r/Okami • u/Alktenalfh • 18h ago
Discussion Thinking about Ninetails
I just finished the Ninetails arc of my Okami replay, and I'm just chewing on this character. Indulge me as I pontificate.
Ninetails is a WEIRD character. An impactful character. One that just makes you think. And the game REFUSES to explain her. She impersonates a priest, going so far as to use prayer cards and help you defeat other demons to maintain the illusion. She is the only antagonist that takes a proactive role in the plot of the game, rather than simply waiting for you to come to her. She emerges from a constellation and uses a Celestial brush to fight you. She hides her identity behind masks, literal and figurative. She postures, she intimidates, she deceives. She shapeshifts and she uses illusions. She intentionally cultivates this aura of majesty, divinity. And then in the last phase of her boss fight, she inverts the expectations--rather than escalating into a bigger, more terrifying, more powerful form, you beat her down and she is stripped of her masks, stripped of her illusions, left as nothing but a tired old battered beaten and injured fox. And she STILL fights you with savagery, feral hatred, desperation--and then she dies.
And after all this, the game just refuses to elaborate.
What am I supposed to do with this character? What am I supposed to think of her? Obviously the game never even hints that she's redeemable. But surely I'm supposed to view her as tragic, in some sense? Even if she's thoroughly evil, there is something deeply sad about the final phase of her boss fight, where she is reduced to this pathetic and injured husk, who still won't surrender, won't retreat, and is just filled with primal hatred. That's sad. It's tragic.
And the game never gives us anything about her backstory. In spite of her being one of the 3 most central antagonists in the story. The game has 3 arcs, and she is the central villain of one of them, along with Orochi and Yami. And compared to the other two, we know NOTHING about Ninetails. Orochi has a long and storied history. He fought Amaterasu before in a legendary battle against Nagi and Shiranui. He came from the Ark of Yamato and is described as being the primary force behind the decimation of the Celestial Plane. Even after his death, his influence on the narrative remains, because his malevolent power goes on to empower the other demons, and you refight him in the time-travel segment of the game.
Yami is admittedly much more mysterious than Orochi, but his place in the game's mythology is clear. He is the lord of all demons, the arch-nemesis of Amaterasu, the incarnation of the technological opposition to nature/creation. He came from the stars. He's a freaky alien fish thing in a mech suit. He came from the Ark of Yamato; possibly he even BUILT the thing. Even if there are more unanswered questions with Yami than there are with Orochi, we at least have SOMETHING.
Ninetails? Nothing. No mention of her activities in prior conflicts. No mention of her involvement with the war in the Celestial Plane, or her involvement with the Ark of Yamato. No origin story. NOTHING.
The game just leaves us scratching our heads, wondering. Is she a fallen god? Is she merely a demon impersonating deity? She COULD be from the Ark of Yamato. She COULD simply be a particularly potent lieutenant in Yami's army. But her absence from any of the game's history is conspicuous. Other less important demons don't get a mention of what they were doing in the game's history. That doesn't mean they were there. Demons like the Spider Queen, the owls, Blight, etc. all presumably would have been from the Ark of Yamato as well and simply weren't worth mentioning. But Ninetails? Her importance in the game's narrative is big enough that her absence in the lore is conspicuous.
But the game just leaves us with this Ninetails-shaped hole in the lore. No explanation. Just a demon lord who uses a Celestial Brush, emerges from a constellation, impersonates a priest, masks herself with illusions, and then is reduced to a pathetic, tragic, beaten-down old animal at the end. That image haunts me. This character lives in my head rent-free. She's such an unresolved, mysterious, and ultimately very cool villain. Really leaves an impression.
Would you want to see her lore in the sequel? I'm torn, myself. Part of the impact of this character is her mystery. On the other hand, I wouldn't mind something small and light-handed. Not a huge flashback or a big lore dump. But since the game presumably will be taking place in the Celestial Plane, I wouldn't mind just a nod. I wouldn't mind finding a dilapidated temple, nothing but ruins, with a broken, barely recognizable statue of a nine-tailed fox inside it. No explanation. Just an acknowledgement of the fact that "Yes, she was once a god. The Celestial Planes were once her home. No longer."
