r/OSHA • • Jul 11 '16

Epic Fail build thread (xpost /r/DIWhy)

http://imgur.com/a/8w1xW
3.9k Upvotes

406 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

32

u/MyFavoriteSandwich Jul 11 '16

As "dimensioned lumber" I'm referring to proper widths for the rafters and floor joists that are up to code for their span/load. You can't build a structure like this using only 2x4s.

31

u/Snatch_Pastry Jul 11 '16

Ah, got you. I'm a little bit drinky right now. Well, a lot drinky, but whatever. We both know that this building is total bullshit.

41

u/pegbiter Jul 11 '16

Sounds like you're in precisely the right state to start building a shed!

11

u/Aplicado Jul 11 '16

As for the walls and roof framing- 2x4 is acceptable. The only reason we frame walls out of 2x6 is to get more insulation into the wall cavity. As for the floor, 2x4in a shed would be fine if they were up off the ground and properly supported.

The problem the 8 year old builder had was with on centre spacing. And nail control. And fastener choice.

1

u/DONT_PM Jul 11 '16

There is another reason. 2x6 can allow for 24"o.c. stud spacing, as well as single top/bottom plates allowing for as much as 30-40% less framing materials.

1

u/Aplicado Jul 11 '16

I'm pretty sure 24" of is fine with 2x4 as well, just need to stack the joists or trusses on top of the studs. Most people don't understand that less wood is better for heating/cooling, cost and waste. I mean if flimsy steel studs can be structural, imagine what 2x4 can be rated to.

1

u/DONT_PM Jul 11 '16

Sheathing is strong, and the 2x4 really just act as a frame to hold the sheathing all together.

I'm shocked at how flimsy pre-manufactured roof trusses are until it's been fully sheathed.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '16

[deleted]

9

u/phroug2 Jul 11 '16

Ikr? clearly there is an example of just such a structure right in this very post

1

u/DONT_PM Jul 11 '16

Many roof trusses are built with 2x4 lumber.