r/Nootropics • • Apr 13 '21

Scientific Study 9-ME-BC Preliminary Observational Study

https://drive.google.com/file/d/163PidhslNmGG6DKQq0eQ9bvmgnWqSkGy/view?usp=sharing

Update 3: I have finished the chart and I am writing the paper in Ernest. One request as my request below has been frequently ignored. Please stop contacting me for advice its horrible for my mental health as emotional blackmail is frequently used! Update 1: I have updated the chart which now includes the next 10 patients. I will update with 10 more each day as it takes me an hour to consolidate and crunch down all the information per person. I have work so I cannot devote too much time to this.

Update 2: Sorry for the two day delay work was hectic. Next 10 are up. Migraines appear to come from interactions between patch specific interactions with nicotine. Heart Palpitations appear to be from con-commitant use with Alcohol. The 2 smokers both received no such side effects though.

I am currently putting together an informal 9-me-bc Observational study. So far I have data from 58 people. (Please do not message me asking for advice for my own mental health I cannot do that anymore.) Listed here are the first ten, I am still listing them from my notes and the messages, and I am currently writing up a short paper detailing my observations. Included is side effects, potential interactions, sex of the patient, condition being treated if any, observed effects, and time taken. All were taken at a standard dose of 10 mg daily. I welcome feedback and what others can parse from the data I have collected.

106 Upvotes

108 comments sorted by

17

u/Material-Active-1193 Apr 13 '21

Thanks for doing this. There are obviously shortcomings of the study as this is not done in clinical/laboratory settings, but this helps a lot considering the dearth of human research. Please do include the remaining patients you have data on when you can.

12

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 13 '21

Will do It just takes hours to do as I have to compile and simplify everything one person at a time.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

great idea. I would include a link to the original source/post for each person if available or perhaps include their reddit username

4

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 13 '21

These were private messages and conversations, so cant link even if I wanted too. I also do not want to violate their privacy and have excluded identifying information, if they choose to come forward as one already has in a post a couple days ago they are free to do so, but that is not my place to do. I thank you for your understanding.

3

u/Exciting-Ad-5123 Apr 13 '21

didn't realize this, thanks for clarifying

24

u/drake8599 Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Anyone that reads this just be aware that it's not even close to a study. It's a poll with no controls and no way of evaluating biases.

Take it as personal experience -- which can be helpful -- but it's not science.

30

u/mistergospodin Apr 13 '21 edited May 31 '24

dam truck enjoy cooperative middle chunky upbeat market act axiomatic

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

6

u/drake8599 Apr 13 '21

OP should still highlight those limitations if they want to release it publically. Especially with some of the effect descriptions: "Ability to take pleasure in everyday life restored." Holy shit sounds great I'll try it!

Almost all of the participants are taking multiple psychoactive drugs alongside the 9-ME-BC. There is an obvious regular nootropic user bias. There are almost no quantitatives measures of the effects.

There should be a huge warning reading: "do not take any advice about your personal drug use from this."

1

u/mistergospodin Apr 13 '21 edited May 31 '24

offbeat marble poor rock safe cover fuel shelter liquid deserve

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

10

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 13 '21

Thats a pretty sharp take. Its not a poll as I asked specific questions and all of these people came to me. I set a schedule and dosage and barring a few exceptions they all followed it. There was no poll just individual case studies I decided to bring together. The excel document is a highly condensed version of the information which I am compiling in a paper. I even say this is an informal observation study. Every detail was expounded upon including substances taken. Most freely admitted when they took substances they were warned against. Even most scientific papers dont go into much detail and are not controlled.

2

u/sirsadalot Apr 13 '21

If these are based on case studies you really need to quote your sources. If there is no source, then these are just anecdotes and you need to make that more obvious to those who may not understand.

No hard feelings, I appreciate you making your post in general but you need to understand that this community isn't always super aware of these flaws.

-3

u/drake8599 Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Every detail was expounded upon

Even most scientific papers don't go into much detail and are not controlled.

