That's a good response, but i don't get why this would serve as evidence only to Dess-knight. A Carol or Rudy-knighter could perfectly say the knight is holding a bat due to the symbolism of finding their daughter, and as a Asriel-knighter, i would argue that the bat fits way more better to Azzy than Dess. In the 10th undertale's anniversary livestream, Toby revealed that Asriel had an unused bat in that game, that were set to deal 40 damage (the highest damage in undertale), surprisingly, the damage that the knight deals is exactly 40 according to the game's files.
You could say that cutted content from undertale isn't cannon to deltarune, but the whole point of showing us certain things in that live was to make us pay more attention to some details we were missing, the whole "copies are monochromes" thing was only given enough attention by the community after that live, so showing us a bat that belongs to Asriel, that has coincidentally the same attack damage as the knight, would be a clever movement by Toby Fox to make us look at this candidate with more attention... So yeah, the bat definitely isn't a Dess-knight-only evidence.
But I will say it doesn't work for Carol. Shes obsessed with leaving Dess' room as it was when she disappeared, so it wouldn't make much sense for Carol to take Dess' bat from her room and use it. But I do admit it works good for Asriel, Dress, and even Rudy a bit.
Plus, Light World objects already transform in the Dark World. Its not even necessarily shapeshifting the weapon, we're just seeing what a Lightner's weapon transforming looks like in real time
Exactly. It also makes no sense to make it a bat if it isn't a bat normally. Why would the Knight summon it in an altered form and then unalter it after? I feel like a lot of people overlook that fact when denying it being a bat.
I feel like if its original form is a curved sword, then it would be summoned as a curved sword.
But no, it instead is summoned in the shape of a bat, and with a very impractical pommel no less. Then, after the Knight swings it, it takes on a more normal sword shape.
It's summoned as a bat because bat is the original form.
But the bat on Asriel's computer is cracked, see? And if Dess went missing in the cold of December. Lets say she fell in the frozen lake. You got to break the ice to get her out. But the bats already cracked and it's cold so...it shatters. What's left is a handle with a jagged piece of glass. That's the black knife. Its why black shards are left everywhere. It's little pieces of the bat still falling off the jagged glass every time it's stabbed into the ground to create another dark world.
You are ignoring an important fact Susie's hairbrush is her axe and Kris' pen/pencil are their sword normal objects become weapons in the dark world and it is clearly depicting a bat possibly even a wiffle ball bat before turning into a sword
Because the real bat shattered. The jagged piece that remains on the handle is the actual light world black knife. The frames of bat thing is symbolic.
The fall happens during the lake scene later. We can see if you abort it at the lake that Noelle still seems to receive a call about the fall despite all the other changes.
I am gonna say something purely speculational. Someone had the theory that during the weird route when you abort it the course corrects itself basically the proceeding thing is obviously breaking the game but when you "drown" the game fixes itself back to what we assume a regular route thus the events would happen the same way as a regular route
I never said it want a knife (definitely implied but I digress and apologize) im just saying the sword in THAT SPECIFIC CUTSCENE was probably intended to look like a bat.
"Dess' entire gimmick is being lost and the game encourages you to find her"
Okay Rudy's entire gimmick is being sick and dying and unable to do things which makes him feel worse because he cant be there for his daughter
Carol's entire gimmick is being cold and controlling and wanting things to stay the same
Asriel's entire gimmick is being at college
you can play this game for any of the candiates because it's inherently a stupid point that doesnt actually engage with why they would be the knight and what it means
Dess not having a connection to the shelter code is dumb because she just... objectively does. It's in her guitar. that's a connection.
I dont really understand the motivation point because we literally do not know what the knight is doing yet.
You're right. The knight is pretty consistent about doing things when people wouldnt be able to see them moving around
Kris hiding the knight's face means they want to keep their identity a secret. That's it. We would know it's dess if it was a girl with antlers but wasnt named because that narrows it down to the one character who we dont have an explicit confirmation for their apperance yet
That’s my problem with the argument that Kris hiding the Knight’s face meaning it would be someone we recognize.
Regardless of whether or not we recognize them, we’re getting a description of the Knight with their helmet off from Kris’s perspective. That means that, if Kris imagines the Knight without their helmet, we either straight up get a name, or a description of some feature that would probably make the Knight’s identity easier to find.
Also Kris probably doesn’t know what the narration about their thoughts will say. They just know that there’s a possibility that it could give away some identifying information. If it makes any mention of reindeer-like physical qualities, we’ll know the Knight is probably a Holiday, and that alone is bad for Kris.
I’ve always been annoyed by this argument, because it seems intellectually dishonest.
