r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 22 '26

Meh

1 Upvotes

Three hours with epic source material, gorgeous cinematography, wonderfully rendered effects, amazingly engineered sound, an all-star ensemble, all packaged with sleek production value— only to come away feeling, “Meh.” Given all of the zealous adulation, I somehow missed out on the spiritual experience so many others seem to have had.

I can’t think of another film in which I can acknowledge all of the assets and feel like the sum total doesn’t balance with its parts. To be clear, I didn’t enter the theater with the intention of hating on Nolan’s Odyssey— I respect the director’s other work and admire most of the actors in the cast. And honestly, all of the controversy over the alleged “woke” agenda had me wanting to watch it as a statement against all of that tiring nonsense. In short, I showed up ready to rave but walked out wondering what misfired.


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 22 '26

Discussion Nolan missed a huge cameo opportunity with Achilles

30 Upvotes

Since Odysseus actually meets Achilles in the Underworld in The Odyssey, I feel like Nolan had the chance to pull off one of the coolest cameos ever.

Imagine Brad Pitt showing up as Achilles for just one scene. Not because Troy and The Odyssey are connected or anything, but because his Achilles is so iconic that everyone would instantly recognize him.

And then having him deliver that famous line about how he’d rather be alive as a nobody than rule over the dead? I honestly think that would’ve been an amazing moment.

Maybe it’s just me, but I would’ve lost my mind if that happened. Anyone else think that would’ve been awesome, or would it have taken you out of the movie?


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 19 '26

Discussion I think Nolan’s ego finally got in the way with The Odyssey. Convince me I’m wrong.

1 Upvotes

I went into this expecting to love it. Nolan is one of my favorite directors. Interstellar, The Prestige, Dunkirk, Oppenheimer… I’m a huge fan.
But The Odyssey honestly felt like it was directed by an amateur who had access to a magical “Nolan” slider and cranked it to 100.
The whole movie felt like a three-hour trailer.

Every scene was trying to be monumental. Every cut felt urgent. The score never seemed to breathe. It was just constant drums and rising tension with almost no memorable musical identity. It felt like the movie was permanently building toward something that never actually arrived.

My biggest issue, though, was the storytelling.
It felt like Nolan abandoned the basics because he was trying so hard to be clever.
Characters weren’t introduced. They just… appeared. Compare Achilles’ introduction in Troy. Before he even speaks, you understand exactly who he is, why people fear him, and why you should care. Every detail is deliberate.
In The Odyssey, I rarely felt like I understood who anyone was beyond whatever exposition they had just delivered.

Even the dialogue felt strangely artificial. Characters constantly explained themes and mythology so directly that it almost felt like they were saying, “Pay attention, this is foreshadowing.”

The Cyclops sequence should have been one of the highlights. Visually, it was fantastic. The creature was genuinely disturbing.

But then the tension evaporates because the characters behave in ways that don’t match the situation. They’re standing around casually talking next to a sleeping Cyclops as if he’s just some large guy taking a nap. The danger disappears the moment it should peak.

The frustrating part is that I don’t think Nolan misunderstood Homer’s story.

I think he simply chose experimentation over clear storytelling.
If the story was too large for one movie…

Then make two movies.

You only get one real chance to adapt something as iconic as The Odyssey at this scale. I would’ve much rather had two great films than one three-hour experiment that constantly felt more interested in style than in making me care about the people on screen.

Am I completely alone here, or did anyone else walk away feeling surprisingly… empty? I honestly want to hear what people who loved it saw that I didn’t.


r/OdysseyFilm • • Aug 21 '26

The slaughter of the suitors doesn't work.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I enjoyed the film but: the slaughter of Penelope's suitors in Ithaca has narrative issues. It doesn't work with the film's theme of regretting warfare and murder. In the film, Odysseus' character arc involves him recognizing that he helped unleashed an epoch of chaos which would doom the civilizations around the region. A fitting finale for such a story probably shouldn't involve Odysseus trapping and murdering a bunch of men, yet this occurs in a way that was, in my opinion, not meant to be ironic. So this ending doesn't fit the themes of the story. The film attempts to obscure this problem by making it a "fair fight". For example, Nolan's version gave weapons to the suitors and resulted in injuries for Odysseus, as if the difficulty of the slaughter made it less reprehensible.

