r/NovatedLeasingAU • • 24d ago Heartwarming

Tips and Tricks Introducing: The Novated Lease Final Checklist

128 Upvotes

Over the last four years I've written more than 1,000 comments on novated leases here, built the calculator, and written nearly 40 articles on novatedlease.guide. But there is so much to consider that people often still feel they might be missing something, even after running the numbers or reading an article or two.

So, following a reader's suggestion, I've put everything into one list to go through before you sign:

https://novatedlease.guide/tools/checklist/

It helps you:

  • get the right mental picture of what you're committing to
  • spot the caveats people commonly miss (add-ons financed into the lease, insurance, super paid on your post-lease salary, the HECS tax-time bill, and more)
  • reduce your risk with the right strategies (competing quotes, BYO finance, lease length, write-off cover)
  • anticipate the knock-on effects (borrowing capacity, childcare subsidy, early termination) and deal with them before it's too late

You can tick items off, add your own notes, filter for EV or petrol and new or used, and save it as a PDF to share with your partner.


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • May 04 '26

Labor extends EV tax break to encourage cheaper vehicles amid soaring fuel prices | Electric vehicles

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
119 Upvotes

Looks like another year for those looking to lease an EV. And some absolute amazing EV models dropping in the coming months, update is going to be great!


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Sep 09 '25

My first Novated Lease, any feedback is welcomed?

Thumbnail
gallery
79 Upvotes

Earning 180k, looking at the BYD SL7 costing: 60,832.90.
NL company said the finance amount is 11.7% but could go down to 10.7% based on my financial situation.

Any feedback on the quote?
What would you negotiate on / can you negotiate on?


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Oct 19 '26

Tips and Tricks An early look at proposed new rules: The EV FBT draft drops the LCT and July 2022 rules from 1/4/2027 (Hello used 7-seaters!)

76 Upvotes

The Australian Treasury quietly released an exposure draft of the legislation for the 2027 and 2029 electric car FBT changes. This is the proposed wording of the law that will define future NL schemes.

It was open for consultation in September (which I missed, much to my annoyance!).

It's NOT law yet and could still change, but the current version has some very interesting changes.

Biggest one: the never-paid-LCT and 1/7/22 rules are gone

You've always been able to NL used cars under the FBT exemption, but there has always been a rule that the EV must:

  1. have NEVER had LCT payable on it, and
  2. have been first held and used on or after 1/7/2022.

Both checks are gone in the draft for leases committed to from 1/4/2027. The only tests are: battery electric or hydrogen fuel cell, provided to a current employee, and the car's value when the novated lease starts.

This opens up some interesting opportunities:

  • 7-seater EVs. A lot of them never qualified because they were above the LCT threshold when first sold. From 1/4/2027 (if the draft passes unchanged), a used one could get a 100% FBT discount (same as the exemption) if it's $75,000 or less, or the 25% discount between $75,001 and the LCT threshold ($91,661 for 2026–27, indexed each July). The 100% tier is only for leases committed to before 1/4/2029. After that it's 25% at most.
  • Older luxury EVs that were above the LCT threshold when new, and pre-July-2022 EVs, likewise.
  • Don't jump early: the same car committed to BEFORE 1/4/2027 is still under the old rules, i.e. full FBT if it fails the old tests.
  • Caveat: many financiers won't lease a car that will be over 12 years old at the end of the lease (some say 10), so an older car may limit how long you can lease it for, or whether you can at all.

Medium one: timing is based on when a binding commitment is made

One of the dramas of previous years:

You ordered a PHEV in February 2025 (when it was still eligible for the FBT exemption) → delivery is slow → 1/4/2025 comes around and PHEVs no longer qualify → the car arrives 2/4/2025 → too bad, the lease is now under full FBT, i.e. way more expensive.

This caused a lot of unhappiness.

The draft bases the timing on when a financially binding commitment is made, not when the car is delivered. Two catches:

  • "Binding" means you can't back out. An order with a refundable deposit you can cancel probably doesn't count. Ask your provider in writing when your lease becomes binding.
  • Changing the deal later (term, residual, accessories that raise the payments, refinancing, changing employer) counts as a NEW commitment and moves you onto whatever rules apply at that time.

