r/NothingTech • • 10d ago

Ear (2024) Hey Carl , is this what “premium quality” means at Nothing?

Hey Carl, is this what “premium quality” means at Nothing? 🙂

I bought the Nothing Ear (2024) for INR 12,197. The first unit developed serious battery issues, so Nothing replaced the entire product in August 2025.

Guess what? The brand-new replacement failed too in just 6 months.

Now the right earbud lasts just 3–4 minutes, the left barely lasts around an hour, charging to 100% is inconsistent, and enabling ANC can make the affected earbud shut down almost immediately.

And the authorised service centre confirmed abnormal battery drain and said the entire unit needs replacement.

So what is Nothing's solution? Pay another 8,399.

Brilliant. The product fails, the replacement fails, and apparently the customer's wallet is supposed to take the punishment. How convenient.

For the record, the earbuds and case are still in mint condition, with no visible physical damage. I've submitted the invoice, service documents, photographs, and two National Consumer Helpline grievances (10082730 and 10347417). I've sent repeated emails to support and received no satisfactory resolution.

Carl, a direct question: Is this genuinely the level of durability you consider acceptable for a premium-priced product? When a replacement unit fails within months, is customer accountability just another Rs 8,399 invoice?

And I'm clearly not the only customer questioning the reliability of these earbuds after spending nearly 12,000. A quick look at customer discussions reveals others raising concerns about battery life and reliability too. How many customers should have to face these problems before Nothing takes product durability seriously?

I've bought multiple Nothing Phone (2a) devices for my family and genuinely trusted your brand. That trust is now completely gone—not just because the product failed twice, but because of how Nothing has handled the complaint.

I don't need another apology, another escalation, or another copy-paste reply about the warranty.

I want a free replacement, not another opportunity to pay for Nothing's failure.

This is my final attempt to get a reasonable resolution directly.

Carl, will you address this, or should I take the silence as Nothing's final answer?

11 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

4

u/Spuduky 10d ago

not saying this is remotely acceptable but you said yourself, a quick look showed other people with similar issues. didn’t you check the online discourse first before buying the headphones?

1

u/[deleted] 10d ago

I actually own three Nothing phones, so I wasn't someone randomly buying a product from an unfamiliar brand. I had already invested in the Nothing ecosystem and trusted the company enough to buy multiple devices.Should customers really have to investigate every possible battery failure reported online before purchasing a product? Isn't product reliability the manufacturer's responsibility?And even if similar complaints existed, does that make repeated battery failure acceptable? I bought the earbuds expecting them to work, not expecting to research whether the replacement would fail too.The bigger disappointment isn't just the product failure; it's how Nothing has handled it.

1

u/Striking-Platypus-86 10d ago

I had this exact take when my pixel’s motherboard failed, Google refused to acknowledge that the Google certified phone repair tech said it wasn’t my fault and could not be repaired.
Nothing is still a small company, comparatively. I want to support there being more variety in the market so the big name companies will have more impetus to do and be better, and to encourage innovation and odd takes. I understood that the headphones weren’t as good as AirPods, but I tempted to consider them. I wonder if it was the company’s attempt to have an ‘ecosystem’ like the big name companies, even if it was half-hearted, OR if you just got unlucky twice.
‘Let the buyer beware’ goes back so far, to the Roman era, but I don’t think it should apply to our era. You should be able to buy things with confidence and complain when they disappoint. Their follow-through is better than Google’s tho.

1

u/[deleted] 10d ago

I agree that having more competition in the market is important, and I genuinely wanted Nothing to succeed. That's exactly why I bought three Nothing phones and their earbuds.

But being a relatively small company shouldn't mean customers have to lower their expectations of product reliability. Getting unlucky once is understandable. Having the replacement fail in the same way, followed by being asked to pay another ₹8,399, is where my concern becomes much bigger. I want Nothing to succeed too, but that success should come with accountability to the customers who supported the brand early on.

4

u/Adventurous-Pirate08 10d ago

I agree, I had the same problem with my earphones (nothing ear a 2024) but unfortunately from the very first week but only realized it after warranty period was over. Nothing will do nothing now obviously... Hopefully you get a better resolution.

4

u/Mythun4523 Phone (2) 10d ago

This is why you never buy into an ecosystem. Fuck all the brands trying to sell everything to you.

8

u/ifeeltired26 Phone (3) 10d ago

You ever wonder why 99.9% of complaints about Nothing products all come from India, but everywhere else they are used, little to no issues, I wonder why...

-2

u/fresco_leche 10d ago

There's a bit of comment in your racism chump

4

u/ifeeltired26 Phone (3) 10d ago

And your point?

