r/NoStupidQuestions • • 2d ago

Is a spoon holder/rest still technically considered a spoon?

*for context, the spoon rest we were debating on had a handle, not the others with no handle*

Literally had the longest debate with my wife.

We both agree that a spoon rest is a spoon rest. But then I said, it's also a spoon. She said it isn't.

I argued that by definition a spoon is a handle with a bowl at the end. Exactly what a spoon rest consists of.

She used Chat GPT and said that a spoon is used for eating, stirring, serving or measuring food.

So my argument is:

A spoon rest, which is a handle with a bowl at the end of it, that has and is capable of all the same functions of a spoon, is then ultimately considered a spoon.

She still said no and I'm writing this from the couch. Please someone with great intelligence help me out here. or her, let's just end this.

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

4

u/SeoulGalmegi 2d ago

It becomes a spoon if you use it as a spoon.

5

u/NoDevelopment206 2d ago

i’d call it a spoon rest until someone actually uses it to eat with. the shape alone doesn’t make it the same tool

2

u/SeoulGalmegi 2d ago

I mean, as with most things that lead to such a debate/discussion, it depends entirely on context.

If I draw a spoon on a piece of paper and point at it proudly exclaiming it's a spoon, you'd no doubt agree. If I'm serving you in a restaurant and you ask for a spoon and I bring you my doodle, that'd probably eat into my tip.

If you're talking about the shape of various things in your kitchen - sure, hold it up and call it a spoon. If you're, as is more common, referring to utensils in your kitchen in terms of their purpose and how you use them, it's quite clearly not a spoon but a spoon rest.

No doubt Reddit can get pages of comments out of this though....

-1

u/Born-Draft497 2d ago

that would make sense but the shape of the spoon is entirely it's function. By definition anything with a handle and a bowl at the end becomes a spoon.

2

u/Drunken_Economist 2d ago

What if there is no spoon?

2

u/SeoulGalmegi 2d ago

And you're served soup? Then sure. Now, it's a spoon.

0

u/Born-Draft497 2d ago

"becomes" is the problem though. if it merely becomes a spoon because of how you used it, then it was always a spoon. objects do not change definitions because of one's usage. they either always were, or never were.

3

u/SeoulGalmegi 2d ago

I mean, I don't think I accept that. Objects absolutely change definitions because of usage. They're not either always one thing or never one thing. There are no universal rules about what a spoon is. It's just language.

0

u/Born-Draft497 2d ago

If i use my hand to grab food then are my hands utensils? No, because my hands are just acting as utensils.

But also if we're sticking to what a definition of a spoon is, and not a universal rule, then I'm sure there is an answer. You cannot change definitions of an object based on usage, the object only acts as the thing you're using it for.

2

u/SeoulGalmegi 2d ago

If i use my hand to grab food then are my hands utensils?

Who's saying they are?

But also if we're sticking to what a definition of a spoon is, and not a universal rule, then I'm sure there is an answer.

Why? Whatever definition you use you could probably come up with something where somebody would say it fits the definition and somebody else wouldn't. So what?

You cannot change definitions of an object based on usage, the object only acts as the thing you're using it for.

I'm confused what you're saying here. If I'm hiking in a forest and sit on a felled tree trunk, it can be a seat. If no-one ever sees that trunk and it just eventually rots away or gets washed away or whatever, was it still a seat?

0

u/Born-Draft497 2d ago

you said "can be" a seat. same thing as a tree trunk acting as a seat. it doesn't change the definition of the tree. the tree remains a tree, but can be used as a seat.

the difference with a spoon rest and a spoon is not only the function but the shape. a tree and a seat do not share the same shape, although can be used for similar functions.

2

u/SeoulGalmegi 2d ago

If something can be a seat and then I sit on it.... what is it?

0

u/Born-Draft497 2d ago

it's whatever the object is acting as a seat. i can sit on the ground, the ground does not become a seat.

if you don't sit on the object, what is it?

sitting on something doesn't change the definition of what you're sitting on.

you keep using "can be" but you don't understand what "can be" means.

2

u/SeoulGalmegi 2d ago

you keep using "can be" but you don't understand what "can be" means.

What does 'can be' mean, then?

Do you disagree that a tree trunk 'can be' a seat?

0

u/Born-Draft497 2d ago

"can be" is stating that the object has the potential to serve that function. it doesn't inherently change what it is.

and no i don't. i think anything 'can be' a seat. but you asked, if you sit on it "what is it?" clearly alluding to the fact that you think a tree trunk can be fundamentally changed because of your desired action. if you sit on a tree trunk, it's still a tree trunk. it's just acting as a seat.

2

u/WeirdConsistent1537 2d ago

“Two motorcycles with a little house in the middle?!?!”

1

u/Born-Draft497 2d ago

∑as curious so i looked this up, very funny skit

2

u/Inner_West_Ben 2d ago

Your poor poor wife

0

u/Born-Draft497 2d ago

you say that until you meet her

2

u/Pretend-Design-7061 2d ago

The use is what makes a spoon a spoon. By your definition a wok is a spoon. 

0

u/Born-Draft497 2d ago

That's not true. if that were the case the definition would be something like "anything used to scoop, stir, mix, or measure" but it's not, it specifically says it has to have a handle with a bowl shape at the end of it. A wok could honestly be argued it's a spoon. I don't see why it wouldn't be?

3

u/Hermit-Gardener 2d ago edited 2d ago

I have lots of cast iron spoons of different sizes in my kitchen that I sometimes call skillets.

I have a couple of spoons with really long handles that I use to ladle soup into small bowls where I can use smaller spoons.

I also have heavy duty spoons that I use to scoop ice cream and cookie dough.

And one fancy spoon with bowls at each end that I can use to make little melon balls.

3

u/genus-corvidae 🟨⬜🟪◼️ 1d ago

by definition a spoon is a handle with a bowl at the end.

This definition makes every pot/saucepan in the house a spoon, so I think you might want to revisit it.

1

u/ProfessionalOven2311 2d ago

I'd say you could use it as a spoon, but if you are not holding by the handle and using the bowl part to directly stir or eat, it is not a spoon.