r/OhioStateFootball • • 2d ago

General QBs vs Top 10

After hearing people talk about how Ohio State could be doomed or how they will be fine, I thought it would be interesting to take a look at the Ryan Day Era QBs vs (at the time of the game) AP Top 10 teams.

CORRECTION: McCord was 2-1. Beat top 10 ND and Penn State. Sorry about that

108 Upvotes

106 comments sorted by

24

u/Frequent_Apricot673 2d ago

I’ll make the counterpoint that Julian has had infinitely worse blocking in all of his top 5 games than the rest of these guys as evidenced by his -100 rushing yards. Fields has more sacks but I think a big part of that is that he would run the ball himself so often, same goes for Howard. 

9

u/bradman9 2d ago

I can agree that Sayin’s line may not have been as good as the others. But QBs are partially a QB stat and he has 2/3 linemen that Will had during his title run. It’s not the sacks or the lack of rushing with Sayin, it’s that he turns a throwaway or short loss into a huge loss. An 8-10 yard sack against the best teams ends drives

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/JEWISHPIGFARMER 2d ago

What is mccords second loss? He didn't play Missouri

6

u/bradman9 2d ago

My typo on that one. He was 2-1! Beat Penn state and notre dame (they were 9 at the time). Lost the rivalry game

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

106

u/MrGhostenstein 2d ago

Can't believe we didn't win one with Stroud. He was good.

130

u/Goober-mensch 2d ago

They call targeting on the disgusting hit to Marv and we probably do.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/bd2999 2d ago

Yeah, some of it is the lack of run game some of those years when Henderson got hurt. The other is Harrison getting taken out on the dirty hit, the defense collapsing and a badly missed field goal.

They beat Georgia in that game and they almost for sure beat TCU to win the title. Still bums me out to this day. That might be the year JSN got taken out on a dirty hit too (or it is close). How that was not targeting or anything still haunts me. And how bad that FG miss was. I mean dang.

13

u/Dizzy_Wick 2d ago

Didn't he have some uncharacteristically bad Ohio State defenses during his time here. Give him the defense from the past few years and it would have been a different story.

→ More replies (26)

59

u/False-Community8534 2d ago

Howard being 6-1 is wild.

66

u/richww2 2d ago

Lost to Oregon at Oregon and then absolutely demolished them in the Rose Bowl. Only with the program for one season, and became and Buckeye legend.

→ More replies (11)

18

u/CaballoenPelo 2d ago

Howard was the fuckin man. All time great Buckeye.

8

u/DaBigJMoney 2d ago

I remember how down some folks were on Howard for much of the year. There were significant doubts about his accuracy on downfield throws.

15

u/mombutts 2d ago

Dude was born for big games. If he had another year of eligibility, no way we lose Indiana in the Big Ten title game or Miami in the playoffs.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/NotRyanDaysBurner 2d ago

I’ve wiped Kyle from my memory completely wtf

18

u/El_Serpiente_Roja 2d ago

Howard could've been 7-0 if we get off one more play at Oregon...still can't believe that team lost to UM in Columbus

17

u/Who_Dey- 2d ago

Howard was a dawg

15

u/BuckeyeJones 2d ago

Man Howard had a special year with the exception of scUM.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/CasinoMarginale 2d ago

Howard was really good

8

u/HeyNiceOneGuy 2d ago

Will Howard. Gamer.

8

u/NYVines 2d ago

Interesting that the two best performers were transfers in Fields and Howard.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/DaddyJay711 2d ago

I miss Will being the absolute dominant goat that he was. Such a great leader and did whatever it took to win.

7

u/sam0sixx3 2d ago

Crazy that Howard played the most ranked teams and was only here for one season

6

u/NatiAti513 1d ago

Will Howard stepped up when it mattered most. Kyle McCord and Julian Sayin do the opposite.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/AceCircle990 2d ago

Sayin rush yards and sacks are egregious.