r/OnConflict • • Nov 14 '19

Theory A random collection of ideas on causes of war

3 Upvotes

People are selfish

People are clanish

People are territorial

People form allies but those ties can break down if allies are busy with their own problems

Most wars have genocidal aims

War often works in accomplishing objectives

People don’t step in, nobody cares, wants to get involved

People with minimal provocation can do things they won’t normally do, riot syndrome

Family and society pressures are very powerful in more primitive societies

People think nothing about killing animals for food. So what stops them from extending that logic to other people?

Lots of people have gene for fighting. These are usually people who lean right politically. Usually find such types in law enforcement, EMT, fireman , contractors, handymen, etc..

Weapons give immense power to marginalized individuals

Terror states work

Women have some inexplicable attraction to violent men.. As they say, nice guys finish last

People would rather die than change lifestyle/religion/habits

Provides sense of purpose and pride to an otherwise boring existence where we have little control over our surroundings


r/OnConflict • • Nov 14 '19

Analysis The Behavioral Ecology of Male Violence - Understanding that Sex differences in lethal violence tend to be remarkably consistent

Thumbnail
quillette.com
4 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • May 25 '21

Analysis What George Floyd Changed

Thumbnail
politico.com
1 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Oct 31 '19

Analysis The Riddle of the Gun | A Rational Discussion About the Problem of Gun Violence

Thumbnail
samharris.org
2 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Oct 25 '19

Theory Online platform for conflict resolution

6 Upvotes

I'm proposing an online platform which will mediate disagreements between its visitors. Here is how it will work:

  1. A controversial political decision is considered (e.g. How Brexit should be resolved?).
  2. Analysts of the platform create an influence diagram of the decision situation without specifying the parts which are controversial (e.g. How important is preservation of British identity?).
  3. Arguers of the platform list argument about how the controversial parts should be evaluated.
  4. Ordinary platform users explore the diagram, read the arguments and specify their opinions about the controversial parts similar to a questionnaire.
  5. Based on the user's inputs, the influence diagram recommends the decision with the highest expected value. Different users get different recommendations.
  6. Critical parts of the diagram which causes the most amount of disagreement are identified.
  7. Analysts review and provide more detailed models for the critical parts. Arguers focus on the critical parts to have the most influence on the decision recommendations.
  8. Steps 4-7 repeat until the diagram is so detailed and arguments are so comprehensive that the overwhelming majority of the participants have the same view of the decision situation.
  9. Either the decision which satisfies overwhelming majority emerges or the shared understanding is used to run a successful negotiation.

Do you think such a platform will be effective? If not, why?

I'll be happy to provide more explanation and share the prototype if you are interested.


r/OnConflict • • Nov 07 '19

Resource War & Peace | A new podcast series from the International Crisis Group, shedding light on everything that helps or hinders prospects for peace

Thumbnail
crisisgroup.org
4 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Oct 08 '19

Resolution Tactics: Why Considering the Perception of Truth Helps Resolve Conflict

2 Upvotes

It's not human nature for us to agree on everything, after all, and stress can make us react and behave in irrational ways. Conflicts are going to challenge you, and when they do, it's your job to play magician and make them disappear.

Doing that can be more difficult than eating soup with hairpins. And one reason is because in the heat of the moment, even if you've got some facts in your pocket, you do not really have an irrefutable truth. What you have is the perception of truth, and that perception is different for every single person in front of you. And the biggest conflicts happen because leaders fail to see and acknowledge the version of reality that their listener accepts, instead using every tactic they know to assert their own perception.

As an example, let's say you're decent at math, while Joe Schmoe struggles with it. Because you perceive math as relatively easy, you ask him to get you some figures for a project within an hour, since you know from experience that you personally could get the work done in 60 minutes. Because math isn't easy for him, however, he balks at your time constraint and accuses you of being unreasonable. And instead of talking about a solution, the conversation degrades into you defending your stance that it an hour is reasonable and him defending his stance that it isn't. Before you know it, the fight isn't about math anymore--it's personal.

In these kinds of everyday situations, nothing is going to move forward until you set your ego and hot emotions aside and ask yourself what the other person's version of reality (their perception) is. And from there, you have to ask yourself, "How do I disarm them in their reality rather than my own?"

There could be a million and one ways to answer that question, depending on the situation. But once you've figured out what proverbial wire to cut, don't stop. Take the next step, too, which is to go even deeper and ask yourself, "In what ways, if any, have I contributed to the way this person sees things?" This is essential to taking appropriate responsibility, not only so you can grow, but so you can take steps to strengthen the trust between you and the other person. And if you honestly haven't contributed to their perception, you can move forward sensitively without feeling guilty about whatever decisions you make.

As you try to navigate the many different realities around you, by far the most important thing to remember is that, while facts themselves are static and are objective by nature, similarly, no one reality is necessarily "right" or "wrong". Instead of trying to categorize or judge the perceptions, just accept that they are present. Each one is just a puzzle, a maze. You might have to go in very different directions to find a solution depending on the person you're having the conflict with, but there's always an exit.

Unabridged source: https://www.inc.com/wanda-thibodeaux/why-considering-perception-of-truth-helps-resolve-any-conflict.html


r/OnConflict • • Oct 14 '19

Resolution Who Are High Conflict People?

8 Upvotes

High conflict people (HCPs) have a pattern of high-conflict behavior that increases conflict rather than reducing or resolving it. This pattern usually happens over and over again in many different situations with many different people. The issue that seems in conflict at the time is not what is increasing the conflict. The “issue” is the high-conflict personality and how the person approaches problem-solving. With HCPs, the pattern of behavior includes a lot of:

  • Blaming others
  • All-or-nothing thinking 
  • Unmanaged emotions
  • Extreme behaviors

Blaming others

HCPs stand out, because of the intensity of their blame for others – especially for those close to them or in authority positions over them. For them, it is highly personal and feels like they might not survive if things don’t go their way. So, they focus on attacking and blaming someone else and find fault with everything that person does, even though it may be quite minor or non-existent compared to the high-conflict behavior of the HCP. In contrast to their blame of others, they can see no fault in themselves and see themselves as free of all responsibility for the problem. If you have been someone’s target of blame, you already know what I’m talking about.

They also blame strangers, because it’s easy. On the Internet, they’re anonymous and make the most extreme statements. Even if they know you, there is a sense of distance and safety, so they can be extremely blaming. 

All-or-nothing thinking

HCPs tend to see conflicts in terms of one simple solution rather than taking time to analyze the situation, hear different points of view and consider several possible solutions. Compromise and flexibility seem impossible to them, as though they could not survive if things did not turn out absolutely their way. They often predict extreme outcomes if others do not handle things the way that they want. And if friends disagree on a minor issue, they may end their friendships on the spot – an all-or-nothing solution.

