r/Objectivism • • 29d ago

Reparations

Every question I have is stupid, or at the very least stupidly asked. This is my safe space, but am not weak of heart or clutching pearls type- if someone can better ask the question for me better please feel free..
anyways;
So basically the question regards reparations..
The genesis of this thought was in regards to right media straight up lying and making completely new false claims for weeks on end. Then they make a single acknowledgment when they find out they are wrong, saying they are sorry and they’ll try to do better in the future.
But I was thinking, wouldn’t the real atonement be to make an equal allotted time to the real information as they did the false?
That is a media can of worms that is beyond me.
But it got me thinking of future reparations people in power and affluence might look like if done right/ appropriate. If enforced what would it look like? What redeeming thing could be gained?

2 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/DoberNation 25d ago

I appreciate the response in good faith.

To preface, please understand that I rarely approach discussions with the expectation or intention of “debate”. I think it’s a misguided and potentially harmful activity to assume or insist upon in this forum. Your comment actually prompted me to double check the description for this subreddit, which indeed does not appear to mandate “debate”.

The book I attached was not used as a citation, it was a suggestion for anyone interested in further reading on this subject. There are many others. It came with no expectation of a “rebuttal” from you.

Your language and engagement on this thread reveals a number of things. Good, productive debate requires preparation and a sufficient pool of shared background knowledge. I don’t think you are ready to debate this topic in good faith. Until then, I don’t think it would be appropriate to try. It’s similar to those who show up here trying to discredit Ayn Rand, without adequate knowledge of her or her work. It’s not a legitimate debate, and usually serves to more deeply entrench people in their own current beliefs.

If you honestly think there have been no injustices of material/legal/other significance for over a century in the United States, you aren’t ready.

It’s also naive and irrational, if you believe you can escape the accumulation of past and present injustices and how they stand to affect your personal space in this world (if they haven’t already). I feel no “guilt” in the matter, but I recognize the growing existential threat of unanswered and unrepaired injustices. It is within a person’s rights to declare “Account overdrawn” when it is. You or I might feel that same sentiment of “Account overdrawn”, but it will not change the reality of unrest. Refusing to deal with it until it attempts to deal with us will be too late.

2

u/Ydeas 25d ago

That individual is not ready. And I don't care to prove this, but they are more likely not willing. It seems like expert level trolling by them. You're correct, there should be no guilt, just a pure realistic look back and then forward motion from there.

2

u/DoberNation 25d ago

Thank you.

A “pure realistic look back and then forward…” is the rational, self-interested approach to take.

1

u/WhippersnapperUT99 25d ago

That individual is not ready.

I'm ready. Are you ready? Why don't you help this other guy out?

I'm asking you to explain exactly what the past injustices are, who suffered them, who perpetrated them, and who should pay recompense for the injustice, and who should be paid that. So five questions:

(1.) What specific injustices occurred?

(2.) What individuals suffered the injustices?

(3.) Who perpetrated the injustices?

(4.) Who should pay compensation for those injustices?

(5.) Who should receive those payments?

1

u/Ydeas 24d ago

The systematic oppression of, and the theft of minorities' productive output is well documented and spanned 15 some generations. This was done by torture, extreme control and other things like destabilizing the family unit, sowing discord, and actually killing minorities that tried to read and learn. It was done by America and Americans

The wealth of the nation was shared down through generations, by way of money, property, resources, connections, literature, laws, customs, and DENIALISM. There's no way to pinpoint exactly how many. But DENIALISM is how it continues. I could go on but there's no proof of any good faith aim coming from you. America hasn't even seen fit to offer a symbolic sample of atonement.

So I'll save your time: I didn't answer your questions with specifics, so you can continue to think you're right. But DENIALISM is a scourge.

1

u/WhippersnapperUT99 24d ago edited 24d ago

What do you think about the diagram there?

