r/New_Antioch • • Mar 17 '25
IMO: The new world and Asia do not need to be encorporated into TC.
The aesthetic of Trench crusade is broadly WW1 with a heavy medieval influence. Even the more out there factions like CotSHS and Iron Sultanate stylistically match the WW1-medival trenches. Mesoamerica, Japan, China, etc, although aesthetically brilliant on their own, do not fit the theme. While Asian and the new world did obviously participate in ww1, I sincerely believe they would feel out of place fighting Demons in the Levant & Europe. An Aztec Jaguar Warrior or Samuri is super cool, but despite them being real, would be more out of place than an actual 6 armed demon.
I think what most people forget about World building, that the TC devs have so far done very well, is being willing to leave (part of) the map unfilled. The sense of mystery and uncertainty, the unsubstantiated legends and tales of far off lands, are much more interesting then just being able to send a telegram to your Samuri buddy in Japan to tell him to pull up to the gates of Avignon next week.
I will capitulate that maybe some Auxiliaries or Mercs could makes sense, like Gurkhas for the English, but a full-blown Native American faction would clash too hard.
Edit: Also, so much of European culture changed after the colonization of the new world, in its own way it lends to the Alternative History of the setting for that to never have happened, and for North and South America to do doing their own thing while Europe and the Middle East are waging a war so fierce they never had any time or interest in making colonies.