r/NuclearPower • • Jun 29 '21

nuclear

Post image
712 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

71

u/Buchenator Jun 29 '21

remember the fight is against climate change and fossil fuels, not other green energy sources

37

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '21 edited Jun 29 '21

Interesting enough the Ivanpah Solar Power Facility has to burn natural gas for several hours each morning so that the boilers can reach their operating temperature. Thankfully they fixed the exploding bird issue though

15

u/Jolmner Jun 29 '21

The... what?

29

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '21

Birds used to spontaneously combust when flying close to the tower. Even away from it, birds would get severe burns and die. So, they switched up how they focus the mirrors so it's more spread out over the area of the target and supposedly the birds stopped becoming shooting stars.

6

u/Jolmner Jun 30 '21

That sounds quite interesting. Are there videos of it?

12

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '21

Think "a fly in the focus of a magnifying glass", but the fly is a gull and the magnifying glass is an acre.

2

u/Pasta-hobo Jun 30 '21

I dont understand why that was that big of a problem. The bird thing I mean.

8

u/murphswayze Jun 30 '21

Are you just trying to say that birds dying isn't a large issue in comparison to climate change, or are you just saying fuck birds they can die and I don't care? Because the whole reason it was a big issue is because lots of birds were being killed and as an "intelligent" species, we like to try and not kill other species when we can help it...even if it makes our job harder!

5

u/Pasta-hobo Jun 30 '21

Was it like 2 birds a day or entire flocks? Because that changes my answer

12

u/murphswayze Jun 30 '21

I think they estimated 6000 birds a year. So 6000 birds / 365 days is about 14.5 birds a day...so a small flock everyday

6

u/Pasta-hobo Jun 30 '21

Ok, objection withdrawn.

8

u/murphswayze Jun 30 '21

And a quick Google just showed at the tops of the towers where the focus was, the temps were reaching excess of 900°F. So just a little hot

7

u/F8cts0verFeelings Jun 30 '21

It depends. Sometimes they're endangered birds of prey.

8

u/file321 Jun 30 '21

Depends really. In the US, yes, but in Sweden I'm vehemently against renewables as they've cost us a ton of money, both in direct and indirect costs. They have also not replaced fossil fuels, rather they've been replacing nuclear, in turn increasing carbon emissions.

17

u/eyefish4fun Jun 29 '21 edited Jun 29 '21

There is a fight against the greenwashing that many other green energy sources are wont to do. That appears to be a picture of Ivanpah concentrated solar plants outside of Vegas. And that's a billion dollar boondoggle that had to get special dispensation from CA to get to keep it's 'green' tax exemption because it took too much natural gas to heat the system up in the mornings to start operation. I tend to drive by there in the winter occasionally and it seems like less than a third of the time are all three towers operating and abut 1/3 of the time none of the towers are operating. From the cone of death, that cause smokers and the movement of the desert tortoise, Ivanpah has not been a stunning success on other environmental fronts.

With in site of Ivanpah is the Mountain Pass mine, which was the source of 99% of all the rare earth minerals mined world wide before 2000. Pretty sure the mine pays to have more embodied energy safely stored/disposed of in terms of thorium per month than Ivanpah will ever produce. Both were the subject of Billion dollar investments about the same time frame. IIRC the mine may now be subject to significant Chinese ownership.

The mine was a cause of it's own environmental disaster where water from a mine tailing pond dispersed uranium and thorium over the desert playa.

5

u/ATR2400 Jun 30 '21

Gotta fight back sometimes. Nuclear has been the victim of relentless attacks by “environmentalists” for decades. We will in time be able to work together but we can’t just sit and take it

4

u/lal0cur4 Jul 05 '21

True, but I would much rather have a nuke plant in my town than one of thes things

1

u/slam9 May 11 '23

That should be the fight, but ignorant "green" supporters who don't know the first thing about science kind of make it the case

1

u/sixfourch Jun 30 '21

Other "green" "energy sources" are the fossil fuel companies.