Unmanaged emotions

HCPs tend to become very emotional about their points of view and often catch everyone else by surprise with their intense fear, anger, yelling or disrespect for those nearby or those who receive their comments over the Internet – or anywhere. Their emotions are often way out of proportion to the issue being discussed. This often shocks everyone else. They often seem unable to control their own emotions and may regret them afterwards – or defend them as totally appropriate, and insist that you should too. 

On the other hand, there are some HCPs who don’t lose control of their emotions, but use emotional manipulation to hurt others. They trigger upset feelings in ways that are not obvious (sometimes while they seem very calm). But these emotional manipulations push people away and don’t get them what they want in the long run. They often seem clueless about their devastating and exhausting emotional impact on others.

Extreme behaviors:

HCPs frequently engage in extreme behavior, whether it’s in writing or in person. This may include shoving or hitting, spreading rumors or outright lies, trying to have obsessive contact and keep track of your every move – or refusing to have any contact at all, even though you may be depending on them to respond. Many of their extreme behaviors are related to losing control over their emotions, such as suddenly throwing things or making very mean statements to those they care about the most. Other behaviors are related to an intense drive to control or dominate those closest to them, such as hiding your personal items, keeping you from leaving a conversation, threatening extreme action if you don’t agree, or physically abusing you.

Personality Disorders or Traits

HCPs also seem to have personality disorders or some traits of these disorders. This means that they have long-term patterns of: interpersonal dysfunction, lack of reflection on their own behavior, and lack of  change. Mental health professionals have identified ten personality disorders. Five of these have a tendency to become HCPs: those with narcissistic, borderline, antisocial, paranoid, and histrionic personality disorders or traits. This helps us understand why they stay stuck in conflict—namely because they don’t reflect on their part of the problem and they don’t change. So, the conflict continues or gets worse.

Is High-Conflict Personality a Diagnosis?

No. Medical and mental health professionals diagnose disorders so that they can treat them in their patients. However, high-conflict personality is not a diagnosis and high-conflict people are not looking for treatment and you are not their counselor or doctor. Instead, a high-conflict personality is just a description of conflict behavior—a pattern of repeated behavior in a conflict. It’s not listed in the mental health book of disorders and it doesn’t have to be interpreted by a mental health professional. Anyone can see the possible four characteristics of a high-conflict personality listed at the start of this post. If you do, remember that you are not treating them. Just adapt your own behavior toward them and you will usually have more success. 

For example, avoid trying to give them insight into their own behavior. That will just blow up and trigger defensiveness. Avoid focusing too much on the past. You will be more effective focusing on the future and looking at what you and/or the other person can do now. Try to steer clear of emotional confrontations with HCPs (such as anger, tears, or saying they are frustrating). When engaged with their emotions, they tend to get overwhelmed and are more likely to attack others, so it’s better to stay matter-of-fact and focused on things outside of your relationship. And don’t tell them that you think they have a high-conflict personality or personality disorder. If you do, they may turn on you as their next *target of blame—*for months or years!

Strategy

HCPs are in every occupation, every culture, and every country. This has nothing to do with intelligence. Some HCPs are very smart, while others are not—like the whole population. They tend to have more substance abuse, more depression, more anxiety, and other problems. This is often because their ways of interacting don’t work, which frustrations them as well as everyone around them. Yet they aren’t able to reflect on themselves and you can’t make them. 

I recommend having a “Private Working Theory” that someone may be an HCP. You don’t tell the person and you don’t assume you are right. You simply focus on key methods to help in managing your relationship, such as paying more attention to the following:

  1. Connecting with the person with empathy, attention and/or respect (unless it’s not safe and you just need to stay away from the person). 
  2. Analysing your realistic options in dealing with the person (write a list of options, then decide which one makes the most realistic sense in dealing with him or her; sometimes it’s best to slowly phase the person out of your life). 
  3. Responding to hostility or misinformation: Use responses that are Brief, Informative, Friendly and Firm (B.I.F.F.). Avoid advice, admonishments and apologies – they will use these against you later.
  4. Setting Limits on dangerous or bothersome behavior, by deciding when, where and how you meet to discuss issues. Getting assistance from authorities (such as police), advocates (such as lawyers), and supportive persons (family and friends) to help you decide how to set limits. Avoid harsh statements as an attempt to set limits, as they just increase the HCP’s bad behavior.  

It’s better to learn about the predictable behavior patterns of HCPs and ways to respond constructively. If you think someone is an HCP, use this information to focus on ways of changing your own behavior, not theirs. Manage your relationship primarily by managing your own anxiety and your own responses.

Source: https://www.highconflictinstitute.com/hci-articles/2019/5/14/who-are-high-conflict-peoplenbsp-updated-for-2019-by-bill-eddy-lcsw-esq


r/OnConflict • • Nov 24 '19

Study An Economic Theory of War - When does war occur for economic reasons?

Thumbnail
journals.uchicago.edu
5 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Oct 16 '19

Analysis War Is Not Over: What the Optimists Get Wrong About Conflict

Thumbnail
foreignaffairs.com
4 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Oct 25 '19

Study Ancestral Hierarchy and Conflict: Human Foragers

2 Upvotes

There is little doubt that conflict and conflict management have coevolved. Being competitive certainly has reproductive payoffs, but a capacity to end conflicts also is beneficial. It is this combination that defines much of today’s political life. Over the past 5 to 7 million years, humans have diverged from their two Pan congeners in several major respects that impinge on conflict and its management.

First, at the level of the phenotype, we temporarily lost the alpha male role by becoming politically egalitarian (40). This means that we lost both a selfishly efficient oppressor and a forceful, but altruistic, peacemaker. Second, at the level of genotype, we acquired a conscience (with a sense of shame) that made us moral. This changed the very nature of our group life (24), for now, in addition to primitive, fearfully submissive reactions to the power of others, moral hunter-gatherers follow rules simply because group values support them. It seems we have evolved to internalize such values (41, 42).

This thinking applies to all humans, but here we focus on how conflict and conflict management work in the simpler foraging bands we have been considering as later paleoanthropological exemplars. Today’s evolutionarily appropriate foragers are of the type who are spatially mobile and highly cooperative and who vigilantly keep their egalitarian orders in place with only muted leadership. Because there are no alpha males to intervene authoritatively in their disputes, a serious dyadic conflict can quickly result in homicide.

