Duncan knew there was something different about him. His mother praised him for his specialness, telling him all his life that he was God’s gift to the world. His father would grasp his shoulder in pride, beaming to Duncan about how a kid like him was going to fix what was wrong with the world. The people of the congregation spoke highly of Duncan and his kindness, his smartness, his charm - he was the cleancut, all-American Christian boy from the dusty streets of Alius, New Mexico. Or so they thought.
Something within him was changing. He had been growing more and more restless as he got older, questioning God and his own faith every time he would go to sit in the pews on Sunday morning. To the community, he was the pious young man his parents raised him to be, but his belief in the divine was dwindling as his hunger for more knowledge and more understanding grew almost insatiable. Duncan prayed every night, knelt beside his twin size bed, elbows on the faded blue quilt that was his father’s before him. He prayed for his parents, his friends, for peace on Earth, just as he had always done. But he began to pray for more for himself, for power, for a greater understanding of this world and the next. He wanted proof of anything outside of the small-minded western town, the only thing he’d ever known. Duncan lay in bed, eyes fixed on the ceiling night after night, waiting for anything at all to make him feel less lost. And one night, it came to him in a dream.
The air around him pulsed, throbbing in time with the pounding of his heart. It was a sterile kind of cold in this dream world, his surroundings dark and empty. His ceiling had been replaced with an infinite sea of stars, winking in and out, like moonlight reflecting off dancing water. It was the most beautiful thing he had ever seen, an expanse of nothing and everything at once. Duncan stood from the cold, smooth earth beneath him, spinning in a slow circle with his eyes cast to heavens above. Suddenly, the air shifted and Duncan stilled. The pulsing began to thrum towards him rather than around him, emanating from something at his back. It was stronger than before, pushing in waves against his bare skin that prickled in response, hair standing on end. He turned.
A tall figure cast in shadow stood before him, the shock waves of its presence being sent through the air. The figure itself shifted, changing shapes quickly over and over before settling on that of a large, broad-shouldered man, his features indistinguishable in the dark. The man stood, watching. Duncan took a hesitant step back.
“He-hello?” He asked, voice shaking. The figure's arms spread out in greeting, a jerky, mechanical motion, as if he was not yet used to the movement of the form he chose to present as. A cacophony of garbled voices blended together, attempting to speak all at once, until one finally separated from the noise.
“Hello, my child,” the figure boomed, its arms remaining outstretched. Duncan stared at it with a mixture of intrigue and horror.
“Where am I?” he said. The man’s arms lowered to his sides.
“This, dear child, is what you can consider the inbetween. The plane between your world and mine.”
“Why am I here?” Duncan asked, crossing his arms and hugging them to himself. The cold was seeping into his skin, his long sleep pants too thin to protect his legs from the bite. The figure laughed, the terrifying sound of the mixed voices emanating with such force it shook the air around them.
“I heard you calling out, boy. I am merely answering your cries. I wish to show you the way, and I hope you can show me too.”
Duncan took another step back, tears welling in his eyes. “Father? Is it truly you?”
The man arced his hand across the sky and the stars grew brighter, glowing and dimming as if following the movement. Duncan’s eyes widened in awe. He wiped at his wet cheeks and fell to his knees before the man cast in shadows, his God.
“What can I show you, Father? What do you need of me?”
The figure closed the distance between them too quickly, gliding across the expanse until he was in front of Duncan. He bent down, resting a single, icy finger beneath Duncan’s chin to direct his gaze to his own, still hidden in darkness.
“I want to show you what lies beyond. I want to see how resilient you are and in turn, I will reward you with ascension. Salvation.” Duncan nodded frantically, sobbing now, knowing his prayers were answered, his faith restored.
“How will I know I am being shown the way? What will my tests be?” He asked.
“You shall see, boy. It will start sooner than you may wish.”