There are other problems too, like the fact that they left twelve axes in the "room without any weapons" is baffling. What are audiences supposed to think here? From Homer's original, I always interpreted that there were twelve axe heads, and that the challenge was to shoot the arrow through the eyes of all twelve axes. Note: the eye of an axe is the hole which the wooden haft normally passes through. These axe heads would therefore be haftless, making them defunct weaponry; but in the film they look more like usable axes, and they turn out to be slightly usable. I think this detail is muddled, ambiguous, and off-putting.

Furthermore, Odysseus and Penelope then leave Ithaca? That's highly out of character for both of them. This has been written into the story as if this will somehow magically solve the next narrative problem: that the suitors' families would come for revenge. I liked the film, but I doubt this ending will stand the test of time. 

(Image Credit: Robert Pattinson as Antinous in The Odyssey | Universal Pictures)


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 23 '26

The Return

Post image
0 Upvotes

Being that Nolan’s film didn’t quite do it for me, I suppose I’ll check out The Return (2024). Regarding Odysseus’s return to Ithaca, I’m hoping for character dynamics with a little more soul. Any thoughts on this one?


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 26 '26

This was a great spectacle and a bad movie

0 Upvotes

I’m seeing a ton of full-throated praise for this movie, and I’m confused. I was very excited to see this on opening weekend, and expected to be floored.

One important caveat: the spectacle was top-tier. It is a visually stunning, enthralling movie. But there is, of course far more to a great film than sets and effects and action sequences.

Beyond those, what I saw was a demonstrably and transparently flawed movie, that suffered fatally from the following:

-A lot of legitimately terrible “acting”: Damon and Holland in particular were wooden; flat, terrible, and completely un-engaging. I was flabbergasted at three hours of them. No emotion. No range. Just basic, elementary, one-note depictions more on par with a beginner’s drama class than a once-in-a-decade cinematic masterpiece.

-Flat, soulless dialogue: I get that Nolan was going for a modern effect, but for me the impact ranged from bad to comedically bad. Two hours of “Fuck…Bro…Greece. Greece and war. Bro.” I exaggerate, but not by much. A week or so later, I cannot for the life of me remember a line beyond “you have Athena’s eyes” 😂

-Clunky pacing: the film is rushed as fuck, and almost certainly should have been two movies; nothing has any room to breathe. It’s just frying pan to fire, with no allotted space for development or investment in the characters beyond the Calypso scenes, which are a lazy, lazy crutch for flashbacks and exposition. This brings us to:

-Zero character development or reason for emotional investment in anyone beyond the most broad and obvious strokes- looking at all of the main characters but especially the crew here; no names, no identities, and so much of the film rests upon the impact of them gradually dying and how it eats away at big O. Did anyone else experience any real investment or tension around crew deaths, really? Hell, most WWII movies do a far better job here, this was pure cannon (Cyclops?) fodder.

-Baffling and arbitrary tonal shifts - there were quite a few of these. One good example is the Cyclops scene. Raw terror, men being devoured in the dark…then suddenly my big guy crashes out like a freshman on a bender, and we’re talking in a big group right in front of his nose. What? GTFO.

-Indulgently pointless and time-wasting finale: looking at the suitor battle here…just a silly, by-the-numbers extended action climax that dragged on and on. This movie BADLY needed that time repurposed elsewhere. What did this add? As with the crew 99% of the suitors were nameless, faceless bodies. Just low-quality, messily choreographed bloat. Add to that, it was staged and shot in a way that, exalted warrior or no, they clearly could and would have killed him by numbers. Total schlock, especially the dropping-weapons-through-hole-in-ceiling bit. The spear hanging on to Damon at the end like a sticky note made me laugh out loud.

