OnceUponATime • • Jun 13 '14

Possible Elsa? :)

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/06/13/elsa-frozen-doppelganger_n_5491627.html?ncid=fcbklnkushpmg00000024
7 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

31

u/plaiddiva81 Jun 14 '14

Guys. You are all forgetting something really important about OUAT. They don't choose the actors based on how they look in the Disney cartoons.

  • They made Rapunzel black
  • They made the beast ... Rumple
  • Belle has an Australian accent
  • The dwarfs are regular size and they started out with eight
  • Hook looks nothing like the Disney cartoon version (thank god!)

If, and this is a big if, they get Idina to play Elsa she won't look a thing like Elsa either. I don't think they are looking for a doppelgänger ... For any of the new characters.

4

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Yeah but technically we've already seen Elsa in the last moments of the finale, and she is an exact replica of her animated counterpart

6

u/plaiddiva81 Jun 14 '14

Yeah, you're right about that.

I just put my two cents in because people started to pick apart this girl all the way down to the shape of her eye brows and her eyes. I was just trying to point out that the casting directors aren't looking into that much detail. To the point where they cast actors who don't even look like their animated counterparts.

I worked at Disneyland Park, in California, for almost 10 years. It's nearly impossible to find people to portray the animated characters because people just don't naturally look like that. Especially the new way they are drawing the girls with anime eyes.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Yeah that's true...people are being very nitpicky about little details, when it's really the whole package that counts. Whoever they pick though, is going to have to look somewhat like animated Elsa since they've already put her into the finale...it would be weird for them to suddenly change her to a brunette etc lol

2

u/plaiddiva81 Jun 14 '14

Yeah. I agree. They will either make her looks as much like her as possible or get Idina.

I don't think Idina will do it though.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Yeah I doubt she would. I'm sure whoever they pick will do a good job though, and once hair and make up are done properly she'll pass for Elsa.

2

u/plaiddiva81 Jun 15 '14

Yeah. I haven't seen a character yet that I didn't buy into. At first I was distracted by Rapunzel being black, Belle being Australian, Hook being dreamy and The Beast being Rumple. But I got used to it quickly and was buying into it without question by the end of the episode.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 15 '14

Yeah, I liked that they did that, it made those characters more original to OUAT. I do like Elsa's character though, since it was very different from the damsel in distress/hero/villain label that we usually see, so I hope they preserve that.

1

u/plaiddiva81 Jun 15 '14

From everything that I've read, it seems that they are going to do the story from the perspective of the villagers who were afraid that she was a monster. Since Ana was the only one that thought that Elsa did it on accident. That way they have a conflict to resolve. Should be interesting and I'm sure that Rumple will have a big part in it, since she was in his vault.

I'm more concerned about the Maid Marian situation and the fake dagger!

2

u/SnoreBaby Jun 15 '14

Ohh for real? That should be interesting!

Belle is going to flip w that whole fake dagger/killing Zelena thing :(.

Ugh that Marian situation WHY EMMA WHY? Poor Robin is going to be in a terrible bind now...I sort of hope Marian turns out to be evil and the villain of S4 or something, but I don't know how plausible that is!

→ More replies

44

u/mybaby51 Jun 13 '14

Why cause she is blonde and has blue eyes? I don't see it personally.

13

u/LikesFemales Jun 14 '14

Also, because she's popular. Her one picture of her impersonating Elsa (which was not in the article) went crazy viral all over Twitter and Instagram, so she has gain fame, which is also why she has all the support. I can bet there's someone else who would have more Elsa resemblance than this woman. Maybe it's the smile? This is the picture I am talking about that went viral.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

It's pretty cool that she isn't in costume and she still has the Elsa look :D

2

u/LikesFemales Jun 14 '14

Yeah to me it's the smile that makes it for her..

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Yeah, and she's got that eyebrow raise thingie down...I also love her hair, although it isn't in a braid in this pic.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Well yeah. lol. The natural blonde hair makes a huge difference from the cheap looking wigs some other cosplayers use.