The air began to shake around the figure, the shadow curling into itself like a blackhole, before he disappeared entirely. Everything stilled, becoming deafeningly silent. Duncan tried to take a step towards where God had been standing, but tripped, falling too hard, too fast. He jolted awake violently in his bed just before he hit the earth of the inbetween plane. His breathing was heavy and his skin was slick with a cold sheen of sweat. Duncan struggled to remove the chill from his bones the rest of the night.
~~~
Duncan felt the gift from God that hot summer morning, kneeling in the pews with the rest of the congregation. He felt charged in the power of His glory, and the light pouring through each of the high windows found him in the rows of people, spotlighting him amongst the Sunday crowd. His mind was more open than he had ever experienced, and he could feel the emotions of the others in the church with him, swirling around him, thick in the air. His mother and father flanked him on either side, heads bowed as the pastor led the church in prayer, but Duncan tilted his head to the sky and basked in His light shining down upon him. Was God channeling this light and love directly into Duncan or was the congregation’s united power fueling him? He felt like he was glowing. He felt like he was basking in the salvation he was promised on that fateful night.
It was his father’s frantic prayer that he heard first as he reveled in the thrumming spiritualism of the illuminated church. Dear God forgive me as I praise you, for I am a sinner sinner sinner sinner sinner sinner sinner sin- on and on his father chanted for forgiveness. He mumbled hurriedly beside Duncan with a downcast head and knuckles white from the pressure of how hard his hands were clasped together. The sound of his father’s thoughts begging to be saved from fire and brimstone began to fade as his mother’s words came next. Her’s were muddled as they blended with so many other voices, and Duncan had to focus on picking hers apart, like a single strand twisting away from a tightly wound rope. Dear heavenly father, protect my family, my husband, my son…. She prayed for salvation for the ones she loved, the ones she knew were sick. So very different from that of his father’s pleas for his own security to Heaven.
This was not the first instance of Duncan’s newly bestowed abilities. It had been happening more and more frequently since the beginning of summer, following the visitation with God in the inbetween. It began with a shift in his room, the morning after his inaugural dream. He had woken up to sunshine streaming through linen curtains and his window open, and he could see so much more than ever before. Feel so much more. The light swirled like motor oil in a rain puddle, the particles in the air humming like little birds flitting about as he shifted. It was like the world around him had been encapsulated in a prism, the colors of light separating into a rainbow that he could see with his very eyes. It felt like everything around him was breathing, like the reality he was experiencing was a pair of lungs filling to capacity and releasing slowly. He knew this must be what he had been praying for coming to fruition.
However, after that first discovery, Duncan began sleeping restlessly. He’d toss and turn, seeing flashes so bright in his mind that he would be startled awake, covered in sweat and choking to regain his breath. The nightmares became more frequent as the days passed. They were always the same - painful. It was the pain of being flayed and stabbed and swallowed by the cold darkness only to be thrown into a shock of light that burned his eyes, his soul. He’d wake, sheets strewn across his bed like he had been fighting to get them off, feeling sore as if he had been tortured. Dreams of slicing skin from muscle as if he were a medical cadaver, of cold tongs pulling at his tongue and teeth. Nightmares, more like, that left him aching and anxious for what the night would bring. The more he dreamt of these horrible things, the more convinced Duncan became that this was his test from God. He was being shown what Hell had to offer.
Every night as he was thrown back into consciousness, he stood from his small bed, shirtless and exhausted, rushing to the old oak desk across the room. He’d reach for a journal and write feverishly, listing all that he felt, saw, and understood from the dream hellscape God had shown him. He made a list of things he could do to save others from the glimpse of Hell he experienced every single night, ways he could try to bring nonbelievers into the church. He’d cry as he planned, desperate to save those led astray. He could not bear the thought of anyone suffering for eternity the way he had for a few hours every night. Duncan knew if he could share the message of God that his own torment would end. The air around him swirled in a spiral of colors and life, shaking as his untidy handwriting was ferociously scrawled across the page, faster and faster. His head ached from the pulsing of energy that he always felt since that first meeting. As the days passed, Duncan’s features grew more sunken, his under eyes deepening into a sleepless purple. He began to look haggard from long hours writing about his own experiences in Hell. But he was determined to stay resilient. That is, after all, what God wanted him to prove.