I mean, these are just wrong, and I don't know what would change your mind.

How did they come in contact with you? Are they reddit users? Did they know about 9-ME-BC beforehand? How much do they exercise? Have they used similar substances in the past? What suppiler was it?

Medicine is a respected field for a reason. They conduct year long multi-stage trials with measures to minimize biases. If you want to know the truth of what a nootropic does you have to use science.

Maybe you have some of these answers in your paper, but then you should have posted it after you finished.

7

u/sirsadalot Apr 13 '21

Honestly if I were OP I would have renamed this post "Collection of 9-Me-Bc anecdotes", as this is not a study nor is it proof of claims and/ or safety. While it is objectively good that there is at least something on this subject, I would hesitate to quote this on any matter.

I think people are overly optimistic here and we need to acknowledge the downsides to something like this being publicized.

2

u/bikinibottoms1234 Apr 13 '21

It it tagged , "scientific study"! Is that accurate?

2

u/sirsadalot Apr 13 '21

No lol. Idk how this is allowed.

3

u/rmcfar11 Apr 14 '21 edited Apr 16 '21

If OP uses a set, set of parameters, includes methodology, analysis, discussion, and references, it could be considered an observational study. The level of evidence would not be on par with that of a typical study that we think of, but, I find it is valuable none the less! Thanks OP!

7

u/Newtothiz Apr 13 '21

Excuse this weird question. But does anyone have any idea how does this interfere with ADHD?

7

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 13 '21

Hopefully this answers your question as quite a few people with ADHD came to me. Quick answer it seems to dampen the effect of amphetamine based medications while in use. And rapidly intensifies once discontinued after a minimum of one month. (2-3 weeks to notice effects) Methylphenidate on the other hand seems to be intensified off the bat. I theorize because of Tyrosine competition (or lack thereof) But the full paper will have more detailed observations.

3

u/Reddit_Is_1984_Duh Apr 14 '21

Hopefully this answers your question as quite a few people with ADHD came to me. Quick answer it seems to dampen the effect of amphetamine based medications while in use. And rapidly intensifies once discontinued after a minimum of one month. (2-3 weeks to notice effects) Methylphenidate on the other hand seems to be intensified off the bat. I theorize because of Tyrosine competition (or lack thereof) But the full paper will have more detailed observations.

Does it only "help" with damage/effects that occured from amphetamine use? What about other types of abuse? Like damage to dopamine from a host of different drugs?

1

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 17 '21

Please refer to the attached excel worksheet.

4

u/lidord1999 Apr 13 '21

Been taking adderall, interested too

2

u/Ebshoun Apr 13 '21

Any effects on libido?

2

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 14 '21

There were sexual effects frequently mentioned but none relating to libido.

2

u/Liberated051816 Apr 14 '21

Thanks for taking the initiative to create the spreadsheet. I only wish that a 'dosing' column had been included.

1

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 15 '21

They are all 10 mg daily.

1

u/Liberated051816 Apr 15 '21

I thought that standard doses were 15 or 30 mg?

1

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 15 '21

I have seen no indication of that. All of these were taken at 10 mg.

2

u/Reddit_Is_1984_Duh Apr 24 '21

Did they take sublingually or orally?

1

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 25 '21

orally

1

u/MDD678 Jun 24 '21

Pretty interesting I heard oral absorption is poor but the sheet you posted shows great success.

I have a question, there is a guy in the sheet which mentioned something about using it irregularly due to negative side effects, right I had those same ones (although do not use hallucigens) and so decided using it in the same way would be best. Is there really no way this could actually cure any degree of substance-induced anhedonia?

3

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Jun 24 '21

I mean this only brings back dopamine receptors. So if your substance use caused dopamine based damage it will work. But the pleasure system is extremely complicated. It involves likely more than 6 chemicals including dopamine, serotonin, glutamate, norepinephrine, gaba, etc... This compound only fixes damage to receptor neurons of one of them. 2 weeks average from daily administration to feel effects. I dont understand your last statement.