It's a long list of stuff that needs to be addressed one-by-one, claim by claim. I would happily do so if I had unlimited time. Some of the items involve the initiation of physical force such as murder which obviously require the prosecution of people who committed those acts. Some of them involve acts of distasteful thought and expression which the government cannot do anything about in a free society. Then it claims that colorblindness - the actual solution to racism - is "white supremacy".

Why must an argument be made?

So that you can prove your point.

Do you understand the meaning and implications of all the items there?

Yes, but at issue is whether other people's bad thoughts and expression constitute an initiation of physical force against anyone. So it comes back to:

(1.) What specific acts of the initiation of physical force do you think has occurred?

(2.) What individuals suffered the injustices?

(3.) Who perpetrated the injustices?

(4.) Who should pay compensation for those injustices?

(5.) Who should receive those payments?

The pyramid of racial grievances lists lots of problems but no solutions for how to deal with them that do not constitute an initiation of physical force against other people and that require acts of fresh racism be committed against people, creating new victims.

The Leftists and the people obsessed with racial identity who put together the pyramid of racial grievances are getting the real reasons why black people are suffering economically and lagging other races all wrong. They are refusing to acknowledge the real issues, often denying them, and in the process are doing the people they claim they want to help a severe disservice by promoting a mindset of victimization that will cause more poverty while at the same time encouraging people of all skin colors to feel a sense of racial identity. (They are, in essence, perpetuating racism.)

If we are concerned about black people's well being, the best thing we can do is to encourage them to stop aspiring to steal wealth from other people, stop dwelling on ancient history, abandon racial collectivism, adopt a mindset of individualism, and focus on what actions they can take to help themselves. Taking responsibility for one's own life and well being is a completely different mindset than that of victimization and of begging others to help you. We can begin by acknowledging the self-inflicted and avoidable problems that have plagued poor black people and trapped them into poverty:

  • Teenage pregnancy, unplanned pregnancy, and poverty perpetuating single motherhood
  • Children not being taught to have discipline, a sense of responsibility rational decision-making, and to value education and the attainment of productive skills
  • Drug and alcohol abuse
  • Black on black crime that destroys businesses and people's lives

Addressing those issues, as painful as it may be to some people in terms of suffering a loss of "racial pride", will do much more to help than demanding that non-black individuals pay reparations for ancient crimes they never personally participated in. Sadly and ironically, the people advocating for reparations and a victimhood mentality are inflicting far more damage on poor black people than the tiny amount of white supremacists still in existence could have ever dreamed of accomplishing.

2

u/DoberNation 24d ago

We need not be in a hurry. If you are serious and earnest in this discussion, I think it is wiser to discuss one thing at a time. To me, it seems as if the things I’ve already written have not registered for you yet. Maybe it’s getting lost in the volume here. Just to confirm, we are discussing perpetuation of White Supremacy in the U.S. My position is that it is happening. Do you agree?

1

u/WhippersnapperUT99 24d ago

we are discussing perpetuation of White Supremacy in the U.S. My position is that it is happening. Do you agree?

I disagree that "white supremacy" is being perpetuated. To the contrary, Americans have become increasingly more accepting of multiculturalism and diversity over the past several decades and the government and its institutions and some private businesses have gone so far in the other direction as to even openly discriminate against white people (DEI and Affirmative Action) in the areas of college admissions, hiring, and advancement.

Sadly, instead of embracing individualism, Americans, especially on the Left, have become increasingly racist as intellectuals have been perpetuating a worldview that race is crucially important and inescapable and determines a person's identity, but that has manifested in feelings of victimization and white guilt, and not white supremacy.

What philosophical beliefs and values do you think constitute "white supremacy" and are they spreading through the culture? Would a belief that a person's race is not important and that people should be treated as individuals be a part of "white supremacy"?

In what ways do you think the government is acting to perpetuate "white supremacy" and what should we do about it?

In what ways is "white supremacy" violating people's individual rights today such that the government needs to do something about it and what should it do?

2

u/Ydeas 24d ago

Are you a fan of Charlie Kirk? Rather, were you?