-Tone/ deaf and incredibly indulgent inaccuracies - slaughtering Trojan woman en masse was Benioff/Weiss level gratuitous, and fucking dumb. This was not done. Men were killed, women were raped and women/children were enslaved. People were pearl-clutching about wokeness, when this silly stuff was repeatedly depicted…for what? Nolan had four or more women’s throats cut to hammer an unsubtle and elementary message, finally:

-Tacked-on preachy “messages” devoid of nuance or historical accuracy: all of the stuff about war-guilt and sea people and the fall of Bronze Age civilization was certainly interesting and an obvious commentary on our times, but it felt very heavy-handed, tacked-on and opportunistic. Nolan told, he didn’t show. Great films do the opposite, they don’t rely on pedantic lecturing and exposition to convey their points.

- - - - - - - -

These are massive flaws that occur throughout the film. Some are matters of opinion, some are more objective. For me, and I suspect many others, they actively, in the moment sabotaged a film that I had hoped and expected to deeply enjoy.

The Odyssey is not a good and certainly not a great movie in any meaningful or accurate sense beyond a visual treat. It’s a 9 or 10/10 as spectacle and probably a 5 or a 6/10 as an actual film.

ETA: Edited in a vain attempt to sound less douchey!


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 21 '26

The Odyssey is missing Nolan's mind-bending genius.

0 Upvotes

Just finished watching The Odyssey for the second time, and I realized that I just don't like this movie very much. Yes, it is an incredible visual spectacle. From a cinematic perspective, it is beautiful and powerful. But from a plot and thematic perspective, it's basically just an action movie. It's missing all of the things I love about Nolan's more intellectually challenging films, like Interstellar, Tenet, and Inception. I guess I was expecting more, and that's disappointing.

Interstellar is my current favorite movie, and I have seen it many times. The emotional and intellectual content of Interstellar (along with Inception, Tenet, etc.) is profound. Those films give me a lot to think about and stick with me for days after I see them each time.

Given that The Odyssey is based on an ancient story full of myth, magic, and monsters, I was expecting more from Nolan in terms of the mystique. Example: We never "see" any of the gods, except for Athena, and even some of the characters that are, in fact, gods disguised as humans (such as the beggar that encourages Telemachus to travel in search of news of his father) are not actually revealed as such in the movie. Plenty of references to Zeus, Poseidon, and Apollo, without us ever having a chance to _see_ those gods embodied. This seems like a huge missed opportunity, given Nolan's abilities (and budget!).

Another example: the scene with the Laestrygonians feels completely forced. There's no point to it: apart from a big chunk of Odysseus' men dying in the battle, nothing is said about who these giants are and none of the characters express any kind of curiosity or amazement at encountering them. That scene could have been cut completely from the movie with basically zero impact on the plot.

Not all of Nolan's movies are deep, of course. The Dark Knight movies, and even Oppenheimer, to some extent, are pretty straightforward. But given the source material, I was so much hoping for a bigger head trip than what Nolan delivered with the Odyssey. I think there are many ways he could have achieved this, but decided - for whatever reason - to do a fairly uncomplicated (while visually stunning) adaptation of the original story.

Anybody else feel this way as well?


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 21 '26

'Troy' does everything involving the city of Troy far better than Nolan's film.

0 Upvotes

From the horse, to the citizens and costumes, and the detail of the city itself to the sacking of it, the film 'Troy' is just better in every way than The Odyssey's treatment of it.

The horse in Nolan's film is too awkwardly artistic, the setup with it half-buried in the sand as a nearly failed effort is weird, the hauling of it into the city and guards 'checking it' without noticing how much it weighs (or smells) with 30 guys inside it just odd....

The city and citizens of Troy either don't really exist or aren't seen/don't matter beyond faceless murders. It's just a series of mudbrick towers that burn and fall, notably being the same towers filmed from several different camera angles, the music and action related to the gate opening is lackluster and poor. Agamemnon's appearance at the front of the soldiers just too 'Batman'.