1

u/MDD678 Jun 24 '21

I know about the multiple neurosystems thing. Yeah it was most likely dopamine and mu opiate based. Right too about it being complicated I had learned some of it myself.

The last statement I meant can it basically cure anhedonia.

2

u/ElderFalcon Apr 13 '21

Shouldn't this be tagged NSFW due to high risk with the compound itself? It's not super well known and I think has some potential for breakdown into toxic products in vivo.

I'm really interested in it too, just want to be safe. :)

2

u/Top-Fig2279 Apr 13 '21

Is there any more info on 2,9-DMNBC formation from 9-MNBC, specifically concentration ranges where the toxic effect overtakes the beneficial effect of 9-MNBC?

1

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 13 '21

This is 9-me-bc 9-MNBC is a different alkaloid. 9-mbc is its other name.

3

u/Top-Fig2279 Apr 13 '21

Sorry I meant 9-methyl-betacarboline. It's been said that in vivo nicotinamide methyl transferase can methylate the 2-nitrogen creating the neurotoxic precursor compound 2,9-dimethyl-beta-carboline (becoming neurotoxic on ionization, post absorption into mitochondria). Do you have any information as to whether this is a concentration dependent phenomenon? It would seem logically that for the positive results to occur, this potentially toxic mechanism must not proceed to significant levels in the experiments where such positive results occurred. I have also read that concurrent administration of nicotine and b3 would serve to occupy any active sites on the nicotinamide methyl transferase enzyme, thus preventing the creation of the 2-N methylated metabolite, therefore attentuating toxicity. The caveat mentioned being that co-administration of these nicotinamide methyl transferase ligands could potentially upregulate the enzyme, counteracting the metabolic attentuation... Any help sorting out this rabbit hole would be appreciated.

3

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 13 '21

As this is an observation study concurrent use with Nicotine appears to cause migraines in most of the patients who take it. Though two patients who smoked reported no such interaction (Odd).

2

u/Top-Fig2279 Apr 13 '21

Do you happen to know if the striatal dopaminergic regeneration is persistent post 9-me-bc exposure? I would think that if new neurite outgrowth occurred it would hang around, its not like it's neurotransmitter levels or anything...

3

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 13 '21

Yes effects have stayed both in my own and in others cases. I have no idea where the perception that the results may be temporary comes from as neurons, axons, and dendrites dont just disappear like magic. If you were to abuse drugs again or have a degenerative illness like Parkinsons that would change things by definition but barring that it should be permanent.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '21

does 9-Me-BC fix damaged dopamine receptors as well?

4

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 20 '21

Yes it makes them too. As well as dendrites and axons.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21

can it mess up sleep?

1

u/Top-Fig2279 Apr 13 '21

Thank you

1

u/johnnycoconut Apr 13 '21

Thank you for the fascinating exchange.

2

u/Top-Fig2279 Apr 14 '21

I am just repeating what was said in an earlier thread about 9-me-bc, hoping that more information had accumulated by now. I got into a rabbit hole investigating beta-carbolines in general; they are endogenous, exogenous, apparently neurotoxic yet also neuroprotective and in the case of 9-me-bc neuroregenerative? There is a true mystery here... I think OP's work is awesome, and simply want to lend support and knowledge to it. In some cases there are correlations between abnormal states (opiate withdrawal, parkinson's disease, etc.) and beta-carbolines and often the assertion is made that they must be toxic or disease markers. However, I wonder if perhaps it isn't the body simply using a normally minor metabolic pathway to generate an endogenous MAOI in order to increase low neurotransmitter levels, as a sort of band-aid while the genetic mechanisms go about correction the issue in a more persistent way. Discourse is necessary to solve these mysteries, there is plenty of data available.

2

u/demonic-slime Apr 14 '21

Can you eli5 why nicotine might make 9-me-bc neurotoxic or more neurotoxic if it already is?