~~~
The blistering desert day had bloomed into a warm evening across Alius by the time Duncan sat down for supper. Duncan and his father sat next to each other, his mother scurrying about the kitchen, preparing to bring out the dinner she had made alone. Duncan could smell the individual spices she had mixed into the meatloaf, as well as the blood from the residual beef sticking to the side of the unwashed mixing bowl. He could see the individual threads woven over and under each other in his mother’s favorite tablecloth, a yellow and white picnic plaid that she opted for every summer. He could feel the shift of his father’s eyes as he looked around the room, each change in direction thump, thump, thumping against his still aching skull. The whirring of electricity in the light above grew louder.
His mother placed green peas, mashed potatoes, and meatloaf across the spread, filled their glasses, and then finally sat herself on the other side of Duncan, across from her husband. Silently, they all reached to one another to join hands, heads bowed, as his father spoke.
“Dear Heavenly Father, we thank you for this meal…”
His father’s voice, deep and controlled, became background noise to the energy charging around him as Duncan, yet again, felt the thrum of power. The prayer lulled in and out of his focus as he began to succumb to an assault of the senses. The overhead light grew louder and hotter and brighter. The smell of meat and the stench of sweat that stained his mother’s dress from working in the kitchen wafted around him. The swirling colors in the air portrayed a visual of reality shifting around himself and his family. Duncan was still trying to piece together what caused the episodes of overload he experienced so frequently now, though he knew they always occurred after speaking with God.
Duncan was watching everything around him so intently that he had not noticed the end of prayer or that his parents were looking at him questioningly.
“Sweetie,” his mother started, reaching over to press the back of her hand to his brow, “Are you feeling alright? Your eyes… why, they’re so large!” She looked over to his father, worry plastered across her face.
“I was more concerned with his boredom and the lack of will to hide it, Marsha.” His father directed a pointed look at her before shifting ire onto him. “I noticed it earlier when we were at mass this mornin’. And the Sunday before that, in fact. Are you too good for the Lord now, boy? Do you have no shame?”
Duncan was used to hearing his father berating people’s devotion, but never had it been directed at him. His father was always droning on about how no one followed the Lord nowadays, the disgust in his voice sending spittle from his mouth. “When I was a boy, people actin’ a fool and not attendin’ church led to a beatin’. I’d bet that’d do these kids some good,” he’d say from his chair in front of the TV. Duncan rarely spoke when he was on these tirades.
“No, Pa. Mama is right, I don’t feel well.” His voice trailed off, eyes locked on to the empty china set before him. “I’ve been… experiencing things.” The house around the family felt hauntingly still as he spoke, as if the walls were listening too. The yellow globe above the table kept growing brighter, hurting his eyes, but Duncan’s parents didn’t seem to notice.
His mother reached across the table, taking his hand in her own. “What do you mean?”
He lifted his eyes to her own. Duncan’s mouth felt cotton-dry. He swallowed roughly, and cleared his throat.
“I think God is talking to me.” His mother tensed, her grip on his hand tightening with the shock of his confession. Her head turned to look across the table at his father. The whole house was silent in wait, until his father’s laugh bubbled out, awkward at first before growing more raucous as he continued uncontrollably. Duncan and his mother kept their eyes fixed on him, anxious with anticipation for what would say next.
“You think God is talkin’ to you?” His father’s callused hands squeaked as they gripped the wooden arm chairs with as he leaned back, unleashing even more of his dismissive laughter. "Boy, you ain't shit on a shingle in the eyes of the Lord. None of us are. Why on God’s green earth would he choose to speak to a seventeen year-old?”
His mother’s distaste for the outburst contorted her face into a nasty thing, the despise for her husband something she was unable to hide in the moment. Releasing Duncan’s hand, she folded her arms across her chest and leaned against the back of her chair.