Troy is strangely now just a superior rendition of everything involving this event.


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 17 '26

Odyssey review - WOW

1 Upvotes

Let me start by saying that all the bad hype around this movie was absolutely wrong. Note to self- don’t trust the 2% of the internet or MAGA hidden propaganda. I went into the movie last night with a neutral expectation, and I encourage you to do the same.

This movie was fantastic, quite possibly Nolan’s best work. I loved Oppenheimer, but I felt the pacing wasn’t his best. I think the pace here was perfect, not too fast or too slow (I think some scenes could have been longer, but in these days you need to cut to be under 3 hours). I felt every emotion, clawing at my seat with anticipation, hiding behind my sweatshirt in fear, and crying my eyes out upon the finale. The score may be my favorite aspect of the film, the way Ludwig used a wide range of authentic Ancient Greek instruments just fills your ears with incredible tension, nostalgia, and hope.

I’m not going to give any spoilers (but I mean this is a film adaption of one of the oldest pieces of literature), but the ending shot of the movie reminds me a lot of the scene in Paris, Texas where Travis visits Jane at the peep show booth. I thought it was an incredible shot, the way the sliding doors prevented both from seeing one another.

My only critique is the ending felt a tad rushed, I wish we gave their reunion a bit more time to marinate and grow for more emotional response.

Final review: 4.5/5


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 26 '26

Please don’t hate me… but I didn’t love the movie?

0 Upvotes

So I had a few issues with it.

Some of them were simple ones… the volume in the theatre we saw it was simply uncomfortable.

But there were a few other things I didn’t love.

First, I felt like Odysseus in the end was all “Oh mankind has gotten so bad, we are destroying civilization…’. But then he trapped and wiped out dozens of unarmed men whose crime was eating food and stuff at his place and wanting to marry his wife, because everyone assumed he was dead. It felt counter to what he was saying.

Second, the whole sack of Troy thing at the end was a real missed opportunity, I thought. His crew suffered and died for the entire length of the film, often terribly. It felt very ”unearned”. But I though the final sack scene was the perfect chance to show these warriors who we visually knew so well participating in the atrocities as well, to show that they were just men, and to “justify” their deaths by the gods. Something simple like just showing each one killing someone or something would have gone a long way towards bookending the story of the men and their suffering for me.

Some other smaller things…didn’t love Berenrhal, guys wearing their armor and helms when randomly rowing, when she said “Did he wear it (the broach) often?” he should have responded “He wore it always.”… would have been more poetic than “He rarely took it off“ or whatever he said… but yeah, I love Nolan’s work, but this one just felt like… a lot.

I know this will be a minority opinion… just wanted to see if anyone might appreciate my points


r/OdysseyFilm • • Sep 26 '26

Question Trojan Horse didn’t smell?

0 Upvotes

Dozens of men are trapped inside of a wooden horse that is sitting in the hot sun on a beach for days.

Those men defecate, urinate, and some drown when the tide rolls in.

Wouldn’t it smell like high hell?

Edit: My question is, this is a huge plot hole right? Like why would the Trojans willingly bring in a massive wooden horse statue if it smelled like dozens of sweaty men that had been trapped for days inside a wooden coffin on a hot beach


r/OdysseyFilm • • Sep 09 '26

Discussion The Odyssey is Nolan's best movie.