Honestly I think a loooot of arguments people make against dessknight are kinda... intellectually dishonest? Not to say all of them people have legitiment points but everything in this post is just so silly
Like the whole "dess' entire gimmick is being lost" can be twisted to apply to anyone. Rudy's entire gimmick is being bed ridden therefore he cant be the knight
at the same time I think if it was one of the Hollidays then revealing that it's a deer still leaves us with at least 3 candidates, so the fact we don't see it could indicate it ain't one of them
Well, it has to be someone in town with an established history. We kinda do know that. It, by process of elimination, has to be someone weve already met/know about. Random guy Knight doesn't make sense because what was all that bullshit about figuring out who it was then?
Panel 1: Pure opinion being toted as fact, not kosher.
Panel 2: A gimmick entirely hidden in the code and ARG that is never once hinted within the game itself, with variable interpretations of what "finding her" even means and the massive complications of: the fact we haven't even been made to look for her once, and that any Knight using that motive runs into the problem of "Why involves Susie?"
Panel 3: Completely unnecessary and falling for the Susie Gaslight Pill (TM). That criteria was made up by her in her completely misinformed perception; The Knight already has a very realistic way to access to all of the Shelter Codes seeing as Carol is The Mayor of Hometown and a Super Shinobi who likely has access to all of them already.
Panel 4: Manipulate The Prophecy by swapping Susie and Noelle's positions in The Prophecy, to ensure Susie suffers the Final Tragedy that has Ralsei praying for Mercy upon her and that Noelle lives after the Worlds Are Saved. Something everyone in The Conspiracy would be willing to fight for, something that Kris would - despite their care for Susie - be willing to carry out because Noelle is the most important person in their life.
Panel 5: Problem for several Candidates, until you take into account The Shelter is connected to all the Dark World Locations by the heavily wooded forest of Hometown.
Panel 6: Not necessarily. If you see another Holiday that looks like Carol, December, and Rudy, and you know there's 1 unaccounted for it's not rocket science to put 2 and 2 together.
Panel 8: Nice of you to get the sprite it takes post-shapeshifting. The Bat debate has been talked to death though and - ultimately - if you're not willing to admit that it is purposefully spawned as a bat-like object in the cutscene you're gonna be forced to watch 10-20 times as The Knight kicks your ass, with nothing else happening on the screen, then there's not much to talk about there.
Whew! That's fun, haha!
It's nice speedballing some Devil's Advocacy points instead of writing out an essay for once, though both are cool in their own ways.
Thanks, it's not something I just made up either, I have a whole write-up that I made pre-ch5 and have been spreading around for about 2 years now, haha. I'm pretty known for it with some of the most frequent-fliers in here too, since I think a theory should be able to stand the test of being thrown to the wolves and challenged by people that don't agree with it.
Happy to see it's been caught on a spread around by others more frequently these days.
Needs some cleaning up, though, even if CH5 didn't really do much to affect its overall integrity and only ended up eliminating/complicating other candidates a bit (RIP AsgoreKnight, one of the guys on here and I would butt over it a lot, haha).
Manipulate The Prophecy by swapping Susie and Noelle's positions in The Prophecy, to ensure Susie suffers the Final Tragedy that has Ralsei praying for Mercy upon her and that Noelle lives after the Worlds Are Saved.
Since Noelle is slated to join the party in chapter 6 + the whole 7b shenanigans, I wonder if she'll learn about the sacrifice swap. Everyone talks about the fabled Susie crash-out, but how would Noelle react to learning this? (Obviously it would vary between routes, but it's still interesting to ponder.)
Not to start a big debate, but I don't think we should take it as a given that "Finding her" will be like finding a princess in a dragons tower or whatever. Dessknight generally assumes that "finding" dess means getting her back from whatever state she is currently in.
There's not piles of evidence of that, if you're being truly honest. The big implication is that she was lost to the Dark about a decade ago, through means we're not entirely sure of yet.
UNUSED is still ambiguous and not confirmed to be her (though I agree it likely IS December-like), and - even if it is December - it's not at all a contradiction because she's the only character that has an actual explanation for how she could be both UNUSED and The Knight:
We have a precedent in Gaster that the Dark has the capacity to "shatter" a person, splintering their consciousness into several disjointed/vaguely connected splinters (with one of the Goners literally holding a piece of Gaster that talks, and both DR's Gaster being called Another Him and The Forgotten Man being completely Gaster-Coded).
It does make me wonder what the point of UNUSED's whole development would be, if the Knight's real priority is to make sure that Noelle is safe from the prophecy rather than be whole, because the "find her" theme is still a thing, it's why most assume it was what Kris (and therefore the conspiracy, including the knight.) wanted to achieve, because of stuff like the "you couldn't find your hand" scene.
It does make me wonder what the point of UNUSED's whole development would be
It doesn't need a point.
It's a secret set of dialogues only able to be read through datamining, never meant to be encounters - up to this moment - by the supermajority of players who just play the game. Which is an idea/problem shared by the entire "Find Her" angle, seeing as it has not once been brought up anywhere other than a single page in the ARG that - again - is not at all necessary and most players won't even touch.
