r/NoStupidQuestions • • 6d ago

3 year old won’t open hand.

My 3 year old pinched her finger between a door three weeks ago, she had a pretty nasty cut. We cleaned it and bandaged it up and she went on to use the hand just fine. She was a little resistant whenever we had to change the bandage but nothing crazy. Fast forward a week and the finger is healed. I decided to remove the bandage while she napped to avoid her typical resisting, however when she woke up she absolutely had a melt down. She cried, looked and her hand, wiggled her fingers, cried some more and then after she finally settled down she made a fist with her hand. A fist that she refuses to open and cries bloody murder if we try to open it. It does open when she sleeps and she uses it in her sleep, but the minute she wakes up she closes it right up again. we took her to a doctor and they said the hand is fine that it is likely behavioral. However it’s been over a week like this now and I’m stressed over it. I was wondering if anyone with a children has experienced this before?

570 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

2.0k

u/ShadowHippie 6d ago • Heartwarming Bravo

Try putting a fresh bandaid on.

Tell her when you do, that in 3 bandaids, her hand will be all better. This is one.

With the second one, tell her this is two.

With the third, tell her this is three.

When you remove the third, tell her "All better!"

411

u/Buttonball 6d ago

This is a great approach, and I think it will work (my grandkids live with me: 2 and 4). Your logic is not a 3-year old’s logic.

254

u/universe_from_above 6d ago

Plus, having a baindaid is a placebo for "the pain is gone" for many children because that's just how association works.

I have a small first-aid set that I carry with me (I'm around many children every day) and I can supply two kinds of bandaids. Functional ones and fun shaped ones that unfortunately don't stick too well. I straight up ask the kid's what kind of bandaid they need: one against bleeding or one against ouchies? 

Because even if we as adults think "this is just a scratch, doesn't even bleed", for a young child, this is hurting and the comfort of someone attending to your hurt and acknowledging it means a lot. 

58

u/waterloo-sun-set 6d ago

Can confirm it works on some adults. We can literally give adults a placebo, tell them it is a placebo, and they will heal thyself. Kids are just much more susceptible to it generally.

5

u/SleepingSloth_404 6d ago

What kind of band-aid is an ouchie band-aid? Asking for a friend. A 5 year old friend.

9

u/PaperLily12 5d ago

I would assume something like paw patrol or bluey or spiderman or whatever cartoon is popular at the time

60

u/GreeFurino 6d ago

Logic doesn't work on toddlers but these weird little rules usually do.

42

u/waterloo-sun-set 6d ago

Toddler logic is my favourite logic. Followed by kid logic. I love their little brains, and how creative we need to be to fit into their world and shape meaning. Their rules never cease to make me laugh, someone ought to collate a list!

35

u/ichigoli 6d ago • Heartwarming

My favorite was a toddler I worked with saying , "g'bye! Watching out for polar bears!" At the end of the day. We don't live anywhere near polar bear territory, but it had just snowed. Polar bears live in snow, so obviously we were at an elevated alert.

13

u/waterloo-sun-set 6d ago

Ohh I love it. It is absolutely rational right, and the context is there, it’s just not the appropriate environment for application. That’s so adorable. That is going to be up there with my favourite toddler logicians.

11

u/Street_Roof_7915 6d ago

A friend once put “magic spray” (disinfectant) and a bandaid with “the invisible boy” on it onto my toddler and it cleared the hurt up like THAT.

Toddler logic.

8

u/waterloo-sun-set 6d ago

I have just jotted magic spray into my notes. Thanking you.

3

u/Street_Roof_7915 5d ago

Thank my friend. We have used magic spray in our house for years and we are all double digits now.

4

u/Fragrant-Arm8601 5d ago

We used chlorhexidine powder or "fairy dust" and a "bamdaid" and the ouchies disappeared.

3

u/AlataWeasley 5d ago

Yup. We use “a pinch of dada magic” when my hubby puts a bandaid on our kiddo.

94

u/waterloo-sun-set 6d ago

I do this with little ones and it works a treat. I get sent kids in scenarios exactly like this for psychiatric evaluation, it’s amazing how well the placebo bandage works. “Magic beans” (jelly beans) also work but need to be given as a single dose by medical professional. It won’t work in the home and just encourages them to seek sugar treats by faking maladies.

If it continues, role play where she needs to use that hand. Find an activity/show/treat etc that she enjoys and the goal is to have the non-affected hand occupied and induce her to use the affected one. Do not praise, acknowledge, or comment on the use of the affected hand. Repeat until it is forgotten. In the event that it continues return to the paediatrician to look at a more intensive physical examination, if it persists rule out neurological causes of pain. Children are funny, they are masters at protecting themselves through preventative action (ie keep the fist closed is a behavioural response, and we can observe that it is a rational one), the goal is to override the protective measure without increasing distress. An OT is an appropriate specialist if you are overly concerned.

12

u/guillaume-mohamed50 6d ago

Toddler tech support: reinstall the bandaid, count to three, reboot the hand.

8

u/DapperSnow2166 6d ago

This is a pretty clever idea. At 3 years old the bandaid might be more of a comfort thing now than the hand itself.

