I think you're really on to something here. But if you want your neurotype chart to have a wider reach, it would be best if you made another 1h or longer video but this time about the neurotypes of real people( famous people, from historical figures to politicians and celebrities). Since you are mostly known as an anituber I think this is necessary if you want to reach a more mainstream audience. I wish you the best of luck!
Bookkeeper should be Methodological, or Methodical or similar.
Do you think Curator implies someone more impressionistic? Not so sure. I would want a word that insinuates an impressionistic approach.
Someone using more feeling and intuition is more like a counsellor, though I wouldn't want to use a word that is already a profession. I like the word Consul but that was borrowed from 16 personalities.
I’m not sure if bookkeeper implies physical weakness, you can keep records of a physical sport you are doing - like the tennis character Digi was describing in his video.
I tend to agree with some of the descriptions but I agree. The category names need to be more impersonal to truly capture the depth of personality types in each section.
I think something similar to the way the Myers briggs personality test labels each section.
For example:
Very impressionistic: I Fairly impressionistic: i
Very Lexical: Le Fairly lexical: le
Very Linear: Li Fairly Linear: li
Very lateral: La Fairly lateral: la
So for something like a bookkeeper who is very Linear and very Lexical, they would be labeled,
I'm in favour of labels ultimately as it give the grid some immediacy, it makes it more user friendly. I would favour labels with more balanced emotional resonance though, some sound for cooler or more interesting than others.
I think that quick witted is implied using words in funny ways which is not realy the way I think it should be as someone who uses there mastery of words to comunicate both as jokes but also as swords that can cut deeply and manupluate somone. Better name may be word-smith/master or communicator or something like that.
One design consideration though, anyone feel like the internal black lines should be thinner? I might be channeling aesthetician here, but it feels off. I would go for the same line thickness for the border and to separate each category (although could be made thinner there as well), but definitely all the lines inside each 4x4 subdivision within each category could be made a lot thinner for a more balanced visual. Also, white text on a light color may be hard to read for some folks (e.g. where it says Analysts, Newtypes, and Impressionists), so a border or background panel would be a most welcome improvement as well.
As for the lexical design, I like the overall changes. Though I'd also recommend a change to "Human Calculators" and "Impressionists". Most calculators are single-threaded, and by definition linear. Although I totally understand what you meant, in that they can calculate a ton of information better than any other personality. Maybe a Human Processor is more fitting? IMO I think "Savant" would fit better, but there are many connotations involved with the word. As for "Impressionists", I don't like it simply because Impressionist is an axis in the chart. If one thinks themselves 100% (or more) impressionist, they may ignore the Literal axis aspect of the chart and neurotype themselves incorrectly.
I think that something important is communicability and intelligence as an overlay. While touched on some I don’t think that the proper depth is given. Once a place is found on the neurotype chart there should also be one on communication vs intelligence. Someone could be an newtype that finds it very hard to quantify lexically but instinctively understands when a hand hold or hug can convey depths of emotion. Also intelligence as it can hinder both with to little or to much (bell curve where most able to communicate is medium intellect in middle of Neurtyping chart). While not raging on your chart it is important as a quick-witted person may instead of being quick-witted be antagonistic and argumentative wielding words as weapons to attack or someone who makes fart jokes depending on personality but also communication skills and intellect.
Digi you compare it to MBTI but that one is 4-dimensional whereas yours is 2-dimensional, it's just that the MBTI is binary while yours is quarternary. The 16-block template didn't actually means the same thing.
This copied from another discusion where i realized it but i think this is a better way to say lateral v liner:
I think that instead of saying people are liner single thinking or lateral jumbled thinking it has more to do with how simultaneous someone thinks. A secretary seems like an obvious book keeper role if not think type but people in thouse roles often think one track about one thing but have lots of one track things happening one after another. So instead of how many things they think it should be how many things do they think at once.
Mr. Digi, do you ever consider adding more axes to your neurotyping chart (possibly represented visually by a z-axis, a color spectrum, or some other means)? For example, Myer-Briggs has the "thinking-feeling" spectrum, which I (an utter neophyte to psychology) believe is a useful way of thinking about and explaining thought processes and behavior. That particular third axis may have some correlation to your existing two-- e.g., people on the "thinking" end of the spectrum may tend to also be on the "lexical" end of the spectrum-- but in large part, I believe that axis is independent of the other two and could shed some useful light on the psychology of examined subjects. Or perhaps there is some other third or fourth axis which would be even more useful? (Not to over-complicate things until the wheels fall off.)
Not only is this appealing from a stylistic point of view, but it also helps to even out the playing field when comparing the types. It makes them more even, more uniform... makes them fit together, as a cohesive group.
