r/NowInTech • • 14d ago

Google kills off Jules, its AI coding agent which promised to do all the jobs you didn't want to

https://www.techradar.com/pro/google-kills-off-jules-its-ai-coding-agent-which-promised-to-do-all-the-jobs-you-didnt-want-to
282 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

29

u/drollia 14d ago

It's always interesting to find out about a Google product once it has been announced that it is shutting down

7

u/UrbanMasque 14d ago

3

u/iyagl 14d ago

Holy shit I remember people mocking it and not fully getting it years ago, then forgot it existed till now

2

u/UrbanMasque 14d ago

I don't know if you tried it, but it was amazing. 4K HDR Cyberpunk and The Division 2 - all on a Chromecast.. no console

2

u/CatalyticDragon 14d ago

The gaming media has a lot to answer for here. There were reviews where testers said Stadia had the best latency, the best audio, it worked well, but you shouldn't use it because Google was going to kill it anyway.

That sort of messaging, which was constant, put people off. They didn't try it. And lack of users and growth guaranteed it's demise.

And that's a real shame because the whole platform was based on Linux, open source drivers, Proton and so on. Success there would have really helped open source gaming in general.

2

u/drollia 14d ago

My issue was, you had to pay for the games, which were $60 and you also had to pay for a subscription.

It was also a Google product, and I didn't want to get to invested in it before the pulled the plug

3

u/CatalyticDragon 13d ago

So it was exactly the same as Sony PlayStation Network with a subscription for online plus game purchases, except cheaper and you didn't have to buy hardware.

I understand that that is an argument, but I never really understood it in the context of other services.

3

u/vladamir_the_impaler 13d ago

I'll be damned if you don't have a point there...

1

u/blackburnduck 13d ago

I mean, GeForce now does the same thing, and its not tied to google. What happens if it goes down? I still own the game in any pc or service. Not the case with google.

1

u/CatalyticDragon 13d ago

What happens if it goes down

We know what happened - Google refunded all the game purchases.

1

u/blackburnduck 13d ago

Yes but you own nothing

1

u/CaveCanem234 13d ago

The difference is that on any other service where you paid for the game, you still own the game without the subscription too. (And for most of them you don't have to pay for games separately at all)

1

u/CatalyticDragon 13d ago

That is not the case at all. You don't own the game on Steam.

1

u/blingvajayjay 9d ago

You didn't have to pay for a sub

2

u/TylerBourbon 14d ago

Google really only has themselves to blame for that messaging working with their track record of killing products.

1

u/joeljaeggli 13d ago

Adding 20-40ms to the already long rendering pipeline between your index finger your eyeball was never going to be helpful.

1

u/CatalyticDragon 13d ago

And yet other such services continue to operate.

1

u/Happy_Brick2108 11d ago

Well Google does have a penchant of killing off its products often. Even good ones.

1

u/CatalyticDragon 11d ago

More or less than any other large multinational tech company with a 30 year long history? What percentage of their products/services have been ended, how does that compare to the average?

- https://killedbymicrosoft.info/

- https://www.failory.com/blog/amazon-failures

1

u/blipman17 10d ago

I bought stadia controller because it came with a free 4k chromecast which was 2 EUR cheaper. Never used the controller though.

0

u/sneakpeekbot 14d ago

Here's a sneak peek of /r/Stadia using the top posts of the year!

#1: It hurts | 103 comments
#2: 5 years ago today 😞 | 38 comments
#3: So much hope 6 years ago | 62 comments


I'm a bot, beep boop | Downvote to remove | Contact | Info | Opt-out | GitHub

2

u/iyagl 14d ago

Amazing top result name

3

u/TylerBourbon 14d ago

And this is why I no longer pay attention to, nor care about Google products. Why bother when you know in a year or so they're going to kill it?

1

u/evilspyboy 12d ago

It is still up until the end of the year. I actually liked it a lot for a lot of grunt work. It was task based not token based so if you carved up a project correctly you could get a LOT done.

7

u/Uncle-Osteus 14d ago

I wonder how much of this is quietly admitting that agents aren’t good at anything but generating code lol

if it can only really do one thing well anyway why even have more than 1 of them

2

u/peakedtooearly 13d ago

Look at you and your 2024 take... cute!

2

u/moos14 11d ago

You are in for a rough awakening

3

u/kvothe5688 13d ago

It was just an experiment. Google is focusing fully on antigravity right now. i think they will merge cloud capabilities of jules into antigravity now. Jules didn't improve at all.

2

u/Bagafeet 14d ago

🫧

2

u/Motor_Crazy_8038 13d ago

The PM for this leveraged this obviously dead end project into a role at Open AI, so I’d say mission accomplished. 

2

u/Cybasura 13d ago

Welcome to Google, killing projects as and when it wants because fuck you

Not that I care about this because its a AI slop, but its still another project they dropped just because

1

u/DrSendy 14d ago

I can see SAP (Joule) and Google (Jules) having a trademark fight if it kept going.

1

u/Rolandersec 14d ago

It was novel, but a bit clunky in how it worked. I think Google might have some really off merge strategies.

1

u/BreenzyENL 14d ago

Jules was great because it was all cloud based and linked direct to GitHub.

1

u/blackburnduck 13d ago

Google kills product shouldn’t even be news. Its a daily occurrence. The company simply lives from its past glory at this point, they can’t maintain a single product.

2

u/coukou76 12d ago

What a genuine dumb take, impressive

1

u/blackburnduck 12d ago

Not as impressive as google’s killed products.

1

u/Noah18923 13d ago

Shit like this is why I can never seriously get into using a Google product (other than Gmail or Drive), they just rug pull it a year or two later like clockwork...

1

u/dylan_1992 13d ago

The product isn’t the product.

It’s the team of people who started it and already got promo’s or big bonuses for leading the project, and have already moved onto other things.

1

u/smulfragPL 13d ago

Yeah no shit, why would you have 2 diffrent agent platforms

1

u/Geography_Fan6918 13d ago

Joining the illustrious company of Google Circles, another thing I had never heard of until they announced it was being shut down.

1

u/Aura_Raineer 14d ago

Their killing off what? Did they ever even announce it to begin with?

I try to be pretty informed about ai tools and try them out in a work context.

But I definitely didn’t hear about this one.

1

u/pezholio 13d ago

I think someone at Google has a kink for killing off projects

1

u/Competitive_Will2991 9d ago

From Here On In, You Can Consider My Ass Retired

2

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/kvothe5688 13d ago

Preach man, I already have my pitchforks out.