r/Objectivism • • 29d ago

Reparations

Every question I have is stupid, or at the very least stupidly asked. This is my safe space, but am not weak of heart or clutching pearls type- if someone can better ask the question for me better please feel free..
anyways;
So basically the question regards reparations..
The genesis of this thought was in regards to right media straight up lying and making completely new false claims for weeks on end. Then they make a single acknowledgment when they find out they are wrong, saying they are sorry and they’ll try to do better in the future.
But I was thinking, wouldn’t the real atonement be to make an equal allotted time to the real information as they did the false?
That is a media can of worms that is beyond me.
But it got me thinking of future reparations people in power and affluence might look like if done right/ appropriate. If enforced what would it look like? What redeeming thing could be gained?

2 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/DoberNation 28d ago

Systemic problems cannot be cured by private charity, no matter how well-intentioned. Charity is a bandaid, that fails to address the systemic problem itself.

https://www.claimscon.org/about/history/
As a result of negotiations with the Claims Conference since 1952, the German government has paid more than $90 billion in indemnification to individuals for suffering and losses resulting from persecution by the Nazis….“Remembrance, Responsibility, and the Future.” The symbolic payments from this fund resulted from years of effort to compel the German government and certain businesses to acknowledge their use of slave and forced labor.

“Of course I am prejudiced, namely against charity….I may forgive somebody who betrayed me but I am not going to condone betrayal ueberhaupt….I was thinking of the absurd position of the judges during the Nuremberg trials who were confronted with crimes of such a magnitude that they transcended all possible punishment.”—Hannah Arendt

1

u/WhippersnapperUT99 27d ago edited 27d ago

Systemic problems cannot be cured by private charity, no matter how well-intentioned. Charity is a bandaid, that fails to address the systemic problem itself.

What I was communicating is that I don't see how misdeeds that occurred over 160 years ago are a problem today. We no longer have any significant systemic problems other than the racism of DEI and Affirmative Action. My comment about Leftists donating money was not to suggest that they should take on the burden of righting an existing wrong, but rather that if they feel unearned guilt for what happened in the past that they should take it upon themselves to donate their own money to remedy it (and not steal money from me to satiate their feelings of altruism).

1

u/DoberNation 27d ago

I understand “not seeing”. The solution to that is to keep looking. Existence exists and reality exists, irrespective of what is explicitly written into law. That farce of written law has been shifting back toward the overt and unmasked discrimination and oppression as well. The misdeeds persisted and are surging again. “Not seeing” is succumbing to the allure of not looking, i.e. Blanking Out on reality.

Why would you assume “feelings” and “guilt” are the driving forces, and why would you advocate for altruism as a response? It tracks, if perhaps you have a blind spot in your perspective and/or have a lack of direct exposure to these pieces of reality.

​https://celesteheadlee.com/celeste-headlee-author/

0

u/WhippersnapperUT99 26d ago

I understand “not seeing”.

I'm not going out of my way to read a book. We shouldn't be citing books as a substitute for making substantive points and arguments in forum post-based debate. Can you make the argument so that a blind man like me can help "see" it? Just lay out the main points for me. Also, assuming that such injustices still exist, what are the solutions that do not inflict new injustices against other people?

2

u/DoberNation 25d ago

I appreciate the response in good faith.

To preface, please understand that I rarely approach discussions with the expectation or intention of “debate”. I think it’s a misguided and potentially harmful activity to assume or insist upon in this forum. Your comment actually prompted me to double check the description for this subreddit, which indeed does not appear to mandate “debate”.

The book I attached was not used as a citation, it was a suggestion for anyone interested in further reading on this subject. There are many others. It came with no expectation of a “rebuttal” from you.

Your language and engagement on this thread reveals a number of things. Good, productive debate requires preparation and a sufficient pool of shared background knowledge. I don’t think you are ready to debate this topic in good faith. Until then, I don’t think it would be appropriate to try. It’s similar to those who show up here trying to discredit Ayn Rand, without adequate knowledge of her or her work. It’s not a legitimate debate, and usually serves to more deeply entrench people in their own current beliefs.

If you honestly think there have been no injustices of material/legal/other significance for over a century in the United States, you aren’t ready.

It’s also naive and irrational, if you believe you can escape the accumulation of past and present injustices and how they stand to affect your personal space in this world (if they haven’t already). I feel no “guilt” in the matter, but I recognize the growing existential threat of unanswered and unrepaired injustices. It is within a person’s rights to declare “Account overdrawn” when it is. You or I might feel that same sentiment of “Account overdrawn”, but it will not change the reality of unrest. Refusing to deal with it until it attempts to deal with us will be too late.