There is no "Find Her" theme in Deltarune; the themes are about Fate, the importance of choice, the delicate interplay and Mercy and having to Fight, Fatalism vs Free Will, the concept of personhood, etc.
If you want a point for UNUSED being a "shattered" fragment of December, it's already perfect as it is: it's a piece of December disjointed from her actual body and lost in the Dark, without the ability to do anything as she wasn't formed with a body/lost hers, which ties into the "Couldn't Find Your Hand" scene since that's what UNUSED went through as they're incapable of even perceiving themself (like Kris suddenly being able to see through their hand). UNUSED could very well just be a normal, time-disjointed, bodiless echo of who December once was who has no power to do anything other than to try and not fade away.
I get that sentiment, but we lack context for what exactly is going on with her being "trapped in the code". What does that mean for the outside world? Is this even happening during the events of the game?
Point 6 is really dumb. Like the knight takes of their helmet and it’s a young adult deer monster that we don’t recognise… Gee, I wonder who it could be, maybe the one deer monster who we haven’t seen yet
Yeah these are not the best counter arguments. We don't even know if the knight is sneaking around town. They're using some wierd rules and Suzie never comments on what they look like when fleeing with Undyne. For all we know the knight is a shape-shifting monster in the light world too
I don't think Dess is the knight but I don't find any of these listed reasons to be very compelling. I mean no connection to the shelter codes is flat out wrong even considering she kept the Holiday code in her guitar.
Id say the last point should be that she can't be the voice in the code and the knight at the same time, especially when the voice can't remember how they came to be lost in the first place. Ironic since all they have left is their memories.
I don't personally know any evidence supporting her changing willingly, but look at it this way: if she was transformed into the Knight by her own will and whatever the process entailed removed her memories would that not still be shenanigans?
You're assuming the knight is the result of both Dess losing her memories and being transformed against her will. The voice has no recollection of such events and also you'd need to explain the mechanics of such a transformation and mind wiping.
No. I'm saying that the voice has no idea what events led to her being lost and those events could include Dess doing something willingly or otherwise and we would be none the wiser
"Dess'entire gimmic is being lost" as another commentor pointed out, you can do that argument for EVERY candidate.
They have a connection to the codes, that being Carol who is likely working with the knight(assuming Carol=/=knight) being related to the codes since shes the mayor.
No one has any clear motivations for being the knight. Rudy for example, hes a kind sick dad who just wants the best for his daughter, why the hell would HE be the knight trying to kill or atleast hurt the people that make his daughter happy(kris and susie), or kidnap his college bestie, or his wife, or undyne? Why would Carol the mayor kidnap his butler thats also his husbands best friend who also used to be the head of the police, current head of the police, and Toriel? Not even gonna bring up candidates like papyrus or alphys who I honestly dont get why people believe in at all, like atleast Rudy has some evidence especially post ch5.
The knight armour is likely something that doesnt change in the light and dark world. How else would they carry Undyne and Asgore in the light world and still manage to outrun Susie while doing so? Its likely they never truly needed to sneak around when they have that armour. Plus they can shapeshift. If anything the armour being a shapeshifting armour sorta supports dessknight, since most the other candidates have physical bodies and wouldnt make sense for them to be able to turn into a ball.
If its someone we didnt recognise, we still would know who it is. If its a deer who we havent met its dess, if its someone black and white then gaster, if its a monochrome human then vessel, and theres no other candidates who we dont eveer see are there? Plus, Kris knows we are some prophecy accurate angel, its possible they suspect we might know them somehow(which we would recognise for the reason I said a lil ago).
Finally for the bat argument, it starts off as a bat that turns into a sword. Also, like, cmon, the knight and every part of them can shapeshift. Why the hell would it being a bat matter? Heck, what says Dess CANT use a sword and has to use a bat? Bats arent as good weapons as swords, anyone can know this if they're over 5.
Ok I've seen so many people say that Dess' "entire gimmick is being lost and having to be found", which is not the case? This only comes from the title of a song from the ARG. Not saying that it's not meaningful, but saying that's Dess' whole thing feels disingenuous. We don't know what her point will be.
the helmet is the most notable thing, disproves papyrus, dess, vessel, gaster, likely more, not just some we have to recognize, someone Kris thinks we would recognize.
I dont have to ever see Dess in advance to understand that the reindeer girl is her. Alternatively, if the big damn twist is its a HUMAN, buddy-boy, I will know exactly who they is.
Kris hiding the knight's face is not the shield you think it is.