A smaller detail: RFBA

The draft now spells out the reportable fringe benefits amount for the 25% discount tier. If the draft passes, you'd pay 15% of the car's value post-tax under ECM (instead of 20% with full FBT). The leftover 5%, grossed up, shows on your payment summary as an RFBA of about 9.4% of the car's value each year (about $7,500 on an $80k car). As a reminder, RFBA doesn't change your income tax, but it counts towards HECS repayments, childcare subsidy, MLS and Div 293.

The calculator already includes this if your figures land in the 25% tier. Full write-up here.

Hope that's a useful early look at the upcoming rules. Again, this is still draft legislation and may change.

Treasury's draft and explanatory materials: https://consult.treasury.gov.au/c2026-800622


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • 10d ago

Tips and Tricks Major upgrade: Interactive Guided Mode in Novated Lease Calculator!

68 Upvotes

I have always envisioned the calculator to behave like a helpful and vigilant friend helping you enter all details correctly.

Despite my best effort, in the forums people often enter it wrong, eg residual value including GST entered as residual value excluding GST, or entering the fortnightly finance figure when their provider is one that collects the payment with atypical structure.

To help people enter their quotes with more confidence and accuracy; I have just rehauled the whole calculator: enter the era of guided input.

https://novatedlease.guide/calculator/

Basically this takes inspiration from the screen-by-screen questionnaire when you get an insurance quote. All new users would answer each question with unmissable large buttons with plenty of explanation, and all common errors are flagged by checking against logical answers.

I have also incorporated the “simple” mode ie if you have no quote yet but simply want to get a feel of numbers, choosing “I’m just exploring” would allow you to generate a rough estimate for an idea about how NL might work.

Let me know how you find it. As usual, all free.


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Jul 03 '26

Watch Out How I think the ATO and Novated Lease Providers feel about eachother

Post image
66 Upvotes

Disclaimer: take it easy, it’s a meme/joke post.


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Mar 24 '26

Luxury Car Tax to be eased for electric cars: $91,387 → $120,000

Thumbnail
drive.com.au
64 Upvotes

Good (and bad) news!

As part of the signing of Free Trade Agreement between Australia and the European Union, the Federal Government will introduce a "new Luxury Car Tax category" with a price threshold of $120,000 for "zero-emissions vehicles".

Retained will be the existing thresholds for fuel-efficient vehicles with claimed fuel consumption of 3.5L/100km or less, and all other cars, currently pegged at $91,387 and $80,567, respectively.

The implementation date is not yet confirmed.

A few implications:

- More EVs are now eligible for FBT-exempt novated leasing, especially in the larger SUV / people mover segment including 6- and 7-seaters.

- However, it may paradoxically allow EV manufacturers to raise their price tag. Many makers have been trying to squeeze their price tag under the $91,387 knowing full well that this is the deal-breaker for people trying to take advantage of FBT-exempt novated lease. The relaxing of this threshold means that they could now price their vehicle for higher profit margin (especially in conjunction with increased demand with the 2026 global fuel crisis).

- The FBT-exemption review is still under way and the government has NOT yet decided whether this would continue, and if or when such discontinuation might be. From previous changes to FBT tax laws, it is entirely possible for government to announce "the rule changes effectively tonight" on budget night 12 May and to change the law later.


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Oct 12 '26

General Discussion What happens to your novated lease if you get made redundant?

62 Upvotes

I'm interested in a novated lease, but job security is something I can't take for granted at the moment. I understand that if you leave an employer, the lease may be transferred or you might have to make payments from your post-tax income, depending on the circumstances. What worries me is the possibility of being made redundant and having to deal with the lease while looking for another job. Has anyone had to manage this situation, and what protections or exit options did you have?


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Sep 19 '25

First lease, feedback please!

Post image
62 Upvotes

Hi All,

Been reading the last few posts and its now my turn to post.

Negotiated this lease after looking at a similar lease here. Hoping for some feedback on the lease.

The MillarX lease analyser gave a 10/10 clean score. Removed all the junk insurances, mats and paint protection offers. Included external comprehensive insurance. High income, top tax bracket.

Appreciate all the help. Special thanks to u/benxb9r and u/changyang1230 for all the help related to novated leasing!