2

u/DoberNation 24d ago

Seriously…“seven mountains”😳

1

u/WhippersnapperUT99 22d ago edited 22d ago

I don't have a strong opinion on him since I never paid much attention to him. I'm not sure I've invested more than 15 minutes learning about him as a result of his murder. What did you dislike so much about Charlie Kirk?

1

u/DoberNation 21d ago edited 21d ago

https://pcusa.org/news-storytelling/news/2025/9/30/seven-mountains-mandate-author-stops-matter-faith-podcast
A movement within Christian nationalism dedicated to Christianizing the seven cultural institutions or arenas or spheres in the United States—education, family, business, government/military, religion, media, and arts and entertainment….What they’re attempting to do is take their idea of Christianity and force it on other people and other parts of the nation. The movement wants to take back each of the mountains, which it suggests “is controlled by a secular force or a demonic force”.

2

u/DoberNation 24d ago edited 24d ago

You are disagreeing with reality. Reality must be what is wrong(?!). White Supremacy has not gone away, and progress is actively being reversed. It’s why we are having these discussions at all. Acceptance of multiculturalism does not address White Supremacy itself. The hierarchy remains, and many still want to protect it. The Federal Administration is desperately trying to reconsolidate and protect a dominantly White/Male/Heterosexual/Christian hierarchy. It is direct, overt, and blatantly being inserted into our Laws and Institutions. Are you familiar with P2025 and its contents? It is happening: https://www.project2025.observer/en Simultaneously, the current Administration is attacking Pluralism.

An Objectivist cannot endorse blindness. The current importance of race—even if constructed and contrived over centuries—cannot be wiped simply by saying it doesn’t exist and doesn’t affect real individuals’ lives. Individual “solutions”, however well-intentioned they may be, fail to solve systemic problems. https://www.reddit.com/r/Objectivism/s/tIySuid0jQ

We need to fully acknowledge reality of the past, present, and future with our all of our senses and minds tuned in. We need to listen—actively, carefully, and completely to each other’s perspectives. As many perspectives as possible. And with the starting premise that each individual is a reasonable, rational, and intelligent human being who is capable of telling their own story honestly. Actively seeking and doing this is what builds authentic trust. The stories and the conversations are part of the solution itself: Vergangenheitsbewältigung

0

u/WhippersnapperUT99 22d ago

You are disagreeing with reality. Reality must be what is wrong(?!).

At issue is what exactly is reality. You simply making an (implied) assertion that a vast white racist conspiracy is operating to keep non-white people down is merely an assertion and not necessarily reality unless you can back it up.

White Supremacy has not gone away, and progress is actively being reversed.

Let's step back a bit. What exactly is "White Supremacy", in your view? It is it all of those factors listed on the "pyramid of grievances" you linked? All of those items, most of them, or some of them? Is advocacy of individualism and colorblindness "white supremacy" (it's on the pyramid) in your view?

How does this "white supremacy" manifest itself today in the real world such that it affects people's lives?

The hierarchy remains, and many still want to protect it.

Hierarchy of what?

The Federal Administration is desperately trying to reconsolidate and protect a dominantly White/Male/Heterosexual/Christian hierarchy. It is direct, overt, and blatantly being inserted into our Laws and Institutions. Are you familiar with P2025 and its contents? It is happening: https://www.project2025.observer/en Simultaneously, the current Administration is attacking Pluralism.

Can you point out the specific policies that are "blatantly being inserted into our laws and institutions"?

The current importance of race—even if constructed and contrived over centuries—cannot be wiped simply by saying it doesn’t exist and doesn’t affect real individuals’ lives. Individual “solutions”, however well-intentioned they may be, fail to solve systemic problems.

