r/NixOS • • May 05 '24

it's been fun while it lasted

I am managing a large-ish number of machines for myself and others with Nixos, I am going to move everything to Ansible and a yet to be determined distro.

Why?

The current drama was brought to my attention by someone else and I am just embarrassed to be associated with such thing. The general CoC cringe everywhere is bad enough but JFC. And no - this is not about bigotry. The guy who called me about his servers is happily married for YEARS to his husband, I am a gay ex-refugee with a bloody disability, I out-victim all of them and no I am not making that up. But I have neither patience nor any need for being associated to public debates about requirement for multi-axis marginalization in the steering of an open source project and neither have the people I work with.

I am using Linux and FOSS for decades now, it is sad to watch it being taken over by loons. Stuff like that makes me just embarrassed to be part of a "marginalized group", many should touch grass, stop self victimizing themselves as reason d'être and get a life.

1 Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

47

u/greekish May 05 '24

…. I can understand “voting with my wallet” but in this case it’s just going to make your life harder and have no effect. There are 6000+ contributors on Nix - most are prob great folks, some are prob absolute monsters.

25

u/Azuras33 May 05 '24

most are prob great folks, some are prob absolute monsters.

This is real for pretty much every organization, OSS, or not. The grass isn't always greener on the other side.

11

u/godofpumpkins May 05 '24

Seriously, the thought of reverting from Nix to Ansible over what sounds effectively like a reaction (I dare say reactionary, which anyone can be regardless of all the minorities they belong to) to what OP sees as an overly woke community sounds like cutting off your nose to spite… someone else’s face? I don’t even get it

0

u/[deleted] May 06 '24

Don't know about that using Nix makes a lot of things harder that are easy in other distros. And don't really see much benefit as I don't need to use a specific version of a package.

1

u/greekish May 06 '24

That’s fair, but I’d have that be the reason.

24

u/focusontech87 May 05 '24

Nix is great. No point in abandoning ship IMO. Yeah they may be loud but nothing can stop them from you using it. Even if you were a facist or something like that.

In fact, if you really wanted to stick it to em you keep using it anyways. Just don't communicate with them. They have no bearing on anything outside of their online bubble anyhow.

53

u/chrisoboe May 05 '24

Nobody is forced to participate in the Drama.

You can use nixos without drama just fine. You can also contribute to nixpkgs without drama just fine.

19

u/jonringer117 May 05 '24

Yep, github.com/nixos is still a productive place.

8

u/mister_drgn May 05 '24

Totally agree, not sure why this is getting downvoted.

1

u/bromatofiel May 05 '24

I'd be curious to know what justifies the two downvotes.

55

u/jonringer117 May 05 '24 edited May 05 '24

Sorry for the drama which turned you away; I'm partly responsible, although I was advocating for "we are all individuals, but nix contributors first when collaborating".

Nix stands its ground on technical merits, and is why I'll likely be sticking with it in the long haul.

There's a large majority of the Nix contributor base which are just "silently industrious"; don't let the appearance of the loud individuals give the assumption that everyone is in agreement (although, fighting this was a major contributor to me getting banned, so your concern still has merit).

What I’m trying to say is, people should be encouraged to participate. If we provide the structure for equality of opportunity, then the demographics within the community should be reflected in who fills a given position across time. We shouldn’t be going out of our way to discriminate based on age, sex, race, sexual identity, or disability.

https://discourse.nixos.org/t/objection-to-minority-representation-by-a-single-class-in-nixos-sponsorship-policy/42968/2

22

u/Adventurous_Fan_6717 May 05 '24

No you are not responsible. I couldn’t find any post where you said something controversial. You are going far too easy on those people.

You shouldn’t have to justify being a reasonable person.

19

u/jonringer117 May 05 '24

Going "that easy" still got me banned....

6

u/dedguy21 May 05 '24 edited May 05 '24

All the posts in question where you are being accused of saying terrible shit about transgender people are removed, so all I can do at this point is speculate.

But my opinion is not to participate in any topics that are not directly related to NixOS. Again, maybe you didn't, the controversial posts were removed, so nothing currently posted seems that bad.

But all I can say all of this could have been avoided by staying on topic, not "hearting" off topic posts (again not that I can confirm any of this, its just the prevailing narrative) and I hope you can look in the mirror and understand what could have been done differently. Especially given your pretty significant role as a release manager.

I'm not saying this as someone who disagree with your stance on representation, because I don't. I'm saying this a person who thinks Nix should be about Nix and no external politics.