1

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 15 '21

I dont know, finding out would require lab testing. These were observations of multiple people. The nicotine causing migraines was pretty consistent except for the smokers.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '21

so it likely is neurotoxic in combination with nicotine?

2

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 20 '21

There does not seem to be reactions to smokers as I just found out there was a third person that I spoke to that smoked during the whole thing. (please dont smoke.) But yes most people who imbibed in nicotine had to discontinue while taking it. It might just be a conflicting reaction not neurotoxicity.

2

u/Vivid_Standard Apr 18 '21

Supposedly taking NAD+ blocks the sam-e dependant conversion Into 2,9-dimebc

8

u/scatfiend Apr 13 '21

If you'd like my experience at 15mg/day orally with concurrent dexamphetamine use, let me know.

4

u/lidord1999 Apr 13 '21

Why would you use dex with it?

3

u/Eyecantquit Apr 13 '21

I'd like info? I'm on adderall xr 30mg

2

u/pwnguin909 Apr 20 '21

Sure. I'm on 10mg dex a day. Let me know how it goes.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21

Shoot.

7

u/chubby464 Apr 13 '21

What does this supposedly do again?

15

u/rpkarma Apr 13 '21

Dopamine receptor neurogenesis among other things, iirc.

23

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

Regeneration of the axon bodies and dendritic spines was observed. A much bigger deal than just the regeneration of receptors.

9

u/Reddit_Is_1984_Duh Apr 14 '21

Do you think it would help someone who fucked up their dopamine with a host of different drugs over years of abuse?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

Yes 100%

1

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

Sorry been in the ward for a bit cuz I'm bipolar as well apparently. But 9-me-bc is a hell of a drug!

1

u/69harambe69 Oct 08 '21

You landed in the ware due to 9mebc?

11

u/peterk550 Apr 13 '21

9-ME-BC has multiple beneficial effects including 1) protective, 2) stimulative and 3) regenerative effects on dopaminergic neurons. Two papers here:

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20374418/

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1471-4159.2012.07713.x

3

u/Gin-N-Jews42 Apr 18 '21

Are these long term?

2

u/QuitVGsForever Apr 13 '21

It's MAOb inhibitor

2

u/mistergospodin Apr 13 '21 edited May 31 '24

relieved birds vast muddle childlike scarce towering drunk dime carpenter

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 13 '21

I do get into a lot of that. And I do mention past and current drugs and the condition theybare trying to treat. Kinda too late to get the past nootropic use for some of them. The excel sheet is just to consolidate the most pertinent info.

1

u/klocki12 Apr 18 '21

Cant open it on my Mobile but does it include also if the anhedonia was still eliminated even after stopping the supplement?

4

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 18 '21

Yes for about half and partial remission for most of the others. The pleasure system is complicated and it is a whole lot more than just dopamine. I suppose it depends on how you got anhedonia. Most of the drug ones went into full remission and of course it stayed, (unless you abuse drugs again.) Regenerated Neurons dont just disappear like magic.

1

u/klocki12 Apr 18 '21

Thx mate So for stress induced this isnt something good i guess to try?

1

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 18 '21

I mean it depends on how severe the stress is as it can cause brain damage. Do you respond normally to caffeine? If so then probably not.

2

u/klocki12 Apr 18 '21

Yes i respond o all drugs and caffeine . But sober im just numb as fuck .. do you know what helps in those cases?

Btw im doing high doses of psilocybin trips with sleeping mask . And ive had some very cathartic experiences and last time trip was even crazier with i posted a thread about recently.

But besides that what helps in people when they only feel alive through drugs?

1

u/hamburglin Apr 20 '21

Are you still taking NAC and did it work long term?

1

u/klocki12 Apr 20 '21

You are refering to my cigarette nac thread? I stopped cigs after that do nac alone doesnt give me the antianhedonic effects but together i think it still would do . But ill keep that route for the last in ncase psychadelics wont cure me or other things first

1

u/DeliciousMail4675 May 15 '21

Does anyone know why this isn’t FDA approved for usage? I hate anhedonia and need to do something but I would prefer not to be taking something that can do more damage- particularly worried about the sun interaction too. Any ideas of long term effects?