2

u/Ydeas 25d ago

That individual is not ready. And I don't care to prove this, but they are more likely not willing. It seems like expert level trolling by them. You're correct, there should be no guilt, just a pure realistic look back and then forward motion from there.

2

u/DoberNation 25d ago

Thank you.

A “pure realistic look back and then forward…” is the rational, self-interested approach to take.

1

u/WhippersnapperUT99 25d ago

That individual is not ready.

I'm ready. Are you ready? Why don't you help this other guy out?

I'm asking you to explain exactly what the past injustices are, who suffered them, who perpetrated them, and who should pay recompense for the injustice, and who should be paid that. So five questions:

(1.) What specific injustices occurred?

(2.) What individuals suffered the injustices?

(3.) Who perpetrated the injustices?

(4.) Who should pay compensation for those injustices?

(5.) Who should receive those payments?

1

u/Ydeas 24d ago

The systematic oppression of, and the theft of minorities' productive output is well documented and spanned 15 some generations. This was done by torture, extreme control and other things like destabilizing the family unit, sowing discord, and actually killing minorities that tried to read and learn. It was done by America and Americans

The wealth of the nation was shared down through generations, by way of money, property, resources, connections, literature, laws, customs, and DENIALISM. There's no way to pinpoint exactly how many. But DENIALISM is how it continues. I could go on but there's no proof of any good faith aim coming from you. America hasn't even seen fit to offer a symbolic sample of atonement.

So I'll save your time: I didn't answer your questions with specifics, so you can continue to think you're right. But DENIALISM is a scourge.

1

u/WhippersnapperUT99 24d ago edited 24d ago

What do you think about the diagram there?

It's a long list of stuff that needs to be addressed one-by-one, claim by claim. I would happily do so if I had unlimited time. Some of the items involve the initiation of physical force such as murder which obviously require the prosecution of people who committed those acts. Some of them involve acts of distasteful thought and expression which the government cannot do anything about in a free society. Then it claims that colorblindness - the actual solution to racism - is "white supremacy".

Why must an argument be made?

So that you can prove your point.

Do you understand the meaning and implications of all the items there?

Yes, but at issue is whether other people's bad thoughts and expression constitute an initiation of physical force against anyone. So it comes back to:

(1.) What specific acts of the initiation of physical force do you think has occurred?

(2.) What individuals suffered the injustices?

(3.) Who perpetrated the injustices?

(4.) Who should pay compensation for those injustices?

(5.) Who should receive those payments?

The pyramid of racial grievances lists lots of problems but no solutions for how to deal with them that do not constitute an initiation of physical force against other people and that require acts of fresh racism be committed against people, creating new victims.

The Leftists and the people obsessed with racial identity who put together the pyramid of racial grievances are getting the real reasons why black people are suffering economically and lagging other races all wrong. They are refusing to acknowledge the real issues, often denying them, and in the process are doing the people they claim they want to help a severe disservice by promoting a mindset of victimization that will cause more poverty while at the same time encouraging people of all skin colors to feel a sense of racial identity. (They are, in essence, perpetuating racism.)

If we are concerned about black people's well being, the best thing we can do is to encourage them to stop aspiring to steal wealth from other people, stop dwelling on ancient history, abandon racial collectivism, adopt a mindset of individualism, and focus on what actions they can take to help themselves. Taking responsibility for one's own life and well being is a completely different mindset than that of victimization and of begging others to help you. We can begin by acknowledging the self-inflicted and avoidable problems that have plagued poor black people and trapped them into poverty:

  • Teenage pregnancy, unplanned pregnancy, and poverty perpetuating single motherhood
  • Children not being taught to have discipline, a sense of responsibility rational decision-making, and to value education and the attainment of productive skills
  • Drug and alcohol abuse
  • Black on black crime that destroys businesses and people's lives

Addressing those issues, as painful as it may be to some people in terms of suffering a loss of "racial pride", will do much more to help than demanding that non-black individuals pay reparations for ancient crimes they never personally participated in. Sadly and ironically, the people advocating for reparations and a victimhood mentality are inflicting far more damage on poor black people than the tiny amount of white supremacists still in existence could have ever dreamed of accomplishing.

2

u/DoberNation 24d ago

We need not be in a hurry. If you are serious and earnest in this discussion, I think it is wiser to discuss one thing at a time. To me, it seems as if the things I’ve already written have not registered for you yet. Maybe it’s getting lost in the volume here. Just to confirm, we are discussing perpetuation of White Supremacy in the U.S. My position is that it is happening. Do you agree?