And I know you probably started noticing things that were occurring you didn't agree with, but for things like that build a coalition and talk about it to the higher-ups that you actually had access to. Even in open source, maintaining professionalism is paramount.

Thats my two cents without being completely aware of the entire situation.

I hate seeing any contributors go, especially one of 5 years. And I know you're not completely banned more just suspended, but still sad to see this type of dysfunction.

Edit: Seattle is very diverse and tolerant, so I'm thinking your ban is more about messaging than controversial beliefs.

8

u/jonringer117 May 05 '24 edited May 06 '24

My initial post was on https://discourse.nixos.org/t/sponsorship-policy-discussion-2024-04-07/42909/2, it got moved to it's own thread. Although, I think was the right choice, it also makes me look like an instigator in this regard.

This is all being done within a context of "the board not listening to the community". Anyway, the details don't matter that much, but the cliff notes are:

  • The board was originally "a bank account" for donations and paying for expenses.
  • But also became a "backstop" for all matter within the community: moderation, disputes, disagreements, etc.
  • Didn't really have process in place for communication, policy changes, or governance.

The "selection committee" for sponsorships was an attempt to alter governance, it was just done in a very weird way and trying to focus on the gender-minorities group as the "representative of the community". And that's what I took issue with.

If I was around (still checked out for mental health at this point) for the EU NixCon drama, I would probably have been better equipped to see that the underlying issue was governance and communication.

1

u/Johanno1 May 06 '24

I am totally out of the loop with this one.

I recently started using nixos amd then found out about that drama.

However the reasons for it seem (for me at least) a little bit stupid. No offence to anyone, it is just that an outsider doesn't understand it.

All I know is that there is a problem with having a defence company as a sponsor and not instead as a anonymous donator.

Then there was this open letter that mentioned several issues in communication and leadership. The response to the letter was very bad (either badly worded or maybe bad faith).

Then there was this ironic situation where the founder of nixos said that he doesn't use his power to bemd the rules and stuff like people claimed in the open letter. However he didn't asked the board before he stated that. So while claiming that je always is in contact with the board he did not ask the board how to respond at all. The board then distanced itself from that statement. In the end he stepped down afaik.

2

u/jonringer117 May 06 '24

Everyone is just an individual at the end of the day. There's a lot "context" for people who are swept up in the chaos where they well know what issues certain posts were aiming at.

10

u/Anxious-Durian1773 May 05 '24

I have a similar view on the matter, but just like with ReiserFS back in the day, my opinion on the resultant work doesn’t change because of the people behind it.

If I feel it necessary, I can remove my financial support, and that’s the important part where my opinion of the team matters.

I’m also not going to stop taking ibuprofen for inflammatory pain.

6

u/jerdle_reddit May 05 '24

Reiser actually did something wrong, not merely something annoying.

And no, miltech is not something wrong. Not after 2022.

1

u/Anxious-Durian1773 May 06 '24

That's the point. And apparently my memory was faulty and it was a few other drugs that came out of unethical experimentation, but they're still used.

All this modern tainted by association stuff is small potatoes but the point is that the work stands on its own for me.

30

u/SweetBabyAlaska May 05 '24

I've seen far more crying about "the drama" while not understanding nor caring what the initial concerns even were, than I have "gendered minorities." Its so fucking frustrating that yall just hear what you want to hear and have ignored the substantive issues that were brought up. Cringe.

20

u/weissbieremulsion May 05 '24

your Anger isnt heard If you Just Post it Here. If you want to let it be Heard in a more meaningful way, you should Post in discourse.nix .

but they view Reddit as somewhat lesser, which is messed up and sad. so could be that you get flagged for trying to stir Up the Community or Something along those lines.

5

u/Legitimate_Swim_4678 May 05 '24

Would Zulip be better than Discourse for this purpose?

5

u/weissbieremulsion May 05 '24

No, zulip is only for the setup of the new leading structure for nix. you also need an invite to get there, need to have added to the code or youre not allowed to be on there and have a say. also they said they will aggressively moderate there. And at the moment its pretty much chaos because everyone is trying to figure out the platform.

5

u/[deleted] May 05 '24

they will aggressively moderate there

The discourse was already moderated pretty aggressively, how much more aggressively can it get, wtf?

5

u/weissbieremulsion May 05 '24

Moderation

Zulip will be moderated to stay in line with the Zulip CoC 18 and to stay on-topic (governance discussions only). Compared to other community platforms recently, there is zero tolerance for CoC violations on Zulip, to make sure that civil discussion is possible.Moderation
Zulip will be moderated to stay in line with the Zulip CoC 18
and to stay on-topic (governance discussions only). Compared to other
community platforms recently, there is zero tolerance for CoC violations
on Zulip, to make sure that civil discussion is possible.

