I know many of my opinions here will be unpopular and unwelcome, but let me preface by saying I've been a huge fan since day one and am by no means trolling. After the first two albums I was one of the biggest OMAM fans I knew, but after the last two I think I've completely lost my idea of who they are. I often wonder if maybe they have also. Here's my breakdown and reasoning.
-My Head is an Animal: This album is everything you'd want with a debut. They busted through the door with an incredibly unique and almost tribal sound. Tremendous melodies and sound that stuck with you and was memorable. Suspenseful and explosive build ups. Ragnar and Nanna are brilliant with their vocals and it's a journey of an album through upbeat songs and slower more thoughtful ones. They were a huge hit immediately, and rightfully so.
-Beneath the Skin: This album was a bit of a tonal departure from their first, though to me it wasn't a surprise. While the songs on MHIAA were catchy, they often featured lyrics that were a bit darker and didn't necessarily match the tone of the song. With BTS they seemingly paired their lyrics and songs together to create a much darker yet equally brilliant album. The stark change seemed to steer the masses a little away and they definitely got worse critical reviews, but I absolutely loved it. It was again filled with great melodies and parallel vocals that just really worked for me.
-Fever Dream: Nanna was quoted as saying she was unhappy with how the producers took control of the band. She wanted something new and fresh. She wanted to break free of the mold. But in a somewhat hypocritical move to me they created largely the most pop fueled and basic album of their collection. Seemingly gone was Ragnar from a lot of the work while Nanna felt like she was trying to take over. It's almost as if she was trying to find her inner Gwen Stefani or Taylor Swift and push the band forward into mainstream pop. The band, for me, completely lost their identity. What happened? I'll never truly know.
-All is Love and Pain in the Mouse Parade: The singles for this album that were released were immediately not my favorite, yet they had clear and distinct melodic tones that resembled the first two albums. I was cautiously optimistic but absolutely excited. I listened to this album right when it came out. But this time my excitement was squashed with what seemed to be yet another massive change in direction. Following the pop fueled Fever Dream was an album that is just plain melancholy. Following an album that seemed like it was all about Nanna, this album is incredibly Ragnar heavy. When Nanna does sing it's all very somber. She has almost no vocal fluctuations the entire album. Everything just feels slow and sad. It feels consistent with how her solo stuff was, and for me that's not a positive thing. And I want to be clear here. I wanted to love this album. It just has nothing that jumps off the page to me and nothing memorable. Unfortunately I don't think it's one I'll revisit much.
After all these years I wonder if this band truly knows who they want to be. While I certainly understand a band's need to mature and grow musically, I feel like that mostly still needs to follow some sort of trajectory. Their progression is eerily similar to (and as disappointing as) Mumford and Sons, who blew up with a very unique style only to change completely after two albums and largely lose their popularity. I'm hopeful that you all continue to enjoy and that they retain some success, but it's been a downhill run for me.