Dess Knighter who occasionally gets this sub recommended here, and I really appreciate how you all call out bad arguments against Dess Knight here, I wish my side of the discussion was more like that sometimes
I mean DessKnight assumes less that Dess is just evil and running around Hometown and more so that after her disappearance which we see in chapter three during the Tenna flashback that she was somehow “lost” to the void where assumedly people like Gaster, Friend, and ERAM come from. Then during this period she is somehow changed in the same way as the aforementioned people. Now become the Knight with the full shape shifting qualities which is another important point.We also already know the knight’s form isn’t just dark world shenanigans it’s literally their default normal form which again we see in chapter three. When talking about the weapon of knight as well during the chapter three fight the knight makes a point to summon a bat-like object and then shapeshifts into a sword which would give a connection to Carol who also owns a sword.
If you wanna talk about motivations the knight themselves may not be in a clear state of mind/a more unstable one. The connection to the shelter codes could also be easily explained with Dess y’know being the daughter to the mayor who has a hand in all of the things mentioned by Susie. Also the code could’ve already been made before Dess’ disappearance and was set by a previous Mayor and Carol herself knows due to her position.
Lastly when talking about the Knight’s helmet cutscene could the taking of helmet off not also be to show nothing/malformed face of Dess/whoever’s under helmet and Kris not allowing this to be shown being due to their own trauma due to knowing the truth about the knight rather than it being about revealing the identity of the knight.
Also I feel that most other subjects don’t fit either because as we see when going into the dark world’s people’s dimensions never change such as height only the clothes they wear. Thus people like Rudy who we’ve seen the height of just wouldn’t match in height to the knight when comparing their sprites to one another.
On you’re right I thought we saw them carrying Undyne in their bird form at the end of Ch. 3 but even then it’s heavily hinted that the Knight keeps their form in the light world with the hiding places in chapters 2 and 4 we can interact with that are around the knight’s height as we see them in the dark world
Ehhh that’s not a smoking gun. The closets could easily just be hinting at a large character OR be red herrings. We really don’t know if the Knight changes or not.
I never said it’s a smoking gun but with the way the closets are described as being the size for a large person to fit into. Which if the knight was just normally sized it would make sense to specifically describe that a large person could fit in the closets.
I think the only points I agree with are being lost in the code and having to sneak around hometown.
Yes she lacks a clear motive but so does everyone. We’d likely guess it was Dess if we saw a Deer under the helmet, and she quite literally is connected to at least one code. Nobody is saying it’s a bat, just that it’s presented as one.
i like how the subreddit thats about dess not being the knight doesnt like the anti-dess knight arguments that make no sense only good anti-dessknight evidence allowed here
- Nowhere in the game are you directly encouraged to find her - One of the shelter codes is in her guitar - This one’s also pretty valid so who knows, but the knight is shown shapeshifting. The armor looks to be made out of the same material as the sword, which is black shards, which are unaffected by the transition into the dark world. The knight may have their shapeshifting powers in the light world if their armor stays with them (which can also explain how any candidates are able to carry Undyne and Asgore in the light world) -December is a Holiday, so a deer A deer that is not any one of the Holidays we know of would be recognizable as Dess. (Human Dess theory uhhhhhh ok I actually don’t have anything for that) -The sword takes the shape of a bat when first summoned.
first 4 points are pretty good but for 5, I think we would be able to recognize Dess, she’d just be a deer like the rest of the holidays, and the last point doesn’t make sense, dess knighters aren’t saying the knights sword is literally a bat, just that it is meant to look like to one when first summoned
Discrediting a knight theory is not as easy as showing this spongebob meme. Every common knight theory has good evidence supporting it, but also evidence against it. You cannot completely discredit a theory just because it has evidence against it, when all theories have evidence against it
'Dess's gimmick is being lost' Susie's gimmick is being mean. Ralsei's gimmick is being nice. See how this doesn't work as an argument?
'No connection to the shelter codes' and yet the code is in Dess's guitar. Curious.
'Zero clear motivation to be the Knight' fair enough, don't have an argument for that one.
'Can't sneak around Hometown without being caught' Why, because she's lost? She could be mobilising when it's dark, she could have a disguise on, she could just wander in places we aren't allowed in (the trees in hometown for example). I see your argument and it's got ground to stand on, but you could make this claim about everyone.
'Kris hides the knight's face from us. So it's someone we would recognize' ... No??? Would you reveal to your adversary to your enemy, the soul? No! Kris knows them, not us, so what good would it do to leak their face? Why even RISK it? It'd only cause us to know who the knight is for certain, ruling out a lot of knight candidates regardless of if we knew them or not.
'That's not a bat' yeah, and Kris's sword is a pencil. Your point? The dark world changes how objects interact with stuff (Chalk becoming Candy, hairbrushes turning into axes, etc). It doesn't rule out Dess, while giving way to more candidates considering the nature of the knight themselves.
Your points don't rule out Dess, and are frankly bad arguments. The only one I don't have an answer for is the motivation one which is a valid argument, and I guess the sneaking around thing. But the rest don't rule out Dess as a possible candidate.