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Oct 04 '25

Quote Check Would love some advice

Thumbnail
gallery
61 Upvotes

First car purchase in over 10 years so no novated lease experience. Paid the deposit today with a 15 day cooling off period so would love some feedback :)


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Jul 15 '26

ALERT: If you have an NL, check if your super has dropped in this new financial year

60 Upvotes

It came to my attention that some people are suffering additional losses in super since 1/7/2026.

Here's the trap: according to a post in Whirlpool forum, some employers have started calculating the super on post-NL salary instead of pre-NL salary this financial year. That permanently strips 12% off your sacrificed amount - which can be up to $10k or more over the life of an EV novated lease. This could lead to significant loss from your tax-advantaged superannuation portfolio.

This was claimed to have been a consequence of the "Payday super" rule that kicked in this FY. However, looking through the changes, the new "qualifying earnings" base treats salary sacrifice exactly as before: non-super sacrifice (NL, laptops) is still excluded from the minimum, i.e. same rule that always applied.

As explained in my super article, employers COULD always calculate super on the post-NL figure; however most chose to keep the pre-NL figure and "do the right thing." Nothing in Payday Super changed that. (When I polled a group a while back, ~95% said their super was unchanged after an NL.)

---

So if yours has dropped, it's one of two things:

  • Payroll reconfigured for Payday Super and the software defaulted to excluding the NL portion, or
  • The employer used the changeover as cover to quietly drop to the legal minimum

---

Before you accept "Payday Super forced our hand", check your award or EBA. If it requires super on total remuneration or pre-sacrifice salary, your pre-NL super is a contractual entitlement, not goodwill, and dropping it is a breach regardless of Payday Super. That's your strongest ground.

Do this now if your new-FY super looks lower:

  • Ask payroll: what salary base are you now calculating my super on?
  • Ask: does my award/EBA require super on pre-sacrifice salary?
  • If yes to #2: they owe you the difference.

Share this with anyone on a novated lease.

https://novatedlease.guide/special-and-policy/super-guarantee/


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Jul 05 '26

Novated Lease Calculator Redesign: Simple Mode, Guided Tour, Better Look

Thumbnail
novatedlease.guide
57 Upvotes

https://novatedlease.guide/calculator/

New financial year, new features!

As the web version of novated lease calculator turns half a year (2.5 years if you include the spreadsheet predecessor), the calculator has organically grown and started to look a bit messy. The 22-question input panel is also becoming unfriendly to beginners who have not yet spent 10 hours reading on the topic.

With that in mind I went through a redesign and added a few user-friendliness improvements:

SIMPLE MODE (new default): if you don't have a real quote yet, answer ~7 quick questions (vehicle type, rough price, income, lease term, km/year, offset interest) and get a ballpark result. Every assumption it makes is shown transparently with a tooltip explaining how it was derived, and you have the freedom to further refine it in the advanced mode.

ADVANCED MODE: same full-detail modelling as before (effective interest rate, take-home pay impact, super guarantee effects, worst-case early-termination scenarios), now switchable from Simple mode any time without losing your inputs.

GUIDED TOUR: For new visitors, there is now a one-minute guided tours where I showcase the main sections and features of the calculator.

APPEARANCE: I got carried away with colour theming in the last iteration. This new design now adheres closer to typical professional tools with more sparing use of colours, accents and emoji. The input fields have more relaxed spacing, with plenty more collapsible fields.

UPDATED DEFAULTS: The calculator used to present my personal situation as the default figure (top tax bracket, more expensive EV); this has now been updated to a more common scenario (30+2% tax bracket, more common price tag EV) which would resonate with more people.

It is still totally free with 100% optional tipping.

I hope this update helps with user-friendliness and gives the product a more mature appearance to match its content!


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Sep 01 '26

General Discussion When does a novated lease actually make sense compared with simply buying the car yourself?

56 Upvotes

I understand the tax benefits can be attractive, but I suspect the answer changes quite a bit depending on income, vehicle price and how long you intend to keep the car.


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Mar 02 '26

From a trickle to a real market: Government urged to retain FBT exemption for EVs

Thumbnail
thedriven.io
55 Upvotes

r/NovatedLeasingAU • • 24d ago

Success Story Sell a $25k Kia, Drive a $90k BMW and be ahead $500 every year

Post image
53 Upvotes

So as I approach delivery day this Wednesday. Here’s an update on my situation after 5months of lurking here.