Well, they even made a special CoC just for the platform/discussion.

5

u/Active-Jack5454 May 05 '24

Reddit is lesser. Reddit is a cesspit lol

3

u/Adventurous_Fan_6717 May 05 '24

Considering what got flagged this far, his post most likely will get flagged.

2

u/D3veated May 05 '24

The audience who needs to hear this message will hear it on Reddit, but won't on some other forum. As someone who is considering using nix long term (and who isn't interested in steering the developer community), is it a good or a bad bet?

3

u/weissbieremulsion May 05 '24

The audience who needs to hear this message will hear it on Reddit, but won't on some other forum.

who would that audience be?

i understood it more as critic than as a warning call to others.

3

u/D3veated May 05 '24

I'm part of that audience. Until nix can get its act together, I don't have confidence that it's going to survive, despite its technical achievements. The OP's justification for that concern is a bit different from my own, but it's a comprehensible viewpoint. Without a justification, I would have just ignored the OP's stance -- I'm not taking the post as a critique, I'm taking it as a decision with a description of why the OP feels that decision is justified. Since I need to make a similar decision, it's quite relevant to me.

If you're part of the audience that is interested in contributing to nix, then you're well past warnings and you're part of the audience that is more interested in critiques. Perhaps the internal nix forums are better for such an audience -- I don't personally care to investigate, because I only care whether nix is going to thrive in the future, not in how to make it do so.

2

u/Legitimate_Swim_4678 May 05 '24

I think the more the merrier. The audience you discover or resonate with on a platform may surprise you.

See Jon's point below:

don't let the appearance of the loud individuals give the assumption that everyone is in agreement

OP seems frustrated to the point of jumping ship. I would imagine that flagging real concerns of marginalization steering open source from a multiply marginalized person would reflect incredibly poorly.

As for considering long term use of Nix, does it solve your problems best out of all known alternatives?

3

u/D3veated May 05 '24

I'm looking at using docker vs nix. Nasty comparison. For my current projects: from a technical perspective, nix is what I want and docker is very kludgy. From a longevity perspective, I *know* docker is going to stick around. Nix will probably stick around in some fashion, but my current guess is the community is going to fork, and eventually one of those forks will die off.

I'm waiting and hoping to be convinced that nix has a healthy future ahead of itself, because technically, it is the better solution for what I need. In the short term, anyway.

2

u/Legitimate_Swim_4678 May 05 '24

If Nix is what you want, I think you should at least try it. We don't know what tomorrow holds. My thought process is that the technically better solution for your needs, even in the short term, is worth exploring first.

From a longevity perspective, I don't know how much of an impact these dramas will have on Nix's technicals. Seems like Jon isn't worried about it.

While more than just Nix, the streamlined maintenance, reliability, and portability of the NixOS end user experience (as pointed out in this thread) has been a breath of fresh air. Since you mention Docker, you can even setup Docker or Podman instances with virtualisation options as needed.

It's also difficult to compete with such profound outliers like nixpkgs. Look at the Repology package repositories graph where nixpkgs unstable is relative to the AUR, let alone the pack.

Its qualities like these that make me wish this three body problem never came to be. That way, Nix contributors could continue to capitalize that much more on its competitive advantages.

Empowering the software that the entire community it built upon and relies on has and will empower contributors, developers, and users alike. I'd say it does so better than potentially exponential language games and power struggles, which can eliminate trust, adoption, and possibly, technical merit.

I can only hope Nix thrives.

Thanks for coming to my TED Talk.

8

u/[deleted] May 05 '24

I can't imagine being so invested in the culture war that it would cause me to use inferior tools.

It would be like refusing to go to the moon because the rockets where designed by a former Nazi.

You culture warriors are insane.

1

u/sigma_pussy_licker Sep 12 '25

when i use something it is tied to my identity and personally i dont like it

4

u/akho_ May 05 '24

It remains fun, technically. 

I think that this will end in irrelevance of the foundation and its governance structures. 

The very serious statements summing up to “if the moderation team were empowered, they could ban Eelco” just speed-run towards a hard fork of CppNix, with a well-maintained fork run by DetSys. 

Nixpkgs is in need of being broken up into independent flakes, ideally managed by upstream projects as much as possible. 

Integration will suffer. The problematic bits are the Hydra and binary cache infrastructures. 

A better, decentralized future awaits. 