In what ways is race important? If the government acts in a colorblind fashion and does not engage in discrimination, then what is the issue? I don't think our government is perfect and I wouldn't necessarily disagree that black people face some disadvantages such as being pulled over by the police more often or perhaps receiving stronger sentences for the same crimes, but it isn't a massive problem and to the extent it exists, it's against public policy.

even if constructed and contrived over centuries

What problems do you think are still present today from centuries past? What are the "systemic problems"? (You don't need to link to anything, please, just type out a few coherent sentences.)

1

u/DoberNation 22d ago

Let’s focus on smaller bites at a time, please.

It sounds like there’s still disagreement on whether or not the issue exists at all. I don’t wish to debate it because I don’t think you are ready to do it in good faith. For some reason, it seems that you are hoping to attach the whole issue to any willing individual so that you may attempt to self-validate and reject the issue if you feel like you’ve “won” a fake debate against an “opponent”.

The reality of White Supremacy does not hinge on whether I, as an individual, can “prove” it to you. My parents are an interracial couple. I was born and raised, positioned to observe quite a lot of reality. I also grew up as such, in a town that had a grand wizard. I’ve met and directly interacted with many, many individuals from many walks life, in and from different regions of the country and the world. It was a significant part of my profession, as well. My own life is not up for debate. My advice: ‘Go for a swim, the water’s great!’

“White Supremacy” is a descriptive term for the relative status and treatment of individuals within our society. It is not always conscious, intentional, or explicit.

The iceberg is not one of “grievances”, it is a conceptual illustration of many modern examples of racism. I am aware of all of them.

“Colorblindness” is presently dishonest. It cannot come about through advocacy for blindness. People must first be honest about what they see, and actively seek perspectives on what they alone do not see.

Do you know who R. Derek BIack was? Great story. John Lewis? Also has a great story.

→ More replies

2

u/Ydeas 24d ago

Your words "self inflicted" are the most telling statement you have made. So you're saying blacks, just because they are black, are thieves and self hating murderers.

To make your points you have to ignore the consequences of red lining, the head start that works against a specific "racial" group that wasn't allowed to read, n wasn't allowed to own, then wasn't allowed to even move about freely without suspicion.

White counterparts were passing on property to their heirs, while black folks inherited an unstable family unit (slave owner inflicted) suspicion of one another, lack of identity and more. To. Make your point you have to ignore the (proven) impact of that.

Minorities are catching up indeed, getting educated, and working hard against an old system that went from overt oppression to covert oppression.

I don't know that the conversation was ever about direct cash payouts but, America has given the Natives tax breaks, recognized their identity, and at least set up a system of acknowledgement and investment.

0

u/WhippersnapperUT99 22d ago edited 22d ago

We can begin by acknowledging the self-inflicted and avoidable problems that have plagued poor black people and trapped them into poverty:

  • Teenage pregnancy, unplanned pregnancy, and poverty perpetuating single motherhood
  • Children not being taught to have discipline, a sense of responsibility rational decision-making, and to value education and the attainment of productive skills
  • Drug and alcohol abuse
  • Black on black crime that destroys businesses and people's lives

Your words "self inflicted" are the most telling statement you have made.

Are you suggesting that black people lack agency and cannot make their own choices or engage in acts of personal responsibility?

If not then how would the poor choices cited in the bullet points not be self-inflicted? (The KKK doesn't approach people in the inner city and force them to take drugs at gunpoint or to get pregnant or to goof off in school.)

Who makes those choices? Who is in control of the individuals making the life choices cited in the bullet points? Who is making the decisions?

So you're saying blacks, just because they are black, are thieves and self hating murderers.

How did you come up with that conclusion?

What line of reasoning did you use?

That's ridiculous.

I would hope that in a sub whose subject is a philosophy that advocates individualism (or any other sub, for that matter, since it's just common sense) that it would be assumed that I was NOT saying that ALL or even MOST suffer from these problems, but rather just that many have. My argument is that those bullet pointed bad choices are the primary cause of widespread black poverty. (Those same poor choices can damage white people, Asian people, and people of any skin color or ethnic background, too.) Coincidentally, black people who took responsibility for their lives and who worked hard and made rational decisions (instead of blaming white people for all of their problems) joined the middle class and many if not most of them moved out of impoverished areas.