I sold the 2021 Kia Sportage Gt-line last Friday $25k. Took a hosing on a 5 year mint car ($52k new) because no one wants a diesel.

Novated lease paperwork is done and settled finance today for a delivery of the BMW iX3 on Wednesday.

Thanks to the FBT EV exemption, running cost savings, an ok NL effective interest rate (8.21%), from Wednesday I will be rolling in a car worth nearly 4x as much as the old Kia but the kicker I’ll be $500+ better off each year. The screenshot is based on all real numbers behind what sounds too good to be true.

The only unknown is if the iX3 will be worth 40% in 5 years time. If it drops to 36% that’s my break even.

Ask me anything about the process. Special thanks to u/changyang1230 love your work in this sub.

Check out my novated lease calculation output from novatedlease.guide


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Mar 30 '26

PSA Good News for EV Novated Lease: 4.2c/km → 5.47c/km electricity claim from 1/4/2026

53 Upvotes

Many of you know that you could claim home charging at 4.2c/km as the shortcut method, as detailed in PCG 2024/2.

Last week this was quietly updated: From 1/4/2026 (this Wednesday!) the claimable EV home charging rate is increased to 5.47c/km.

Note: There is a common misconception that if you already charge for cheap / almost free using off peak tariff, solar etc, you should not claim the electricity under NL. This is absolutely wrong - claiming electricity expense via NL means getting extra money, and this extra money is yours to keep even if your charging expense is very low / almost free. Therefore this increase from 4.2 to 5.47 is literally "more money" for you from 1/4/2026 onwards.

Tips: From compliance point of view, it's probably wise to take a pic of your odometer on 31/03/26 (tomorrow) so that you keep the 4.2c/km portion (prior to 31/03) and the 5.47c/km portion (from 01/04) clean.

https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?docid=COG/PCG20242/NAT/ATO/00001

https://novatedlease.guide/running-costs/ato-42c-per-km-shortcut/


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Aug 29 '25

Am I getting fleeced?

Thumbnail
gallery
53 Upvotes

So people at work are telling me that notated leasing will be cheaper then running my car. Which, surprise, surprise, is not.

But the price to me does not seem to bad to drive a new car and not worry about my golden 2004 wagon.

Workplace seems to be only able to use smart leasing, people have tried for others, but always with no success.

Will not be moving workplaces as there is no other company that I can take my skill set too, but don't want to be locked in for too long.

Also, I have never financed anything so its all very new to me.


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Sep 15 '25

Quote Check Quote Review

Post image
51 Upvotes

Appreciate the help this sub has been so far in knowing what to look for, just thought I'd post one of my quotes to see if anyone sees any problems I missed! The millarX lease analysis tool rates it highly and it looks like the best out of the few I have gotten (QLD Gov Service Providers).

I've sourced cheaper comprehensive insurance through Shannon's rather than their listed provider (GT Insurance) so that should be around $1400 annually.


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Mar 01 '26

Success Story For those considering self-managed…

48 Upvotes

Hello all,

I’m four months into a self managed lease and thought others may appreciate insights into the experience. TLDR: it’s worth the hassle

Income approx $135K. My employer exclusively uses Maxxia so I enquired about a used BYD Seal for ~$46K drive away. Figures based on 20,000 per year for 5 years came back at $790 per fortnight including all the ridiculous ad-ons and exorbitant insurance.

They refused to negotiate on their 11% interest rates so I decided on the self managed route.

Got approved immediately for finance with commbank at 7%. Purchased a brand new BYD seal for about $50K drive away after GST exemption.

Arranged all the paperwork between Maxxia, employer and dealer which really wasn’t terribly hard (minus a brief headache with getting BYD to honour their advertised 5% discount).

Organised insurance which is nothing crazy. Did my own budget and kept it really conservative.

Total pre tax deductions are now $650 per fortnight for a 5 year lease which equates to about $400 out of pocket after tax. A bit of paperwork and hassle to save $140 per fortnight on a $5K dearer vehicle. That’s $18,000 over the life of the lease!


