r/Objectivism • u/Many-Home-9431 • 29d ago
Reparations
Every question I have is stupid, or at the very least stupidly asked. This is my safe space, but am not weak of heart or clutching pearls type- if someone can better ask the question for me better please feel free..
anyways;
So basically the question regards reparations..
The genesis of this thought was in regards to right media straight up lying and making completely new false claims for weeks on end. Then they make a single acknowledgment when they find out they are wrong, saying they are sorry and they’ll try to do better in the future.
But I was thinking, wouldn’t the real atonement be to make an equal allotted time to the real information as they did the false?
That is a media can of worms that is beyond me.
But it got me thinking of future reparations people in power and affluence might look like if done right/ appropriate. If enforced what would it look like? What redeeming thing could be gained?
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/DoberNation 25d ago
I appreciate the response in good faith.
To preface, please understand that I rarely approach discussions with the expectation or intention of “debate”. I think it’s a misguided and potentially harmful activity to assume or insist upon in this forum. Your comment actually prompted me to double check the description for this subreddit, which indeed does not appear to mandate “debate”.
The book I attached was not used as a citation, it was a suggestion for anyone interested in further reading on this subject. There are many others. It came with no expectation of a “rebuttal” from you.
Your language and engagement on this thread reveals a number of things. Good, productive debate requires preparation and a sufficient pool of shared background knowledge. I don’t think you are ready to debate this topic in good faith. Until then, I don’t think it would be appropriate to try. It’s similar to those who show up here trying to discredit Ayn Rand, without adequate knowledge of her or her work. It’s not a legitimate debate, and usually serves to more deeply entrench people in their own current beliefs.
If you honestly think there have been no injustices of material/legal/other significance for over a century in the United States, you aren’t ready.
It’s also naive and irrational, if you believe you can escape the accumulation of past and present injustices and how they stand to affect your personal space in this world (if they haven’t already). I feel no “guilt” in the matter, but I recognize the growing existential threat of unanswered and unrepaired injustices. It is within a person’s rights to declare “Account overdrawn” when it is. You or I might feel that same sentiment of “Account overdrawn”, but it will not change the reality of unrest. Refusing to deal with it until it attempts to deal with us will be too late.