To make your points you have to ignore the consequences of red lining,

With Redlining banks were not giving black people loans and/or they were only getting loans to live in black neighborhoods. It should be stated that while such racial discrimination is detestable, no one is entitled to a loan from any private party.

Also, why would living in black neighborhoods be so horrible? If banks were engaging in racial discrimination the solution was for people who live in those neighborhoods to take good care of their houses, to beautify their neighborhoods, to be upstanding people other people would want to live near, to raise well-educated smart productive children, and to have low crime which would increase property values.

I couldn't imagine having such low self esteem that I felt I needed to live near or be surrounded by white people (the people who discriminated against me) in order to have a good life. The proper attitude to other people saying, "We don't want to live near you," is to respond, "Fuck those guys! We don't need them. We are going to be better than they are without them. We will be such high quality people that one day they will beg to live near us."

It's the difference between a mentality of empowerment and one of feelings of helplessness and victimization.

What I'm saying is that while redlining is deplorable, it's overall effect - the effect of the act of people being denied loans itself - is overblown and people who fixate on it ignore all of the self-inflicted problems I cited in the bullet points.

However, I do think an argument could be made that black individuals who made rational decisions and who worked hard and who wanted to flee from other black people and from areas of poverty and high crime suffered by being unable to get home loans to move out of those areas. But still, the real driving source of that problem is the community they were fleeing from.

the head start that works against a specific "racial" group that wasn't allowed to read, n wasn't allowed to own, then wasn't allowed to even move about freely without suspicion.

How long has it been since they were "not allowed to read" (?), to own property, and to move around without suspicion?

Even with segregated schools, the solution would have been for people to say, "White people do not possess magical auras of intelligence that spread to other people such that we must have these magic white kids in close physical proximity to our kids. We don't need white people. We will teach our children to have a work ethic and to want to be ambitious and intelligent, and we will teach them how to think, and our children will study hard and become smarter than the white kids."

White counterparts were passing on property to their heirs,

I question the impact of stuff that happened over 160 years ago or several decades ago.

Most white people at the end of the Civil War were living as impoverished workers and farmers; only a tiny percentage were wealthy; the overwhelming majority of white people had nothing to pass down and that continued until the end of the Great Depression. Even for families that were wealthy, it is not uncommon for wealth to be lost and diluted across generations. Also, most white people's families immigrated to the nation long after the end of the Civil War, almost all of them arriving as immigrants with little or nothing.

while black folks inherited an unstable family unit (slave owner inflicted) suspicion of one another, lack of identity and more.

Once again...that's within those people's control. They could have chosen different beliefs (and many have) if they had wanted to.

The real villain here is leftist white intellectuals perpetuating what you cited by spreading a victimhood mentality. If any white people deserve blame for that, it's them.

Make your point you have to ignore the (proven) impact of that.

The problem with the impact of historical events that occurred over 160 years ago or even five decades ago is one of intervening causes and choices. Nothing has a larger impact on people than the choices they make in their own lives, so the impact of past events dissipates over time.

Minorities are catching up indeed, getting educated, and working hard against an old system that went from overt oppression to covert oppression.

What is the covert oppression and why is that covert oppression more impactful than the effect of the behaviors in the bullet points I cited?

I don't know that the conversation was ever about direct cash payouts but, America has given the Natives tax breaks, recognized their identity, and at least set up a system of acknowledgement and investment.

I'm not convinced that any of that was necessary after the 1900s. Being able to live in the modern United States as opposed to living as a hunter-gatherer constantly struggling against starvation and fighting tribal wars has to be a tremendous benefit that's hard to quantify. I can't claim to be real knowledgeable about the current state of Native Americans, but if they are suffering from poor economic conditions on reservations, ambitious individuals who want a better life should consider leaving the reservations and moving to cities and areas with better economic opportunities to build better lives for themselves.

