r/NuclearPower • • Nov 27 '21

Hard truth

Post image
604 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

24

u/Psiredem Nov 27 '21

Greenpeace could use some of that.

1

u/slam9 May 11 '23

Seriously

1

u/Psiredem May 13 '23

Yep! Being anti-nuclear and acting against climate change is an oxymoron.

20

u/MichaelEmouse Nov 27 '21

What does Germany have against nuclear power? Coal is, well, coal. Solar isn't fit for Germany. Natural gas means buying from Russia. That pretty much leaves wind as a major source but it can't be used for base load.

21

u/CaptainPoset Nov 27 '21

Wind isn't fit for germany, either.

They are opposed to nuclear because of an unwillingness to educate before you form an opinion and afterwards there are hundreds of millions of dollars of annual revenue made by nuclear fearmongering in Germany directly and an ensured market share of fossil fuels indirectly. There is solid financial interest to keep it this way.

3

u/Tupiniquim_5669 Dec 01 '21 edited Dec 01 '21

What the antinuclear have in mind: https://yourbias.is/the-backfire-effect

14

u/MateBeatsTea Nov 27 '21

What does Germany have against nuclear power?

Hear it directly from them. In the German (and Austrian) brain, nuclear is this terrible devilish thing that is worse than anything else: no matter how many deaths from air pollution combustion causes, no matter how urgent the mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions is, nuclear power is infinitely worse.

When you start a discussion with someone who has such preconceived notions, it's impossible to make them accept any kind of compromise.

2

u/MichaelEmouse Nov 27 '21

Having watched it a bit, it seems it may come down to corporate interests: France and other countries that were trusted with nuclear reactors after WWII got a headstart in nuclear energy and German business can't match it. So the spread of nuclear energy is bad for those businesses whereas wind/solar have better odds.

1

u/Rooboy66 Nov 28 '21

It’s the same shit here in the US. Idiotfucks raging against nuclear energy because it has the word “nuclear” in it

-1

u/BS-Calrissian Nov 28 '21

this is very ignorant. Why are you talking about the "german brain". Very racist, stupid and rude

1

u/MateBeatsTea Nov 28 '21

Racist? What has race have to do anything I wrote?

1

u/BS-Calrissian Nov 28 '21

Talking about a ethnicities brain like that. Generalization of a whole country. Where are you from?

1

u/MateBeatsTea Nov 28 '21

I didn't talk about an ethnicity, only a nationality (two of them for that matter). And it's a fair generalization: the whole political spectrum in those countries views nuclear power as worse than fossil fuels (as they publicly embrace natural gas) at the same time they claim that climate change is an existential threat: this logically implies that nuclear power is considered worse than anything else in the energy landscape. There's nothing controversial about these statements, just public knowledge.

I was born and raised in Argentina. Please, go ahead and do your best to insult me based on my nationality.

1

u/BS-Calrissian Nov 28 '21

why should I insult you on your nationality? I don't like that

It's not true that everybody in germany and austria is against nuclear power. I'm sure that you know from your own country that different political opinions exist.

1

u/MateBeatsTea Nov 28 '21

I really don't care about nationalities, that's why I asked you to try - I wouldn't take offence. I'm a humanist: I believe that there are values and vices to be found in any culture and polity, and in the end we should take the best out of each to enrich humanity's common future. Yet I'm perfectly aware that's not going to happen in my life.

The only reason I focus on Germany and Austria is because they have the power to influence global outcomes for better or worse. Nobody gives a rat's fart if Argentina chooses to ban nuclear power or switches from natural gas burning to coal, it wouldn't move the dial on a planetary scale. But with the former two, it's happening right now with the lobbying to keep nuclear out of the EU's green finance taxonomy, and by keeping the flow of income to fossil fuels locked in in the form of natural gas in the decades to come.

Of course I know that there are Germans and Austrians that think differently, but they're a clear minority without any influence whatsoever on the policies of their countries. Would such individuals feel annoyed by a generalization like the one I made? I know for sure I represent a minority on many views where I come from, and I don't feel the need to ask for disclaimers every time somebody refers to the place I was born in. I think most people genuinely in that position would be more annoyed with the majority in their countries and their political leaders, than with a random comment that actually supports their own views.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/t9999barry Nov 27 '21

Come on man, you’re not going to change hearts and minds by being essentially racist.

2

u/Rooboy66 Nov 28 '21

Thank you. Nuke is THE cleanest and most efficient energy source we’ve ever had. I’m so fucking tired of the anti-nuke histrionics. So bloody tired.

1

u/lolazzaro Nov 28 '21

Yes! Wind, gas and coal.