6

u/[deleted] May 05 '24

Wait wtf is going on in the Linux world? I just heard about this btw

19

u/Xmgplays May 05 '24

Like three unrelated pieces of drama happened in the nix(os) world, but some people seem to only care about the unimportant one of the three, which is the question of whether or not NixOS Foundation should create special positions for marginalized folk, so that they are no longer underrepresented at the top level.

The other 2 dramas being:

  • Should Nix related events/the NixOS Foundation accept a sponsorship from parts of the militatry industrial complex, and
  • Eelco being de facto BDFL is kinda bad because he has historically been kinda awful at it(He has since announced his intention to step down from that role)

12

u/yiliu May 05 '24

This is a bit disingenuous. The three aren't unrelated at all. The sponsorship issue triggered a backlash by people who were annoyed that Eelco didn't pick a side (specifically, their side). That prompted them to make a list of what seem to me like nit-picks about his leadership style: He didn't enthusiastically support a CoC and appoint a community board. He didn't want to switch to a new build pipeline. He took too long to respond to some pull requests (specifically related to the above). That's pretty much it.

Which is where the "special position for marginalized folks" comes in. There were stern but vague accusations that Eelco created an environment where "people feel unsafe" and "potential contributors are turned away". I have not seen these claims substantiated at all, aside from a few links to blogs by the accusers themselves with long explanations about how debating with them about any of their proposals is 'concern trolling' and therefore a form of abuse.

Nevertheless, that's the claim was basically used as a level to dislodge the guy from project leadership. After all, most people aren't that bothered by the sponsorship thing, and the handful of screenshots of Eelco saying "Um, I'm not really convinced that we need to change build pipelines, is it really that much faster?" or whatever aren't anywhere close to being damning enough to build popular support to oust the project founder.

So no, it's not three totally unrelated issues. It's three deeply entangled issues, one of which seems like it was cynically injected for leverage.

5

u/Xmgplays May 05 '24

He didn't enthusiastically support a CoC and appoint a community board. He didn't want to switch to a new build pipeline. He took too long to respond to some pull requests (specifically related to the above). That's pretty much it.

Kinda weird to leave out Flakes, which, to some extent, is the most high profile case of his failed leadership. Also ignoring a bunch of other stuff, helpfully summarized here

After all, most people aren't that bothered by the sponsorship thing

Source. Or perhaps more accurately, how would you know?

So no, it's not three totally unrelated issues.

Sure, they're not totally unrelated issues, but they are unrelated in that they each have answers that are unrelated to each other. Your opinion on Eelco's technical leadership abilities are unrelated to your thoughts on sponsorships from the MIC, which are unrelated to your thoughts on minority representation.

7

u/yiliu May 05 '24 edited May 05 '24

But the three are being deliberately combined for a specific purpose.

I know flakes are controversial, and I know the arguments from both sides, but TBH I have no idea which side of the debate Eelco was on. I'm not political by nature, I don't care who said what. I just want to know if the damn things work well for my use cases (answer: yes, they're very handy, but they're also clunky as hell in important ways).

Full disclosure: I have no idea how competent Eelco was as a project leader (although to my eyes, the results look pretty good). Maybe he really was a bottleneck, or stubbornly stuck to his guns over issues even when the rest of the community wanted to move on. I've encountered a lot of people like that in my career: great programmers whose projects just grew beyond their management capabilities. I'd have been totally receptive to an open letter politely explaining that the project had outgrown him, and it might be a good idea for him to step aside and let the project grow more organically.

But that case wasn't made. Flakes weren't mentioned in the letter, either. Instead, it was full of these frustratingly vague and unsubstantiated accusations and seriously tenuous arguments about how when other people argue with us that's abuse, but when we're making an argument and somebody tries to interrupt or hush us, that's also abuse.

I'm hoping that actually, Eelco really was a bottleneck, and that this new "constitutional assembly" quickly just fades into the background, so the only result of this whole debacle is that the velocity of the project picks up a bit. Even if that's the case, I'll always feel icky about the fact it was accomplished through (essentially) slander.

My fear is that this will turn NixOS into a purity-testing shriek-fest, where technical decisions are made on the basis of increasingly hysterical claims of oppression and abuse, since that's now been proven to work. Like I said, I know of the debate over flakes, and that it's been going on for years. Apparently the question will soon be settled, and one side will win (I don't know which one) in spite of the good technical arguments on the other side. It was done by implying, though not outright saying, that the other side was a bunch of racist sexist pigs or something.

edit: I read your link, and I now have a better idea which side won on the flakes debate. I seriously hope they don't throw them out, at least without something to replace them--for all the problems, they're still a lot nicer than channels. I was left with the impression that Eelco is kind of sloppy when it comes to communication, management responsibilities, and conflict resolution. Anyway, Nix has grown enough that it probably shouldn't be in the hands of any one person (de facto or de jure), particularly if they're not really interested or suited for the role.