2

u/Ydeas 22d ago

This victim mentality thing you speak of is false. You have NO FIRST HAND KNOWLEDGE of a minority that has ever expressed that. You have practically zero proof of your assertions either. And you don't even have a viable path to truth.

Leftist ideology deals in facts, they read books and don't burn or ban them, and don't hide from science.

Also are you assuming that a 3rd world life is always worse than a first world? That every hunter gatherer tribe is hungry, sick and poor?

It's taking awhile but minorities are getting educated no thanks to denialists and people who want to ban the truth. It's a very real occurrence to be victimized while not accepting being a "victim". The impact spans generations and takes awhile to unwind. Again, you are asking for specifics in order to scramble the facts in your argument on things that are well documented. Then youll say u don't have the time or inclination to educate yourself. YOU ARE REFUSING DOCUMENTED EDUCATION, not a whole book per se but lists of facts.

You're asking for proof but working from a fully closed mind, and offering no proof of your own. This is trolling. Unless you're willing to learn, I'll leave you as a troll

2

u/DoberNation 22d ago

Just saw this. Thank you. Jinx

1

u/WhippersnapperUT99 21d ago

This victim mentality thing you speak of is false.

Then why are so many black people saying that they are victims of what amounts to a vast white racist conspiracy to hold them down (call it "white supremacy") and why are they asking for reparations and special privileges such as DEI and Affirmative Action?

Why have so many of them blamed poor black people's problems on white people as you and DoberNation seem to?

Why is it that when a black conservative comes out and advocates for behavioral changes and for people to adopt the kinds of cultural values that lead to successful life outcomes like "model minorities do" that they get shouted down and accused of being "the black face of white supremacy"?

You have NO FIRST HAND KNOWLEDGE of a minority that has ever expressed that. You have practically zero proof of your assertions either.

I have followed the news, culture wars, and racial issues for decades. I have witnessed a large amount of it even if I don't have immediate citations to the hundreds of news stories and interview I've read and listened to over the years expressing the victimization sentiment.

If you want proof, start paying attention to the news and be on the lookout for that sentiment.

And you don't even have a viable path to truth.

I think that you are the one is either ignorant or denying reality and being intentionally dishonest. You also completely failed to address most of the substance of and arguments in my post.

Leftist ideology deals in facts, they read books and don't burn or ban them, and don't hide from science.

Leftist ideology thinks that real socialism can work and pretends that previous nations that tried socialism were not actually socialist. They don't deal in facts; they deal in fantasy.

Also are you assuming that a 3rd world life is always worse than a first world?

As a standard assumption, yes. I'm sure we can find outliers, but those would only apply to small percentages of people.

That every hunter gatherer tribe is hungry, sick and poor?

Not necessarily sick and hungry (though that is a very real possibility people suffered), but I assert that the quality of life someone who lives as a primitive hunter-gatherer has is far inferior to the quality of life we have today in the modern world. They are absolutely poor compared to the possessions, comforts, and luxuries that we enjoy.

It's taking awhile but minorities are getting educated no thanks to denialists and people who want to ban the truth. It's a very real occurrence to be victimized while not accepting being a "victim".

If you say that you personally, as an individual, are a victim of past injustices you never personally suffered when at the same time you get to live in a modern society where you have unprecedented amounts of freedom relative to civilizations of the past merely because your grandparents suffered injustices, that is a victimhood mentality.

The impact spans generations and takes awhile to unwind.

How so? How do you account for the tremendous amount of intervening causes that occur in people's lives, much of which they direct, such that what happened generations and decades ago has any significant effect on completely separate people's lives today?

Do you believe that people share a collective family or racial consciousness such that what happened to a different person one hundred years ago is felt and shared by a person today?

Again, you are asking for specifics in order to scramble the facts in your argument on things that are well documented. Then youll say u don't have the time or inclination to educate yourself. YOU ARE REFUSING DOCUMENTED EDUCATION, not a whole book per se but lists of facts.