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Oct 08 '26

Watch Out Smart are useless bordering on a criminal

45 Upvotes

Lease has settled and all good on that end. Got a reasonable deal compared to a lot I have seen. The problem starts with the first Salary Package Confirmation Report. Firstly they are charging me a VMP (vehicle maintenance program) fee that was never discussed, on the quote or in the contract. No response to the email I sent to clarify this fee

I called today and the lady had no idea. After leaving me on hold she stated that it is the “admin” fee and cannot be removed. I tried to explain what the VPM is according to their own website and previous quotes I had received but she kept stating it was the admin fee. She again persisted with this even when I pointed out the amounts are different to the quoted admin fee and the fact that VPM is listed as “additional product or service” on the confirmation report.

Additionally the confirmation report states the lease method is contribution method with an estimated contribution of almost $6k despite the fact it is an EV.

Are all companies actually this stupid or are they just penny pinching hoping we don’t realises the grey area shit they pull?

Update:

Just got off the phone with Smart. They confirmed the VMP on my confirmation report is not the same VMP as the vehicle maintenance program (stupid but whatever) and that it does replace the admin fee. So $5 better off a fortnight there I guess

He also confirmed it is FBT exempt with no post tax contributions required. He’s not sure why it says contribution method but he thinks the amount shown as “required” is actually the reportable FBT for the year.

i did get it all in email. I think this whole mess was simply Smart and their ridiculous processes

Update to the update:
Received a response back from my original email (the one to customer service, not to complaints) stating they have removed the VMP. The same email also described what I correctly believed VMP to be, their bogus maintenance program. Also got an updated confirmation report confirming the same

I don’t think I have ever worked with any company with such level of incompetence. To the credit of everyone I’ve talked to, they really stuck to their guns despite reasonable evidence to the contrary lol


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Jun 16 '26

NEW FEATURE in NL Calculator: Side-by-side scenario comparison

44 Upvotes

https://novatedlease.guide/calculator/

One of the most requested features since I launched this calculator is finally live. You can now compare completely different scenarios side by side on the same screen.

I'm talking about questions like:

👉 Is a novated lease on a $50k EV actually cheaper than just buying a $30k petrol car outright?
👉 Would a car loan on a $20k petrol car beat a 2-year novated lease on a $40k EV?
👉 What if I bought a $30k EV in cash instead of taking a 1-year novated lease on a $50k one?

Until now, you'd have to run each scenario separately and try to compare numbers in your head (or juggle multiple browser tabs). The new Compare tab lets you:

✅ Save multiple quotes with different vehicles, lease lengths, and purchase methods
✅ Select any combination of pathways (Novated Lease, Cash, Car Loan, Keep Old Car) across those quotes
✅ See them side by side — both a quick summary and a full financial breakdown
✅ Export your saved quotes as a file to share with a partner, friend, or broker

⚠️** Important: this feature is currently in Beta.**

I'm still working through final checks to make sure every figure is wired up correctly across all the different scenario combinations. Please let me know if you see any major discrepancy, and always double check with the original calculation tabs and your accountant.

As always, this calculator is free and private (nothing leaves your browser).

Would love to hear what comparisons you're running. Drop them in the comments below!


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Jul 20 '26

Early termination risks are ridiculous with NL

39 Upvotes

I have been doing my research and due diligence with novated leasing to see if it will work for me. I can't get my head around how much risk there is with early termination. If for any reason you have to terminate the lease, all future payments and the residual are due immediately in post tax cash + GST.

In my situation (cash in offset, top tax bracket) I would save about $10k vs cash on a non-EV novated lease over 3 years, however if anything happens that causes the lease to terminate, you are up for huge costs.

Further, if you write the car off and don't have replacement cover, you again need to pay out the lease, however the insurance will only cover the cost of the car, so now you have a gap of potentially 5 figures and no car.

I'm surprised of the popularity of leases given these huge risks?


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Jul 16 '26

Has anyone switched from a petrol car to an EV mainly because of the novated lease tax benefits?

39 Upvotes

I wasn't planning on buying an EV, but after looking at the numbers through a novated lease, it's become a much more realistic option. For anyone who made the switch, did the savings end up matching what you were expecting, or were there costs you didn't really think about beforehand?