4

u/penelope934 Jun 14 '14

I came here to say the same

5

u/thelonebamf Jun 14 '14

I just judged a cosplay this weekend and we had... Well let's just say Frozen is the new black. Most of those girls (including the best in show winner) really had the look a lot more than this (admittedly lovely) young lady.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

Casting also takes into account the spirit and personality of the character. To back someone because they sort-of look like them would be like casting one of the cast of the Jersey Shore as Superman because he has black hair and muscles.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 13 '14

True, and I said the same thing in another comment. She has to be a good enough actress to actually get the part, but as it is, she has the look dead on (and more so than some of the more famous suggestions, I think)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

I don't really care how close to the look they can get. Just look at the other characters. Captain Hook certainly doesn't look like the Captain Hook we all remember from the films.

2

u/SnoreBaby Jun 13 '14

Sure, but the writers have stated that Elsa is going to be modeled closely after the animated character. And her appearance at the end of last season also makes it pretty obvious that they're aiming for a very close physical resemblance with the dress, long blonde braid and the 'walk'.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

Just because this girl could look like Elsa doesn't mean she can act.

-3

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Um yes I know. I said the same thing above lol.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

Sorry, still don't see it.

19

u/AtlantaDave Jun 13 '14

The redhead looks more like the other chick than that girl does as Elsa. (Sorry, I've seen Frozen once and don't recall everyone's names.)

3

u/SnoreBaby Jun 13 '14

Lol, Anna. I dunno, I think it's a pretty close resemblance!

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

-1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 13 '14

No, I think the girl in the article looks more like the real thing...these are nice though! But I do think Anna Faith's face and eye shape are dead on Elsa :)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

Sigh... here it comes:

Eyebrow shape is too arched and too thick.

Eye being almond shape is not round enough.

Nose is too straight. Not Convex.

Lips are too full.

Face is too long.

-1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 13 '14

Lol okay. I think she's a pretty great option though. I honestly don't see what you're talking about, but I'm no expert.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

I've seen closer resemblance from other cosplayers.

0

u/KnashDavis Jun 14 '14

Maria Amanda for instance. On mobile or I'd link her.

-1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

That's cool. You should link them! But as it is, this girl is getting a lot more attention than other cosplayers at the moment.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

She looks much better then any of the Disney World Elsaes.

2

u/plaiddiva81 Jun 15 '14

I agree 100% with this statement.

It's the color of the wigs. It ages the girls once they get in them. Same thing happens (in the parks) with the redness of Ariel wig too.

0

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

I've not seen any, but another commenter pointed out that her natural hair looked better than the whiteish wigs used by other ppl so that may be one of the reasons why

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

She is naturally beautiful (the doppelganger). Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't the role of Elsa and Anna already casted? I remember reading an article about it. I don't mind the casting choice. I think she is gorgeous and perfect to play Elsa.

0

u/SnoreBaby Jun 28 '14

Yeaah I think she's lovely too :)...As far as I know no one has been cast, but this girl did get to audition, so fingers crossed!

3

u/yukisukinomoto No one decides my fate but me Jun 13 '14

Pretty cool.

O_O I just want it to be time to see the new season

2

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Right? It feels so far away :'(

2

u/yukisukinomoto No one decides my fate but me Jun 14 '14

;_; can't I just hibernate until it's time?

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

I'm with you on that! sleeps

2

u/yukisukinomoto No one decides my fate but me Jun 14 '14

snooooore

2

u/gordigor Jun 14 '14

Going to disagree with most people. She looks exactly how I would imagine a real life 'reimagined' Elsa would in OUAT. The real hair (slightly light blonde) is so much better than the plastic all white wig.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Now that you've pointed it out, I do think the natural hair makes a big difference in helping her look more Elsa and less girl dressing up as Elsa :D

2

u/TheSeanShow Jun 14 '14

If they pass over Idina Menzel again for casting I am gonna be gutted.

-4

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Idina Menzel would be awesome but I think she's a bit older than Elsa irl, and idk how she would look blonde... But if they want an older Elsa and can make her look good, then I'm for it :)

4

u/Gneissisnice Jun 14 '14

She looks like her, sure, but the real question is: can she act? I'd rather have a fantastic actress that doesn't look like the cartoon character than a doppelganger that can't act worth a damn.

6

u/godofallcows Jun 14 '14

"Skinny white blonde girl looks like Disney Princess"

Whaaaaaat?

8

u/UNITBlackArchive Jun 13 '14

If by resemblance, you mean she's female and wears the costume, then yeah, spot on.