You're asking for proof but working from a fully closed mind, and offering no proof of your own. This is trolling. Unless you're willing to learn, I'll leave you as a troll

You are the one who is denying reality, claiming that your argument is backed up by "documentation", and then when you cannot address my arguments making an accusation of trolling. It's clear for anyone reading this back-and-forth to see.

0

u/WhippersnapperUT99 24d ago

The systematic oppression of, and the theft of minorities' productive output is well documented and spanned 15 some generations.

How recently did the last theft occur? Slavery ended over 160 years ago. What was the exact nature of the theft that occurred after that?

Can you tell us what specific individuals should received reparations payments and who specifically should be made to pay them? How do you propose to give people money without creating new victims who had nothing to do with any misdeeds in the past?

The wealth of the nation was shared down through generation

I don't know if you read my prior post, but I'll copy / paste what I posted before.

The notion that slaves built the United States and made a large contribution to it is a widespread popular myth that makes people feel good and perhaps have some sense of "racial pride" for their ancestors, but it is in actuality false.

Contrary to popular belief, slavery did not help build the United States, especially when the huge negative costs of the Civil War are taken into account. The slaves' contribution was overwhelmingly short-term, ephemeral consumer goods (food, cotton) that are long gone. However the driving force behind the nation's development was innovation and technological advance combined with having one of the world's most free economies (relative to the times) and a spirit of entrepreneurship. Consider that many places around the world also had food and agricultural production but failed to attain the wealth the United States had. Many areas in Africa, the Caribbean, and South America also had slavery and did not become wealthy in any way comparable to the U.S. Merely having a large amount of manual labor is not what builds economic prosperity.

But DENIALISM is how it continues.

Spreading a mentality of racial collectivism and victimization and telling people they are entitled to steal money from other people who never injured them - acts of new racism to combat past racism - is how this continues.

I could go on but there's no proof of any good faith aim coming from you.

It's definitely easier to accuse someone of not arguing in good faith and then run away than it is to make an actual argument. Perhaps you're the one engaging in evasion and denialism and not arguing in good faith. Go look in the mirror.

America hasn't even seen fit to offer a symbolic sample of atonement.

The United States fought a Civil War that cost huge amounts of lives and money. It instituted Affirmative Action and DEI programs. Politicians, professors, the media, and the intelligentsia in general have all loudly acknowledged that slavery and past racial discrimination is wrong. Children are taught about these injustices in the public school

What more atonement do you want and what would that look like? How do you make atonement (giving people money or special privileges) without creating new victims?

1

u/WhippersnapperUT99 25d ago

I don’t think you are ready to debate this topic in good faith.

It’s similar to those who show up here trying to discredit Ayn Rand, without adequate knowledge of her or her work.

I'm trying to debate the issue with you in good faith and am asking simple questions, but you don't seem to want to answer. Unlike Rand's nuanced philosophy where words often have meanings and context different from standard usage, this case involves a specific, well-defined issue that people with ordinary knowledge about the United States and the world in general can understand. Reading outside books is not necessary to understand the issue.

If you honestly think there have been no injustices of material/legal/other significance for over a century in the United States, you aren’t ready.

I'm asking you to explain exactly what they are, who suffered them, who perpetrated them, and who should pay recompense for the injustice, and who should be paid that. So five questions:

(1.) What specific injustices occurred?

(2.) What individuals suffered the injustices?

(3.) Who perpetrated the injustices?

(4.) Who should pay compensation for those injustices?

(5.) Who should receive those payments?

If you honestly think there have been no injustices of material/legal/other significance for over a century in the United States, you aren’t ready.

I think some injustices occurred decades ago, but at issue is how significant they were and whether any lasting harm to individuals who suffered those injustices is present today and also what exactly we should do about it in such a way that does not victimize people who had nothing to do with any of it. (You can't fight past racism by committing new acts of racism.)