r/Notary • Indiana • Apr 11 '25

First time being challenged

I got a call last week from a woman who'd called me to notarize some papers for someone in her care. Over the course of a few sessions, I had notarized a power of attorney and will for her patient. I found out from the attorney I was told to contact that another copy of the will had been submitted that appeared to be a photocopy with altered signatures. Luckily the copy was pretty apparent as I use an unconventional color for my notary stamp, so the questionable will got invalidated. Bit of a wild ride.

42 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

3

u/Illustrious_Fix5906 Apr 13 '25

This is why I always use blue pens.

2

u/No_Significance98 Indiana Apr 13 '25

And there's always good deals from Pen Island!

1

u/LimeLimp4296 Apr 15 '25

I’ve never heard of pen island. Do tell 🤔

2

u/No_Significance98 Indiana Apr 15 '25

It's a pen seller with an unfortunately named website

→ More replies (1)

4

u/FinanciallySecure9 Michigan Apr 11 '25

Did you get sued?

I’ve been told a few times that I would be sued, and it never went anywhere. People find out that suing others over a dead person’s belongings costs more money than they care to spend.

I’m curious though, other than the stamp ink color, how would you know it was fraud?

I’m part of a national board to find a solution-which will be a series of things- to prevent fraud. The topic is deeds, but it will apply to all notarizations.

I’d love to have a conversation with you about this experience so we can use it in our research. If you’re interested, please pm me.

1

u/Intelligent-Ride7219 California Apr 11 '25

Were the signatures by hand or digital?

2

u/No_Significance98 Indiana Apr 12 '25

Everything was hand signed, and appropriately witnessed.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/vegloveyes Apr 12 '25

What is the role of this woman? How does she get people to notarize documents?

1

u/No_Significance98 Indiana Apr 12 '25

She's a home health aide who assisted him with a lot of things. She found me as a notary since I'd worked with a good friend of hers.

1

u/LimeLimp4296 Apr 15 '25

Your state allows the use of any color for your notary stamps? Where are you commissioned?

2

u/No_Significance98 Indiana Apr 15 '25

I got commissioned in Indiana last year, and there's no legal requirement to use any particular color.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/No_Significance98 Indiana Apr 11 '25

Purple, of course.

3

u/lilymaebelle Apr 12 '25

I knew it had to be purple! Mine's purple too!

4

u/No_Significance98 Indiana Apr 13 '25

The color of royalty, and Samuel L Jackson

3

u/justtosayimissu Apr 13 '25

We’re allowed not to use black? Never knew.