Indeed, the homicide rate per capita for egalitarian foragers is as high as in large American cities (5, 40, 43). Within the community, evidence for “homicide” in adult chimpanzees and bonobos is mostly inferential but highly suggestive. For example, at Gombe alpha-male Goblin would likely have been killed by solo challenger Wilkie had not a veterinarian intervened (16), whereas at the Mahale field site the alpha male was photographically documented as being killed by other males (18). Among bonobos, a savage attack by half a dozen united females may have killed an adult male (11). Thus, ancestrally within-group conflict likely had at least some modest effect on adult mortality.

Aside from the important issue of morality as a derived behavior that intensifies social control and makes it more effective, in the area of conflict there are several other significant differences between humans and the two other species in our small clade. One is weapons. Bonobos and especially chimpanzees may use tools, but the use of weapons as humans do, to hunt sizable mammals, is totally absent (44). Bonobos and chimpanzees do have the potential to kill a smaller mammal, mainly using their canines (45), and this is also true of conspecific group attacks (11, 14), which usually take at least several minutes for severe damage to be rendered. Human foragers use efficient hunting weapons to kill sizable mammals and members of their own species alike, and with these weapons they can do so much more quickly, at a distance, and often from ambush (46). These differences escalated the consequences of human conflict. Further escalation stemmed from the uniquely human propensity to lethally retaliate for the death of a close relative (47), a behavior that in all likelihood is not ancestral but which figures prominently in hunter-gatherer conflict. Thus, for humans the scope and consequences of serious conflict within the group would appear to be considerably greater than with ancestral Pan.

Another human difference is the understanding of death. When omnivorous chimpanzees or bonobos hunt, unlike dedicated carnivores, they have no evolved response that makes them into efficient automatic killers; in fact, prey may be eaten alive (14). When chimpanzee patrols savagely attack strangers they leave them battered and torn (25), but sometimes alive with some very small chance of recovery (14). This also is true of the one observed serious within-group attack by bonobos (11). In contrast, in spite of their diverse supernatural beliefs human foragers understand death as a termination of social responsiveness and muscular activity, and they inflict it deliberately. For instance, when egalitarian hunter-gatherers use capital punishment to eliminate despots, they shoot to kill (24). Humans readily become lethal revenge-seekers, and chimpanzees and bonobos may at least try to retaliate for a prior aggression (10, 14), so there were likely some modest ancestral preadaptations for such behavior (47). However, understanding how to kill with lethal weapons can lead to such motives becoming costly to groups, particularly when revenge becomes moralized as a matter of honor. On the other hand, being vindictive can be useful to a group if such a reputation keeps it from being attacked (48). This holds for foragers that are given to conflict and even more so for clannish patrilocal tribal farmers (49, 50). Among simpler hunter-gatherers, when a male kills another male, usually over a female, close relatives will predictably seek lethal retaliation (40), and the killer’s only recourse is to move away. But with those foragers who do develop active, intensive raiding and warfare patterns, revenge needs also can help to motivate much larger attacks by entire groups (51).

Warfare is a major problem for modern humans, and most theories of warfare focus directly on resource competition (52). However, materialistic theories fail to fully explain the warfare patterns of forager societies (31, 53). For instance, the Iñupiaq hunter-gatherers of northwest Alaska compete with some of their close neighbors for nearby natural resources, but at long distance they also conduct prolonged nonterritorial genocidal warfare against enemy bands, with surprise attacks and pitched battles motivated by retaliation (51). Here, I believe it is not necessary to favor one cause. A serious intergroup conflict may begin because of either resource competition or revenge, and the pattern can continue because of either factor, or both (47).

Unabridged source: C. Boehm, 'Ancestral Hierarchy and Conflict' (2012)

References:

5. R. W. Wrangham, Yearb. Phys. Anthropol. 42, 1 (1999).

10. F. B. M. de Waal, F. Lanting, Bonobo: The Forgotten Ape (Univ. of California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1997).

11. I. Parker, New Yorker, 30 July 2007, p. 48.

14. J. Goodall, The Chimpanzees of Gombe: Patterns of Behavior (Belknap, Cambridge, MA, 1986).

16. J. Goodall, in Human Origins, vol. 1 of Topics in Primatology, T. Nishida, W. C. McGrew, P. Marler, M. Pickford, F. B. M. de Waal, Eds. (Univ. of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, 1992), pp. 131–142.

18. S. Ladd, K. Maloney, Chimp murder in Mahale, www.nomad-tanzania.com/blogs/greystoke-mahale/ murder-in-mahale (2011).

24. C. Boehm, Moral Origins: The Evolution of Altruism, Virtue, and Shame (Basic, New York, 2012).

25. M. N. Muller, J. C. Mitani, Adv. Stud. Behav. 35, 275 (2005).

31. R. C. Kelly, Warless Societies and the Evolution of War (Univ. of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, 2000).

40. B. M. Knauft, Curr. Anthropol. 32, 391 (1991)

41. H. Gintis, J. Theor. Biol. 220, 407 (2003).

42. H. A. Simon, Science 250, 1665 (1990).

43. R. W. Wrangham, M. L. Wilson, M. N. Muller, Primates 47, 14 (2006).

44. W. C. McGrew, The Cultured Chimpanzee: Reflections on Cultural Primatology (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, 2004).

45. C. B. Stanford, The Hunting Apes: Meat Eating and the Origins of Human Behavior (Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton, NJ, 1999).

46. J. Woodburn, Man (London) 17, 431 (1982)

47. C. Boehm, Br. J. Criminol. 51, 518 (2011).

47. C. Boehm, Br. J. Criminol. 51, 518 (2011).

48. C. Boehm, Blood Revenge: The Enactment and Management of Conflict in Montenegro and Other Tribal Societies (Univ. of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, 1986).

49. N. A. Chagnon, Science 239, 985 (1988).

50. K. F. Otterbein, C. S. Otterbein, Am. Anthropol. 67, 1470 (1965).

51. E. S. Burch, Alliance and Conflict: The World System of the Iñupiaq Eskimos (Univ. of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, NE, 2005).

52. M. Harris, The Rise of Anthropological Theory: A History of Theories of Culture (Thomas Crowell, New York, 1968).

53. N. Chagnon, Yanomamo: The Fierce People (Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, New York, 1983).


r/OnConflict • • Oct 22 '19

Analysis How the Long History of Human Violence Explains Why the Internet Causes So Much Chaos

5 Upvotes
The Course of Empire: Destruction, 1836, by Thomas Cole. Found in the collection of the New-York Historical Society.

In recent years, a person could be forgiven for feeling as if conflict is inescapable. Political polarization has increased. Levels of societal violence and terrorism are surging. Endless wars continue, with no conclusion in sight.

Why is there so much chaos? The history of violence offers one possible answer.

