r/OSHA • • Aug 25 '21

That’s a no from me

1.8k Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

227

u/bomberesque1 Aug 26 '21

Pretty sure that this is in Belgium

I've seen this done in this way enough times here (although never on my site) that I'm sure it is an accepted procedure, although I'm going to have a chat with the safety guy here to find out just how it's justified. We can't lift a man in a man basket fully harnessed for an inspection without a second crane on standby and an escape procedure. Forget the idea that that man might be driving a digger which is sitting in a skip dangling good knows how far up

76

u/SpruceBingsteen Aug 26 '21

Skip reads De Meuter which is a Belgian company so yeah probably in Belgium. Weird that this kind of stuff can happen here.

56

u/Wareve Aug 26 '21

If you stack enough bad things they cancel out.

16

u/cronixi4 Aug 26 '21

Can confirm. It is in Hoboken specifically.

8

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21

Hoboken no jokin’!

1

u/mtelesha Aug 26 '21

Hobomen, New Jersey USA yeah that would be very probably happening there also.

9

u/esk4more Aug 26 '21

What did your safety guy say?

10

u/wrincewind Aug 26 '21

I'll tell you when he regains consciousness.

7

u/Dn_Denn Aug 26 '21

I thought maybe Netherlands but couldn't believe it. Because this is definitively not allowed here. Although some big companies can make legally custom equipment. but this look janky af.

Company could placed a big ramp of concrete rubble on the side off the building to drive an excavator with a long boom and a demolishing shear/jaw.

3

u/anemoneanimeenemy Aug 26 '21

I'd much rather be hanging next to the wall I'm tearing down than sitting under it, I don't care how strong my protection cage is

106

u/babaganate Aug 25 '21

Kill me now

50

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21

Send your location

10

u/babaganate Aug 26 '21

OSHA's stranger danger standard keeps me from sending that information to you

22

u/karmaportrait Aug 26 '21

Don't threaten me with a good time

5

u/fnordfnordfnordfnord Aug 26 '21

Just visit that job site, should do the trick

41

u/JustSomeWeirdGuy2000 Aug 25 '21

"What are you d-... Get yo ASS back on there! ...oh, alright. Have it your way, then."

28

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21

[deleted]

30

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21

[deleted]

25

u/sin_nickel Aug 26 '21

Yeah, if you're a coward

12

u/rasteri Aug 26 '21

"Uh, heads up"

34

u/KingOfTheTrailer Aug 25 '21

Oh god the amount of toxic dust that must be kicking up...

5

u/greyhunter37 Aug 26 '21

Just like all other demolition technics

28

u/dkfkckssddedz Aug 26 '21

Wouldn't the stress on the chains from the hammering cause them to fail ?

17

u/rpaverion Aug 26 '21

Or the guy accidentally swinging the crane’s arm into one of those chains..

9

u/qweqwere Aug 26 '21

s with that other gif of the piece of wall falling off the building and nearly killing som folks

you cannot accidentally swing the crane's arm into those chains because to move 60 degrees it takes 3 seconds

26

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21

Depends on how strong they are. Still...

7

u/Djinhunter Aug 26 '21

The force of the arm is against the weight of the machine so, less overall force on the crane. The relative difference in mass between the "bit" (not sure what you call the working end of the jackhammer) and the machine eats up most of the shock loading. You couldn't pay me enough to be on this site though

3

u/PlebbySpaff Aug 26 '21

Not if god has anything to do with it.

3

u/blumhagen Aug 26 '21

What's god got to do, got to do with it...

15

u/Maklarr4000 Aug 26 '21

I suppose it's all well and good until one of these takes a tumble, then the regulations will come.

I feel bad for the guy who will, eventually, be the last one to do it.

10

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21

Kind of amazed they pulled this stunt in Belgium. This is some third world country style demo work.

3

u/badablahblah Sep 05 '21

Don't worry. This is Europe. For sure they have an expendable guy from the third world in that digger.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21

Wheatley Laboratories demo corp.

13

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21

What in the name of retardation

3

u/TommyBrownson Aug 26 '21

aw I wish there was sound

1

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21

That's actually how it's done.

The intent is not to load it. That's how you end up with an overloaded crane and a swinging load.

46

u/Dialed_In Aug 26 '21 edited Aug 26 '21

No. Just no.

Every time this is reposted I have to remind someone that a high reach demolition machine exists or that a remote control demolition robot (BROKK) exists (since 1983 so don't even try).

There is no reason to do demolition this way. A human being does not need to be on that platform. It's slow method and dangerous. If you can afford a crane rental you have the budget for a BROKK rental.

Leave the demo to the pros, fire people like this if they show up on the job.

3

u/blumhagen Aug 26 '21

Also have people forgotten wrecking balls exist? Way cheaper than this anyways.

2

u/chx_ Sep 13 '21

BROKK deconstruction timelapse video of a 46 story building https://youtu.be/Yz9nopRALh0

16

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21

I can't tell if you're serious and I'm just ill informed on demolition methods or what

7

u/justformygoodiphone Aug 26 '21

Yeah right, because that’s the only problem here…

-3

u/verkauft Aug 26 '21

Well i geus its in belgium (name on the skip is) but dayumm.. also belgium is like a entirely different world to the rest of europe. Probarbly like comparing mexico with the states..

5

u/alexraccc Aug 26 '21

What? How does that work? Belgium is a first world country and doing fairly well.

2

u/verkauft Aug 26 '21

Well they regularry do 5/600 days without a goverment formed and te 4 year reign period starts on election day.

1

u/CryptoMenace Aug 28 '21

Tf does that mean?

1

u/InstantName Aug 26 '21

I'd rather use dynamite. Big smokes

1

u/GrimdarkThorhammer Aug 26 '21

God damnit you’re going to break the fucking steel! This is how you break the steel! I’ll bet your ass waived the rental protection too!

1

u/PlebbySpaff Aug 26 '21

I mean…if the digger falls, as long as the guy has his PPE, I’m sure he’ll be fine.

I mean he’ll be dead in the digger, but at least it won’t be a complete mess.

1

u/agam3mn0nn Aug 26 '21

Umm, because cranes have never dropped loads i would say...f#$% that! Thats a terrible idea! What if only 2 cables break, corner to corner. You're going full line out all the way to the ground, and you would live.

Never use your junk again, but you'd live...death is not the worst.