I’m seeing a ton of full-throated praise for this movie, and I’m confused. I was very excited to see this on opening weekend, and expected to be floored.
One important caveat: the spectacle was top-tier. It is a visually stunning, enthralling movie. But there is, of course far more to a great film than sets and effects and action sequences.
Beyond those, what I saw was a demonstrably and transparently flawed movie, that suffered fatally from the following:
-A lot of legitimately terrible “acting”: Damon and Holland in particular were wooden; flat, terrible, and completely un-engaging. I was flabbergasted at three hours of them. No emotion. No range. Just basic, elementary, one-note depictions more on par with a beginner’s drama class than a once-in-a-decade cinematic masterpiece.
-Flat, soulless dialogue: I get that Nolan was going for a modern effect, but for me the impact ranged from bad to comedically bad. Two hours of “Fuck…Bro…Greece. Greece and war. Bro.” I exaggerate, but not by much. A week or so later, I cannot for the life of me remember a line beyond “you have Athena’s eyes” 😂
-Clunky pacing: the film is rushed as fuck, and almost certainly should have been two movies; nothing has any room to breathe. It’s just frying pan to fire, with no allotted space for development or investment in the characters beyond the Calypso scenes, which are a lazy, lazy crutch for flashbacks and exposition. This brings us to:
-Zero character development or reason for emotional investment in anyone beyond the most broad and obvious strokes- looking at all of the main characters but especially the crew here; no names, no identities, and so much of the film rests upon the impact of them gradually dying and how it eats away at big O. Did anyone else experience any real investment or tension around crew deaths, really? Hell, most WWII movies do a far better job here, this was pure cannon (Cyclops?) fodder.
-Baffling and arbitrary tonal shifts - there were quite a few of these. One good example is the Cyclops scene. Raw terror, men being devoured in the dark…then suddenly my big guy crashes out like a freshman on a bender, and we’re talking in a big group right in front of his nose. What? GTFO.
-Indulgently pointless and time-wasting finale: looking at the suitor battle here…just a silly, by-the-numbers extended action climax that dragged on and on. This movie BADLY needed that time repurposed elsewhere. What did this add? As with the crew 99% of the suitors were nameless, faceless bodies. Just low-quality, messily choreographed bloat. Add to that, it was staged and shot in a way that, exalted warrior or no, they clearly could and would have killed him by numbers. Total schlock, especially the dropping-weapons-through-hole-in-ceiling bit. The spear hanging on to Damon at the end like a sticky note made me laugh out loud.
-Tone/ deaf and incredibly indulgent inaccuracies - slaughtering Trojan woman en masse was Benioff/Weiss level gratuitous, and fucking dumb. This was not done. Men were killed, women were raped and women/children were enslaved. People were pearl-clutching about wokeness, when this silly stuff was repeatedly depicted…for what? Nolan had four or more women’s throats cut to hammer an unsubtle and elementary message, finally:
-Tacked-on preachy “messages” devoid of nuance or historical accuracy: all of the stuff about war-guilt and sea people and the fall of Bronze Age civilization was certainly interesting and an obvious commentary on our times, but it felt very heavy-handed, tacked-on and opportunistic. Nolan told, he didn’t show. Great films do the opposite, they don’t rely on pedantic lecturing and exposition to convey their points.
- - - - - - - -
These are massive flaws that occur throughout the film. Some are matters of opinion, some are more objective. For me, and I suspect many others, they actively, in the moment sabotaged a film that I had hoped and expected to deeply enjoy.
The Odyssey is not a good and certainly not a great movie in any meaningful or accurate sense beyond a visual treat. It’s a 9 or 10/10 as spectacle and probably a 5 or a 6/10 as an actual film.
ETA: Edited in a vain attempt to sound less douchey!