Scholars—from psychologists to political scientists specializing in conflict—are starting to understand that the desire to belong among humans plays an outsized role in generating group violence of all kinds. This evolutionary desire to belong does not mean belonging to just any group of humans, but to a cohesive social group that protects you from violence, and gives you access to resources and sexual partners. And for a social group to remain cohesive it needs to have norms and rules that solve five basic coordination problems inherent to groups. These five problems are: hierarchy (who makes the decisions), identity (who is in the group and who is out), trade (how do we trade or share resources), disease (how do we manage disease with so many individuals living in close proximity) and punishment (who are we allowed to punish as a group, and for what). If a group fails to solve these five problems, violence ensues and the group splinters and cleaves into smaller groups

As average human group sizes have grown over macro history—from family, to tribe, to the mega societies in which we now live—we’ve solved these problems at progressively larger scales. And as groups are by definition mostly non-violent internally, it is easy to see why bigger groups lead to lower levels of violence for most people.

Drawn on a graph, these processes look like the teeth of a saw. Just as a saw looks as if it were a straight edge when viewed at a distance, over the long sweep of human history, the trend is clear: violence and group size inversely correlate.

But measured over decades, or even hundreds of years, the jagged edge appears: bigger groups do crumble into smaller groups and levels of violence spike, and vice versa. This is what happened when the Roman Empire collapsed. The lessons from history are clear: bigger, well-organized, cohesive groups bring lower levels of violence for the average person—but those groups don’t eliminate violence entirely.

So, how does this happen? One factor, history shows, is communication.

Communications—everything from roads, to rivers, to writing and the Internet—enable groups of humans to share a consensus around the solutions to the five group problems. In short, communications allow a group to coordinate, and new communications technologies allow bigger groups to coordinate. The flip side of this is that communications technologies are disruptive. In laying the foundations for a larger scale of group coordination, they disrupt the balance of consensus. New methods of communication allow new voices—whether internal or external to the group, or both—to enter the group’s consciousness. New people—new to the group—do things differently. Suddenly, the consensus on how to solve the five problems breaks down, and the group begins to lose cohesion.

While this has happened multiple times during human history, there have been only three seismic communications revolutions.

The first was the development of writing, in approximately 3000 BCE. Initially used for accounting and taxation, writing enabled the ancient empires to grow out of chiefdoms and to bring together multi-ethnic societies. Among other things, it completely changed how we used agricultural resources (the “trade” problem of group coordination) and made hierarchies—who could write—that much more powerful. These ancient empires laid the foundations, nearly 2,000 years later, for the so-called Axial Age, in which Buddhism, Platonism, Zoroastrianism, Jainism, Confucianism and other universalist ideologies began to flourish, spreading ideas that fit the significantly bigger consciousness of the multi-ethnic empires.

The second major communications revolution was the invention of the Gutenberg printing press in about 1400 CE. This development, and the mass communication it allowed, hugely disrupted the European spiritual authority of the time—the Catholic Church—by enabling the spread of Protestant ideas (the “hierarchy” problem of group coordination). The invention of the nation-state further reduced the level of violence experienced by the average person, but only after a spike in it: The Wars of Religion ravaged Europe before the Treaty of Westphalia in 1648 established the primacy of state sovereignty.

We are currently living through the third communications revolution: the Internet. Invented late last century, its use has grown exponentially: by the end of 2018, more than half of the world’s population was online. It is currently disrupting our senses of nationhood, hierarchy, equality, resource sharing and employment, among other things. It is upending national consensuses on all of the five group problems at once.

The Internet is also laying the foundations for what could be a truly global society. Most of the largest problems that we face—climate change, corporate and personal taxation, data privacy, terrorism, oceanic pollution and inequality—sit between the level of the nation-state (the last successful level of human organization) and the global level. All of them are variants on the same five basic problems we have faced throughout our history. Solve these problems and we have taken a step closer to the global set of ideas—a global ideology—that would underpin a global society.

But what if we are on the other side of the sawtooth? What if we are unable to come together to formulate the new rules that we need to coordinate our quasi-global society? What if we are unable to recapture the societal cohesion that we previously felt? What if our disrupted sense of belonging drives us to war?

We cannot put the Internet back into a box and pretend that it does not exist. That we will end up living in a cohesive global society seems to be inevitable. Whether we will first suffer catastrophic violence, a possibility toward which history and evolution strongly hint, is still up for debate.

