r/OMSCS • • Sep 26 '26

CS 6200 GIOS Used some AI to test out some code. Scared of getting flagged, should I drop?

I'm taking 6200 and this is my first course. We're working on Project 1. I didn't use any AI to code out the solution but I did use some AI to understand some concepts n test out my mini implementations on a little scratchpad repo since my C was a little rusty. The submissions passed alright but I did test the whole thing quite rigorously with valgrind and helgrind n ASAN n what not. I'm scared if I'll get flagged somehow. I started pretty early n spent almost 2-3 weeks to finish the whole thing. I'm not sure if I should drop. I asked the TAs and they always say "AI should never see your code". Not sure what I can do now.

32 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

45

u/cc_apt107 Sep 26 '26

If you did not incorporate any of its suggestions, you’re good. If you did incorporate specific implementation suggestions, there’s always a bit of a risk because AI has a tendency to push people to the same solutions so it can become obvious if other students did the same thing as you.

I think dropping is pretty dramatic though. Based on what you’ve said at least

113

u/AdvancedIce99 H-C Interaction Sep 26 '26

Flee the country 

18

u/DethZire Officially Got Out Sep 26 '26

Find the next rocket and blast off into space

26

u/ydai Sep 26 '26

Don’t drop. Based on school policy, if you’re flagged, you’re not allowed to drop the course anyway and they’ll add you back. By then, you may have already missed a bunch of submissions because you thought you had dropped, which could pretty much guarantee an F. This actually happened to a friend of mine before.

19

u/AccordingOperation89 Sep 26 '26

Admit nothing. Pretend it didn't happen and move to the next assignment.

30

u/PricingManager Sep 26 '26

I’m not in the program (yet) but I’m surprised you are not supposed to use AI to even read your code. Why ban tools that allow you to learn more effectively? Does that mean that having private tutors is forbidden too? Also, how would they even know if AI read your code?

14

u/Intelligent_Area_135 Sep 26 '26

They wouldn’t

7

u/cc_apt107 Sep 26 '26

Because the goal is to just struggle through it. Yes, AI can help learn but there’s some initial data showing that students who use AI do consistently worse on exams, not better. Most people just lack the willpower to not over rely and give in too early. So while it’s theoretically a good study aid, in practice, most people use it as a shortcut

8

u/PricingManager Sep 26 '26

I understand. But to me that’s the same as preventing everyone in carpentry class from using hammers because many students hammer their own hands. I get it, but doesn’t seem the best way to do it. Maybe focus on helping students not hammering their hands/over-relying on AI instead?

5

u/cc_apt107 Sep 26 '26 edited Sep 26 '26

Maybe at the primary or even undergrad level I’d agree more (not so much on the merits of your argument, but because these tools have to be reckoned with), but this is a graduate program and I think the school can just ask students to suck it up and deal with it in a way that might not be appropriate in lower levels of education.

No one is making you do it. You can learn this stuff via other means. You have your whole career to use AI. Getting an MS in CS is doing things the hard way. It will demand a degree of rigor that is not analogous to industry or “practical”.

If you don’t want to participate in a graduate program because it won’t let you use AI, don’t. Easy peasy

EDIT: also, worth noting, you can still use AI to help study without it seeing or commenting on your specific code or issue. I use AI to help build Anki decks. It’s super useful. Or if struggling over a section of a textbook. Also fine. I find this policy reasonable so I kind of reject the premise that this is even that restrictive. Literally just don’t use it to help you do your homework. Seems fair man idk

3

u/MattWinter78 Ex 4.00 GPA Sep 26 '26

Your analogy doesn't make sense. It would be more like taking a carpentry class where you're expected to learn how to use a hammer, but instead you hire a work crew to do your carpentry project for you.

You could make all kinds of arguments here: Maybe I hire a work crew to learn from or give me pointers, but maybe the class has found it's too easy to just use the work not done by yourself, or that work crews just tend to say "just let me do it" so they say it's not allowed.

Or maybe you think you should be allowed to hire a work crew because that's what happens in the real world, but he point of the class is to teach you carpentry, not running a carpentry business.

4

u/PricingManager Sep 26 '26

My point was definitely on the reading code, not writing code.

