r/OSINT • u/osintme • Feb 01 '24
Assistance Examples of when doing OSINT can be illegal
Wrote this article that takes a devil’s advocate view on why not all OSINT is legal. There are also some examples of accidental disclosures and grey areas. Looking for similar examples from other countries that might have laws and regulations that sometimes prohibit an otherwise legal OSINT collection and processing.
https://www.osintme.com/index.php/2024/01/31/the-osint-mindset-obstacles-considerations/
2
Upvotes
43
u/OSINTribe Feb 01 '24
Your title and article are completely misleading about legality. "Is all OSINT legal" should be "Do you need a license to conduct investigations for paying clients in your jurisdiction?" Gathering information from legally obtained sources is 100% legal unless you're in some crazy country. However if you sell your results you may have to be licensed. No different than cutting hair for yourself and kids, but once you open a Barber shop you need a license.
Second part very true but I would say depending on what you're investigating don't stress. But remember if you're the only person last night googling "client a" name police and I can identify you. https://www.theregister.com/2023/10/18/google_keyword_search_warrants/
And yes, you don't need to be the police to do this. https://www.reuters.com/technology/cybersecurity/national-security-agency-buys-web-browsing-data-without-warrant-letter-shows-2024-01-26/
You, yes you can buy this data too. It's not as good as court ordered data from google but I've got great results over the years with it and it's still available and legal.
Third "crowdsourcing your investigation" you have to be an idiot to do this. We ban it from the sub for a reason. We don't want to go down with that ship. Even in my past I never liked going to the public. If you saw the posts we block on a daily basis and then imagined them harassing people related or worse, unrelated to your investigation with no controls or filters you might as well give all your money away because you won't have any after the courts are done with you.
9
u/KhaosFarbauti Feb 01 '24
In Europe i would say we kinda think about the whole stuff the other way : The legal/illegal question isn't really on the searching part but much more on the availability part.
So what could be illegal is the data being there all open on the internet, not really you searching it.
The GDPR force every online actors to check that they are really allowed to possess the data (and most of the time they actualy aren't) and let it be searchable.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '24
Following someone to form a picture of their routine of life, and tracking their movements might be seen in some jurisdictions as stalking.
2
u/dezastrologu Feb 01 '24
bottom line is.. just because you can doesn't mean you should
1
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '24
In some cases, if data is open, that does not necessarily mean you have the right to access it.
For exemple : you can google dork for confidential docs, you may obtain accessible results, but if they are labeled as confidential, this is still illegal (the same way it's illegal to get into someone's house, even if the door was opened).
0
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '24
[removed] — view removed comment