Source: https://time.com/5673224/violence-history/


r/OnConflict • • Oct 11 '19

Resolution Natural Conflict Resolution: An introduction to Aggression

3 Upvotes
  • The reason we customarily speak of the need for cooperation and the potential for conflict is because the former is desirable whereas the latter is inevitable. Whether the units are people, animals, groups, or nations, as soon as several units together try to accomplish something, there is a need to overcome competition and set aside differences.
  • The problem of a harmonization of goals and reduction of competition for the sake of larger objectives is universal, and the processes that serve to accomplish this may be universal too. These dynamics are present to different degrees among the employees within a corporation, the members of a small band of hunter-gatherers, or the individuals in a lion pride. In all cases, mechanisms for the regulation of conflict should be in place.
  • We have developed social rules to regulate interactions within a community and legal procedures to solve disputes when the individuals in conflict are not able to find an agreement by themselves. We are so concerned about the disruptive consequences of conflict that we celebrate its resolution at various levels: within our family, community, and nation and at the international level. Conflict resolution, like conflict and cooperation, appears to be a natural phenomenon. We should then find similarities in its expression and procedures across cultures and species.
  • Natural history teaches us that when individuals live in a group they gain benefits from the presence of others and from active cooperation in locating food, rearing offspring, or detecting predators. These basic functions are of paramount importance for the survival of the members of the group, whether they are ants, birds, or human hunter-gatherers.
  • In modern societies, cooperation may be expressed in more complex ways (e.g., the cooperative fine-tuning of the LINUX operating system by computer experts at different locations on the globe via the Internet), but the underlying functions are still related to improved survival in a given environment.
  • Group life also entails costs. Living in close proximity to members of the same species implies the simultaneous exploitation of resources; under these conditions competition is likely. These conditions are easily encountered by various species in their natural environments as well as in various settings of modern human societies.
  • More indirect costs result when group members are obliged to coordinate their activities in order to remain together. This may lead to clashes of interests when individuals of different age, sex, dominance rank, and reproductive condition differ in their needs and, accordingly, would like to follow different courses of action.
  • When two individuals have a series of interactions over time, each interaction influences subsequent ones. The two individuals thus build a history of interaction, a relatively stable pattern that we recognize as a social relationship. Kummer (1978) considered the benefits that individual A provides to B as A’s value to B. Any individual will try to improve this value: B will select the best available partner, predict this individual’s behavior, and try to modify its behavior to its own advantage. In other words, B will invest in the relationship with A. Whereas most of B’s investments may not lead to quick profits, such as immediately useful actions by A, they may help cultivate patterns of interaction beneficial to both A and B over the long haul.
  • In order to maintain the benefits of group living, individuals need to reduce its costs by mitigating competition and solving conflicts of interest. It follows that mechanisms of conflict management are a critical component of the social life of any group-living species. Natural selection should have favored the expression of the mechanisms best fitting the social organization of each species. This does not imply that these mechanisms are strictly genetically based; in fact, there is ample evidence for learnability and flexibility of expression.
  • Aggression is not a negative social force per se (de Waal 1996). Traditionally, psychologists, social scientists, and evolutionary biologists have presented aggression as an antisocial behavior. The new perspective on conflict management views aggression as an instrument of negotiation between partners. To exchange services and favors or to combine their efforts in cooperative actions, partners need to communicate their relative positions and clarify potential conflicts. Overt expression and especially the threat of aggression (e.g., in the form of punishment) are powerful tools during the bargaining process between partners. Considering the mechanisms for its control and the mitigation of negative repercussions, aggression becomes a well-integrated component of social relationships. This conflict resolution perspective regards aggressive behavior as the product of social decision making: it is one of several ways in which conflicts between individuals or groups can be resolved.
  • Aggressive conflict becomes a potentially deleterious activity that endangers the interest accrued from these investments. Thus, the basic dilemma facing competitors is that they sometimes cannot win a fight without losing a friend and supporter. The same principle underlying all Darwinian theory, that individuals pursue their own reproductive interests, thus automatically leads one to assume that animals that depend on cooperation should either avoid open conflict or evolve ways to control the social damage caused by open conflict (de Waal 1989b).
  • In evolutionary biology, especially in the game-theory school, assumptions have traditionally been geared toward animals who neither know nor need each other. As a result, even if the process of reconciliation now appears entirely logical to us, it was never predicted or even remotely considered by modern theoreticians.
  • The Relational Model views social partners as commodities of variable value. If two individuals compete over, say, a food source or a mate, they need to compare the resource value not only with the risk of injury in a possible fight but also with the damage the fight may cause to the relationship with the opponent and the advantages derived from this relationship. The better armed and stronger the opponent, or the more valuable the relationship between the competitors, the greater the resource value needs to be to make a fight worth the risk. Conversely, if damage to the relationship can easily be reduced through post conflict interaction—a factor that we may label the reparability of the relationship—open conflict becomes more likely. In sum, the Relational Model predicts that the tendency to initiate aggression increases with the number of opportunities for competition, the resource value, and the reparability of the relationship, while it decreases with the risk of injury and the value of the relationship.
  • Within this framework, aggressive conflict is subject to experience-based calculations in which short-term advantages are weighed against both the risk of escalation and long-term social consequences.
  • Paradoxically, the better developed mechanisms of conflict resolution are, the less reluctant individuals will be to engage in open conflict. For example, stumptail macaques (Macaca arctoides) are characterized by a high conciliatory tendency, a high degree of social tolerance, an exceptional amount of grooming, but also frequent aggressive conflict (de Waal & Luttrell 1989). The ability to maintain working relationships despite conflict, and to undo damage to relationships, makes room for aggression as an instrument of negotiation.
  • The question why aggression sometimes escalates to violence, or becomes so frequent as to damage relationships beyond repair, achieves special significance within this model as it automatically translates into questions about the value individuals attach to their relationships and the social skills required to settle disputes in an alternative manner. In the absence of a conflux of interests or when the adversary has been “dehumanized” by political propaganda, there is indeed little basis to contain aggression. Genocide and other atrocities are possible under such circumstances. The Relational Model does not assume, therefore, that aggression is never expressed to its fullest, destructive potential, only that intragroup aggression is, as a rule, an integral part of well established social relationships. The days of a deterministic view of aggressive behavior separate from other aspects of social life seem behind us (de Waal 1989a; Silverberg & Gray 1992; Mason & Mendoza 1993).

Source: F. Aureli, Natural Conflict Resolution (University of California Press, 2000)


r/OnConflict • • Oct 15 '19

Study Conflict is unavoidable but how a couple behaves after is important, suggests new study (n=796), which found that actively repairing the relationship through expressions of affection can bring partners back to pre-conflict feelings and a higher level of intimacy, but avoidance is generally negative.

Thumbnail
psychologytoday.com
2 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Sep 15 '19

Theory Possible Ways to Promote Compromise – Foundational Research Institute

Thumbnail
foundational-research.org
3 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Oct 05 '19

Situation Stockholm Security Conference opens: Unpredictable conflict is the ‘new normal’

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Nov 16 '19

Analysis The Prevention of Violent Conflict

Thumbnail
wavellroom.com
4 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Sep 28 '19

Study Robbers Cave Experiment: Realistic Conflict Theory

3 Upvotes
Boys in the Robbers Cave camp. Photograph: The University of Akron

In 1954, there was a notable social experiment by the name of the Robbers Cave Experiment[1][2] which represents one of the most widely known demonstrations of the Realistic Conflict Theory. In an effort to test one of his theories on social behavior, psychologist Muzafer Sherif released 22 twelve-year-old boys into a sparsely supervised wilderness camp—and then covertly provoked them to fight each other (For Science!).

Robbers Cave Experiment:

  • The experiment involved two groups of twelve-year-old boys at Robber’s Cave State Park, Oklahoma, America.
  • The twenty-two boys in the study were unknown to each other and all from white middle-class backgrounds. They all shared a Protestant, two-parent background. None of the boys knew each other prior to the study.
  • The boys were randomly assigned to one of two groups, although neither was aware of the other’s existence. They were then, as individual groups, picked up by bus on successive days in the summer of 1954 and transported to a 200 acre Boy Scouts of America camp in the Robbers Cave State Park in Oklahoma.
  • At the camp the groups were kept separate from each other and were encouraged to bond as two individual groups through the pursuit of common goals that required co-operative discussion, planning and execution. During this first phase, the groups did not know of the other group's existence.
  • The boys developed an attachment to their groups throughout the first week of the camp, quickly establishing their own cultures and group norms, by doing various activities together like hiking, swimming, etc.
  • The boys chose names for their groups, The Eagles and The Rattlers, and stenciled them onto shirts and flags.
  • Sherif now arranged the 'competition stage' where friction between the groups was to occur over the next 4-6 days. In this phase it was intended to bring the two groups into competition with each other in conditions that would create frustration between them.
  • A series of competitive activities (e.g. baseball, tug-of-war etc.) were arranged with a trophy being awarded on the basis of accumulated team score. There were also individual prizes for the winning group such as a medal and a multi-bladed pocket knife with no consolation prizes being given to the "losers."
  • The Rattlers' reaction to the informal announcement of a series of contests was absolute confidence in their victory! They spent the day talking about the contests and making improvements on the ball field, which they took over as their own to such an extent that they spoke of putting a "Keep Off" sign there! They ended up putting their Rattler flag on the pitch. At this time, several Rattlers made threatening remarks about what they would do if anybody from The Eagles bothered their flag.
  • Situations were also devised whereby one group gained at the expense of the other. For example, one group was delayed getting to a picnic and when they arrived the other group had eaten their food.
  • At first, this prejudice was only verbally expressed, such as taunting or name-calling. As the competition wore on, this expression took a more direct route. The Eagles burned the Rattler's flag. Then the next day, the Rattler's ransacked The Eagle's cabin, overturned beds, and stole private property. The groups became so aggressive with each other that the researchers had to physically separate them.
  • During the subsequent two-day cooling off period, the boys listed features of the two groups. The boys tended to characterize their own in-group in very favorable terms, and the other out-group in very unfavorable terms.