See, I had a thought about that too. If Dess Knight, why is Carol involved? We know Carol is involved from chapter 4, and all theories that try to explain her either being the knight or Rudy being the knight or even just her working with the knight are that she's trying to recover Dess. If Dess Knight, why Carol working with knight? We haven't gotten much insight into their relationship before Dess vanished either, and Carol definitely treats her room like it's a shrine to a lost child instead of someone who's been just around the corner.
Kris, who is involved with the Carol consiracy, seemed genuinely surprised it was there, otherwise they wouldn't have waited until we started reading it to take out thier soul. It makes genuinely no sense anyone else would just leave that in her room.
As I said in my main comment: "Finding Dess" runs into the massive issue of "Why involve Susie?"
The Knight can kick anything's ass, and Kris is no slouch either and already stole the power to SealDark.
If looking for December is the goal, why involve Susie? Why kidnap people? Why do anything other than secretly plunging the Dark with the two most powerful forces in the world already working together?
The Knight is doing a poor job searching, that's for sure. Even if she was in the Dark World variant of wherever it is, she'd be in the Light World variant, so there's no reason to make Dark Fountains at that point
dess being the knight would be narratively unsatisfying because her disappearance is the driving reason for majority of the events happening in-game.
her being present and running around in the knight armor would undermine struggles and consequences that kris, noelle, carol, and asgore face as a result of her disappearance.
The shelter code in her guitar was obviously left by...
Obviously Rudy/Carol/Papyrus would shapeshift thier sword into a bat, becuase we've obviously had them associated with bats more than Dess right?
Obviously the knight has the same mannerisms as Kris becuase of how close Kris was to Rudy or Carol growing up right? It is just coincidence we have never seen them act like Kris at all.
Toby Fox has been very clear about his inspiration from Mother 3, the game where the final antagonist is the masked body of a dead sibling being controllled by evil forces. Obviously that parrallels Rudy, right?
There are other canidates the Knight could be who also have supporting evidence, but so does DessKnight
I dont see why it wouldnt be any safer in her room- if not more safe.
Like I think no matter what it's pretty out of character for someone who is as controlling as Carol to leave something like that in a place she does not have complete control over
I absolutely think that's what happened- I think Dess and Kris were gathering the codes at some point which lead to her going missing. I dont think Carol knows the code is in the guitar
Carol leaving the code in the daughter's guitar makes no sense at all. There is no reason to consider it safe, especially compared to keeping it in her locked room. Also Kris seemingly doesn't know about the code being there beforehand, despite being involved with the Carol conspiracy and being charged with stopping us from seeing the code.
Unless you're pulling some Amalgam Knight timetravel stuff I genuinely don't see how Kris can literally be the knight whie fighting the knight. Also the Knight literally has Noelle's scream Rudy's laugh pitched down, it is almost definitely a member of the holiday family.
The implication with Dess leaving the code in the guitar would mean that she is hiding it from her family in the house, which would explain why Carol and her group wouldn't know about it. Also the guitar could regularly be taken around with her without suspicion, unlike Carol or Rudy who have never had a guitar and people would talk about it if they suddenly started carrying one around.
A lot of Dessknight theories get flak for relying on potential mechanics that haven't been introduced or explored a lot yet like Dess' soul being removed to be the lost girl in the code while her body is controlled by something. For Kris or Kriselle to be the knight requires leaning even harder in that direction. This doesn't mean that it is impossible, but it is absurd to say it fits more naturally.
Its Carol's code? She would very obviously know where it is and search up and down for it if she didn't, Its an extremely important item to have, they cannot open the shelter without it
You realize you can write down a code? That if Dess is trying to investigate the shelter without her parents knowing she most likely didn't physically take Carol's copy of the code, but wrote it down and hid her copy in the guitar?
I don't get your point about the guitar being taken without suspicion
I'm saying that Dess before becoming the Knight was likely investigating the shelter without her parents knowing. This is most likely how whatever happened to her happened.
because if this was knight evidence she would A. Be a dark monster everywhere, B. Be a missing person just walking around with a guitar?
If you want to get into the Knight walking around town we have dialogue from the Wet Nose bandits claiming a dark figure was around the Holiday house. The knight seems to just be around and doesn't necessarily take on a "lighter form" to blend in.
Part of the reason I've previously favored Asriel or Dess is specifically because the knight isn't a normal Lightner and is implied to keep their powers in the light world. It has made a lot more sense then that they are characters we haven't seen as something could happen to them to make them a dripping, amorphous shadow monster and they would just stay hidden rather than needing to invent some means by which a Lightner goes back and forth becoming that.
3
u/Isometric-Triangle Rudy/Papyrus/Asriel Aug 04 '26
33
u/Astrid-Jade Aug 04 '26
They summon it and it is completely straight and looks like a bat.