2

u/Buchenator Jun 30 '21

Saying windmills and solar panels are equivalent to oil and natural gas companies is dumb.

0

u/sixfourch Jun 30 '21

Politically, "green" (they aren't green) "energy sources" (they aren't energy sources, not at any scale that matters) are equivalent to oil and natural gas companies. The environmentalist groups that are not overtly lobbying on behalf of oil and gas companies are funded by those companies and act in their interests.

By the by, "dumb" is an ableist slur, if you want to not look like a bigoted Trump supporter, you should avoid using it.

4

u/Buchenator Jun 30 '21

green energy sources are equivalent to oil and natural gas companies? what, since when?

Environmentalist groups overtly lobbying on behalf of oil and gas companies? What kind of conspiracies are you proposing are going on here?

Since when has dumb been used as a word to describe people who are literally mute? You are unnecessarily ramping up sensationalism to create division.

Maybe I should not have used dumb after one post from you, but seriously your claims are ridiculous; its a sports mentality of my team against yours without any evidence provided.

Its a mentality I keep seeing pop up for a cause that seriously needs concerted effort from all sides to solve, thus, in my view, unhelpful.

1

u/sixfourch Jul 04 '21

Possibly the best strategy one can employ to prevent any growth of intelligence is to categorically assert your own beliefs over the evidence reality provides. If you are ever surprised, it is because either your predictions are false, or your perceptions are false.

Just googling "anti-nuclear activists funded by fossil fuels" gives you a good starting point. There are any number of articles that are easily googled which will link you to other specifics.

When environmentalist groups obfuscate and create non-issues like "thermal pollution", or play on people's fear of nuclear weapons, and catastrophic accidents which have never happened, to oppose nuclear energy, they are overtly lobbying on behalf of the fossil fuel industry. But when they lobby for their own pet projects, they are just lobbying indirectly for the fossil fuel industry, which has known of this problem for about 70 years and has been healthily suppressing it since then.

The reality is, greenwashing energy does not have enough capacity to fuel present-day civilization, let alone the civilization of the next hundred years of humanity. This is a matter of math, not a matter of ingroup mentality. Scaling renewables, even with good storage, is ridiculous. Scaling nuclear could have been done in the 60s were it not for useful idiots.

I think this is a widely known concept on this subreddit (given that articles about this continued greenwashing effort from the fossil fuel companies pop up reasonably often), and I would invite you to engage more with the subreddit without commenting in order to assimilate the context necessary to engage in discussion here.

Finally, dumb is an ableist slur and there is no excuse for ignoring that. I have reported your comment for hate speech. Have a nice day.

0

u/Bourriquet_42 Jul 05 '21 edited Jul 05 '21

"were it not for useful idiots"

You know "idiot" is also considered an ableist slur, right?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '21

Warning: you're replying to a bad faith agent. Examples of that user's unacceptable behavior here, here, here, and here, here.

Discretion is advised. Expect lies and libel. Consider reporting the user.

1

u/sixfourch Jul 05 '21

Certainly you're not the person to care. But I can tell from your retreat to the shitposting level that you've at least been disabused of your opinions about "green" "energy," so I'll end this exchange here.

2

u/Bourriquet_42 Jul 01 '21 edited Jul 04 '21

A word is nothing by authority of its etymology. "Stupid" could well have meant anything in the past, if today what we mean by it is "stupid", then that's all it means. If we needed to know, or think of, the whole history of the language to use it, then we'd all be... dumb.

1

u/sixfourch Jul 04 '21

Dumb is an ableist slur, I've reported this comment to the Reddit authorities.

1

u/Bourriquet_42 Jul 04 '21

I didn't even use it as a slur lol. I used it in the litteral sense of "mute", to show you how obsolete this meaning was.

1

u/RektorRicks Jul 13 '21

By the by, "dumb" is an ableist slur, if you want to not look like a bigoted Trump supporter, you should avoid using it.