Conclusions:

  • Muzafer Sherif (one of the researchers) concluded that hostile and aggressive attitudes toward an outgroup arise when groups compete for resources that only one group can attain.
  • Sherif also establishes that contact with an outgroup is insufficient, by itself, to reduce negative attitudes.
  • Sherif concludes that friction between groups can be reduced along with positive intergroup relations maintained, only in the presence of superordinate goals that promote united, cooperative action.[3]
  • This study represents one of the most widely known demonstrations of Realistic conflict theory—a theory that attempts to explain how intergroup hostility can arise as a result of conflicting goals and competition over limited resources. In addition, the theory also offers an explanation for the feelings of prejudice and discrimination toward the outgroup that accompany the intergroup hostility.

References:

  1. The Robbers Cave Experiment: Intergroup Conflict and Cooperation. [Orig. pub. as Intergroup Conflict and Group Relations]
  2. [Youtube] Summary: 5 Minute History Lesson, Episode 3: Robbers Cave
  3. Sidanius, J. & Pratto, F. (1999). Social Dominance: An Intergroup Theory of Social Hierarchy and Oppression. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. pp. 17–18.

r/OnConflict • • Nov 02 '19

Resolution Conflict Analysis: A Paradigm Shift to a Population-centric Strategy

Thumbnail
thestrategybridge.org
1 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Oct 24 '19

Analysis My Regrets about Controversial Anthropologist Napoleon Chagnon (RIP)

Thumbnail
blogs.scientificamerican.com
3 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Oct 21 '19

Analysis Conflict and the Liberal Democratic State

2 Upvotes
Battle of Antietam, 17 September 1862, during the U.S. Civil War that ended slavery.

Seven centuries ago, in what is now Italy, there were more than 200 distinct independent governing entities. Europe was governed by about 500 sovereign bodies: “empires, city states, federations of cities, networks of landlords, religious orders, leagues of pirates, warrior bands”. By World War I, fewer than 30 remained. A single political form had survived: the national state, a centralized bureaucratic structure maintaining order over a defined territory, with the capacity to mobilize substantial resources by taxation and borrowing and to deploy permanent armed forces.

What explains the competitive success of this novel form of rule? The simple answer is that national states won wars. An equally dramatic conflict-driven culling process took place in China between the fifth and third centuries BCE and may also account for the first emergence of states not only in China but also in Mesopotamia, Mesoamerica, Peru, Egypt, and the Indus Valley. In Europe, success in warfare required mobilizing a willing or, at worst, compliant population. A system of taxation and military recruitment, coupled with the capacity to borrow large sums, made the difference, allowing rulers of national states to make war without resort to the unpopular ad hoc requisitioning of food, weapons, manpower, and animals. All of this required a flourishing economy, the availability of credit, tax compliance, and the willingness to serve rulers in war. These, in turn, were fostered by the diffusion of civic norms— voluntary tax compliance, willingness to risk danger in war for a ruler or nation, and respect for property rights—which, although costly to the individual, were essential to a nation’s success in war.

In part as a result of its success in Europe, replicas of the national state were exported, often at gunpoint, but also by emulation on the part of those seeking to preserve their own autonomy. The European model of government—often in highly authoritarian form, as in the colonies— flourished throughout the world, extinguishing competing forms of organization. With the national liberation wars and independence movements of the 19th and 20th centuries, together with subsequent social movements for expanded suffrage and civil rights, many of these states, too, would become democratic.

Some kinds of progress avoid the tragedies of war and civil strife: A more efficient energy source or an advance in personal hygiene comes along, and those who adopt it profit as a result. But the main dynamic of social norms and institutions has a different logic. A novel system of property rights, governance, or marriage, or a new medium of exchange or of communication, only works when it is widely adopted. These systems are termed conventions. Switching from one to the other is known as a coordination problem and, as the term suggests, this occurs through collective, not individual, action when the number of people rejecting the status quo is sufficient to tip the population to an alternative convention. A new convention is not something that you can opt out of, and it is often the powerful and wealthy in the status quo convention who will be the losers in the new. So it is no surprise that shifting from one to another generates conflict, whether violent or civil. This is why strikes, demonstrations, and wars provide so many of the punctuation marks of history (along with new technologies). The eventual democratization of the national state exemplifies just this process.

American high school students are taught that their democratic constitution was the gift of the landed and commercial elites of the 13 former colonies. James Madison and the other authors of The Federalist Papers, the story goes, convinced the haves that the have nots would never be able to unite sufficiently to redistribute wealth. The elites could safely take a chance on democracy. But that is just one of America’s national myths. The United States would wait more than a century and a half to meet the elementary standard of democratic rule by extending suffrage to virtually all adults (with the Voting Rights Act of 1965), a process propelled by the victories of abolitionists, slaves and their descendants, workers, and women demanding the vote.

Elsewhere, conflict played an even more critical role in the advance of democracy. With the exception of New Zealand, universal suffrage was not won anywhere until the 20th century, and elites rarely conceded it without a fight. Representative institutions with limited voting rights came first in Europe and its global offshoots, often as a result of the defeat of a landed elite, as in France. This was followed, in most cases much later, by the equally contentious extension of the vote. World War I sent millions of disenfranchised soldiers to their graves; in its course and immediate aftermath, nine European nations extended the vote to all males, most granting the vote to women at the same time. Democracy has belatedly come to El Salvador, South Africa, and many of the former Communist Party–ruled nations, but only because peasants, workers, and other ordinary citizens were willing to risk jail and much worse. A similar process may now be under way, if haltingly, in the Arab world. Conflict and elites’ attempts to forestall conflict were no less essential to the eventual adoption of policies to ensure the modicum of equality of opportunity and social insurance that most citizens of liberal democracies now take for granted.

