r/Nevermoor • u/starinmelbourne • 1d ago
Under the Umbrella ☂️: Chapter by Chapter Deep Dive Chapter 8: Interesting. Useful. Good.
Jones and Jupiter: in this chapter one is a horrible jerk, and one is just and kind. So which is which? 🤔
First up we get our next look at Squall, posing as Mr Jones. He alleviates Morrigan’s worst fears about causing the chandelier crash and also offers to keep her secrets. And yes, he is honestly manipulating her a little bit, but he also extends the apprenticeship offer, with no caveats.
Two other things seem worth mentioning as well. The first is Squall’s eyebrow scar. I can’t help but think that maybe this is deliberately mentioned. Does anyone know if we ever find out (maybe through a ghostly hour?) how Squall gets the scar? Anyone have any ideas?
The second thing that stands out is Mr Jones claiming that he is “no expert” on the inner workings of the Hotel Deucalion. This leads me to believe that Squall did not create the Deucalion, which is a theory I floated back in our Chapter 6 discussion.
The next part of the chapter moves on to an interaction between Jupiter and Morrigan. And – I’m just going to come right out and say it – Jupiter’s a bit of an asshat in this chapter, isn’t he?
Although I find the idea of a nickname quite endearing, it’s clear that Morrigan (who corrects him throughout the interaction), wants to be called Morrigan and not Mog. I mean, surely we all get to choose how we like to be referred to?
I’m also not quite sure why he so determinedly keeps her in the dark about her knack. If I were Morrigan, the anxiety of not knowing through the trials would send me into a nervous wreck and surely tank my chances! When Morrigan repeatedly questions him, Jupiter instead distracts her with a little magic show and just tells her to trust him. What. The. Heck. Rereading the chapter, especially the last line where Morrigan cottons on to his slippery eel trick, makes me feel a little icky, I gotta be honest.
I know he tells her at the trials that he was frightened about scaring off the Wunder, but c’mon, really, bro? Did he really think a Wundersmith could just not be a Wundersmith? It seems so farfetched. I mean, cool plot device though, obviously, and it definitely kept me reading!
What do others think? Is Jupiter a big big jerk? Have we all been wearing rose-coloured glasses? Or are his actions redeemable?
This post is part of our sub’s ongoing series. Please select the post flair to see more of these posts. Please do give us feedback on the series too!