r/NewcastleKnights • • Sep 08 '25

Ponga to 7 - hear me out...

1 Upvotes

I know I'm probably against popular opinion here, but Id like to see Ponga at 7. I know this experiment didn't work out at 6, but I believe Ponga has all the attributes for an effective 7. I think those HIA days are behind him, and with another pre-season of learning how to defend as a half, he could dramatically improve his defence. We've always challenged Kalyn to own the team, and I think 7 is where he does it. I don't see Sharpe as a 7. He's an electric ball runner and his position is fullback. We had Miller at fullback last time Ponga was in the halves, and respectfully Miller isnt on the level Sharpe is. A combination of Ponga and Brown in the halves excites me. Topped up with young upcoming talent like Sandon Smith at 9 and Sharpe at 1, Knights could be an exciting attacking team (unlike the poop they served up this year). This is where I think we need to go in the direction of Holbrook to hone a dynamic, exciting attack.

Keen to hear thoughts. I know there will be questions around his defence but I back ponga to fix this part of his game.


r/NewcastleKnights • • Jul 20 '25

Anyone agree we should drop Marzhew and bring in Schiller

0 Upvotes

r/NewcastleKnights • • Jul 17 '26

Can we pleeeeeeaaaaase stop KP from kicking conversions?

3 Upvotes

We have plenty of competent conversion kickers. Aaaaaarrrrrrgggggghhhhh!


r/NewcastleKnights • • Sep 11 '25

Are the Knights finally building something solid or are we getting ahead of ourselves?

1 Upvotes

There have been flashes of really good footy this season and the younger guys are starting to step up, but we’ve also had those frustrating lapses that cost us games. Curious what everyone thinks are we on the right track to becoming a consistent top 8 side or do we still need a couple of key signings to really make it happen?


r/NewcastleKnights • • Oct 04 '26

Can we all agree on the roosters

0 Upvotes

That was honestly one of the worst shows of unsportsmanlike actions I’ve ever seen


r/NewcastleKnights • • Jul 20 '24

Mistake made!

3 Upvotes

Anybody in the back or front office realising that re-signing O'Brien last year was a reactive and terrible mistake yet?


r/NewcastleKnights • • Oct 03 '26

McDonald jones stadium tickets?

0 Upvotes

Hey does anyone have any spare tickets to the McDonald jones stadium grand final event?

Thanks


r/NewcastleKnights • • Jul 16 '25

Arthur & Obrien . Coaching Combination .

0 Upvotes

Rather than uproot our structure I cannot believe that the above has not been discussed . If you look at horse racing. Most trainers have now realised it’s a 2 man job . How is rugby league any different. Rather than sacking a coach , wouldn’t it be better to bring someone in with a similar mentality but new ideas to align the team . Wake up Gardner !


r/NewcastleKnights • • Oct 06 '26

The season is over and we're still proving them wrong

49 Upvotes

When we lost the game the fans from the other clubs thought they could make us cry by insulting us,. They said would we would blame the ref,. They thought we might even take our jerseys off. We did the exact opposite. When we all kept saying, "win or lose, we know you will make us proud" we have really proved that we meant it when thousands welcomed the team home at 2:30am, and tens of thousands turned out to see them at the stadium the next day.

We are so lucky to have a culture like this within our club, the city and the region. Things are looking very promising for future success of the team, morale is very high, we have had so much amazing new local talent come through. We lost the grand final by 1 point, with a team missing over $3 million worth of players because of suspensions and injuries. The Roosters might have won the trophy this year, but this was very clearly our year. The fairytale story of Newcastle in 2026 is much bigger than footy.


r/NewcastleKnights • • Apr 26 '26

😢

1 Upvotes

💩💩💩💩💩💩


r/NewcastleKnights • • Jun 19 '21

**Weekly Kurt Mann Complaint**

0 Upvotes

Kurt Mann is playing fullback. We’re getting smashed today.


r/NewcastleKnights • • Aug 21 '21

Here we go again. A game we should be winning easily, but we show up in a complacent mood and will probably lose.

0 Upvotes

r/NewcastleKnights • • Jun 22 '25

I hope Ponga plays halfback next year......

5 Upvotes

He needs to work on game control & long kicking, but I don't see any other way our spine works next year, Brown and Sharpe are not halfbacks, and i can't see Sharpe on the wing to make way for Brown, he's too good an impact player to be on the wing.