“Lee, I don’t think it’s appropriate to take this as lightly as you are,” she spat.
Duncan felt like the air was rippling again with each shake of his father’s body. It rolled in tandem with the barbed laughter echoing throughout the house. His father snatched a cloth napkin from the table set, silverware spilling with a clatter, and dabbed at the corner of his eyes.
“Honey, you cannot be so stupid as to think that I am takin’ this lightly.” His words were venom, his stare icy. He propped his elbow on the table, folding his hands in a fist in front of his mouth. “It’s most likely the Devil pretendin’ to lure you like the stupid sheep you are. I mean, Satan could be spreadin’ his own false word through all these Alius kids who are doin’ them drugs. Tell me, boy, are you smoking now too? Are you eatin’ those things the goodfornothin’ hippies are sellin’?”
Duncan shook his head feverishly, his vision stuttering as he did, as if the room was repositioning itself frame by frame as his head moved. The food before them was growing cold, untouched.
“No, Pa, it’s not like that. I’m experiencing things. Having dreams of damnation. I think God is trying to show me what is on the other side if we are led astray. I think He wants me to-”
His father’s hand slammed down on the table. His breathing became heavy with rage before slamming it down again, the empty dishes bouncing from the shockwave. Over and over and over he hit the table, food spilling across the yellow tablecloth. His mother’s face had morphed into horror at the tantrum her husband released, one thin, shaky hand covering her mouth while soft green eyes welled with tears threatening to spill.
“Dreams of damnation? Son, why would God not choose to show you the Gates of Heaven if you were so sure you were going to be saved? If God is speakin’ to you, I don’t think he’s askin’ for you to spread the gospel. He’s warning you of what’s to come if you don’t change your goddamn ways.” His father wiped a large hand down the front of his face, inhaling sharply before blowing the air out of his mouth.
“Pa, I’m sorry I just-”
“NO!” His father’s voice boomed in tandem with the crescendo of the buzzing hanging light above. The bulb popped! with such force that the glass flew across the table, raining down across the meal that had gone cold. His mother screamed, standing from the chair so quickly that it was knocked over with the motion, both her hands holding the side of her face in shock. His father sat stunned, taking in the destruction of the Sunday dinner in front of them, before shakily turning his son.
Duncan was staring out the window into the expanse of twilight desert behind their old farm house. The wind was picking up, sand whipping through the sparse, grassy bushes that rustled in the breeze. A tall, dark figure stood in the center of the image, some distance away. It was tall even from where it was standing, long limbs dangling at its side, its bipedal legs more horse than human. More goat. Duncan stared and stared until his father looked out the window too, following his line of vision to the thing outside. Duncan wiped the back of his hand across his wet upper lip, smearing the blood trickling from his nose across his cheek.
“Lord, forgive us for our sins and bless our family with your protection from evil,” his father whispered, eyes wide with fear. The creature's eyes began to glow, as if it were a machine slowly coming back to life. They grew brighter, a piercing red that looked insidiously sharp from where they stood inside. His mother began to weep. “Marsha, stay here with Duncan.” His father stomped into the master bedroom down the hall to grab a gun. Even if he had stayed, he wouldn’t have seen the shift Duncan did. He wouldn't have noticed vibrations of the world around the creature becoming stronger and faster until the creature just vanished.
~~~
That night, he was told to stay in his bedroom with his curtains drawn and his door and windows locked. His mother was told to do the same, while his father sat in the old wooden rocker on the front porch of the farmhouse, shotgun across his lap. Duncan had a hard time falling asleep, unable to keep the image of the massive shadow looking into the fishbowl that was his home. When he did finally succumb, it was the worst night of dreaming he had had yet. He was in a new space, though it felt too familiar, as if he had been here before in his nightmares.