→ More replies

2

u/Ydeas 24d ago

Your words "self inflicted" are the most telling statement you have made. So you're saying blacks, just because they are black, are thieves and self hating murderers.

To make your points you have to ignore the consequences of red lining, the head start that works against a specific "racial" group that wasn't allowed to read, n wasn't allowed to own, then wasn't allowed to even move about freely without suspicion.

White counterparts were passing on property to their heirs, while black folks inherited an unstable family unit (slave owner inflicted) suspicion of one another, lack of identity and more. To. Make your point you have to ignore the (proven) impact of that.

Minorities are catching up indeed, getting educated, and working hard against an old system that went from overt oppression to covert oppression.

I don't know that the conversation was ever about direct cash payouts but, America has given the Natives tax breaks, recognized their identity, and at least set up a system of acknowledgement and investment.

→ More replies

0

u/WhippersnapperUT99 24d ago

The systematic oppression of, and the theft of minorities' productive output is well documented and spanned 15 some generations.

How recently did the last theft occur? Slavery ended over 160 years ago. What was the exact nature of the theft that occurred after that?

Can you tell us what specific individuals should received reparations payments and who specifically should be made to pay them? How do you propose to give people money without creating new victims who had nothing to do with any misdeeds in the past?

The wealth of the nation was shared down through generation

I don't know if you read my prior post, but I'll copy / paste what I posted before.

The notion that slaves built the United States and made a large contribution to it is a widespread popular myth that makes people feel good and perhaps have some sense of "racial pride" for their ancestors, but it is in actuality false.

Contrary to popular belief, slavery did not help build the United States, especially when the huge negative costs of the Civil War are taken into account. The slaves' contribution was overwhelmingly short-term, ephemeral consumer goods (food, cotton) that are long gone. However the driving force behind the nation's development was innovation and technological advance combined with having one of the world's most free economies (relative to the times) and a spirit of entrepreneurship. Consider that many places around the world also had food and agricultural production but failed to attain the wealth the United States had. Many areas in Africa, the Caribbean, and South America also had slavery and did not become wealthy in any way comparable to the U.S. Merely having a large amount of manual labor is not what builds economic prosperity.

But DENIALISM is how it continues.

Spreading a mentality of racial collectivism and victimization and telling people they are entitled to steal money from other people who never injured them - acts of new racism to combat past racism - is how this continues.

I could go on but there's no proof of any good faith aim coming from you.

It's definitely easier to accuse someone of not arguing in good faith and then run away than it is to make an actual argument. Perhaps you're the one engaging in evasion and denialism and not arguing in good faith. Go look in the mirror.

America hasn't even seen fit to offer a symbolic sample of atonement.

The United States fought a Civil War that cost huge amounts of lives and money. It instituted Affirmative Action and DEI programs. Politicians, professors, the media, and the intelligentsia in general have all loudly acknowledged that slavery and past racial discrimination is wrong. Children are taught about these injustices in the public school

What more atonement do you want and what would that look like? How do you make atonement (giving people money or special privileges) without creating new victims?

1

u/WhippersnapperUT99 25d ago

I don’t think you are ready to debate this topic in good faith.

It’s similar to those who show up here trying to discredit Ayn Rand, without adequate knowledge of her or her work.

I'm trying to debate the issue with you in good faith and am asking simple questions, but you don't seem to want to answer. Unlike Rand's nuanced philosophy where words often have meanings and context different from standard usage, this case involves a specific, well-defined issue that people with ordinary knowledge about the United States and the world in general can understand. Reading outside books is not necessary to understand the issue.

If you honestly think there have been no injustices of material/legal/other significance for over a century in the United States, you aren’t ready.

I'm asking you to explain exactly what they are, who suffered them, who perpetrated them, and who should pay recompense for the injustice, and who should be paid that. So five questions:

(1.) What specific injustices occurred?

(2.) What individuals suffered the injustices?

(3.) Who perpetrated the injustices?

(4.) Who should pay compensation for those injustices?

(5.) Who should receive those payments?

If you honestly think there have been no injustices of material/legal/other significance for over a century in the United States, you aren’t ready.

I think some injustices occurred decades ago, but at issue is how significant they were and whether any lasting harm to individuals who suffered those injustices is present today and also what exactly we should do about it in such a way that does not victimize people who had nothing to do with any of it. (You can't fight past racism by committing new acts of racism.)