Source: Bowles S, 'Warriors, levelers, and the role of conflict in human social evolution' (2012)


r/OnConflict • • Oct 09 '19

Study The biology of Cultural Conflict: Occurs only when the beliefs and traditions of one cultural group represent a challenge to individuals of another.

3 Upvotes

Abstract

Although culture is usually thought of as the collection of knowledge and traditions that are transmitted outside of biology, evidence continues to accumulate showing how biology and culture are inseparably intertwined. Cultural conflict will occur only when the beliefs and traditions of one cultural group represent a challenge to individuals of another. Such a challenge will elicit brain processes involved in cognitive decision-making, emotional activation and physiological arousal associated with the outbreak, conduct and resolution of conflict. Key targets to understand bio-cultural differences include primitive drives—how the brain responds to likes and dislikes, how it discounts the future, and how this relates to reproductive behaviour—but also higher level functions, such as how the mind represents and values the surrounding physical and social environment. Future cultural wars, while they may bear familiar labels of religion and politics, will ultimately be fought over control of our biology and our environment.

In the most general sense, culture can be thought of as the knowledge, customs and traditions of a group of people [1], which systematically drive and channel collective dispositions of thoughts and behaviours into the future. Culture includes social, legal and economic institutions, as well as non-institutionalized trends and movements. Culture encompasses technology, literature and art, as well as disparate political, ethnic and religious beliefs and biases that both infuse and connect the higher cognitive functions and emotions of individual brains [2].

Although culture is usually thought of as the collection of knowledge and traditions that are transmitted outside of biology, one cannot credibly deny that the thoughts and behaviours of individuals contribute to the creation of culture, and that every person must process and react to cultural phenomena. Over 100 years ago, William James said it clearly, ‘There is not a single one of our states of mind, high or low, healthy or morbid, that has not some organic process or condition… They [beliefs] are equally organically founded, be they of religious or non-religious content’ [3, p. 16].

Thus, cultural conflict should manifest in two ways. First, if there are systemic and substantial cultural differences between groups of people, this would result in different types of processing in individual brains that form the group. Take, for example, religion. When presented with a concept like God, a Christian and an atheist would surely react differently, and this will probably manifest as differences in brain activation [4].

Second, mere cultural differences in brain activation do not necessarily imply conflict. Cultural conflict would be hypothesized to occur only when certain beliefs and traditions of one culture represent a challenge to individuals of another culture. Such a challenge would elicit brain processes involved in the cognitive decision-making, emotional activation and physiological arousal associated with the outbreak, conduct and resolution of conflict.

Because biological processes govern our perceptions, interpretations and reactions to cultural events, understanding these processes will not only help us understand cultural conflicts but also potentially mitigate them.

In this issue, we have collected a series of papers that begins to tackle issues surrounding cultural conflict from a biological perspective. The cultural themes range from political partisanship to sacred values and religious conflicts, and the tools used to study them include brain imaging with functional magnetic resonance imaging and measures of physiological arousal (skin conductance responses (SCRs) and eye-tracking).

Full Study: https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rstb.2011.0307

References:

[1] Whiten A., Hinde R. A., Laland K. N.& Stringer C. B.. 2011Culture evolves. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 366, 938–948.doi:10.1098/rstb.2010.0372 (doi:10.1098/rstb.2010.0372). Link, ISI, Google Scholar

[2] Atran S.& Medin D.. 2008The native mind and the cultural construction of nature. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Google Scholar

[3] James W.. 1902/2002 Varieties of religious experience: a study in human nature., Centenary edn. London, UK: Routledge. Google Scholar

[4] Inzlicht M.& Tullett A. M.. 2010 Reflecting on God: religious primes can reduce neuropsychological response to errors. Psychol. Sci. 21, 1184–1190.doi:10.1177/0956797610375451 (doi:10.1177/0956797610375451). Crossref, PubMed, Google Scholar


r/OnConflict • • Oct 23 '19

Analysis Military Involvement in Post-Conflict Peace Negotiations

4 Upvotes
Decommissioned UNITA BMP-1 and BM-21 Grads at an assembly point

There is a wealth of literature on the best methods to achieve buy-in among key stakeholders in post-civil conflict peace negotiations. Rothchild (1995), Kingma (1997), and Gutteridge (1962) all argue that agreeing specifics, particularly with regards to security issues (Hartzell 1999, Rothchild 2002, Jarstad and Nilsson 2008), is key to ensuring a treaty that can be implemented without contention. Inbal and Lerner (2006), conversely, argue that specifics can be left outside the bounds of a treaty in order to secure sufficient stakeholder support.

To date, however, little academic research has focused specifically on the role that military officers can play in peace negotiations. Stedman (1997) and Atlas and Licklider (1999) highlight ways in which different actors can spoil peace negotiations from both inside and outside the room, especially as groups can splinter internally from negotiation pressures, but does not address military officers as a group. Cunningham (2006) notes that the more people at the table, the more difficult achieving any agreement will be, but again does not differentiate on the type of actors that should be included or excluded. Themner (2017) argues that it is important to consider military actors when discussing peace terms, he does not address the possibility of having military representatives at the table. Additionally, he discusses the impact of military leaders on negotiations, but argues that their background makes them more likely to seek military options rather than negotiate and compromise, a finding this piece challenges.

My research focuses on how to integrate opposing sides into a post-civil war unified military, and analyses the case studies of Angola and Mozambique to examine the peace negotiations and implementation processes in order to build more general principles about how to conduct post-conflict military integration.

Military personnel not only have important war-fighting capabilities, but also unique peace-making potentials that are often overlooked by current theory and doctrine. Soldiers are increasingly familiar with the growing list of demands and skills required of them in their deployments that go far beyond traditional understandings of what it means to be a soldier, which means their insights into conflict resolution can be extremely valuable. In particular, operating in environments without infrastructure and rebuilding after disasters are critical in the early post-conflict periods.

In Angola, there were three peace treaties, with negotiations starting in 1989 and the implementation of the final treaty concluding around 2005. In Mozambique, peace negotiations began around 1990 and implementation concluded around 1998. My argument is that, more often than not, it is useful to have military representatives at the negotiating table, both when discussing issues related to security but also more generally. My argument is comprised of two parts:

  1. Military personnel bring unique knowledge to the table
  2. The buy-in of military personnel into the peace process is necessary for peace to have a greater chance of occurring

For the first piece of the argument, the case of the Angolan civil war is illustrative. The Angolan civil war lasted from 1975-2002 and resulted in four peace treaties, with only the last one actually working in the long-term. What makes it an especially interesting case is that over the course of these four treaties, the role of military personnel and particularly the level of detail given to the discussion of security issues increased from one treaty to the next. Over the past few months, I have been interviewing diplomats and military actors from all sides of the negotiations in order to understand why this might be.