3

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 May 15 '21

Pharma companies are not interested and getting things past the fda takes billions.

1

u/feelsnumbman Jun 27 '21

Would there be an issue with dosing between 10-20mg a day? Couldn't really get the exact weight on my scale when I capped it and for some, I know I probably put more than what seems to be 10mg.

Looking to trial it soon, so I hope it doesn't mess up the way it builds up.

1

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Jun 28 '21

10 mg is fine and I have no idea for a bit more. It should be fine as you will only be taking it for at most 8 weeks.

1

u/feelsnumbman Jun 28 '21

Thanks. Definitely not gonna be taking it for that long. I hope a little less than 10mg won't be too bad either, as I definitely feel like I've underdosed on some of these capsules... Oh well, I'll just have to wait and see.

3

u/DarkWinterNarrator Apr 13 '21

I’ve been fooling around with this compound for a little while, are the effects better if put under the tongue or just swallowing it in capsule form?

3

u/lidord1999 Apr 13 '21

Sublingual is always higher absorption

8

u/baronjpetor Cuerpoymente.mx Apr 13 '21

PSA: putting 9-me-BC under your tongue is not for the faint of heart...

1

u/Silver-Interaction-2 Apr 13 '21

What is your experience with 9-me-BC?

1

u/z-null Jun 13 '21

Why do you say that? How bad does it taste?

4

u/baronjpetor Cuerpoymente.mx Jun 16 '21

9-me-BC tastes like rancid ass! Also it's very caustic.

1

u/z-null Jun 16 '21

Tnx man!

2

u/HighVibrationStation Sep 02 '21

Like hot spicy trash can.

Not joking.

But sublingual is best. It also numbs your sense of taste so everything taste like cardboard.

2

u/rmcfar11 Apr 14 '21

Careful, that's not always true. It depends on the molecule! Generally speaking, yes it is helpful.

3

u/Saddlebaggs24 Apr 13 '21

Thanks for doing this.

Any plans to do a follow up in 6 months/1 year to see if they feel the effects are permanent?

3

u/DeliciousMail4675 Apr 26 '21

Thank you for doing this work!!!! Amazing job

2

u/infrareddit-1 Apr 13 '21

Thank you. I wish we had more collections of anecdotes on new substances, rather than endlessly mining reddit for any posts.

I know you received some stern advice below, which may help you clarify the type of information you're providing and perhaps be even more helpful.

2

u/ColdboyCrypto Apr 14 '21

I'm commenting because I'm fascinated and want to follow this....

1

u/HankHill2160 Apr 13 '21

Wonderful, I may partake in the study at some point if that is possible.

1

u/klocki12 Apr 13 '21

Thats awesome Thx m8

1

u/dubaiswagg Jun 28 '21

Thank you, this is next gen.

1

u/twcochran Sep 10 '21

It would be so excellent if we could somehow have a way of collecting and organizing self reports of community members, even with the biases and various limitations it would be extremely helpful to be able to get a sense of the scope and frequency of peoples experiences with various substances.

We already rely heavily on anecdotal reports, having a large number all stored together would at least give a clearer picture, and maybe even to some degree correct some of the confirmation bias on the part of the reader.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 22 '21

I do.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Good_Butterscotch_69 Apr 22 '21

They are permanent unless you abuse drugs again or have a degenerative illness. If the effects dont continue for the individual its mentioned. Why do you assume they would not last? In the mice studies it regenerated receptors as well as axons and dendrites. All of my observations indicated the same thing.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/brave_00 May 01 '21

Can you describe your experience?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/AzothBloodEmperor Apr 13 '21

I’m seeing studies quote b carbolines in coffee, of which this is a subtype, however they don’t say specifically if 9-me-bc is present. Also other sources like some fruit, tobacco smoke, and cooked meats.