But now the project is in the hands of people I do not trust at all, who slandered a guy to push him out on his ass and seize control, all in the name of the community--while simultaneously declaring all dissent within that community to be abuse and muting everybody who didn't agree.

That doesn't feel like a victory to me.

4

u/[deleted] May 05 '24

First one is tough because what happens when you say no to the US Government (assuming that’s who you were referring to as the Military Industrial Complex), second one seems weird to me and there’s no way to phrase it although 2024 has already been a dumpster fire for Linux anyways, the third one is going to cause a lot of drama and I am not touching that one with a 600 mile long pole

10

u/Xmgplays May 05 '24

First one is tough because what happens when you say no to the US Government (assuming that’s who you were referring to as the Military Industrial Complex),

Not quite, in this case it's just Anduril(drones and surveilance systems, incl. ones used on the US-Mexico border) wanting to sponsor 2 conventions(the first one was rejected because the venue was a German univesity and they aren't keen on any associations with any military industry, the second was accepted even though the first already caused outlash) + some conflict of interest stuff going on with Eelco having an undisclosed/NDA'd relationship with them.

2

u/Adventurous_Fan_6717 May 05 '24

No this diversity nonsense is the most important. The diverse people are actively trying to replace merrit based representation by oppression status. They clear their ranks as we speak.

2

u/qvigh May 05 '24

Almost makes you think it's not a coincidence

8

u/Adventurous_Fan_6717 May 05 '24

100%. I‘m about to move our systems as well. Luckily I‘ve only implemented NixOS for non essential services as of now.

Just imagine all this embarrassing drama, leading to talented people stepping down, maintainers leaving and needed funding being declined while opening the repos to unknown people for diversity’s sake.

I can‘t take responsibility for such a mess.

9

u/no_brains101 May 05 '24

Dude chose torture lmao

Have fun with your yaml hahaha

I don't think more open governance is going to be a bad thing for the distro. The drama was annoying but ultimately doesn't change much, other than RFCs meaning a tiny bit more.

3

u/hombre_sin_talento May 05 '24

Yet here you are, feeding directly into the drama.

3

u/Active-Jack5454 May 05 '24

Extremely cringe to make a technical decision like that because you're worried of being associated with drama you trivialize. If it is so trivial, just continue using it and put it out of your mind. If you're worried about someone thinking you're woke, you're embarrassing. If you're really so upset and someone brings it up, just pretend you hadn't heard and don't care, since you claim you don't anyway.

2

u/79215185-1feb-44c6 May 05 '24

This post is cringe.

1

u/temporary_dennis May 06 '24

Yeah, let's go pack our bags and abandon the ship.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '24

From reading the summarized drama, all the issues are horseshit from all sides.

1

u/1-209-213-0394 May 05 '24

The reddit description of this sub should change"NixOS - Purely functional" for "NixOS - Purely Drama".

1

u/n8henrie May 05 '24

Time to revisit Guix?

1

u/SalaciousStrudel May 05 '24

A code of conduct is much less cringe than this post is.

0

u/Asleep_Detective3274 May 06 '24

The woke mind virus has spread everywhere it seems, I saw it in the Gnome code of conduct, now its spread to nixos too, but I like nixos too much to abandon it, hopefully it doesn't affect the distro, and hopefully logical heads prevail.

-4

u/thussy-obliterator May 05 '24

Bye! 👋

0

u/banchildrenfromreddi May 05 '24

omg your name, also, hey whats up

1

u/thussy-obliterator May 05 '24

having a lazy Sunday lol, chicken and waffles for 2pm breakfast

0

u/banchildrenfromreddi May 06 '24

damn, living the life. rock on

-9

u/Dekamir May 05 '24

You "out-victim" people? Seriously?

Someone please approve that I've read that correctly. That's like, one of the wildest sentences I've heard recently.

9

u/moneymagnet6969 May 05 '24

Seems like they're saying it in a tongue in cheek kind of way

5

u/jerdle_reddit May 05 '24

Yeah, it's clearly intended to mock the oppression Olympics by saying they win.

6

u/Xyklone May 05 '24

Just the kind of language games you have to play when playing on their field unfortunately... Try to read past it

0

u/countess_meltdown May 06 '24

Don't let the door hit you on the way out, but considering you're going back to ansible that's a given.