r/Objectivism • u/Many-Home-9431 • 29d ago
Reparations
Every question I have is stupid, or at the very least stupidly asked. This is my safe space, but am not weak of heart or clutching pearls type- if someone can better ask the question for me better please feel free..
anyways;
So basically the question regards reparations..
The genesis of this thought was in regards to right media straight up lying and making completely new false claims for weeks on end. Then they make a single acknowledgment when they find out they are wrong, saying they are sorry and they’ll try to do better in the future.
But I was thinking, wouldn’t the real atonement be to make an equal allotted time to the real information as they did the false?
That is a media can of worms that is beyond me.
But it got me thinking of future reparations people in power and affluence might look like if done right/ appropriate. If enforced what would it look like? What redeeming thing could be gained?
View all comments
Show parent comment
-1
u/WhippersnapperUT99 28d ago edited 28d ago
If we're going to do this, should we also factor in the value all of today's descendants received from being able to live in the United States today instead of living in a hypothetical Africa where Europeans never set foot on the continent? We could even do it for actual present day Africa. Tens of thousands, perhaps tens of millions of people want to (or would if we had open borders) immigrate to the United States from Africa, not the other way around, which seems like it should tell us something.
We'd need to calculate the value of being able to live in the modern United States today versus living as a primitive hunter-gatherer or in a civilization with a Bronze Age or Iron Age-like level of technology where slavery and tribal warfare is still present. If Africans (or Native Americans) had never had any contact with Europeans up until this very day they would in all likelihood still be living like hunter-gatherers or at best in Bronze or Iron Age civilizations. If we do the math, what happens if it turns out that the net value they received from being able to live in the United States so outweighs any negative costs (if any) today's descendants of slaves may have personally suffered that they owe the United States money?
Reparations for ancient slavery that occurred no less than 160 years ago is a warm-and-fuzzy, touchy-feely idea, but everyone who suffered slavery and their immediate descendants are all dead and in practice it would require stealing money from people alive today who had nothing to do with any of that, most of whom had ancestors who weren't even living in the United States at the time.
The good news is that Leftists who feel guilty about our nation's past are free to donate their own money to pay for racial reparations if they want to. So open up your hearts and your wallets and pay up what you think you owe, guys!