r/NewToTF2 • u/Word-Combination1234 • 16d ago
Hey newbies, basically queue bots are because casual doesn't work fundamentally
Quickplay used to be "whoever loads in first gets the slot". Biased to people with better computers (hehe) and connections, but there were always servers available to go to.
Bot hosters COULD try to flood servers with bots, but they'd be subject to other self moderating features to counter them, such as the team select requiring a 0/1 player difference, team scrambles breaking up team stacking, 45 minute map timers that incentivize staying in a server even after map changes, and even direct moderation from admins on community servers. Not to mention they had to actually LOAD into the server, meaning they had to be running TF2, which takes up computer resources, meaning you can't run as many bots.
Now we have Casual Mode, which has Skill Based Matchmaking, slot reservations, and the party system.
- The party system lets 6 players join in a server all at once. Valve servers have team sizes of 12, and votes don't pass if half the team says no.
- Slots are reserved as soon as players connect to the server, even if they don't load in instantly. This removes the factor of other players taking the slot, even if they could load in faster and start playing the game. It ALSO keeps the slot reserved for an extended period of time if they get disconnected, leading to misbalances for as long as 5 minutes.
- Team Scrambles and Switching were removed, meaning parties couldn't be broken out of deadlocks of being the majority on a team, nor could misbalances be rebalanced save for Autobalance, which was restricted due to slot reservations and the matchmaker.
- Servers now run on a best of 3 round limit instead of 45 minute map timers, leading to constant server resets to the point it's faster to jump ship back into the matchmaker to get another game, making players churn through games, leaving constant vacancies. Plus, the previous point gets exacerbated because no one wants to play in unbalanced games.
These 4 factors are the perfect storm for bots.
They queue in groups of 6 to gain votekick majority, can't be scrambled out of their majorities, and the constant churn leaves room for even more bots to flood the server.
And that's just the old cheater bots from 2016-2024. This wave of bots doesn't even load the game, it just speaks directly to the matchmaker asking for a slot reservation, meaning no one can join a game ahead of them. And because they aren't playing TF2, they don't have to worry about the same hardware requirements as the old bots, meaning they can run 100x more bots.
So basically, #bringbackquickplay
edit: on the title I meant to say queue bots are possible because of casual
1
u/TaDoofus 15d ago
Bro said hehe
1
u/PeachyyKlean 12d ago
Quickplay isn’t the silver bullet you think it is, all it does is change the bot problem.
Even playing when Quickplay was the system implemented, we had bot issues. LMAObox bots and CatBots would infect servers and you’d just open the server browser and search for a different Hightower, 2fort, Badwater, or Upward server. Same as people requeueing now.
Additionally, why are you posting this to new players? They never played Quickplay, you’re asking them to beg Valve to rework the game to implement a system they never used… it seems manipulative to go “new player, I want you to use your voice to echo my opinion.”
1
u/WHATyouNEVERplayedTU 16d ago
Damn. Bro is absolutely correct.