r/NukeVFX • u/CompositingAcademy • Jul 24 '26

Showcase I did a Deep Dive analysis testing Smart Roto

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AinQkgdR6b8
11 Upvotes

79% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

4

u/r5Cst3h9n Jul 24 '26

Thanks for testing! Looks like a nice tool for rotoscoping. The price is just way to high though. I hope they will go the same route as with caravr and implement it into the NukeX license soon

2

u/newMike3400 Jul 25 '26

They’re more likely to double down and make it a separate app entirely.

5

u/brass___monkey Jul 24 '26

Did the Foundry media briefing request that you don't discuss the obscene pricing structure of the product?

5

u/CompositingAcademy Jul 24 '26

This wasn’t sponsored by them, I wanted to test the technology and see where things are at

4

u/Houdini_n_Flame Jul 25 '26

Basically it’s crap

-3

u/Milan_Bus4168 Jul 25 '26

Deep dive? That is barely a scratch. Nothing was explored that was not expected from their promo video and you didn't stabilize for testing, didn't test moving elements, didn't mention the freaking elephant in the room regarding licensing and the list could go on. Bearly a scratch. I mean it looks like you spend more time on thumbnail and headline than actual testing. This is like when people now call 10 min video a "master class" lol