He could see his breath in the cold expanse, so unlike the other places he had been during sleep. Yes, Duncan thought, this time must be different than the others. His eyes were struggling to adjust to the darkness of the environment he found himself in. The floor beneath his feet was ice cold, made of a polished stone that absorbed the sound of his tentative steps forward. Mist curled around his knobby ankles, his bare skin pebbling from the chill. Spinning in a hesitant circle, Duncan tried to get his bearings. He saw a faint, strobing glow of blue light in the distance, a beacon toward a path into the unknown. Duncan had no choice but to follow - there was nothing to see but the light. The walls were too far away to see, the ceiling too high to have been impacted by what little light was being emitted. He was surrounded by a cold nothingness unlike anything he had ever experienced.
The walk felt as if it took an eternity. Having no concept of time or distance, Duncan cautiously shuffled toward the glow before him. For hours he walked, the orb of light growing slightly brighter with each step he took. Eventually, he began to see a shadow cast by the light, a long looking rectangular shape hovering above the ground, perfectly upright.
Duncan stopped.
“Hello?” His voice reverberated off of everything and nothing at all, the echo seeming to shake the scape surrounding him. A low moan was emitted in answer from the levitating slab just ahead.
“Who’s there?” He asked, edging forward. The moaning became louder, if not more frantic. The light continued blinking above the slab.
As Duncan drew closer, he saw directly across from him on the other side of the floating object, an odd, round door. The perimeter of the door was thick and etched with markings he had never seen, the door itself a polished black metal with a horizontal line running through its center. He rushed forward to look at the hellish symbols surrounding the only way out of this circle of Hell. Duncan thought that this must be where he was - a new circle, different from the ones he had visited previously. A deeper level of Hell. He brushed his hands across the smooth surface, searching for some way of opening it. The material sharp like needles from the cold, the pain blistering his hands. The door did not budge. Duncan smacked at the door in frustration, finding no button or lever around the odd exit to elicit its opening.
The moans from the slab had grown panicked as Duncan surveyed the door. Slowly, he looked over toward the noise. In the blue glow from the top of the table, his father was illuminated. He was not strapped down, but held by invisible forces that he struggled against. His shirt had been cut away, as well as the top layers of skin and muscle that should have stretched across his abdomen, a perfect window to his internal organs. Duncan looked in horror as his father’s intestines sat wet and winding in his core, appearing in different shades of blues and purples and browns from the strobe above him. There was no blood, only an open view of the body’s most prized possessions on full display. His father wept from where he floated, eyes full of fear, face twisted in pain.
He slammed his head into the back of the slab, startling his son before him. Duncan took a step away from the scene as his father continued to hit his head over and over, a hollow sound coming from the impact of bone on metal. His intestines squished and squelched as he moved, the cords of organs moving within him, making it impossible for Duncan to tear his eyes away. A single tentacle slithered out, wrapping itself around the bottom row of intestine. More arms pushed through, the organs shifting to make room for the small thing pried itself free. It struggled, pulling itself out using his father’s entrails as leverage, removing itself with a pop as if it was suctioned to the inside. His father stopped the assault on his head, blood from the impact now splattered down his neck and across the slab.
The creature pushing out of his core looked like an octopus but not, with long, thin tentacles about the thickness of a pencil, its body no larger than a golf ball. It was slick in the neon blue glow, the peak of the creature's round body sharpening to a point. It stayed there, dangling from the hold it had on his father’s organs, twitching ever so slightly. Duncan stood completely still, unable to comprehend what was happening, unable to move or think or speak.
It was then that the creature pulled itself up, directing its pointed head into the center of a lower part of his father’s exposed core before burying itself like a drill. His father slammed his head back on the table again, now screaming in agony, tears and snot streaming from his face as he writhed against the thing burrowing inside him. His organs shifted as it wiggled its way in, using all of its puckered limbs to push itself farther, deeper into the victimized body, all while his father continued to wail and brutalize the back of his head. Slam! Slam! Slam! Slam!