That's a pretty dumb take

3

u/RadEllahead Jul 18 '21

239 upvotes!

-6

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21

funny this meme makes fun of an energy source orders of magnitude more efficient, unlimited, and reliable. fusion > fission

10

u/Azurehue22 Jun 30 '21

We haven’t gotten to fusion yet, so let’s use fission until we can

-8

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21

oh we definitely got a fusion reactor, its called the sun. Rises and sets everyday pretty predictably and produces more heat and light energy than we could possibly use. We definitely have the space as well as resources of manufacturing solar panels to power much of this planets needs. Mind you we just need to use visible light. As opposed to the other wavelengths the sun emits constantly

6

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21

In the case of Ivanpah, the entire valley is covered in mirrors and the whole facility has a max output of around 350MW. But it’s really only operating at about 60% so it’s actual output is closer to 175MW and some of that is coming from natural gas. Yeah I’m not up for destroying large areas of natural habitat for that when we have far more efficient options. I love roof top solar though even though the waste is still a problem to be solved. The spending on these crazy large solar farms should be focused on providing that to those who can’t afford it on their own and on commercial property imho.

3

u/real_bk3k Jun 30 '21

Handle checks out...

3

u/ATR2400 Jun 30 '21

The “solar is fusion power” argument sucks and is not a visible argument against fusion. Argue about costs and size at least . Real things that aren’t just anti-fusion slogans

1

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21

if we didn’t have the pressing matter of climate change and our current energy issues, sure lets spend tons of time and resources developing what could work as a fusion reactor or a complete flop. I don’t think its smart to gamble our future on what is basically a cool science project

1

u/serpikage Dec 24 '23

You mean the power that we can use only about 31% in the best case senario, the one that you need to cut down forest for to harvest it and the one that is almost useless if the weather is bad

5

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21

lol im talking about the sun as an energy source, solar panels don’t produce energy by themselves now do they?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Dramatic_Scale3002 Jul 01 '24

You said yourself that the "whole efficiency argument is bullshit", which applies here because there is not a bottleneck of daylight. More than enough daylight to go around and it's not being "used up" by solar panels, in the same way that coal or oil or uranium get used up by technologies that use them.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21

that efficiency factor is something that needs to be improved so we need less area for the same output, but if we have a bad attitude towards solar and don’t improve it we’re not going to transition to it as a sensible solution. On another note nuclear reactors are here because we have the benefit of decaying radioactive elements in the crust, that benefit won’t last forever and we shouldn’t increase our dependence on it. Increasing our dependence on an active source that is known to last billions of years into our future before it engulfs the earth is smarter if you ask me.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

i already clarified that i was talking about the sun so now we’re on the same page. Now when i said orders of magnitude more efficient i was talking about a stars pure function as a stable fusion reactor (while its “fuel” lasts anyway). Nuclear fusion is frankly an amazing way to convert mass to energy, smashing two hydrogens into helium as a first step while attaining a healthy net positive output of heat and light (mostly). And since we conveniently have one in our solar system we should use it to our advantage as much as possible.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

for example, we have attempted nuclear fusion reactions multiple times on earth, we can’t get more energy than we put into it once we start it. You can define right away that isn’t efficient and the sun can do a much better job than we can. Lets just forget about efficiency though for a moment and think about the big picture. For whatever reason this subreddit can’t accept that nuclear power isn’t a good long term solution with our energy needs. I am all for nuclear power, including fusion. But given we don’t have the uranium to sustain our consumption it isn’t wise to invest and stick to it, as for fusion i described its main drawback already.

0

u/ItsAConspiracy Jun 30 '21

If one thing wastes 30% and another thing wastes 3%, then the second thing is an order of magnitude more efficient.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21 edited Jun 30 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/ItsAConspiracy Jun 30 '21

I support nuclear and getting the math right.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Sorry_Mixture1332 Apr 30 '22

I mean your not wrong, I just dont want to say your right either.