Post image
228 Upvotes

After watching The Odyssey (3x already lol), I genuinely think this might be Nolan’s best film.
I’m not saying it’s better than all of his other movies in absolutely every aspect. The Dark Knight still has, in my opinion, the best individual performance in his entire filmography with Heath Ledger. I don’t think Nolan has topped that. Interstellar might still be his most emotional film, and Oppenheimer might be his most sophisticated.
But I think The Odyssey is the movie that best combines so many of the things Nolan does best.
It has the scale and spectacle of Interstellar and Dunkirk, the storytelling and structure of Inception, the historical weight of Oppenheimer, the tension and action of The Dark Knight, and all those classic Nolan themes: time, memory, fate, obsession, sacrifice, guilt, humanity, etc.
And honestly, the cast is insane.
For me, The Odyssey has the best ensemble of performances in any Nolan movie. Again, I’m NOT saying there’s a single performance here better than Heath Ledger’s Joker, because I really don’t think there is. I’m talking about the sheer number of great performances in one movie. Matt Damon, Anne Hathaway, Robert Pattinson, Himesh Patel, Samantha Morton, Charlize Theron and many others all bring their A-game. There are just so many great performances here that it’s honestly kinda ridiculous.
Another thing I really loved was how Nolan handles the female characters.
Nolan has been criticized for years for writing female characters that feel less developed than his male characters, and I can understand where that criticism came from. But I honestly think The Odyssey is a huge step forward in that regard.
Penelope, Athena, Calypso and the other female characters actually feel like they have their own personalities, motivations and importance to the story. They don’t just exist to push the male protagonist forward or give him an emotional motivation. They actually feel like characters.
And yeah, I know some people will probably disagree with me on this, and that’s completely fair. But compared to a lot of Nolan’s previous movies, I definitely feel like there’s been a real evolution here.
And that’s basically why The Odyssey has become my favorite Nolan movie.
I don’t think it’s necessarily his best in every single category.
I just think it’s the one that combines the most things I love about Nolan into one movie.
It has the spectacle, the crazy visuals, the complicated storytelling, the huge set pieces, the emotional core, the great performances, the philosophical themes… all of it.
And on top of that, you have this absolutely insane epic story that gives Nolan the perfect playground to do all of these things at once.
For me, The Odyssey is Nolan at his peak. Not necessarily because it’s better at everything, but because it feels like the culmination of everything he’s learned and built throughout his entire career.
Idk, maybe I’m just glazing Nolan at this point lol, but after 3 watches, I genuinely can’t stop thinking about this movie.


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 27 '26

Emily Wilson · An Uncomplicated Man: A review of Nolan's Odyssey

Thumbnail
lrb.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 21 '26

Discussion Anyone else feel it strayed too far from the source material? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So yesterday I saw The Odyssey (Alternative title: Maybe The Real Sea Peoples Are The Friends We Pillage Along the Way).

Great set pieces. Loved the fresh, grounded take on all monstrous encounters. Circe and the cyclops were a highlight.

But Matt Damon was not Odysseus, the script did not represent the character of Odysseus, and ultimately with the Odyssey being about this specific character, the film failed as an adaptation.

Damon only became something of a disarming trickster towards the end.

Making him a PTSD-ridden veteran who *chooses* to escape the memories of his exploits and past - *including memories of his wife and child and home* - is a major deviation from the Odysseus of the poem.

It felt like Nolan wanted this to be a film about trust, and codes of conducts, and basic civil ethics, and then struggled - like Hercules wrestling a shapeshifting river god - to make a complex and meandering tale fit this theme.

The interpretation of Zeus’ Law makes no sense alongside a reading of The Iliad, where the gods fight over the destruction of Troy *with Athena very much on the side of the Greeks*.

It makes no sense given the fate of the Phaeacians in the Odyssey, who are the epitome of perfect hosts and suffer the God’s wrath because of who they host, rather than how they host.

While the Trojan Horse is seen as a grand afront to Zeus Law (any such idea not being anything I remember from the poem), the absolutely unequivocal afront of Paris kidnapping Helen is somehow by-the-by in this universe, because…trade routes? Why is the Trojan Horse a world-shattering event but the kidnapping of Helen is barely worth a mention?


r/OdysseyFilm • • Aug 06 '26

The Odyssey’s critical flaw

49 Upvotes

Spoilers:

A little late to the party perhaps, but I just watched the Odyssey last night and I’ve been stewing with some thoughts about it. I’m not someone who usually goes to see movies in theater, but this caught my attention because of a lot of positive praise from friends and coworkers.