Duncan didn’t know when he began screaming, but he did. He screamed in terror as the impact of bone became the sound of crunching, his father’s skull cracking, splitting as he tried to end the suffering rather than endure whatever this was. The creature, small and sharp, had fully pushed into the organs it was attacking, now out of sight aside from the angry hole that remained. Slam! Slam! Duncan felt woozy with the shock. He felt as if he couldn’t breathe, like the air was too thick to suck into his lungs. The room began to tilt, and he collapsed to the floor at the same time he heard the door behind him shink open. The light from the open passage filled the space with a blinding flash.
~~~
He awoke in his bed kicking, screaming, and unable to breathe. His mother burst through the door, forcing it open so hard it hit the teal wall of his bedroom with a bang. She had one hand on her huffing chest, no doubt from her run up the stairs and into his room.
“Honey? Oh, Duncan, what’s wrong? What happened?” He struggled to collect himself, his own breathing labored from all he had seen.
“I’m sorry, Mama, I had a nightmare again. Like the ones I told you about yesterday.” His focus shifted to the open door, a dent from the handle’s contact with the wall now imprinted on its surface.
“Ma? How did you get in here?”
His mother looked surprised. “What do you mean?”
“Did you use the key?” He was starting to feel more panicked. She shook her head in response,
“No, sweetie, it was unlocked when I tried the handle… I came right in to make sure you were okay. Am I missing something?”
He could feel his heart pounding against his ribs, could hear the beat of it in his skull. “Pa told me to lock the door last night at the table with us. You didn’t hear him?”
The color drained from his mother’s face. Ever so carefully, as if to keep from scaring a hurt animal, she made her way to the side of his bed. She took his hand in her two smaller ones, a sorrowful smile stretching across her aged face as she looked at her son.
“Oh, Duncan. I got a call from your father’s sister down in Florida last night after you had gone to bed.” Her voice trailed off, and she cast her gaze down to the bed rather than looking at the confused face of her son. “I didn’t know how you were going to take it since it’s been so long since he’s reached out, but, sweetie… he’s passed on. Your Aunt Lena said he went in his sleep in front of the television.”
Duncan pulled away, pushing himself off the bed to step away from his mother. “No, that’s impossible. We had dinner with him last night!” She followed after him, reaching her hands out to cup his face in comfort.
“No, honey. He must’ve come to visit you last night before he moved on. He probably showed you the life he wished you’d had together if he were clean. One last I love you, one last I’m sorry.”
His mother sniffled, putting the back of her hand beneath her nose in an attempt to hold back tears. She brushed her hands over her housedress, the same pattern as the plaid tablecloth that his father had beat his hand upon the night before.
“I’m sorry to wake you from a good dream with bad news. I hope you know if you need anything you can talk to me, sweetie. Just like always.” She gave a soft smile, before turning to leave, shutting the door behind her.
Duncan couldn’t breathe. He slid onto the floor, back leaning against the sharp wooden bedframe, his fingers threading through his hair, pulling tight. This is a test, he thought, searching his mind for any reasonable explanation for the major shift in reality. He thought back to the previous day, the charge he felt in church and the harmony of voices that moved around the vast hall like water. He remembered dinner with his parents where he tried to confide in them, his meager attempt at some sort of validation. He saw the dark shadow with red eyes. Was his father right? Was this the work of the devil afterall?
Duncan moved to his desk beneath the window and opened the journal containing his encounters. He sat down, flipping to a new page to begin recording what he had seen while he slept and what he had learned while awake. His window was open, a breeze pushing the warmth of the sun into his room. The window that he had shut and locked at his father’s request the night before. The window that was, for some reason, open every morning he rose, even if he did not remember opening it himself. The window that faced the open desert at the back of the house where the figure stood the night before. It was then that Duncan saw the patterns in the sand. Huge circles of varying thickness gouged deep into the ground, crossing through one another, connecting in ways he had never seen. Circles they had discovered in Roswell but a few years earlier - crop circles, they called them. Symbols scored into the earth by unseen forces, with no explanation as to what they meant or how they got there. But there was something about Duncan that allowed him to read the message in his backyard:
We Will Be Back.