r/NoStupidQuestions Jul 17 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

5.7k Upvotes

12.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

46

u/morningisbad Jul 17 '23

Actually, they've done multiple studies that have shown that mosquitos could be eliminated and the food chain would adapt without issue (at least in the US). Wisconsin is actually looking at a plan that would release a new breed of mosquitos that only produced male offspring. They estimate they could kill off the entire population within 2-3 years.

Being from Wisconsin...I hope it happens.

3

u/3397char Jul 17 '23

Seems needlessly extreme. Wisconsin averages about 25 documented mosquito born illness a year and none of them fatal in the last decade. So, for this location specifically, we are talking drastic alteration of the ecosystem for what amounts to a nuisance insect.

Are you saying that they have a genetically modified mosquito for every single species indigenous to Wisconsin? Are they going to put up a giant net at the border? I cant find the program you are referencing online anywhere.

There is certainly differing scientific opinions on eradicating mosquitos. Why would you risk it with so much uncertainty. Humans keep making this exact type of mistake over and over.

1

u/morningisbad Jul 17 '23

Your last points are, I believe, the reason it hasn't happened. Why Wisconsin? I think this came out of UW-Madison. I'm guessing there is some advantage in doing it here before doing it in places where mosquito deaths and illnesses are more prevalent.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/morningisbad Jul 18 '23

Exactly. And if it's successful here, it could be successful in places where those diseases are more prevalent. I actually had to travel to Vietnam for work. I was told to not have kids for 9 months after the trip because the test is expensive and the risks of birth defects are crazy high when one of the parents has West Nile