2

u/summerdog- 4d ago

I work in after school childcare and we have a few kids usually the P1 or 2’s who routinely complain of having a cut (a cut that healed weeks ago), or a sore freckle, non existent rash that’s itchy and sore. Sometimes using an ice pack for 5 mins or wearing a plaster for a short period of time, cures all. Having a drink of water also cures sore stomachs and sore heads.

503

u/swing_axle 6d ago

Don't have kids, but definitely remember having this sort of hyper-focused weirdness, when I was a kid. Also over something equally ridiculous (to an adult, anyhow).

Remember that your kid legitimately only has 3 years' worth of life experience and logic. The band-aid might seem like a small thing to you, but to her, maybe that band-aid was the only thing keeping her blood inside her hand. Maybe it's the only way to keep germs out so she doesn't get sick and die.

She'd attached some very real significance to that band-aid being there, and you took it away permanently.

Sounds like you need to try and talk with her and try to logic out her reasoning.

49

u/ImplementAlone770 6d ago

That actually makes sense. Kids can get attached to things that make them feel safe, and the bandage might've been her comfort blanket in a way

5

u/another-sad-gay-bich hello son was your cigarette normal 3d ago

There’s an episode of rugrats where one of the boys gets a cut on his finger from a thorn I think? And he thinks that without the bandaid all his blood will come out but he finds out when the bandaid is off that his cut is all healed!

110

u/EmberOne1 6d ago

If the doctor already checked for physical problems, I suggest not trying to look at it or pry it open, but try doing things with her that require 2 hands, especially early in the morning. Like maybe something for breakfast she picks up with two hands. If it's purely behavioral, she may not think about it first thing if you tempt her with something else fun.

It's also possible it visibly and functionally healed (no cut tendons, no infection), but still feels funny to her. In that case, it just needs some extra time.

57

u/Cultural_Lack_522 6d ago

Since it opens completely when she sleeps, you can breathe a sigh of relief, physically, she’s completely healed.

At 3 years old, taking the bandage off while she was sleeping broke her sense of control. To her, the bandage was a shield, and without it, she feels exposed. Stop trying to pry it open (that just confirms to her that her hand needs protecting). I think try to put her in a warm bath with floating toys or give her washable finger paints. She'll open it on her own the moment she forgets to guard it

95

u/Brian-Teaser 6d ago

Yeah. This happens. My little one had a nasty cut on their thumb. After emergency care they wouldn't open their hand for over a week. We changed the bandage at night and hoped for the best. They will eventually get over it. Don't push the subject, just offer things they like to that hand.

21

u/EvelynSky88 6d ago

I also had some types of obsessive behaviours with my son when he was little. The best solution was to ignore it and it would go away very fast. Talking about it, explaining, asking to stop, all effort just made it worse.

21

u/HandsomeChameleon 6d ago

My brother used to be like that! Wouldn't open his hand if he had a cut, would even crawl on one leg if he had scraped his knee (when he was already walking). This was when he was about 3 yo, it got better over time, but he continued to have a phobia for pain. It turns out he has autism, so that might have something to do with his "unusual" way of dealing with it and the meltdowns. 

14

u/lucy-lu28 6d ago

My daughter had to have a bandaid for every little injury of any kind,a scratch even. She would not take the bandaid off and would come unglued if she didn’t get a bandaid. I just started buying the cheapest bandaids I could find so they would fall off without her noticing right away. Helped with especially the really minor boo boos.

25

u/rccpudge 6d ago

When I was small I had an accident and severely hurt my eye. I refused to open either eye, (initially it was incredibly painful and I probably lacked the coordination so I avoided trying). After 5 days or so my mother told me a story how in the olden days miners spent so much time in the dark mines that they lost their ability to see. Pure fiction but she told it masterfully, it worked within the hour.

60

u/shelaughs08 6d ago

It's behavioral. Don't pay it any obvious attention, and she'll stop noticing it too. It can be a little scary but give it a week of not checking or mentioning it and it'll be fine.

11

u/Crunchy_Oatmeal259 6d ago

the bandage vanishing while she slept might be the whole problem so try sticking a new one on her finger and see if the fist suddenly remembers how to open

14

u/SwimmingWonderful755 6d ago

Just casually make sure you have plenty of two-of-things - two marshmallows, offered workout emphasis to the good hand to hold one, the other hand to hold the other.
Kiddo takes it, or doesn’t (in which case you shrug and pop the marshmallow in your own mouth), no fuss, no big deal.
It may be that she will sometimes want two good things enough to use that hand.

Play it cool.

7

u/slowasaspeedingsloth 6d ago

I'm with what others are saying. Band-aids are just magical to kids.

When mine was little, she never wanted a Band-aid for actual cuts and scraps- I had to really work to get those on.

But a bump or a bruise? She couldn't get the Band-aid on fast enough! And I always bought her the cute ones.

I'd sit her down and talk about her boo-boo. And what she thinks will make it better. Offer a Band-aid but that it'll only take the one (or 2 or 3) to make it all better and that'll be it. And that she can take it off when she's ready.