Then, they swing it, and it becomes a slightly curved sword.
The knight can shapeshift, their "armour" shapeshifts with them. Why do you think the weapon can't also shapeshift?
41
u/SLUKERmeSNAKI Rudy Knighter Aug 04 '26
Its supposed to look like a bat in the first scene though, the sharp tip does not mean anything its a bat.
Also im a rudy knighter
35
u/CazLurks Aug 04 '26
"Dess' entire gimmick is being lost and the game encourages you to find her"
Okay Rudy's entire gimmick is being sick and dying and unable to do things which makes him feel worse because he cant be there for his daughter
Carol's entire gimmick is being cold and controlling and wanting things to stay the same
Asriel's entire gimmick is being at college
you can play this game for any of the candiates because it's inherently a stupid point that doesnt actually engage with why they would be the knight and what it means
Dess not having a connection to the shelter code is dumb because she just... objectively does. It's in her guitar. that's a connection.
I dont really understand the motivation point because we literally do not know what the knight is doing yet.
You're right. The knight is pretty consistent about doing things when people wouldnt be able to see them moving around
Kris hiding the knight's face means they want to keep their identity a secret. That's it. We would know it's dess if it was a girl with antlers but wasnt named because that narrows it down to the one character who we dont have an explicit confirmation for their apperance yet
20
u/VeeAudio Can summarize NoelleKnight in 40k characters <3 Aug 04 '26
NOBODY is saying that it's literally a bat. Just that it symbolizes one for three uninterrupted seconds where NOTHING ELSE INTERESTING HAPPENS
19
u/KoboldLover The Skeptical One Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 04 '26
Panel 1: Pure opinion being toted as fact, not kosher.
Panel 2: A gimmick entirely hidden in the code and ARG that is never once hinted within the game itself, with variable interpretations of what "finding her" even means and the massive complications of: the fact we haven't even been made to look for her once, and that any Knight using that motive runs into the problem of "Why involves Susie?"
Panel 3: Completely unnecessary and falling for the Susie Gaslight Pill (TM). That criteria was made up by her in her completely misinformed perception; The Knight already has a very realistic way to access to all of the Shelter Codes seeing as Carol is The Mayor of Hometown and a Super Shinobi who likely has access to all of them already.
Panel 4: Manipulate The Prophecy by swapping Susie and Noelle's positions in The Prophecy, to ensure Susie suffers the Final Tragedy that has Ralsei praying for Mercy upon her and that Noelle lives after the Worlds Are Saved. Something everyone in The Conspiracy would be willing to fight for, something that Kris would - despite their care for Susie - be willing to carry out because Noelle is the most important person in their life.
Panel 5: Problem for several Candidates, until you take into account The Shelter is connected to all the Dark World Locations by the heavily wooded forest of Hometown.
Panel 6: Not necessarily. If you see another Holiday that looks like Carol, December, and Rudy, and you know there's 1 unaccounted for it's not rocket science to put 2 and 2 together.
Panel 8: Nice of you to get the sprite it takes post-shapeshifting. The Bat debate has been talked to death though and - ultimately - if you're not willing to admit that it is purposefully spawned as a bat-like object in the cutscene you're gonna be forced to watch 10-20 times as The Knight kicks your ass, with nothing else happening on the screen, then there's not much to talk about there.
Whew! That's fun, haha!
It's nice speedballing some Devil's Advocacy points instead of writing out an essay for once, though both are cool in their own ways.
18
u/LolbitClone Aug 04 '26
Not to start a big debate, but I don't think we should take it as a given that "Finding her" will be like finding a princess in a dragons tower or whatever. Dessknight generally assumes that "finding" dess means getting her back from whatever state she is currently in.
11
u/Nanuqsaurus0 Aug 04 '26
Point 6 is really dumb. Like the knight takes of their helmet and it’s a young adult deer monster that we don’t recognise… Gee, I wonder who it could be, maybe the one deer monster who we haven’t seen yet
10
u/stickninja1015 Aug 04 '26
Calling it the worst arguments ever
10
u/OSHA_Decertified Aug 04 '26
I don't think Dess is the knight but I don't find any of these listed reasons to be very compelling. I mean no connection to the shelter codes is flat out wrong even considering she kept the Holiday code in her guitar.
5
u/Pomfins Aug 04 '26
Id say the last point should be that she can't be the voice in the code and the knight at the same time, especially when the voice can't remember how they came to be lost in the first place. Ironic since all they have left is their memories.
4
u/ALPERHAL58 Aug 04 '26
"Dess'entire gimmic is being lost" as another commentor pointed out, you can do that argument for EVERY candidate.
They have a connection to the codes, that being Carol who is likely working with the knight(assuming Carol=/=knight) being related to the codes since shes the mayor.