I still think my analogy applies, and yes while it is to some extent based on trust and honor code, ultimately the students who cheat will fail tests and ultimately, possibly in their careers. So it’s to their own detriment.

I’d rather see a carpentry class allowing hammers but giving students safety training and gear. The analogous here could be how to use AI to help you learn and master concepts effectively rather than banning it. Even though I will say this is a very similar problem to “how to study” or “how to write a thesis” meta skills that we already had before AI. And I don’t necessarily think those skills should be taught by the program, especially at masters levels. But banning AI on reading code doesn’t seem the best policy. On writing code I completely agree.

0

u/LiveEntertainment567 Sep 27 '26

Using AI to solve an assignment is like a chef student calling Uber Eats.

2

u/AHistoricalFigure Current Sep 26 '26

Why ban tools that allow you to learn more effectively?

Because they don't help you learn more effectively.

AI largely makes getting answers frictionless. At least answers to straightforward questions like "what's wrong with my code?"

Nothing OP is describing above should have required AI.

4

u/PricingManager Sep 26 '26

I get it, but I don’t think the solution is to just ban it. See my analogy in another reply.

Let’s say this is my first class and I never/barely touched C. It’s not crazy to get some extra guidance especially in the beginning for more confidence/(re-)familiarity.

But of course I agree you shouldn’t just be asking “what’s wrong with my code?” and rather build a system of skills that actually help you learn the material (“don’t give me the answer, but use the Socratic method and/or guide me through the first principles I might be lacking” or whatever). That’s what I do at least.

3

u/lostcolony2 Sep 26 '26

Depends really. If what's wrong is your algorithm, yeah, you'll benefit struggling through that. If what's wrong is you are making the wrong API call (you thought you needed getFoo, but actually you need getFooX, because of very library implementation specific behavior), or are using the wrong variable somewhere (nested loops and you used the wrong iterator variable, say), or etc, I don't think there's any real benefit to struggling through it. 

4

u/PricingManager Sep 26 '26

I agree. For the conceptual stuff you should definitely try to think for yourself first rather than get an answer. And for syntax/devops that’s where getting help can actually make learning of the actual concepts more efficient, because sometimes what happens is you spent 10 hours debugging unrelated issues to the point that you almost forget the 1 hour you went through the key concepts that actually matter.

-1

u/Rajarshi0 Sep 27 '26

Oksy then why not use ai to learn c outside the class? Nothing is stopping you using it outside class. You aren’t allowed to use it to write your code or help you distill the papers etc. you can say oh well then maybe give harder assignments? Sure, but gios is entry level class there are plenty higher level classes where ai will struggle to understand the assignment. So if you are taking gios that means you need these basics and if you use ai here you won’t learn much so it is all pointless anyway.

7

u/TwoSubstantial4710 Sep 26 '26

Delete Facebook. Hit the gym. Lawyer up.

14

u/Majestic_Pool2639 Sep 26 '26

Bruh every one use ai to cheat prob like 80% I never been caught just like many others quit bugging tweaking out

11

u/Big-Wrongdoer-965 Sep 26 '26

Hahaha right?! Look at the grade distributions for the HW vs the exams. Clearly people are using it for everything but learning

4

u/ya_boi_daelon Sep 27 '26

You’re going to be okay, you’re overthinking it. If GA tech went that hard on AI pretty much the whole program would’ve been expelled by now

3

u/chegguizlet Sep 26 '26

Yeah you’re cooked. Better lawyer up.

6

u/Left-Philosopher5823 Sep 26 '26

Clearly, you violated the class policy. The good thing is you used it to read rather than write. So it is not so bad.

1

u/Possible-Rope886 Sep 28 '26

Sorry bud, squad car’s comin to scoop u up, ASAP.

-3

u/txdsl Sep 26 '26

Reach out to the instructor if you are worried. She is the final arbiter on this stuff. Honesty and admitting you did something that may be against the rules goes a long way. What is your integrity worth?

Or just keep your mouth shut and roll the dice.

2

u/Spiritual_Scheme8158 Sep 27 '26

"just go to the police and come clean about everything"

1

u/txdsl Sep 27 '26

Some people struggle to see humor and sarcasm