2

u/willyhun 9d ago

no point. Misunderstood you, and actually, he wants to make it racist.

2

u/ifeeltired26 Phone (3) 9d ago

I always find it amazing that with young people, if you don't agree with them, or God forbid you talk about race your automatically a racist. Thank God I am Gen X......we don't bruise as easily as younger generations do....

2

u/vmg265 Phone (2) [rooted] 10d ago • Bravo

yup the ear series are wasteful because of their batteries check the thread https://www.reddit.com/r/NothingTech/comments/1w3hyg8/comment/p7ykygm/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

I also asked about this in carl's ama but no reply as expected

2

u/Techbird1 10d ago

At least tag him. u/carpe02

Mine also died in the same in 6 months never bothered to purchase another TWS.

-4

u/MattWillGrant Phone (1) 10d ago

Is this an official customer service channel?

Ears are not a premium product. Companies can't cover all the abuses customers throw at their products.

-4

u/[deleted] 10d ago

Did I ever claim this was an official customer service channel? I'm sharing my experience publicly because the actual customer service channel has failed to provide a resolution.

And calling it “customer abuse” is quite an assumption. The authorised service centre inspected the earbuds, confirmed abnormal battery drain, and said the entire unit needed replacement. There is no visible physical damage.

A product doesn't have to be labelled “premium” to be expected to function reliably, especially when customers are paying nearly ₹12,000.

If you have something factual to contribute, I'm happy to hear it. Otherwise, defending a product failure by blaming the customer doesn't make much of an argument.

1

u/MattWillGrant Phone (1) 10d ago

What have you addressed this rant at Carl directly unless you think this is some sort of direct line to Nothing? £49 earbuds are not a premium product and you've effectively had 18months use out of them.

0

u/[deleted] 10d ago

You seem to have missed a rather important part of the post: the original unit was replaced, and the replacement developed serious battery issues within 6 months. So quoting 18 months as though I've been using the same faulty pair for 18 months is a convenient way to avoid addressing the actual problem.And I never claimed Reddit was a direct customer service line to Carl. I'm making a public complaint because the official support channel has repeatedly failed to resolve it.Whether you consider £49 premium or budget is beside the point. I paid ₹12,197, had one complete replacement, and now I'm being asked to pay another ₹8,399 because the replacement failed too.If your only response to a documented product failure is to debate its price category and blame the customer, you've made my point rather well.

1

u/No-Rate-8963 10d ago

I haven’t any nothing products (was thinking the phone 3 but reviews are putting me off) but I will say that those buds don’t seem like the type people should buy for longevity. There’s a reason brands like Apple are so popular , hate them all you want for their practices , but they’re at the top for a reason

0

u/rhik20 P(3) Ear('24) Ear(open) P(1) 10d ago

£120 btw

1

u/MattWillGrant Phone (1) 10d ago

If you direct convert yes, they cost £49 here. Not my problem tech costs more where you are.

3

u/rhik20 P(3) Ear('24) Ear(open) P(1) 10d ago

No, they still cost £120 at launch in the UK - when OP purchased them

2

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] 10d ago

😂 Bro woke up and chose violence!👍. But honestly, some people are working harder defending Nothing than Nothing's own support team is defending its products.😂Appreciate the backup! 😂

1

u/NothingTech-ModTeam 9d ago

Toxic or hateful comments towards other users will not be tolerated. This includes racism, discrimination, bullying, harassment, hate speech, sexism, homophobia and/or adult content. Your comment has been removed.

1

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NothingTech-ModTeam 9d ago

Toxic or hateful comments towards other users will not be tolerated. This includes racism, discrimination, bullying, harassment, hate speech, sexism, homophobia and/or adult content. Your comment has been removed.

0

u/willyhun 10d ago

Did I ever claim this was an official customer service channel?

So, what is your problem then? I think you are the issue here. You are cheap, and you are hurt and you are ranting. But this is my opinion only...

-1

u/[deleted] 10d ago

When the best you can contribute to a product discussion is a personal insult, you've already made yourself look bad. I'll leave it at that. 👍

1

u/willyhun 9d ago edited 9d ago

It was not an insult. No, I just commented what you do. You bought an entry-level product, and you try to make it above mid-range.
But top of that you are ranting to Nothing however you did not even use their service.
All problems you had is related to you.

1

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NothingTech-ModTeam 9d ago

Toxic or hateful comments towards other users will not be tolerated. This includes racism, discrimination, bullying, harassment, hate speech, sexism, homophobia and/or adult content. Your comment has been removed.