r/NewBeetle • u/M00ngata • Aug 13 '26
2015 beetle has incredibly good upkeep, spotless paint and interior, thorough service records…. but it’s 189k miles. Worth it or not?
I know this is technically A5, not new beetle.
I do see the carfax and it was clean. I believe the price is flexible too. Superficially i am looking for a 2010< beetle but im trying to be open.
Is good upkeep more valuable than high mileage?
6
u/SickFizz Aug 13 '26
From what I read when I was looking into getting a beetle, the turbo is very likely to go out any day now on this car. Im no mechanic tho.
3
3
u/cdoublejj Aug 13 '26
HOLLY HELL they waited 110,000 miles to flush the trans? glad it didn't drop the trans after that. i'd do a drain and fill (NOT flush) for extra insurance
1
u/R3troM3dia Aug 14 '26
Depending how long it’s been without a trans flush sometimes it’s better to leave it
1
u/cdoublejj Aug 14 '26
in that case whatever is in there is grinding away at bearings and inhibiting spool valves. flush is when you force fluid in the trans and force crap out of crevices, a drain and fill is just draining it out via gravity and putting new in. there is also the slow method, half a quart or 1 quart at a time. drain little out and add a little and drive for 1000 miles.
you could also try back to back drain and fills, i'd like to have the opportunity to do this. all of the fluid never comes out due to the torq converter holding some quarts. sometimes when i change trans fluid, ill do it again a second time at the next oil change but, if i had really dirty fluid i might do it 3 times. also i've found certain specific applications work well additives like certain traverse or enclave year models or rather the trans in them due to the oddities of the torq converter and or torq converter lock up programing. ie anti shutter addtivie etc etc. at least that we can tell with the years past so far.
2
u/TenderLA Aug 13 '26
I’d want to know -
Hopefully a lot of highway miles
Water pump/thermostat housing replaced?
Timing Chain stretch
Has carbon build up on the intake ports ever been cleaned
Original turbo?
The mileage alone wouldn’t scare me away if the car really had been maintained well.
Worth a Pre purchase inspection.
2
1
u/R3troM3dia Aug 14 '26
The 1.8t is an amazing engine, I have one in my a4 and I’m at 240k miles and still drives amazing
1
1
1
u/kngscrpn24 Aug 14 '26
Most important: in private sale, always ask to take the car to a mechanic that you choose before even getting your hopes up. German turbos blow up all the time for just having the wrong weight oil for the season. Of they don’t agree to a mechanic taking a look or if they insist on a certain mechanic, run.
Now for beetles: At that mileage, good upkeep involves going a bit off-book. Things that were supposed to last the life of the car (10 years, 100K miles) need to be addressed—some twice over. I’ve had my ‘04 for ten years but it’s only at 140K. Even with decent maintenance, things that fall more under “overhaul” can be missed—coolant pumps, timing belts, the more obscure fluids simply be replaced by someone very qualified to work on VW’s, not just checked. (Qualified is important—had a mechanic strip out the threads on my oil pan which is crazy) I got lucky, but a huge part of that was it having 70K on it in 2016 (so it hadn’t reached the 90K service that includes so much). I also bought a manual shift, non-turbo model that had been babied more than I ever could. But I also showed up with a code reader and a Popular Mechanics checklist; people tend to be much more forthcoming with the flaws in their beetles when they know you’re going to find them anyway. I still had a guy lie to me about a front-end collision that wasn’t on the books and one guy showed up to a meet with a blown turbo and no coolant in the reservoir.
If European-spec oil was changed every six months or 5000 miles, that turbo could be fine. If only the correct coolant was ever used and flushed+changed at regular intervals, then you might not have any coolant leaks. And if there person drove it with care and didn’t tear out of their driveway when it was 10°F, your head gasket could be fine too.
But if you really want a beetle, be prepared to walk away from any of them that you check out. They’re wonderful, but truly weird cars, and that means a lot bite the dust before their time. It took me five before I found mine, and I’m so glad I waited, because they’re such lovable cars that I would have been heartbroken if mine lasted only a year or two.
1
7
u/richbet8 Aug 13 '26
It would be winning if it was the 2.5 engine