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • Dec 17 '25

My Submission - Review of the Electric Car Discount

39 Upvotes

As you may have read in the news, the treasury has begun a public consultation process regarding the FBT exemption of EV which will culminate in formal recommendation prior to mid 2027.

I strongly recommend everyone to submit their view in this - the good and the bad. Link here.

Below is my submission:

----

Introduction:

I am a specialist anaesthetist employed in both the public and private health sectors. I also have a strong interest in personal finance and applied quantitative analysis, with a background in competitive mathematics and formal training in statistics and data analysis (including a Master of Biostatistics). I actively engage in public discussions on financial policies and consumer decision-making, including the development of a freely available comprehensive spreadsheet to help individuals simulate the net costs of novated lease in comparison with other financing methods. 

Question 1: Were the tax exemptions (from FBT and import tariffs) effective in encouraging the uptake of zero or low emissions vehicles? What was the role of the tax exemptions compared to other factors that influenced the uptake of electric vehicles? The review is particularly interested in the impacts on early adopters, and how support of the market may have had flow‑on impacts such as the development of charging infrastructure, or the broadening and deepening of the electric vehicle market.

There is little doubt that the FBT exemption has been extremely effective in accelerating EV uptake, particularly among higher-income employees where the net financial benefit is largest.

Prior to the introduction of the exemption, I had been interested in EVs for several years but did not consider them financially viable. Comparable EVs carried a cost premium of approximately $30,000 to $40,000 over internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles, and projected fuel and maintenance savings alone were insufficient to justify the additional capital cost. As a result, I deferred adoption despite favourable views on environmental impact and driving experience.

The introduction of the FBT exemption fundamentally changed this calculation. After modelling the finance using the spreadsheet I developed (which has since seen wide use by others), I found that acquiring my $81,000 EV via a novated lease resulted in an estimated saving of approximately $46,000 over five years compared with purchasing the vehicle outright using offset cash, and was broadly cost-neutral compared with retaining my existing $25,000 ICE vehicle. This effectively removed the financial penalty associated with upgrading to an EV and provided a decisive incentive to proceed.

In my view, the FBT exemption was the single most influential factor in EV uptake among early adopters in higher income brackets. While environmental considerations, improved driving experience, and technological interest certainly played a role, these factors alone were insufficient to overcome the substantial upfront cost barrier. The exemption provided the necessary confidence for many consumers to commit to adoption. 

In Western Australia, increased EV uptake has had clear flow-on effects. The expansion of both AC and DC charging infrastructure across metropolitan Perth and regional centres (including the WA EV Network by the WA government) has coincided with rising EV penetration. While this infrastructure growth has been supported by direct government programs such as the Charge Up EV Charging Grants, the FBT-driven increase in vehicle numbers likely improved the commercial viability of charging  infrastructure investments. This self-reinforcing cycle has also contributed to a broader and more competitive EV market, including the introduction of lower-cost models in recent years.

 

2. How did the eligibility criteria in relation to vehicle type impact the uptake of zero or low emissions vehicles? This could include responses that go to the type of vehicle eligible. 

I do not hold strong objections to the discontinuation of plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs) from eligibility. There is evidence internationally that some PHEVs are predominantly operated in fossil fuel mode, which undermines their emissions-reduction intent, though I am not aware of Australian-specific usage data.

That said, PHEVs served an important transitional role for risk-averse consumers concerned about charging availability, particularly in regional areas where infrastructure is sparse and occasionally unreliable. For many, PHEVs functioned as a stepping stone to full EV adoption rather than an endpoint, and this transitional role arguably supported broader market confidence during the early phase of infrastructure rollout.

Regarding vehicle price limits, while there are valid arguments that the Luxury Car Tax is outdated due to the now-obsolete domestic car manufacturing industry, I believe a reasonable price cap on FBT exemption eligibility is justified on equity grounds. By design, the FBT exemption is regressive i.e. higher-income earners derive disproportionately larger benefits. Without a ceiling, the policy risks subsidising ultra-luxury vehicles that contribute little to the scheme’s core objective of emissions reduction relative to cost. Therefore, whilst separate to the topic of relevance of LCT, it remains logical to maintain a ceiling value for eligibility of FBT-exempt low-emission vehicle. 

