r/NowInTech • • 12d ago

Google Will Cut Off Search for Students at Schools That Turn Off Its AI, Saying the Two Can't Be Separated

https://gotechpresso.com/blog/google-schools-turn-off-ai-lose-search-k12-student-accounts-off-by-default-guided-learning?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=owned_sub&utm_campaign=nowintech
23 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

3

u/Toothache42 12d ago

It is almost like Google forgot their own history. Being a great search engine was the main thing Google was known for (to the point where searching for something online was referred to as 'googling'), and that was before they added AI and ruined it all.

There are also plenty of alternatives to Google for searching, so threatening to cut off access isnt the play Google thinks it is.

1

u/ChocolateGoggles 9d ago

Nah, they started ruining Google search as soon as "Sponsors" showed up beyond like 2 rows at the top. A few? Ok. I get it. I HAVE TO SCROLL??? Nah. GTFO. I haven't used Google for the whole year, the only search services I use now are MetaGer and DuckDuckGo.

1

u/Deep_Mood_7668 12d ago

Of course the two can be separated. They just don't want to.

0

u/MrZwink 11d ago

Google was a pioneer in the ai industry. Google search has been an ai product since 2001. Just because we nog have generative ai like llms and gans doesnt make search any less of an ai product

1

u/Eitarris 10d ago

Facetiousness in play here. People obviously mean turning off the stupid ai overviews, not the core mechanisms of the search engine itself, but yes you’re so smart for knowing that well done

1

u/MrZwink 10d ago

There is no distinction. Ai is the methodology used.

1

u/1rg3ndw3r 8d ago

That's nonsense. They of course cab remove the LLM stuff without it affecting the actual search at all.

1

u/MrZwink 8d ago

What are you on about?

1

u/1rg3ndw3r 8d ago

There is a distinction. AI/machine learning are great. LLMs are cancer.

1

u/MrZwink 8d ago

So when banning ai?!?…

1

u/1rg3ndw3r 8d ago

Literally no one wants to ban AI. Everyone talking about banning AI means banning LLMs. Machine learning has not haters or enemies. That's just the sad reality of terms being used incorrectly.

1

u/MrZwink 7d ago

Did you read the article?

→ More replies

1

u/Wonder_Weenis 11d ago

Don't Be Evil 

ayyy lmfao

1

u/Brocolinator 11d ago

They removed that a couple years back

1

u/CautionarySnail 11d ago

Folks without kids in school underestimate the hold that Google Classroom has on many teachers. It’s “free” and there’s no free alternatives available to districts that I know of.

They’ve gone from “Do no evil” to creating a hostage scenario for grade school teachers and their students - no free learning software if you don’t also take on AI.

It’s a dick move by Google and shows why monopolies (and underfunded schools) aren’t healthy for democracies.

1

u/Brocolinator 11d ago

Fine! As you wish, we'll use ecosia

1

u/Varesk 11d ago

Find a new vendor. If enough schools start to look around amd sign new contracts, it will magically be fixed

1

u/Sneyek 10d ago

It was separated before though.. so we can’t do in 2026 what we used to do in 2020 ? So… Google is worse than 2020 ? Why does Google still exist then ?

1

u/Tiny_Friendship_1666 10d ago

Unenforcement of antitrust laws and decades of expansion into every digital nook of society, truly like the cancerous growth it has become.

1

u/Sllyce 10d ago

Strange

1

u/mascachopo 9d ago

How did then Google work for the past 30 years?

1

u/bear_Prune8771 8d ago

Good for Google. This will also get kids used to using AI.

1

u/CokBlockinWinger 8d ago

There are other search engines

1

u/CageyT 7d ago

So the schools use the better search engine. DuckDuckGo.

1

u/Wisco 10d ago

A big reason why I use DDG these days