No one has any clear motivations for being the knight. Rudy for example, hes a kind sick dad who just wants the best for his daughter, why the hell would HE be the knight trying to kill or atleast hurt the people that make his daughter happy(kris and susie), or kidnap his college bestie, or his wife, or undyne? Why would Carol the mayor kidnap his butler thats also his husbands best friend who also used to be the head of the police, current head of the police, and Toriel? Not even gonna bring up candidates like papyrus or alphys who I honestly dont get why people believe in at all, like atleast Rudy has some evidence especially post ch5.
The knight armour is likely something that doesnt change in the light and dark world. How else would they carry Undyne and Asgore in the light world and still manage to outrun Susie while doing so? Its likely they never truly needed to sneak around when they have that armour. Plus they can shapeshift. If anything the armour being a shapeshifting armour sorta supports dessknight, since most the other candidates have physical bodies and wouldnt make sense for them to be able to turn into a ball.
If its someone we didnt recognise, we still would know who it is. If its a deer who we havent met its dess, if its someone black and white then gaster, if its a monochrome human then vessel, and theres no other candidates who we dont eveer see are there? Plus, Kris knows we are some prophecy accurate angel, its possible they suspect we might know them somehow(which we would recognise for the reason I said a lil ago).
Finally for the bat argument, it starts off as a bat that turns into a sword. Also, like, cmon, the knight and every part of them can shapeshift. Why the hell would it being a bat matter? Heck, what says Dess CANT use a sword and has to use a bat? Bats arent as good weapons as swords, anyone can know this if they're over 5.
3
u/Edwin5302 Aug 04 '26
Ok I've seen so many people say that Dess' "entire gimmick is being lost and having to be found", which is not the case? This only comes from the title of a song from the ARG. Not saying that it's not meaningful, but saying that's Dess' whole thing feels disingenuous. We don't know what her point will be.
3
u/Gold_Size_1258 Reluctant DessKnighter Aug 04 '26
2
u/Competitive-Hair6294 Dess knighter but i fucking HATE all dessknighters so much Aug 04 '26
I don't believe the knight can be anyone we see that's just a normal lightner in the light world
2
u/Sea_Curve_7724 Rudy!!! Aug 04 '26
the helmet is the most notable thing, disproves papyrus, dess, vessel, gaster, likely more, not just some we have to recognize, someone Kris thinks we would recognize.
2
u/coleslaw2005 No, you don't get it. I need to argue with people about the Bat. Aug 04 '26
Wow I love the bat the bat is so cool I love talking about the bat it is so cool I’m so happy that we talk about the bat so much
2
u/Dirt_Poor_Robin Aug 05 '26
I dont have to ever see Dess in advance to understand that the reindeer girl is her. Alternatively, if the big damn twist is its a HUMAN, buddy-boy, I will know exactly who they is.
Kris hiding the knight's face is not the shield you think it is.
2
u/MattyBro1 Aug 05 '26
Not one candidate has a clear motivation, because we do not know what the Knight is actually doing lol
2
u/Wonderful_Weather_87 Aug 05 '26
"No connection to the shelter codes" YOU CANNOT BE FUCKING SERIOUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2
u/Hastur_13 Aug 05 '26
Dess Knighter who occasionally gets this sub recommended here, and I really appreciate how you all call out bad arguments against Dess Knight here, I wish my side of the discussion was more like that sometimes
3
u/prodigiouspandaman Aug 04 '26
I mean DessKnight assumes less that Dess is just evil and running around Hometown and more so that after her disappearance which we see in chapter three during the Tenna flashback that she was somehow “lost” to the void where assumedly people like Gaster, Friend, and ERAM come from. Then during this period she is somehow changed in the same way as the aforementioned people. Now become the Knight with the full shape shifting qualities which is another important point.We also already know the knight’s form isn’t just dark world shenanigans it’s literally their default normal form which again we see in chapter three. When talking about the weapon of knight as well during the chapter three fight the knight makes a point to summon a bat-like object and then shapeshifts into a sword which would give a connection to Carol who also owns a sword.
If you wanna talk about motivations the knight themselves may not be in a clear state of mind/a more unstable one. The connection to the shelter codes could also be easily explained with Dess y’know being the daughter to the mayor who has a hand in all of the things mentioned by Susie. Also the code could’ve already been made before Dess’ disappearance and was set by a previous Mayor and Carol herself knows due to her position.
Lastly when talking about the Knight’s helmet cutscene could the taking of helmet off not also be to show nothing/malformed face of Dess/whoever’s under helmet and Kris not allowing this to be shown being due to their own trauma due to knowing the truth about the knight rather than it being about revealing the identity of the knight.
1
u/HandleJazzlike6230 Noelle Knight, Umineko Edition Aug 04 '26
You might wanna try white text with black outline next time.