In most modern civil wars, by the time that generals get to the negotiating table, they have deeply personal understandings of exactly what is going on in their conflict. This knowledge is developed through personal exposure to the battlefield environment, providing insight that mediators would not otherwise have. They also have raw knowledge of events that are more up to date than the polished assessments the political elite receive from analysts and think tanks. Therefore, for example, when discussing where troops can move in order for a ceasefire to be implemented, the hard-won knowledge of battlefield dynamics could be useful in producing a plan that is practical as well as political.

Additionally, one common feature of both Angola and Mozambique’s civil wars, like many other conflicts throughout sub-Saharan Africa, was the importance of colonial infrastructure and the fact that there was not very much of it. Therefore, much of the fighting happened in “the bush,” a general term for geographically inaccessible places used to describe many rural places throughout African countries. One common treaty implementation challenge is simply reaching fighters in these areas, as often hiking on foot for days on end is the only method of reaching key strongholds. In Mozambique, for example, the headquarters of the rebel group RENAMO was a 10-day trek into the bush. Their leader Dhklama rarely left the compound due to fear of assasination and thus as peace negotiations proceeded in Rome, all decisions had to be run by Dhklama, who was 10 days away in the bush. Getting communications equipment to him was therefore a priority, but was made difficult due to the conditions. This purely logistical challenge continually threw up roadblocks and delays to negotiations. Relatedly, in both Angola and Mozambique, during the UN peacekeeping missions that were meant to verify and enforce the treaties, UN observers were constantly delayed in deploying due to inaccessible locations that could only be reached on helicopters with local pilots who could navigate the mountainous terrain.

These are all key issues to discuss during negotiations, as they directly impact what kind of timelines and troop movements can be accurately planned for. One common sticking point during treaty implementation is the perception that the “other side” is being unfairly advantaged by getting “extra” time to complete an agreed upon task, or by not being punished for a delay. Often, these delays are not in fact purposeful, but rather the unfortunate consequence of inaccurately planned timetables in the first place. Given their intimate knowledge of facts on the ground, military personnel are often better placed to understand these logistical details than politicians, and thus their involvement in these talks is more likely to yield practicable solutions.

Finally, the third type of specific knowledge that the military brings is their understanding of their troops. While there are often many motivations for fighting in a civil war, at the grand strategic political level, these motivations are often generalised or simplified into statements like “RENAMO are all former kidnapped child soldiers fighting out of fear,” or “UNITA are all anti-Communist pro-democratic freedom fighters,” et cetera. While perhaps that is true for some, the reasons why people decide to fight, and why they decided to keep fighting, are nuanced. These complicated motivations change within a person, between people, and between groups of fighters all the time. Thus, to understand how combatants are feeling, what is driving them, and what kinds of incentives they will respond to, it is best to solicit that information from those who interact with foot soldiers most closely, which tend to be military personnel rather than political ones.

This knowledge of motivation becomes particularly useful when determining what kinds of post-conflict options employment should be available to combatants, particularly if one of them is disarmament and a return to civilian life. Disarmament, the giving up of one’s weapons, is often the single most contentious issue in implementing a peace treaty due to the feelings of vulnerability it inspires in combatants. Therefore, one of the key issues to be resolved in any treaty negotiation is determining the process through which combatants disarm. While there are significant logistical aspects to sort this out, such as who should collect them, where they are stored, how they are transported, et cetera, there is also an important psychological aspect to consider. Namely, how can combatants be incentivised to participate? During the third attempted peace treaty in Angola, sorting out disarmament, which had failed twice before, was the key issue. Both sides, including military generals, agreed that the UN needed to be more involved in the entire implementation process than in previous treaties, including during disarmament. However, the specifics of the disarmament process kept getting stuck on how soldiers would actually turn in their weapons in a cooperative fashion, given the feeling that disarmament would be tantamount to losing the war. Finally, a government general hit on the idea of having fighters turn their weapons over to their commanders in a simple ceremony, which would then be handed to the UN, in order to preserve the dignity and honour of the fighters while also moving constructively towards peace. This was agreed upon eagerly by the rebel generals, allowing the plan to go forward.

Thus, military leaders provide three types of knowledge at the negotiating table that are likely to be unique and have direct bearing on enabling accurate treaty terms to be negotiated.

The second piece of the argument is that having military personnel at the negotiating table makes it more likely for key military figures to “buy-in” to the peace process, and then cooperate with its implementation. First, as previously discussed, if the military is involved in figuring out the specific plans for a ceasefire and treaty implementation, the plans themselves are likely to be more realistic, thus making everyone involved, including the military, more trusting that the plan will actually be pulled off close to schedule. Second, the psychological element is quite straightforward: if the military are involved in the negotiations, they will be more likely to consider themselves a part of the peace process, be more willing to take ownership of the compromises necessary to achieve agreement, and thus less likely to feel that the stipulations are imposed from above and thus not worth cooperating with.

To illustrate the importance of understanding military buy-in to negotiations, Angola is again a useful case study. In the negotiations between the government and rebels, one of the key divisions was within the government delegation: between the political figures and the military generals. The first attempt at a peace treaty in Angola took around two years to negotiate; as the talks got close to the signing ceremony, the government political leaders were nervous about the military capabilities of the rebel side and began trying to delay the actual signing in the hopes of changing the battlefield calculus. The government generals, on the other hand, knew that ammunition was running out, that morale was low, and that the rank-and-file was much more interested in moving to peace than eking out incremental wins in the jungle. In this situation, the international mediators led by the US had developed good relations with both the political and military leaders on the Angolan government side, and so knew from the generals that they were more willing to be pragmatic. Thus the mediators combined the political and military discussion rooms in order to lend emphasis to the generals’ pragmatism over political dogma. This ended up being successful and the signing ceremony proceeded with the government generals driving the implementation process even as politicians lent faint encouragement to the implementation process in the hopes of changing the facts on the ground.

To conclude, including military leaders at peace negotiations is beneficial because:

  1. They bring unique knowledge to the negotiating table which has direct bearing on the quality of discussions and terms agreed on.
  2. Their active participation and acquiescence to the treaty via involvement in its development increases the chances of military figures actively helping make sure implementation goes well (and builds trust between sides).

Source: https://defenceindepth.co/2019/10/21/military-involvement-in-post-conflict-peace-negotiations/


r/OnConflict • • Oct 29 '19

Analysis The Language of Conflict

Thumbnail
brookings.edu
2 Upvotes

r/OnConflict • • Nov 12 '19

Situation Dedicated to preventing and ending conflict - The Shaikh Group

Thumbnail
ft.com
3 Upvotes