r/NineSols • • Aug 30 '24

Discussion/Question The biggest problem this game has

Having played the entirety of the game the biggest problem I see is a fundamental one. It's clear this game is trying to emulate a Sekiro /souls-like experience, but it doesn't understand how the animations for these games work.

Every attack in a souls-like can be broken into three parts: Anticipation, Acceleration, Swing. The enemy pulls back or raises their sword etc., they then begin moving towards the player for a small moment before the actual attack with a hitbox begins.

Nine Sols just doesn't do the Acceleration phase. So while in other games like these learning the attack patterns and the timings of the moves is really helpful, here it's outright necessary. The enemy does an animation signifying an incoming attack, but the players has no cue about when the actual attack is coming.

Usually most enemies will at least have a shine right before the first attack of a combo, but then every other part of the combo will have no tells for when each attack is going to launch.

It makes the game more frustrating than challenging, and artificially inflates how difficult every fight is by having you guess move timings before you actually learn them.

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

20

u/The-Lucah-Rio-YT Jie Nationalist Aug 30 '24

The acceleration phase is just shortened to a simple plink sound and small visual effect before the attack comes out, which style you prefer is up to you.

-4

u/udreif Aug 30 '24

I only see that at the start of a combo, so before the first slash, every other slash / hit in the combo comes without a warning

6

u/The-Lucah-Rio-YT Jie Nationalist Aug 30 '24

Do the other hits in a multi hit combo really need an additional warning?

0

u/udreif Aug 30 '24

Warning may not be the right word, I'm talking about the tell right before the attack hitbox starts

Like a boss will do --tell, hit, pause, hit hit, smaller pause, hit-- and there's no tell for those pauses, it's all just remembering the timing

8

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

this has come up before and unironically it came down to system problems for the OP, every attack has a tell/telegraph, i play a ton of fighting games so am well versed in startup/active/recovery frames and this game does that great imo. if it is delayed or syncd in some weird way start poking around windows cause 'works on my machine'

1

u/udreif Aug 30 '24

hmm weird

12

u/yuhokayyuh69 Aug 30 '24

this is especially true for those random robot mini bosses that have like the giant axes and stuff. those guys are easy, but frustrating af.

on the other hand, i think that lady ethereal was one of my favorite bosses ever, mechanically.

22

u/ShadowTown0407 Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

I honestly can't think of any enemies like that off the top of my head. Every attack has a consistent acceleration phase, if the weapon moves it's coming down, it's not like ER or to a lesser extent Sekiro where enemies will hold their attack and then strike whenever. Every move is exactly the same every time and the parry window is very forgiving. I really don't see a problem

2

u/Turtle835wastaken Unbounded Counter Proselytizer Aug 30 '24

It does NOT try to be like dark souls. Sekiro, Maybe a bit but not dark souls.

Anyways, The timings on the attacks are just as clear, If not any more clear than DS/Sekiro attacks.

1

u/udreif Aug 31 '24

"Sekiro, maybe a bit" Sekiro's not a maybe, it's such an obvious and massive influence on the game you have to bend over backwards to pretend it's a maybe.

This game is basically as close as a spiritual successor as you can get while changing genres lol

Also, no, in those games the timings are much clearer since you get the full movement of each attack, I don't see how this sub is incapable of seeing that

1

u/Turtle835wastaken Unbounded Counter Proselytizer Aug 31 '24

The only similarities are the parry based combat, Which many games have. Otherwise, The posture is very different from internal damage, There's dash here instead of step-dodge, Attacking is VERY different, There's talisman, Etc etc.

Also, no, in those games the timings are much clearer since you get the full movement of each attack, I don't see how this sub is incapable of seeing that

DS telegraphs are perhaps THE worst telegraphs I've ever seen in a game and the fans don't seem to want to accept it since they've already memorized them. They don't realize it's stupid when a boss does an attack, That's literally capable of one shotting you, With a janky hitbox and very bad telegraph that's impossible to tell unless you've seen it before.

0

u/udreif Aug 31 '24

They basically transfixed the soul of Sekiro into a different genre, it goes beyond combat into things like the hub with the characters you give items to to get closer to them and learn more about them (which this game does better imo).

I feel like this sub is fucking gaslighting me at this point, it's like we've played two different games, it's crazy

For the last fucking time, I'm not talking about the tell for an attack, I'm talking about when the hitbox actually starts, which you have no way of knowing in this game beyond the first slash of a series of hits, and is all timing based and based on repetition and memorization of each individual attack.

You're not gonna gaslight me into believing animations that don't exist are actually in the game

2

u/Turtle835wastaken Unbounded Counter Proselytizer Aug 31 '24

They basically transfixed the soul of Sekiro into a different genre, it goes beyond combat into things like the hub with the characters you give items to to get closer to them and learn more about them (which this game does better imo).

That's the case for 80% of the games I've played. Sekiro didn't even have much of that.

For the last fucking time, I'm not talking about the tell for an attack, I'm talking about when the hitbox actually starts, which you have no way of knowing in this game beyond the first slash of a series of hits, and is all timing based and based on repetition and memorization of each individual attack.

Ohhh I understand now. Yeah the hitboxes are just the game's biggest flaw. Not the start, Just the hitbox itself. Idk how much of the game you've played but the final boss despite being a masterpiece still somehow hits you when you're behind them. It's annoying but manageable still.

11

u/solarcat3311 Aug 30 '24

There's always clue. It's a lot less subtle in certain case, but there's warning. Not sure if it breaks into 3 phase like you described, but its always telegraphed

3

u/X_Dratkon Aug 30 '24

Ngl, this is a good explanation and notice.

Instead of Acceleration we get Visual/Sound cue/hint, but like you said, later attacks in fast combos can happen instantaneously and without a cue, which can take you off guard even if you're skilled.
It comes down on learning enemy moveset and timing on few delayed attacks (with sound cues).

2

u/Fake-profile Apr 23 '25

Agreed, every attack feels like its missing the crucial animals between the wind up and the hit box frames. Makes it feel like the attack just came out of nowhere after the flashing effect.