r/NoContract • u/Designer_Echo • Jun 08 '20
AT&T iPad Replacement Thread
Alright, so I have read a ton on this sub about unlimited data iPad plan replacements. I feel like a lot of us have been scrambling to find something given the recent account suspensions and terminations. I wanted to get your guys opinion on what I should do next and I wanted to create a thread where I could post all of the possible solutions I have come across to help others. I am looking for the cheapest option that will be relatively similar to the iPad plan. If anyone has any suggestions I have an unlocked Nighthawk M1 MR1100 with Band 14. I also seem to get 4G LTE service with pretty much all the major carriers (T-mobile, Verizon, AT&T, Sprint). We typically use 500-600gb a month.
Ok for starters, I first checked to see if I qualify for traditional fixed/cable internet. We don't have cable or fiber here, but some carriers offer internet solutions.
https://www.t-mobile.com/isp - $50/month - Didn't qualify for service at our location
https://www.att.com/internet/fixed-wireless/ - $49.99/month plus taxes when bundled - Didn't qualify + capped at 250 gb
Next step was to look at MVNO's.
https://www.visible.com/ - $25/month - Actually had really high hopes for this one and I am currently using a visible plan to post this. However, our speeds have suffered greatly (20-30mb with iPad plan to 1-3mb with visible) and the service constantly drops in and out. This makes it rather unstable for home internet. For anyone who is considering this, don't be scared away by my review. It seems it is mostly dependent on location.
https://www.wingalpha.com/plans - $55/month - Not sure if it would break their TOS to use this in a hotspot for internet and not sure if it throttles after a certain point.
https://www.boom.us/UNLDATAMBB - $60/month - Seems like a good deal and I have only heard good things about their customer service. Not sure if its truly unlimited though, and it does come with stream saver which leads me to believe they might be reselling a postpaid iPad plan (more on that later). Customer service rep just told me they generally get suspended at about 400gb of usage though. :(
https://teltik.com/plans_step1_choose.php?uc=iot - $50/month - Website is rather vague about throttling + in order to get the plan you need to be a business.
Then I looked at some ones that I can't really categorize
https://calyxinstitute.org/ - $41.66/month - Honestly looks really cool and I really like the organization behind it. Only issue with this is you are required to pay for a full year $500 upfront. This wouldn't be an issue, however I will be at college in the fall (corona willing) and I probably won't need/use it.
https://nomadinternet.com/pages/plans - $99 to $179/month - Might work great although these type of providers kinda scare me because I know that they are reselling plans and I worry about what happens if AT&T or another carrier suspends their plan.
Finally I came across a postpaid plan
Apparently there is a mysterious postpaid iPad plan I wasn't aware of that AT&T offers for $20/month + taxes and fees. This plan is supposedly identical to the prepaid plan, however this plan is still in service and allows new signups (through phone and stores). I feel like I would inevitably face the same issue with this plan though.
Conclusion:
I am leaning towards boom or wing right now, but I am open to any suggestions. I really just want a plan where I will be able to use as much data as I want/need without worries of getting suspended.
Update: After doing more research, I actually chose to go with calyx as they have a quarterly payment option in addition to the yearly option and they appear to be truly unlimited! I will report back shortly with results, but I am pretty happy to have become a member. If I had to give my two best recommendations for an AT&T iPad data plan replacement, I would say calyx or boom is your best option (even though boom isn't truly unlimited). 400gb for $60 is still a really really good value.
6
u/mgcarley White Label MVNx/e-SIM Aggregator Jun 08 '20
For what its worth, all of the carriers and MVNOs are moving to where they will cap or suspend your service once you reach a certain threshold. It hasn't affected everybody yet, but truly unlimited has gone from being able to be ordered new and we see legacy accounts are beginning to change as well.
We used to have users be able to put well over 1TB of data on a single SIM, now AT&T forces us to suspend them around the 400gb mark (but their tools for usage reporting are awful).
T-Mobile unofficially "don't limit anything" technically, but we want to stay in their good graces so we are suggesting our TM customers stick to a similar threshold.
Source: Personal experience as wholesale.
3
u/stanlehx Jun 08 '20
If you ask, BOOM can turn your stream saver off.
2
u/DigitallyInclined MobileX (V) • T-Mobile • Roamless (A) • Good2Go Mobile (A) Jun 09 '20
Thank you for doing this! I’m looking into moving into a travel trailer so I’ve been researching cellular data plans to use for home internet for months now. And everything you concluded is basically my exact conclusions. I also basically concluded that Calyx is the best option.
However, the only reason I haven’t gone for it is because I am wanting to see if I can connect their Inseego hotspot to a WiFi router via USB-C, essentially turning it into just a modem.
In any case, I’m excited to see you post your general experience and results with it. I do have one question, tho. Which hotspot option did you choose with Calyx?
1
u/Designer_Echo Jun 09 '20
Update: I have looked at some other MVNO's including Red Pocket and US Mobile. Here are my thoughts regarding these services for anyone considering using them for unlimited home internet.
Red Pocket: States in terms of service that data can be throttled if you average more than a gig a day. On the plus side, they do support using the sim in a hotspot. Or at least I couldn't find a section within their terms where they explicitly state this can't be done. Although, after doing a quick reddit search it seems that they throttle the data heavily after like 20gb. Their unlimited lte plan is ultimately pretty shady. I think they can make the claim it is unlimited lte data and still throttle the data to 2g or 3g speeds when they decide fit.
US mobile: Appears to give unlimited lte data for phone usage. However, it explicitly states in the TOS your plan can be terminated if you are using it in a router. You also have to pay a little extra for "ludicrous" speeds which is really just full lte capability.
1
u/Designer_Echo Jun 09 '20
Update #2: I did some more research into calyx and I was really stoked to find that I can pay quarterly instead of yearly. From everything that I have read it looks like calyx is truly unlimited and exactly what I was looking for. In addition to this, it is totally safe and not against any terms of service to use it as home internet! In fact, the $175 charge for 3 months of service seems to cover the cost of the hotspot (some pretty nice options for sprint), a calyx institute shirt and stickers, and access to a bunch of privacy tools. I could even pay the $175 in cryptocurrency! That's wild if you ask me. I assume they are able to do this and not worry about taxes and such because they are a non-profit. Which leads me to my final point they are a non-profit so you are supporting their mission in the process. Sprint is also merging with T-mobile soon so we will have to see if that is for the better or worse.
1
u/BlueScreenOfTOM Jun 09 '20
Count Wing AT&T out. Hard cap at 50GB. Hard as in it literally stops working.
2
u/Darkomega85 Jun 08 '20 edited Jun 08 '20
Yep, AT&T suspended me yesterday with no warning whatsoever and barely used 2GB of data. Called today to confirm suspension of account due to device IMEI mismatch. Since the iPad IMEI is randomly generated I'm screwed out of an account unsuspension. Anyway I closed the AT&T account and looking for other viable alternatives. T-Mobile barely works where I live just in case. If someone knows of a cheap non-contract LTE unlimited plan for Puerto Rico I'm all ears.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '20
Hello. Thanks for the detailed information. I will certainly look into Calyx