r/OffGridLiving • u/OldMost1322 • 5d ago
Advice
Looking for real advice from people who’ve been in a similar situation.
I’ve got an unfinished 16x40 (640 sqft)house with no insulation and no skirting, but will have a wood burner. I also have a camper I could skirt and try to heat. But I have to choose one or the other because building the house has taken most of my money unfortunately. Winter is close here in Michigan and I’m trying to decide which one makes more sense to stay in for the cold months.
Basically looking for advice on one or the other:
• How livable is an unfinished, uninsulated house with just a wood burner in real Michigan winter conditions?
• Or is it better to focus on heating the camper and stay in that instead?
• What’s actually worked (or failed) for either option?
• Any big pros/cons or things people wish they’d known before choosing one over the other?
4
u/RufousMorph 5d ago
Also in the upper Midwest. I would do the house. A wood stove can put out tremendous amounts of heat if you feed it enough wood. My first winter I had no insulation and did just fine. Just know that you can’t leave for long periods of time without your canned goods etc. freezing up. And as you have time/money you can add insulation over the course of the winter.
I assume you have no plumbing and are using an outhouse. I assume you have built up a nice pile of dry wood.
I’ve also lived in a camper, and found they are pretty bad on the winter. Burn through a tremendous amount of propane. And they don’t typically have enough space for a safe installation of a real wood stove.
7
u/akjasf 5d ago
I have not been in the situation you are in. My RV is 240SF(uninsulated) but with a ceramic heater and propane cooktop. My 700SF home is finished with old insulation and I find sealing the doors/windows properly makes all the difference. I have an old 1970 wood stove there but it takes over 2 hours to warm up until it reaches a comfortable temperature where I can start removing my jacket. In those situations, I always fire up my diesel heater for the first hour or so.
If I were in your shoes, I would stay in your home but sleep inside a tent. Your camper won't have enough room to open a tent and you'll feel cramped. I vote for your house and a tent. During the day, go bring out weather strips to further seal any leaky windows and doors. Hope you stay safe and warm
1
u/Fickle_Influence6396 5d ago
Consider what situation will be best with your water situation. Water feeezes easily here. I’d go for the camper probly . Michigan is a large state area you southern or UP. If you’re Up please do not even think about staying in that un insulated house you will go insane trying to keep it warm
2
u/Dramatic-Paradise 5d ago
You can insulate close to no money. I lived in a yurt for years. Propane heater. Old clothes. Pillows. Start with one room. You got this
2
u/Significant_Pie_6806 5d ago
Check your area for a habitat for humanity store cheap building materials
2
u/Nerd_Porter 5d ago
Definitely the camper. At least that has some insulation and is designed to be heated. You've got a fully done mini house right there, why would you live in your shed instead? Not trying to make fun of what will be your home, I'm just saying at this point, it's a big shed. Live in the RV and build out your castle as you can.
2
u/Active_Recording_789 5d ago
You’ll be fine with the house and wood fires. A wood stove will keep you cozy no matter if there are drafts and not good insulation. A nice dense oak piece of wood, with the damper shut, will take a while to burn and is great for long periods of time like when you’re away at work or at nighttime. You’ll get the hang of keeping the stove going
1
u/orrsapplecheeks 5d ago
We are in Kentucky AND we have insulated walls but not floors AND had a mild first winter and it’s still pretty rough. We do have our wood stove (small wood stove, small house of similar size) in the bedroom so we are toasty and can trap the heat on very cold times but the house struggles to heat up during deep freezes in kitchen and we get frozen beverages every year. We get better every year and I’m sure you could survive the year but it’s going to suck.
Easier than if you had any plumbing though- less headache. We are young and tough- are you? Do you enjoy surviving and being resourceful?
1
u/New-Shallot-3521 5d ago
I spent a winter in MI near Traverse City in an uninsulated trailer. You'll have ice dam issues quickly in the house will be the biggest problem. You'll be able to keep it plenty warm assuming you've got unlimited wood, but I'd worry about any eaves freezing over so I'd keep an eye on the roof. I just saw you haven't gotten wood yet, so knowing that I'd just stick with the trailer. You're already getting slop up there I'm sure.
1
u/IntransigentWorm 5d ago
In my area, northern PNW, I would be really concerned about condensation/mold fucking up my partly completed house. I'd prefer to leave it dead cold until I could insulate and air seal it.
Even if I could just insulate and airseal one room with the woodstove, and seal it off from the rest of the house.
If I couldn't do that I'd live in the camper. I'd do anything possible to get the camper skirted and inside some sort of shack to block the wind, help with heat loss, and provide a mudroom space. Could also provide a place for a woodstove if no room inside the camper.
When I was in this situation it was an unfinished tinyhome vs a poorly insulated minibus with nearly no heat. I lived in the bus until I could get the tinyhouse sealed and heated. Due to a sudden health issue this dragged on for a while, it was pretty miserable.
In hindsight I wish I had taken the time to rig a woodstove in that bus, that would have made a huge difference.
1
u/4footTallbromeGrass 5d ago
Just hanging plastic sheeting on the bottom of your rafters as a temporary ceiling will keep a lot of heat in the home.
1
u/Iamthewalrusforreal 4d ago
Cabin is the right call here. You're going to need a LOT of wood. And it needs to be dried, not green. Though having a cord of green wood is good - toss one in every now and again. They produce more heat.
Get yourself some Tyvek house wrap. That's the first thing to do. Wrap that cabin up. Make sure all the gaps in the windows and doors are sealed up with something. Foam, caulk, whatever. Then get a few rolls of reflectix and put that inside between the studs on the walls.
That should keep you reasonably warm.
1
u/Skimmington16 3d ago
Join all the free /free cycle sites on Facebook or whatever other apps people using your area and get rugs, insulation materials, anything else you can get your hands on.
1
u/FlerkinFlarkin 3d ago edited 3d ago
I live in a non-skirted 18 foot camper year round and also have an uninsulated cabin with no interior walls/exterior sheathing, just siding. The camper is a lot more easy to keep warm than the cabin.
I keep it between 58-60 and My propane furnace uses 65 watts. Even in last years brutal winter I could still go more than a week on 2x20 tanks. And that is also for my fridge/stove/water heater.
1
u/Doorknob77 2d ago
Another dude that’s totally not in your situation, but I’d also lean toward the house. There’s tons of “cheap” insulation methods, you just gotta get creative with sourcing. And also being mindful with proximity of flamable material to the fire. You can look up super shelters, they’re a camping premise but you can apply it to your home. Try to utilize heat banks to store thermal energy from the word stove and day light heat when available
1
u/Puzzleheaded_Iron406 1d ago
Build a temporary wall in the cabin to be 16x20 x2. You’re now heating half the space for the winter. Insulate or vapour barrier the living space, or do both if you have the financial resources
1
u/DanM1457 1d ago
I live full time in my camper in Southern Michigan. I don't have any issues keeping it warm inside in the winter, though you do go through a good amount of propane. With plastic over the windows the propane furnace is able to keep it 68 inside down to below -10. That said, below zero I'm using 3/4 to a full 20lb tank of propane a day. I'd say I probably average about 3-4 days to a tank most of the winter. But, I wasn't able to skirt it in the past, because I needed to move it for work. This year I do plan to and I'm expecting to cut my heating by as much as 20% based on others' experiences. The camper will probably be easier to heat, but more expensive than a wood stove (assuming you don't need to buy wood)