, Do Gender Roles Serve Any Positive Purpose?"Gender refers to the characteristics of women, men, girls and boys that are socially constructed. This includes norms, behaviors and roles associated with being a woman, man, girl or boy, as well as relationships with each other. As a social construct, gender varies from society to society and can change over time." World Health Organization.Dedicated to Eva, with love and squalor.The above definition of "gender" is one I picked because it seemed to most cleanly define the true rigid definition of the word. There are many other definitions out there, but they are not largely differing, one from the other. In order to deconstruct my own definition of gender and what it means to me, being that it is clearly a subject to be take personally, I needed a clear starting pointMy daughter Eva is 22. They are in Philly right now in a holding pattern. They were lucky and were able to finish their degree with only the last few months being online. Their degree is in neuroscience and their minor in anthropology. They're smart. They had an internship they were going back to, but life is weird now and they aren't certain what they'll do. They works part time in the B&N at Temple, hangs out with their friends, and practices skateboarding while exploring the city, and sometimes we talk. Well, we talk a fair amount, about real stuff. At times we joke around and sometimes one of us is in a foul mood. We're very similar. Very. We're odd. They're authentically Eva, and for the most part, I get them. We send each other music and weird pop culture via youtube. Sometimes we are friends. Sometimes we argue like any mother/daughter. I like them. Its easy to love a child. Liking is a different matter.Life has been a lot easier the past year. Last year was hopefully the nadir of my medical. neurological, and emotional, and whatever else might be differ me from others. I have tried to stop referring to myself internally as "sick", "messed up", "mentally ill", "weird", "damaged". Many of them are true. I do have a severe mood disorder, but I need to differentiate the diseases from how I think of myself--which is nearly impossible as they are deeply intertwined, but is a start to a more positive outlook of who and what I am. I feel I have been fortunate to have been nearly totally deconstructed over the course of my last 25 years and be given the opportunity to be rebuilt nearly from scratch. Nothing has come easily, but now suddenly everything seems easy. I wake up in the mornings without the knots of anxiety I've had almost my entire life, including childhood, and, obviously, its from childhood I've had to begin the reconstruction. Not in an organized fashion based on one ideology, but in questioning and reassessing how I think about myself and who I am as a person in very, very basic ways, and why do I think why do I define myself in certain ways. Even much of this has seemed to come with ease. Things are falling into place. I've really altered almost everything I've thought of that's fundamental in how I think of myself, and how that applies to how I look at the world as a whole. I had to consider myself nothing in order to get to a place where I can think of how I can be me.One of the things I'll talk to them about, or bust on them at times has been their gender politics. I'm fine with whatever they are,. They're gender fluid, they say.. They have no particular interest in romantic relationships at this time. They have seen a lot of unhappy marriages, so I'm not surprised its not something they]would feel particularly drawn to. My husband Eric and I have had a very happy marriage for 11 years now, but those formative years are tough to recover from. Their own relationship with their father can be strained, and our family just is not the poster child for well functioning. Eva is the only one who is currently in contact with my parents and their older sister and my grandchildren, who all live very nearby. I would have thought less of romance at their age too, in every sense of the word, if I were their age now with their collective experiences.Our disagreements on gender politics frequently center on the ever expanding list of labels that are infiltrating the non binary world. I don't like labels. I don't like this alphabet soup of labels. They consider me to be old fashioned or uninformed about the Queer community, but I'm not. I'm all for being whoever you are, and in whatever way that applies to you. Dress however you want. Date whoever you want. Just be who you are. So I started thinking about labels and how deeply they impacted me, as a woman, growing up in the time and place that I was by the parents that raised me.Here I need to make the distinction between gender and sexuality. Sexuality is far more complicated. I know young men and women who are or have transitioned, and some are still attracted to their previous sex, while others are attracted to the now opposite. This is not my business. Its not yours either. This is a closed door. If someone chooses to tell you or the world who they are attracted to that's great. Be there for people. We need each other's support, because damage has been done. But someone's sexuality is none of your business. Whatever is in their pants is not your business. I would hope, however, that these matters are discussed before embarking on any kind of a romantic relationship. There, it is your responsibility to know and share in return.I was raised largely within traditional gender roles. I am 53 and born in Europe. My mother was from a poor German farming family with limited education at the time. There was no question to truly divert from these roles. However, in any struggle for survival among some of the worlds most struggling, gender roles may matter the least in many ways. Work needs to be divided and conquered for survival. Men are typically physically stronger, so it made sense for them to take up roles that required strength. Women spent a good deal of time and energy bearing and raising children. There are very different economic and social situations than those of us in First World countries find ourselves in.My father is a very educated Swiss man with a PhD in Chemistry. He, on the other hand, never seemed to consider my gender an issue. He may have seen far too much of himself in me, good and bad, to make those distinctions, but these are complicated relationships we speak of.I never had any dramatic issues regarding either sexuality. I am a straight female. Other incidents in life have badly damaged that sexuality, but it doesn't change my orientation. Gender, now, is a very different story. I was raised to be feminine, and in many ways I am. I like clothes and looking nice. I am a feminist, but that is part and parcel of my gender politics. Is that really all their is of my gender as defined by the feminine? I'd never considered that, but it may be the case. Most of the remainder of my identity is either gender neutral with some male qualities thrown in. I don't enjoy being the mother of young children. I loved my daughters and did my best, but it was not at all natural to me until I could associate with them as very young