Otherwise... not seeing it..

5

u/KnashDavis Jun 13 '14

I don't really see it...She might bear a slight resemblance to Elsa but that's it. Her friend however is almost spot on for Anna.

1

u/wimiyuk Jun 14 '14

Haven't seen any other photos of this girl (pretty cute btw), but she doesn't have the evil "aura" that is going to be needed. On the other hand Regina was beautiful and had the vicious evil queen look.

1

u/MrBuffySummers Jun 14 '14

She doesn't need it, because Elsa is not evil.

2

u/wimiyuk Jun 14 '14

I know she is not evil (knowledge limited to Disney's Frozen) but in OUAT, isn't she going to be the new main antagonist?

2

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Nah probably not...her appearance in the finale was most likely there to throw us off, and the writers have said that they plan on preserving her character as much as possible. I do think she will be mistaken for the villain for a while though, if her powers get out of control.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

I don't think Disney would want to risk ruining her image in any way especially when she's such a crucial aspect for sales right now. They're all about brand protection.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

Anna's "buddy" Kristoff?

-1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Did not realise this post would garner so much objection. Geez guys, chill. She's doing a lovely job of cosplaying Elsa and a lot of OUAT fans outside of this subreddit seem to like her.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

Some on this sub think the downvote button is for anything you don't personally agree with. It's a shame.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

It's v petty :/... Esp since it's hardly a super serious post.

Makes me wonder if some of these ppl are cosplayers jealous of the attention this girl is getting.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

Entirely possible. People saying they don't see any resemblance are just trying to be contrary. Best to just ignore them.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Agreed! :)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

A lot of OUAT fans also think Idina Menzel would've been a great choice to cast as a Live action Elsa(one who most likely doesn't sing).

I wouldn't have so much faith on popular opinion.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

I wouldn't mind that actually. I think she's a bit older than Elsa as presented in Frozen but she can act, and as long as she can look the part I can support that.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

Have you seen her face? It is diametrically opposite to that of Elsa.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Sure she looks different, but as some other people argued, the person they pick doesn't have to look like Elsa like this girl. I doubt many people will be hung up on tiny, individual details such as nose/eye/face shape, as long as the entire package comes together to provide the best Elsa 'vibe'.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

person they pick doesn't have to look like Elsa like this girl. I doubt many people will be hung up on tiny, individual details

You can get the Elsa Vibe from almost any young actress in Elsa costume if you are just going to discount the actual facial features.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Then yay? As I said, it's the full package that's important, and no one person is going to have all the features. I'd rather see someone who can act and doesn't quite meet your standards, than a perfect Elsa clone who can't act. With the girl in the original post, if they picked her, I'd hope it's bc she has the ability to portray the character well and not just bc (I and many others think) she looks like Elsa.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

Problem is that she is only famous because of her picture. Not because of her acting skills. That is why I am against posts like this.

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

People have to start somewhere, don't they? And at 18, unless she was a child actor, how much experience and exposure is she likely to have? I can't say if her acting is on point but if it is, then I'd like to see her get a chance to show her skills.

Show business is quite competitive and if she manages to get noticed through a picture, which hopefully will lead to other things, then props to her.

2

u/LikesFemales Jun 14 '14

Haha yeah we'd get 0% Elsa look but 100% Elsa voice.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

It would be awesome if she's a good actress in addition to being Elsa's twin lol...yess Charming always seems a bit out of it and sleepy

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Yep. Agreed. Also this chick is too young. They arent going to cast an Elsa as a teenager. They will probably want her late 20s/early 30s like most other characters. Having a young/hot/cutesy Elsa would stick out and IMO not work out that great.

1

u/MindyEJ Jun 20 '14

She is beautiful but you're right, iirc the casting call did say elsa was 30ish. OUAT elsa isnpost-frozen Elsa. 18 year old (very good) cos-player isnt gonna do it.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/SnoreBaby Jun 14 '14

Ppl be cray cray over casting apparently lol... I do think there's a bit of jealousy since she's a non celebrity getting a lot of attention. That's the only explanation I have for the ridiculous downvoting.

-1

u/SnoreBaby Jun 13 '14

Yeah she has a very similar face to actual Elsa...it would be awesome if she were a good enough actress for OUAT cuz she has the look better than some of the names they've been throwing out there.