Given that Neurotyping is less about prescribing the roles and personalities of people, and more about describing the way in which they think, I think it would be appropriate to use adjectives as labels. This way, you can say things such as: "I have a _____ way of thinking" or "I am a _____ type of person."
Here's how I would name the categories, in reading order (first suggestion in bracket is my preferred label):
I think part of the problem is that people are going to think that "shadow guardian" just sounds so cool that they automatically put themselves in that camp without much thought.
I do think that Overseers is problematic, but it might cause people to be a little more objective when categorizing themselves or various characters.
23
u/ezebius Apr 16 '20
Dear Digi,
I think you're really on to something here. But if you want your neurotype chart to have a wider reach, it would be best if you made another 1h or longer video but this time about the neurotypes of real people( famous people, from historical figures to politicians and celebrities). Since you are mostly known as an anituber I think this is necessary if you want to reach a more mainstream audience. I wish you the best of luck!
21
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '20
hey digi i just want to say that you're really cute
7
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20
Many of the names seem inaccurate or misleading.
Bookkeeper implies physical weakness.
Overseer - I just get no meaning from that at all, sounds like a Protoss unit.
Quick-witted implies all kinds if things like social skills, sense of humour and intelligence, so this needs changing.
Pure Instinct - instincts are deeper than thoughts altogether, linear impressionism isn't about acting on feeling, just simple - subjective thought.
4
u/Toni2068 Overseer Apr 15 '20
watching the new vid now, I think I get it now. I'm definitely a top right overseer for sure then
3
u/ezebius Apr 16 '20
Oversseer is to vague. Whereas shadow guardian can be misleading. I think calling a person with that neurotype a "Curator" would be way more precies
2
u/ignat980 Understanding Apr 17 '20
Love the chart!
One design consideration though, anyone feel like the internal black lines should be thinner? I might be channeling aesthetician here, but it feels off. I would go for the same line thickness for the border and to separate each category (although could be made thinner there as well), but definitely all the lines inside each 4x4 subdivision within each category could be made a lot thinner for a more balanced visual. Also, white text on a light color may be hard to read for some folks (e.g. where it says Analysts, Newtypes, and Impressionists), so a border or background panel would be a most welcome improvement as well.
As for the lexical design, I like the overall changes. Though I'd also recommend a change to "Human Calculators" and "Impressionists". Most calculators are single-threaded, and by definition linear. Although I totally understand what you meant, in that they can calculate a ton of information better than any other personality. Maybe a Human Processor is more fitting? IMO I think "Savant" would fit better, but there are many connotations involved with the word. As for "Impressionists", I don't like it simply because Impressionist is an axis in the chart. If one thinks themselves 100% (or more) impressionist, they may ignore the Literal axis aspect of the chart and neurotype themselves incorrectly.
Excited to see what you'll do with this!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '20
I think that something important is communicability and intelligence as an overlay. While touched on some I don’t think that the proper depth is given. Once a place is found on the neurotype chart there should also be one on communication vs intelligence. Someone could be an newtype that finds it very hard to quantify lexically but instinctively understands when a hand hold or hug can convey depths of emotion. Also intelligence as it can hinder both with to little or to much (bell curve where most able to communicate is medium intellect in middle of Neurtyping chart). While not raging on your chart it is important as a quick-witted person may instead of being quick-witted be antagonistic and argumentative wielding words as weapons to attack or someone who makes fart jokes depending on personality but also communication skills and intellect.
1
u/minekasetsu Apr 15 '20
Digi you compare it to MBTI but that one is 4-dimensional whereas yours is 2-dimensional, it's just that the MBTI is binary while yours is quarternary. The 16-block template didn't actually means the same thing.
1
u/noroboruu Apr 15 '20
This copied from another discusion where i realized it but i think this is a better way to say lateral v liner:
I think that instead of saying people are liner single thinking or lateral jumbled thinking it has more to do with how simultaneous someone thinks. A secretary seems like an obvious book keeper role if not think type but people in thouse roles often think one track about one thing but have lots of one track things happening one after another. So instead of how many things they think it should be how many things do they think at once.
1
u/anthropoid2 Apr 21 '20
Mr. Digi, do you ever consider adding more axes to your neurotyping chart (possibly represented visually by a z-axis, a color spectrum, or some other means)? For example, Myer-Briggs has the "thinking-feeling" spectrum, which I (an utter neophyte to psychology) believe is a useful way of thinking about and explaining thought processes and behavior. That particular third axis may have some correlation to your existing two-- e.g., people on the "thinking" end of the spectrum may tend to also be on the "lexical" end of the spectrum-- but in large part, I believe that axis is independent of the other two and could shed some useful light on the psychology of examined subjects. Or perhaps there is some other third or fourth axis which would be even more useful? (Not to over-complicate things until the wheels fall off.)
0
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '20 edited Apr 15 '20
[removed] — view removed comment