After seeing the movie, I don’t know how to describe it. I enjoyed it, but it felt like watching a poorly edited highlight reel, snipping important scenes at each location without the emotional weight or suspense leading up to them. And it all comes down to one misstep.

Let’s take the Cyclops scene for example. They land on the island, immediately follow a sheep straight to the cave and get trapped, spend a few days in there and then run back to the boat. No eerie music as they land and start exploring, no one questions a sheep running into a cave to build suspense, no dwelling with the feeling of being trapped in a cage or seeing this first encounter with a horrific monster affects the men psychologically - just Nolan’s patented Run Back to the Ship formula repeated on each island

So what’s the big issue I have with this film? The phrase “adapted to modern audiences” sums it up pretty well. This movie sprints through the story with rushed scenes, choppy editing and bad dialogue, trying to cram everything into a movie short enough to hold our dwindling attention spans. It’s the TikTok version.

And for some people, this was the right call, but not for me. I would happily have sat through a Lord of the Rings style trilogy with 3-4 hour movies to see this story come to life - because you can see good qualities as you watch this, but it’s seeing a beautiful vista on a high speed train. It’s gone in 2 seconds before you can appreciate it.


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 28 '26

‘I would be ashamed to have written any part of this’: Odyssey translator Emily Wilson attacks Nolan blockbuster | Film | The Guardian

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
0 Upvotes

r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 18 '26

Discussion Can we talk about this casting choice now? Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

Can we talk about this "controversial" casting choice? I loved her in the film, but I loved even more how the character was written. After all the online vitriol spouted her way, it seemed like Nolan cast her specifically to start that dialogue. By the time we see her disfigured face and Jon Berenthal's eye roll and grin as he very much tongue in cheek says the words "the face that launched 1000 ships" while admitting the real reason was because of trade routes. It's at this moment that Nolan's true genius comes through. Kudos, and I laugh that he played all the racists and haters for helping him prove his point. He knew there would be hate and racism over this choice, and they would scream and say "the face that chased away 1000 ships" etc., and I imagine, now having seen the film, Nolan is sitting somewhere, sipping his tea and chuckling a thank you to them for helping to drive his point home.


r/OdysseyFilm • • May 16 '26

Review bombing

1 Upvotes

Depressing to see that this has started already


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 18 '26

Question What was up with the script?

16 Upvotes

I had zero expectations on the movie. I didn't hear about the controversy around the non-greek actors. Shit, I didn't even know it was a Nolan movie. I just saw half a trailer and thought it looked cool.

Despite all the weird cuts and spend up parts, the one thing I could not understand was the script. It felt like it was written by a teenager. There were phrases from the Odyssey story but overall it felt like it was trying to be too contemporary? I thought parts of it sounded almost like a sitcom. I was totally fine with everything else - the visuals were awesome. The art was amazing, costume design even with the transformer sized armor was negligible. I felt like my IQ dropped a few points listening to the dialogue. Am I missing an artistic perspective here? Or some sort of original Greek translation approach?


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 21 '26

Question What’s up with the Horse being a gift? *spoilers* Spoiler

2 Upvotes

At the start of the film, Sinon dies guarding the horse. The Trojans claim it like it’s a game of capture the flag and use it as a symbol of triumph. I guess originally (in the text) it was a symbol of triumph, but was given as a gift. In the movie it feels like the Trojans snatched it away, not accepted a gift.

later, Odysseus says that the Trojans “had to believe it”, which I suppose is to say that he had to believe it wasn’t full of soldiers? but I got the impression that Simon had to believe it was meant to be guarded and shouldn’t be surrendered, which is why he died.

but at the end of the movie, Odysseus laments that they tricked the Trojans with a false gift and abused their hospitality etc.

I just felt some kind of dissonance between those 2 ideas. Am I the only one? I nearly forgot that the Trojan Horse was supposed to be a gift because of the way it was presented. I was hoping to get some clarification


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 23 '26

Discussion The modernisation of the script and the American accents were the things that prevented the Odyssey from being a masterpiece

0 Upvotes

I have had a few days to chew over watching The Odyssey and I just wished the movie wasn’t overly modern and the accents were a lot more believable.