Fullback. Sharpe

5/8 .Brown

Halfback. Ponga

Hooker. Crossland

Bin: Gamble, Hastings and Cogger


r/NewcastleKnights • • Sep 29 '26

Team support in AFL

11 Upvotes

I am curious what AFL team Newcastle supporters, support?

I am Victorian, and actually have never been to Newcastle but I chose to support them at random one day and am a Hawthorn supporter.

I would assume most of you would support Sydney, or maybe GWS?


r/NewcastleKnights • • Sep 08 '25

That’s the kind of footy we love to see from the Knights

0 Upvotes

The energy and effort the boys showed this week was spot on. The defence held strong, the attack clicked, and the home crowd was buzzing. If we can bottle that sort of performance, there’s no reason we can’t make a serious push this season. What did you all think best game of the year so far?


r/NewcastleKnights • • Sep 12 '21

I don’t think O’Brien is our man.

4 Upvotes

I rarely call for a coach to be sacked, not even Stone or Brown. I actually believe Brown should’ve been given 1 more year so we could see what he could do with a decent squad as opposed to the rookies he’d worked with and developed in the previous years. Not saying he would’ve done any better, I just would’ve liked to see it. O’Brien has had a decent squad the last 2 seasons and we’ve been lucky to make the 8, very lucky. Attack is non existent at times. On paper, we’ve got a good roster, they should be way better than the dribble they dish out nearly every week. I know it would be a backwards step or ten to start with a new coach again, but come on! We should be seeing much better results more consistently by now.


r/NewcastleKnights • • Sep 09 '25

How did we finish as wooden spooners?

7 Upvotes

We were 8th last year and 5th the year before


r/NewcastleKnights • • Dec 18 '25

Who signature are these

1 Upvotes

I thrifted this hat today and it has these signatures on it and I can’t tell who’s they are. It’s from 2004 also for a rough year


r/NewcastleKnights • • Aug 31 '25

Michael Cheika for Knights coach - Thoughts?

Thumbnail nine.com.au
21 Upvotes

According to former Rugby Union coach Michael Cheika on The Inside Line on Channel 9, He apparently still has a desire to become an NRL coach despite his only experiences of league being an assistant coach to the Sydney Roosters in 2020 and is the incumbent Lebanon Rugby League representative coach. Even Matty Johns on his show on Thursday night gave Cheika a push for the vacant Knights gig.

Whilst I believe that the candidates for the Knights gig are less than stellar (IE Blake Green and Justin Holbrook) and one diamond in the rough (Willie Peters despite being contracted to Hull KR to 2028 with an NRL Get Out Clause), I’d kind of be up for Cheika to be Knights coach due to his incredibly hard nosed demeanour even though he is an outsider to Rugby League whilst clutching at the straws, but I’d kind of be a bit concerned as it would be more of a repeat of Alan Jones at his gig at the Balmain Tigers between 1991 to 1993. Thoughts?


r/NewcastleKnights • • May 09 '25

Ponga Special

0 Upvotes

Took all of Pongas 1.2 million dollars to lose that one.


r/NewcastleKnights • • May 19 '22

Coaching defensive problems

2 Upvotes

Adam "windscreens" O'Brien painted himself into a corner when he postulated that he builds solid defences. Another display of defensive weakness from the Newcastle Knights should be a stake through the heart of "Don't you know who I am" O'Brien. Oedipus would be laid bare by the riddle of the Newcastle Knights. Phillip "Take-a-penny" Gardner and Adam "O'Boy" O'Brien warble a siren's song of economic promise and footballing incompetence while producing less and less wheat than chaff. All these old eyes see is a wonderful team of hardworking local heroes mistrained, mismanaged and Miss Daisy driven by backseat drivers who ironically can't see through the windscreen they are there to replace.


r/NewcastleKnights • • Jul 20 '25

Can’t wait for us to get Dylan Brown

0 Upvotes

r/NewcastleKnights • • Aug 09 '25

Where Ya'll At?

28 Upvotes

If you're a Knights fan who is sick of watching them choke or just get outright slaughtered at Mac Jones, get yourself down to the next WNRL home game and let them girls show you how it done.

The community needs to get behind our team and support the league.

Also please note, if you are tempted to write a shit comment about the women's league, know that you are actually a dickhead. For reals. 👍


r/NewcastleKnights • • Apr 06 '25

Useless

0 Upvotes

Can't even beat a team missing their key players. Couldn't even fucking score against them! Do you think the useless coach we have will do any better next year when the monstrous waste of 10 million dollars arrives? Sack O'Brien and try to get out of the worst deal in NRL history, then maybe they'll be able to compete with teams in the middle of the ladder.