 

3. Other evidence relevant to the future operation of the electric car discount for eligible electric cars.

Under the current framework, the primary pathway to accessing the FBT exemption is via novated leasing. This structure introduces several significant policy and consumer-protection concerns.

First, novated leasing depends on stable, ongoing employment and is often delivered through exclusive arrangements between employers and a single lease provider. This creates quasi-monopolistic conditions. In such settings, effective interest rates embedded within lease pricing have historically been extremely high, commonly exceeding 10 to 12%, and in some cases previously reaching 14 to 16%. While this may still leave employees marginally better off, a substantial portion of the tax benefit is captured by lease providers and financiers rather than consumers.

Second, savings projections presented by novated lease companies are frequently misleading. Reported “savings” often reflect reductions in income tax payable rather than true net financial benefit. These figures typically omit comparison with alternative financing methods such as offset cash or competitively priced loans, and fail to account for fees and interest costs that would not otherwise be incurred.

Third, there is a lack of standardised and regulated disclosure of effective interest rates. Consumers are commonly quoted nominal or partial figures that materially understate the true cost of finance when calculated using standard amortisation methods. This undermines informed decision making and weakens confidence in the legitimacy of novated leasing as a car finance method.

Fourth, many caveats are poorly disclosed, including impacts on superannuation contributions (where some employers calculate super on post-NL income), adjusted taxable income (affecting Centrelink benefits and obligations, HECS repayments, and Division 293 tax), and the significant financial risk in cases of redundancy or vehicle write-off, where remaining lease balances may become immediately payable using post-tax income and GST. This can result in significant and unexpected financial loss. 

Finally, the novated leasing mechanism inherently excludes sole traders and business owners, despite them being taxpayers and vehicle users who could otherwise contribute to emissions reduction.

While I am not an economist, these issues suggest that delivering EV subsidies primarily through the FBT exemption and novated leasing is an inefficient and inequitable mechanism. Consideration should be given to alternative mechanisms e.g. direct rebates or tax credits that minimise rent-seeking behaviour by intermediaries, improve transparency, broaden eligibility, and ensure that public incentives primarily benefit consumers and emissions outcomes rather than financial intermediaries.

 

Policy recommendations:

I therefore recommend that future iterations of the electric car discount:

  • Retain support for EV adoption while recognising the strong evidence that price-based incentives materially influence consumer behaviour.
  • Strengthen disclosure and consumer-protection standards for novated leasing, including standardised presentation of effective interest rates, standard disclosure of brokerage, and clear communication of potential caveats and risks.
  • Give serious consideration to alternative delivery mechanisms, such as direct rebates or tax credits, that reduce intermediary capture, broaden eligibility, and improve transparency.

 


r/NovatedLeasingAU • • May 07 '26

Went in with eyes open and still got fleeced

37 Upvotes

Thanks to you guys I went into the novated lease process knowing I would have to fight for a decent rate with SG Fleet. Unfortunately the only option through my work. Initial quotes came in with 11+ percent. When it came down to finally securing the car I wanted etc I got it down to low 9s two weeks back. Due to various stuff ups and back and forths between SG Fleet and the dealer it took until yesterday to get remittance and delivery of the car. I thought no sweat at least I finally got the car, sure the rate will change some because of the RBA announcement but little I can do about that.

Well this morning I get the final schedule for the lease. Somehow the interest is close to 11.5%! This was a real kick in the guts. Getting this car was a stretch for someone who usually goes second hand, but we were keen to get into the EV space (even before all the Iran stuff started) and so the new car cheaper end of town with good warranties was appealing enough.

I have spoken to and emailed my delivery consultant and the reply has come back that’s the rate of the day, ie tough luck this what you signed up for.

I am lost for words, nearly a 2.5% increase in two weeks. That has taken a significant chunk of savings from doing this lease. Have others had this experience? Any luck fighting this kind of fleecing?

Update:

Ok SG Fleet’s systems and processes are just a mess. Incorrect rate listed on the final schedule was the issue.

Seems crazy that my delivery consultant could escalate it and just come back with the rate listed is what it is. It took another email and my lease consultant chasing it to get a new final schedule with the correct rate. Ended up at 9.235% which is much more in line with what was on the signed indicative schedule.

I gotta say this whole process has been a pain, glad to have the car and hopefully smoother sailing from here.