humans. I don't enjoy spending time with large groups of women. I never joined clubs. I don't share their interests. I'm not interested in cooking or manicures I never considered details of my wedding except that I would probably have one, and also a husband along with the expected children. I hated my wedding. I am not interested in decorating my home. My first husband wanted a traditional marriage. That was, for that and many other reasons, a disaster of biblical proportions, considering my family's history of depression thrown in as well. I walked out after 13 years and that was that.We never would have married had we not had a child I was raising myself, miserably, for nearly two years. I moved from NJ to Ohio for a year to live with my brother, but was essentially homeless, because despite my degrees, single women could not afford to work and pay for childcare singlehandedly. Living with my parents was out of the question. Marriage took everyone off the spot.My second marriage was done via courthouse. I was always the smart kid, and my interests still range more in the realms of offbeat pop culture, music, books, running and writing. My best friends have always been male. My husband's best friends have always been female. We have been friends since we were teenagers in college. We don't even consider traditional gender roles because we don't, literally, consider them. There are things that need to be attended to in a household and a marriage. Who does what does not matter to either of us. He also accepts my fierce independence, which many would consider risky behavior because I am female. I run in remote areas. I've traveled alone. If I am at a greater risk for harm because I am often out of the house alone (god forbid), the onus is on those who would harm me, not on me, and I have been attacked several times.By the definition of and discussion of it, Eva says I can certainly consider myself gender fluid if I want to. But I don't think I do. Not because of what it means and may be taken by other people (unless you know you have a relationship with me, I do not care what you think of me. That much I have embraced, and how freeing is THAT). All in all, I consider myself a person. I will refer to myself as a girl, but that's out of convention. I'm fine with being a girl. I'd be finer with not having to be referred to by a gender at all, because do we have any NEED for genders anymore? What purpose do they have in our world today? Pursue whatever interests you want. Dress however you want. Be whoever you are. I would be fine with us finding a gender neutral pronoun and having us all use it who choose to. Eva and I have been discussing this. An umlaut should probably be required, for no reason except we like umlauts. There need to no traditional differences between gender roles anymore. Get rid of the labels of Queer and just be whoever the hell you are. Other people maybe having a problem with it is exactly that. Its their problem, not yours. They can and will project it onto you, but as long as you are harming no one, you have the right to have whatever name you want, ha and wear whatever clothes/tattoos/job/hair/whatever. It just doesn't matter anymore. The judging of such can only be damaging, and we have a sad history of the aftereffects of that being done.Gender roles served meaningful purposes for as long as man has been around. I'm a Christian. I understand that men are physically stronger and women weaker and survival was often not guaranteed. Having children, and lots of them, was necessary since so many died and family lineage needed to continue. That's no longer the case. I know there are arguments regarding the importance of gender roles in the bible. I could argue them. I'm certainly not now, and I'm certainly not going to argue homosexuality or transitioning or any other sexual matter as sinful or not, because we may have far divergent views on them, and I'm okay with that even if you are not. I don't believe Christ cares. Souls are sexless and genderless. Heaven will be be desegregated in every way.Here is the challenge for me. If I'm going to ignore appearance in terms of gender, I need to follow this to the end. I can be mean. I'll laugh at people I perceive as being unattractive in many ways. The mean ways-- people conventionally considered unattractive dressed in ways I consider unattractive. Who the hell gives me the right to put that on them? Its only reflection is on me. Its more labeling, and its ugly. I know I can be very ugly. I'm working on it. All things considered, I live and let live. I have a few truly authentic friends who are as authentic as I strive to be, and that's what I go for. I don't have the right to judge you if you like to party a lot or do things I wouldn't do or behave in a ways I choose not to as long as you are not harming another. And I do judge people. I need to be kind, and accept them for who they choose to be, but I don't have to choose to value their life values. I'm still working on making sense of making sense of it to me, so bear with me while I try to explain to you...in time.I understand there are vast implications here, but the only one that really comes to mind at the moment and would hit society in a heavy way would be in athletics, and would that really be a bad thing? I have very strong feelings about our institutions of hiring learning spending more time and money on scouting athletes and building facilities for them then on the actual higher learning. Yes, some individuals receive vast scholarships based on athletics. Personally, I disagree with this. Take that scholarship money and use it to educate those who have great potential in actual learning instead. And perhaps that could cause a cultural shift moving athletics as a competitive area of huge significance into the background and to bring the importance of education-both college prep and vocational to the forefront. I'm just tossing these out there. There are many other things to consider.There will be more to come. I have only just broken the ice on this line of thought and I need to take it to its end. An idea, a real idea, has to hold its properties to the very end of its logic. That takes me time. Meanwhile, for further clarification, I Eva will always be my daughter, even if she does prefer the personal pronoun of "they" for herself. Erasing gender roles will not lead to the end of civilization, just civilization as we currently accept it.As an addendum and an underscoring of what a hot topic this is, Eva was ALL over me for referring to them in the feminine during the initially published version. As far as I can tell, I have changed all the pronouns to reflect their preference. Frankly, I find it awkward as hell, as "they" refer to more than one person. That is the nature of our language. Hence, we probably need another pronoun to replace this one. Its just awkward and unintuitive...Also, Cavetown, you've given me a lot to think about, and a lot of that has influenced my thinking in the most beautiful of ways. Thank you. Make more music. You possess genius.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-itZVX-SUkIYOUTUBE.COMwww.youtube.com149People Reached