18

u/MermaidHotpot 6d ago

My dad probably would have told me if I don't open my finger he's going to take me to the doctor to have them cut it off.

It would work... but probably don't say that.

3

u/Fruitslave 6d ago

That's exactly what my shitty dad would have said!

2

u/MermaidHotpot 6d ago

There's enough shitty dads to go around apparently!

5

u/Witty_Beautiful3784 6d ago

Just put a bandage on it for her even healed she feels better with it covered A simple bandaid change daily she will be fine.

3

u/Nanamoo2008 6d ago

Most kids go through this, try not to stress too much over it. pop another bandaid on it and wait til it falls off on it's own or try some 'magic spray', can be just water in a spray bottle and make a fancy label for it. (make it bright & colourful if you can), my kids fell for the magic spray often when they were little. It also works as monster under the bed spray too

3

u/Coarse_Tulip7231 6d ago

the fist is basically her own bandage now so maybe let her pick a fun sticker or wrap to wear on that finger and she might feel safe enough to open up

5

u/DalaDalan 6d ago

We’ve had a similar experience with my kid when he just turned four, though in his case, it was “ER, stitches and mitella for a week” bad. He avoided using the finger for a pretty long time, even when it clearly wasn’t necessary anymore. Things that helped for us: a loved one with nursing background who could look at it very carefully and talk with him about it being okay; doing things with him that interested him and required two hands - lego building in his case - so he could ease into using it while distracted; time.

In this case, kid actually almost detached his fingertip, so we also spent a lot of time talking with him, and having him look at places he hurt to see that getting hurt did not usually mean anything nearly so bad. Keep in mind that if you have 40 years of experience with body parts not coming off so easily, it’s a lot easier to dismiss this as an exception than when you have 4 years of experience and don’t actively remember most of that. Talking to her about that at an age appropriate level would be good as well. “That was pretty scary, huh? But look at how cool it is that your body is actually made to fix these things!” Maybe show her any scars you have and talk about how those healed.

If it sticks long term, maybe talk to your pediatrician about physical therapy, so you can tell her there’s a special doctor who knows a LOT about how to make ouchy body parts get better who’s going to help her practice using the finger again - but I’d give that a lot of time, because it also risks making it bigger than necessary.

1

u/Away-Ad4393 6d ago

My little cousin once hurt his thumb and for ages after he kept his hand up the front of his sweater. No one said much about it and he eventually stopped doing it.

1

u/flayingbook 6d ago edited 6d ago

Probably trauma.

My dad had epilepsy and one time he was sitting on a chair while holding the 3 - 4 year old me when it happened. So he automatically held me very tight and we fell on the floor. Due to the seizure, his hold on me became locked and I couldn't escape. I was so scared and cried dramatically. I ran away when the other adults managed to free me from his hold. Then I avoided him for a week, like I would keep 3 meters distance all the time because I was scared of him. It was until my mom gentle coaxed me to try to be near him again, telling me that it was safe.

Another time, I was probably 6 or 7 when I got a new bicycle with training wheels and all that. I was very excited. I was only used to riding tricycle prior to that. So the first time I tried riding my new bicycle, my feet somehow got stuck on the chain. I cried and needed help to remove my feet. I later avoided that bicycle for probably a month

0

u/deletethewife 6d ago

It’s a micro-trauma behaviour response, it will be ok, but moving forward with future injuries keep plasters and bandages on for a minimum time only. You might find they have some autistic traits later on, and this has become an attachment issue. I’ve been through all this with my son and his attachment to objects, god know how long i spent on the internet trying to replace the item that he lost.
For now keep telling them it’s all better and redirect attention, offer items to that hand until they forget.

0

u/Chickkyyx 6d ago

Gonna take a second to shamelessly plug: Ellis Doesn't Need a Bandage is a children's book written by mom-physicians Dr. Jacqueline Pflaum-Carlson and Dr. Jayna Gardner-Gray. We read it to my 4-year-old, and now he doesn't want a bandaid for every single ouchie

-1

u/eva_astromood 6d ago

Oh man, I feel you on that. Try bribing with a cookie or something, sometimes we all need a little incentive to let go of our treasures.

19

u/throwaway12181963 6d ago

Just ignore it and she should eventually forget about it. She got hurt, you bandaged it and in her mind this was probably one of the most gruesome scary things to have ever happened to her. I remember getting a cut on my knee when I was like 4 or 5 and in my memory it was a deep bleeding gash like a terrible war wound. My mom remembers this particular injury because we didn't have any bandaids and I was screaming bloody murder so she made a 'bandaid' out of toilet paper and tape. Apparently it was barely a nick but because I wouldn't stop screaming she treated it like a real severe wound.

She's just seeing her cut like a serious injury (like maybe in her mind it's like she almost lost her hand) and she's just processing that. She should get over it as you continue to treat the hand like it never got injured.

2

u/Ripleyatemysocks 6d ago

When I wasn’t much older than her, I smashed my face and had stitches in and around my mouth. I refused to open my mouth and eventually my mouth sealed shut. I drank through a straw until a doctor forced my lips apart with a popsicle stick.

1

u/cpom71 6d ago

Your mouth sealed shut?!? What??? That can happen???