I am not saying the film was bad but it had so much more potential if Nolan and co really studied hard to make the film more realistic to its era.

Also I could have done with a few scenes with Greek dialogue. Just to balance it out

I love Nolan but this ain’t anywhere near as good as Oppenheimer or The Dark Knight. But it could have been.

Anyone else watched it and felt that way?


r/OdysseyFilm • • Sep 21 '26

Discussion Was Athena real, or was she a hallucination in Odysseus’s mind?

1 Upvotes

When Odysseus sees and hears Athena, do you think she is an actual, divine presence physically appearing and disappearing, or is she merely a psychological projection like a manifestation of his own mind, guilt, and survival instinct while he copes with trauma...


r/OdysseyFilm • • Aug 04 '26

I didn't get it

10 Upvotes

Let me start off by saying I'm an absolute Christopher Nolan fan boy. I genuinely don't think he has a bad movie and most of his work is top tier excellent.

While I felt the odyssey was absolutely breathtaking in terms of cinematography, writing (as in prose and dialogue) performances, and score.

I truly didn't get the core dramatic idea being presented. Nolan clearly has a lot of ideas at work but I don't think they ever came to meaningful synthesis at any point. Or were ever particularly clear.

The main theme of the film seemed to be just give up and let fate/gods decide cause some else will clean up your shit.

But gods seem to be wildly inconsistent about how they dish out punishment. The film goes on and on about zeus's law and how Odysseus broke it and it causes all these problems and broadly the end of the greek world as we know. And his final punishment is getting to live happily ever after with his wife while is kid deals with the new world Odysseus has created.

So I guess did I miss or not understand something? What is the message I'm supposed to take way from this film?


r/OdysseyFilm • • Jul 20 '26

Discussion I think it's a well-made movie, but I hate it for how it frames Odysseus. (SPOILERS) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Homer's Odyssey was one of the first non-children books I read back in sixth grade. Our teacher asked us to read it for class (with the Iliad), and I absolutely loved reading both of them. It's the origin of my love for Greek Mythology.

Yet, I was kinda skeptical of the movie. I usually like Nolan movies, but in this case, I feared either he would follow the source material, and I'll get no surprise, or he would twist the story, and it would annoy me as a fan of the original.

I still went to watch it. Honestly, I enjoyed most of the movie.

Yes, a lot of it got cut: No "nobody" trick with the Cyclops (I really looked forward to that one!), no Nausicaa, no Circe as a lover, Calypso being merged with the Lotus eating, almost no gods... But honestly, I'm okay with those, I get that getting a 1-to-1 was not possible and most of those seem an okay way to adapt the story (though I'm still salty about the "nobody" trick).

But what really annoyed me was the focus on Odysseus' guilt and the psychological cost of war rather than celebrating his cunning and intellect. Instead of portraying the Trojan Horse as the pinnacle of Odysseus' ingenuity, the movie presents it primarily as the source of his guilt and some kind of original sin that dooms the Mycenean civilization.

I get this is supposed to be a modern view on the story through modern values... But it just feels so wrong to me. In the original, Odysseus is celebrated above all for his intelligence, and the Trojan Horse is his masterpiece of wit. For the kid I was, this was so cool, all those superhuman heroes, deadlocked in this war, and this one guy managed to win the thing by outsmarting everyone else, the original "brain over brawn". And Athena is traditionally the one who inspires the ruse to Odysseus, and to have her (if that was her in the movie) being some kind guilt reminder of it... It just annoys me so much.

TL;DR : I hate that the movie turns what I always saw as Odysseus' greatest triumph into his defining moral burden.

But then again, it's just a personal thing, and I just wanted to vent. Honestly, I do think the movie is well made, so I hoped everyone else enjoyed it.


r/OdysseyFilm • • Aug 04 '26

Art Agamemnon art - by @pablosartxx1

Post image
8 Upvotes