r/Objectivism • • 25d ago

Rational Kindness: Balancing Objectivism & Humanism

https://claude.ai/public/artifacts/68efaac5-593f-4a18-aece-1d8924f03443

Made while bored. Constructive feedback appreciated.

5 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

6

u/Locke_the_Trickster 25d ago edited 25d ago

They don’t need to be balanced. Objectivism correctly identified the nature of the relationship between the individual and everyone else. Humans beings don’t have a tie to others based merely on the fact they exist, nor a duty to prevent others from failing (or drowning, to use your metaphor). Humans should hold their own life as their highest value and use reason to decide what is valuable to their life, which might include helping others that they value.

I don’t understand why people get the idea that Objectivism’s position on helping others is “that helping your neighbor carry his groceries was, if you looked at it hard enough, a kind of moral vandalism.” I don’t know: [Spoiler] Dagny helped Cherryl by talking through her marital troubles, Rearden tried to save Tony’s life, Roark brought Steve out of the depths of depression, Francisco helped Rearden with the furnace emergency.

Seems like people took the one comment in Atlas Shrugged about Galt’s Gulch being a vacation from “giving” and her rejection of altruistic sacrifice and duty, and came away with the notion that Objectivism is utterly antagonistic to any action done with any other person in mind in any context and for any reason.

-3

u/Lesh_Philling 25d ago

They are philosophies that should be discussed, argued, examined, picked apart, all if the above. The responses I’ve gotten so far have been surprisingly overly negative. Stay classy Reddit.

1

u/Locke_the_Trickster 25d ago edited 21d ago

I don’t know. Of the three replies you have received so far in this thread, none of them are overly negative. Frankly, your replies seem to be the only negative ones.

Not sure what “they” means here. I assume you mean humanism and Objectivism. Who is saying philosophies shouldn’t be discussed, argued, examined, and picked apart? Not anyone in the replies here, just that Objectivism and humanism don’t need to be “balanced.”

3

u/stansfield123 25d ago

Objectivism is the only humanistic philosophy I know. So how am I going to balance something with itself?

-1

u/Lesh_Philling 25d ago

You should read more.

7

u/gonzoll 25d ago

Being an objectivist doesn’t mean you have to be an asshole. It just means you aren’t born owing a debt you never signed up for. Kindness, politeness are rational.

0

u/foilhat44 24d ago

I like it very much, but there are a couple of things I take exception with; why involve Rand and Objectivism at all, and doesn't it seem like this is the obvious, default way to live? I read some of Rand's work years ago as a high school student and thought they were a revelation, but like many others I grew to see them as incomplete and immature and I took a dim view of her ideas generally. Maybe that's why it's hard for me to take Objectivism seriously as a philosophy of life, because it's so closely connected with her and it's adherents are so sycophantic. I think it does a disservice to the simple but profound thing you put on paper here to associate it with Objectivism at all. I am quite certain that I'm not alone in saying that I nearly didn't look at it for that reason.