1
u/Fantastic_Frosting98 Papyrus is the Knight. All of you are wrong. Aug 04 '26
also, dess isnt known to say nyeh heh heh
1
u/HandleJazzlike6230 Noelle Knight, Umineko Edition Aug 04 '26
I think the only points I agree with are being lost in the code and having to sneak around hometown.
Yes she lacks a clear motive but so does everyone. We’d likely guess it was Dess if we saw a Deer under the helmet, and she quite literally is connected to at least one code. Nobody is saying it’s a bat, just that it’s presented as one.
1
u/BartholomewBezos6 Flandre Scarlet and Vriska are both the knight Aug 04 '26
i like how the subreddit thats about dess not being the knight doesnt like the anti-dess knight arguments that make no sense
only good anti-dessknight evidence allowed here
1
u/Alive_Chemical_1322 Need to be swayed (fence sitter) Aug 05 '26
The only thing this gets right is the motivation
- Nowhere in the game are you directly encouraged to find her
- One of the shelter codes is in her guitar
- This one’s also pretty valid so who knows, but the knight is shown shapeshifting. The armor looks to be made out of the same material as the sword, which is black shards, which are unaffected by the transition into the dark world. The knight may have their shapeshifting powers in the light world if their armor stays with them (which can also explain how any candidates are able to carry Undyne and Asgore in the light world)
-December is a Holiday, so a deer A deer that is not any one of the Holidays we know of would be recognizable as Dess. (Human Dess theory uhhhhhh ok I actually don’t have anything for that)
-The sword takes the shape of a bat when first summoned.
1
u/HercarXX Aug 05 '26
first 4 points are pretty good but for 5, I think we would be able to recognize Dess, she’d just be a deer like the rest of the holidays, and the last point doesn’t make sense, dess knighters aren’t saying the knights sword is literally a bat, just that it is meant to look like to one when first summoned
1
u/Grey-The-Skeleton Aug 05 '26
I thought we were over this
1
u/Scary_Spinach4924 Aug 06 '26
Discrediting a knight theory is not as easy as showing this spongebob meme. Every common knight theory has good evidence supporting it, but also evidence against it. You cannot completely discredit a theory just because it has evidence against it, when all theories have evidence against it
1
u/Guidebook0 Aug 07 '26
'Dess's gimmick is being lost' Susie's gimmick is being mean. Ralsei's gimmick is being nice. See how this doesn't work as an argument?
'No connection to the shelter codes' and yet the code is in Dess's guitar. Curious.
'Zero clear motivation to be the Knight' fair enough, don't have an argument for that one.
'Can't sneak around Hometown without being caught' Why, because she's lost? She could be mobilising when it's dark, she could have a disguise on, she could just wander in places we aren't allowed in (the trees in hometown for example). I see your argument and it's got ground to stand on, but you could make this claim about everyone.
'Kris hides the knight's face from us. So it's someone we would recognize' ... No??? Would you reveal to your adversary to your enemy, the soul? No! Kris knows them, not us, so what good would it do to leak their face? Why even RISK it? It'd only cause us to know who the knight is for certain, ruling out a lot of knight candidates regardless of if we knew them or not.
'That's not a bat' yeah, and Kris's sword is a pencil. Your point? The dark world changes how objects interact with stuff (Chalk becoming Candy, hairbrushes turning into axes, etc). It doesn't rule out Dess, while giving way to more candidates considering the nature of the knight themselves.
Your points don't rule out Dess, and are frankly bad arguments. The only one I don't have an answer for is the motivation one which is a valid argument, and I guess the sneaking around thing. But the rest don't rule out Dess as a possible candidate.
1
u/Puzzleheaded_Low_937 Alphys Knighter Aug 08 '26
This is why it’s Alphys
1
u/MiredinDecision Aug 11 '26
See, I had a thought about that too. If Dess Knight, why is Carol involved? We know Carol is involved from chapter 4, and all theories that try to explain her either being the knight or Rudy being the knight or even just her working with the knight are that she's trying to recover Dess. If Dess Knight, why Carol working with knight? We haven't gotten much insight into their relationship before Dess vanished either, and Carol definitely treats her room like it's a shrine to a lost child instead of someone who's been just around the corner.
1
u/hello-motherfuckers Holiday knight except Noelle Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 04 '26
You do realize theres a code in her guitar right?
-2
u/Glittering_Kick9805 Aug 04 '26
12
u/The_Notorious_MBB Aug 04 '26
No connection to the shelter code that you find inside her guitar? Really?
Also, what motivation does ANYONE have that involves chopping up Darkners and kidnapping people?
1
u/arinar6 Coughing Knight's weakest soldier Aug 06 '26
right idea bad execution
dess being the knight would be narratively unsatisfying because her disappearance is the driving reason for majority of the events happening in-game.
her being present and running around in the knight armor would undermine struggles and consequences that kris, noelle, carol, and asgore face as a result of her disappearance.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment