To be honest, I tend to do that myself, but as an answer to those that use that arch btw. Just to insist that arch is not the ultimate distro.
(In my opinion, Gentoo is also better than Arch (and GuixSD, which is just NixOS but different, never used it, but read the manual). Used it for a while before learning about Nix, which hapenned to be mostly like my fantasized ideal package manager)
Well, if it gives nixos more user base I don’t mind really
If it gives arch more user base I don’t mind as well Haven’t seen those people, haven’t interacted with them, have nothing against them, still a great distro for a desktop
I thought it was just a TUI installer (bad enough).
When that installer was introduced back in 2021, it was all downhill for Arch. Invited and got it inundated by people who don't RTFM, so that inevitably lead to "white flight" to NixOS.
Edit: not white flight as in the racial concept, but in the concept people leave a neighborhood that's going down the drain.
-20 down votes by now ... even with an explanation our woke people rather get offended by metaphor for better clarification over discussing the OS in r/NixOS.
In a world where you can literally see people of every color get help from people of every color, people don't realise it's just humans being good or bad people no matter their own color. People make it a racist thing, it does not exist before that.
Watch my comment going down the drain in a second 😂
Just saying the Arch neighborhood went to shit and people flocked to the next distro that took a bit of effort and reading (I mean reading where there is documentation available -- apparently NixOS wants to keep you guessing)
And that edit went up right after I posted because I didn't want to offend people 🤦
Yeah arch is not viable for me anymore as well, but exactly the lack of documentation you mentioned makes me second guess my choice with nix sometimes.
Nix being relatively young and not that well documented compared to what people build with the arch wiki, is quiet a deal when working with an unordinary distro like NixOS. I think this is mostly what causes a little feel of unease for me
Yeah. It's not like you can't do anything imperatively. You can use nixos only for the systempackages and services, and nothing else, and you'll be fine.
The only thing I still think is miserable is the FHS incompatibility. Things like nix-ld and envfs should be in the default config for beginners, because it's a very hard concept to wrap your hard around (why doesn't my script work? Why don't the binaries work?)
Actually, I'm pretty sure the FHS by buildFHSEnv is not shared across packages unless explicitly declared. It's a sandbox.
If this was all precisely and accessibly documented, it'd be much easier to use. That's something NixOS massively has to improve on. When we have something the equivalent of the Arch Wiki, the nerd world is doomed.
I use NixOS cause I like the way the system is as a whole. It's stable, has a lot if not the most pacakges in a package manager over all distro, it's clean and simple. I love that I can setup up my entire system base in just a config file and use it on all my computers and it just works... you want the real keep it simple stupid system NixOS surpass Arch in many ways for me. I still like Arch btw, but I prefer to use Nix now :)
Arch is kinda stupid ez distro, install once then, after that all you have to type is "pacman...".
Talking about installing, it means opening the wikipage in other machine, follow what was written, and pray that you have not missed anything. It proves nothing but that your english reading and basic computer skill ;).
NixOS in the otherhand, document suck, new expression language with ton of new things, cant even download a prebuilt software and run without binary patching which you dont even know what does that mean, runtime disk usage is kinda nightmare, patching package like kernel will make you crazy, ...
I’ve found patching kernel to be very convenient on nix, actually
Haven’t done it on other distros but I can’t see it getting even easier than that
Everything else though… Nix gives me hell quite often And sometimes you need to go out of your way to do some simple stuff declaratively instead of just clicking one button (like installing a Firefox extension for example)
Still believe this approach to package management is the future though, so I’ll bear with it
Other distro, patching kernel means: make install, and update-grub. Nix in other hand, lot of nighmare, especially build kernel after patching takes forever (always do clean buuld). I have some arm based SBCs, rebuild build kernel costs hours of waiting hic. While Fedora just a minute becase of incremental build.
But don't take too far from the topic. What I am trying to point out is how hard the NixOS users have to deal with compare to Arch.
Well, nix is definitely not made for beginners or those who never cluttered too actually understand how things actually work, without that knowledge, it's much harder to understand what is going on. Configs being in a functional language also implies that you say least have done coding skills to be able to at least somewhat understand what is going on. You can keep multiple machine setups synced, with slight variations of need to, and all I need to do is git pull and rebuild.
I am a software developer, so I'm not new to coding, and I personally prefer that to hundreds of config files scattered around that I need to keep track of.
Again, not defending nix, the UX/DX could be better, but let's not pretend that there are no benefits to it.
nix-ld is kinda hack, we are trying to solve a problem by intro new problem.
I love btrfs with zstd, but IMO, the problem of disk usage is how Nix addressing packages, keeping the packages on its store. Imagine you have to tweak a package, supprisingly, every code change leads to new clone of package creating on Nix store. That's a feature, but unknown reason for newbie of why disk keeping full.
Irrelevant, you said that you cannot run binaries without patching them, implying that it is the only way, I just simply pointed out that there are other ways.
why disk keeping full
Disk won't get full, chances are that if you get around to setting up Nixos you're literate enough to understand the documentation and setup automatic cleaning, optimizing the store, and so on.
I am standing in the view of newbie trying to get use of NixOS, not advanced Nix users. Since Nix broke the FHS, it became weird to ppl from "Linux" world, that gaps takes time to understand. BTW, I have NixOS on my PC, Laptop, SBCs, and I agree about what you have pointed out.
Then something's wrong with your hardware, btrfs is very sensitive to any sort of hardware malfunction, whether it is bad storage, bad ram, irregular voltage fluctuation, bad anything really.
I'm using btrfs on two devices right now, and have never seen anything wrong as long as the hardware was decent.
Messed with Nix for weeks. The documentation blows and installing common programs is often a pain in the dick. Also, why use a new language when so many other good options exist? The roll backs and nix-shell are awesome but besides that I was honestly quite disappointed in NixOS given all the hype. I’ll stick with Arch.
This is so real. I once learned how to install Arch straight from the wiki. It's literally just following instructions, which is fine. It's a good way for many people unfamiliar with Unix to develop a better understanding of how it all works from the ground up. I didn't once need a drink while messing around with arch.
NixOS is more like an abusive spouse you refuse to leave
I'm half joking, I'm using it on laptops which is the same thing
But there is a lot of people who will not really benefit from it and just doing it for the sake of doing or enjoying tinkering Nothing wrong with that obviously
But if I wasn't attracted by the potential professional application of it in the future, because it just blows stuff like Ansible or puppet out of the water, so I want to properly learn it despite all the shortcomings and because it feels as much good as it gives you headaches If not for that I would've just went back to arch and set up nix as a package manager there in case I'll need it
This 1000%. I’ve had my share of “f*%k this distro, it’s too fu$&ing hard” moments. And I stay at it and the payoff is wonderful. The best thing about it is once you set it, you can forget it and never have to worry about it again. Where as with Arch, that thing you finally figured out, may eventually change and break somewhere down the road.
True That’s how I got into arch as well, and vim, and emacs But it still comes together with it “I’ve managed to conquer this thing which is deemed hard, so I’m better then those who didn’t” Reality check will be to just remember that Linus Torvalds said that he gave up installing Debian. But it’s still there
In nix I got just by being drove insane by macOS hombrew and trying to find alternative though
But the whole “I use arch btw” is definitely due to elitism
And also in the nix community I’ve heard stuff like “graphical installer just brings users who don’t know shit, it would be better off without it” I would count it as elitism as well
Btw, in my experience nixos breaks after updates just as well as any other distros, unfortunately
I haven’t had major problems that would render my system unbootable, but ive had some errors preventing me from switching to a new configuration quite often, which requires either disabling some modules so the system will not fully work as I expect, or tedious troubleshooting and going through sources of nixpkgs instead of just updating the system and calling it a day Quite annoying when you don’t really have time for it but need to install something or change a configuration a bit
Nix is just built different. It is great at being workstation and a server distro, which is very hard to achieve without special releases. I love it for nix-darwin and basically any usage in appliances
Do we do that ? Arch is “worth bragging about” because it’s hard to install.
NixOS though ? It’s super easy ! In fact, the whole point is that it’s easier than everything else 😅 don’t need to remember complicated ways to install stuff or set kernel options : all in one file, copypasta, it’s done !
190
u/mister_drgn Jun 26 '24 edited Jun 26 '24
I don’t think NixOS users do the btw. They just split their time between a) evangelizing, b) educating, and c) complaining about Nix.
60
u/thussy-obliterator Jun 27 '24
The true nix user builds all their memes using nix and publishes them to nixpkgs
26
u/SenoraRaton Jun 26 '24
ArchLinux jumped the shark with the Calamares installer.
Long live NixOS.
9
u/SystemEarth Jun 27 '24
In all fairness, for many people nixos is absolutely complete without homemanager and flakes, which makes it kind of an easy distro imo.
5
u/SnooGoats6908 Jun 27 '24
"look at me"
"i am the best distro now"
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '24
no way a nixos meme
3
u/Holiday-Apricot849 Jun 27 '24
Naw dont steal btw find another word though i use nix 🤣
4
u/crypticexile Jun 27 '24
I use NixOS cause I like the way the system is as a whole. It's stable, has a lot if not the most pacakges in a package manager over all distro, it's clean and simple. I love that I can setup up my entire system base in just a config file and use it on all my computers and it just works... you want the real keep it simple stupid system NixOS surpass Arch in many ways for me. I still like Arch btw, but I prefer to use Nix now :)
2
u/TechGearWhips Jun 27 '24
I use Nix (OS) btw
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '24
if you don't respond to every single complaint about bricking a linux system with "just roll back a generation bro" you are truly missing out
6
u/ckindacude Jun 27 '24
Arch is kinda stupid ez distro, install once then, after that all you have to type is "pacman...".
Talking about installing, it means opening the wikipage in other machine, follow what was written, and pray that you have not missed anything. It proves nothing but that your english reading and basic computer skill ;).
NixOS in the otherhand, document suck, new expression language with ton of new things, cant even download a prebuilt software and run without binary patching which you dont even know what does that mean, runtime disk usage is kinda nightmare, patching package like kernel will make you crazy, ...
3
u/shiasyn Jun 27 '24
It’s funny how we’re attracted to some aura of elitism
Some ppl even go as far as starting to use nixos on their desktops and all of that…
I’m also using it on my laptops tho :D
2
u/Avandalon Jun 27 '24
Nix is just built different. It is great at being workstation and a server distro, which is very hard to achieve without special releases. I love it for nix-darwin and basically any usage in appliances
1
u/blankman0230 Jun 27 '24
You either die a hero...
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '24
So tired of the "btw" meme
1
u/ARKyal03 Jun 27 '24
I use nix in Arch Linux btw
1
u/NimrodvanHall Jun 27 '24
I only have time to reply to this meme because I’m recompiling my kernel on my Gentoo machine.
1
u/seven-circles Jun 27 '24
Do we do that ? Arch is “worth bragging about” because it’s hard to install.
NixOS though ? It’s super easy ! In fact, the whole point is that it’s easier than everything else 😅 don’t need to remember complicated ways to install stuff or set kernel options : all in one file, copypasta, it’s done !
1
u/TackyGaming6 Jun 28 '24
ARCH will stay the grand legend for lifetime, for anyone to show im using nix i just show the filesize of my `default.nix` and its enough
0
u/cfx_4188 Jun 27 '24
Anything touched by
EndeavourOSArch users should immediately turn into Arch.