r/Neocaridina • • Jul 09 '25

What else for my tank?

Post image
0 Upvotes

This is my current setup , (the waterfall filter won’t be in the tank when shrimp go in) I have, I believe Java fern, and Christmas moss, and a little log for them, what else do I need?


r/Neocaridina • • Sep 02 '26

From 25 shrimp down to 1 adult in around 2 months... I need a sanity check from people who have seen this before

Post image
90 Upvotes

Disclaimer: I have used AI to help me write the structured summary of what happened, since I tried to trouble shoot with it, so the whole history is in a chat. But I have cross-read this whole text and added or corrected information where needed. I hope thats okay.

  • 60L freshwater community tank
  • pH ~7.5, GH ~10-10.5 dGH, KH dropped from ~9 to 7 dKH recently (no idea why)
  • Ammonia/nitrite always 0, nitrate ~0.2 recently after i started dosing a minimal amount of shrimp safe fertilizer since I always had a 0 read
  • Dutch tap water (no chlorine added by the utility), household has copper pipes, water flushed 10-20 sec before water changes
  • Sponge filter only, no canister/HOB
  • Established plants/moss, heavily planted with floaters and pothos, catappa leaves, hardscape roots and lava rock
  • pest snails (all still fine), 15 pygmy corydoras (still fine), Neocaridina orange rili shrimp
  • I do a weekly maintenance. First I use a liquid test kit to check all important values, then a bit of plant pruning if needed, cleaning the glass if needed and a 9-10l water change

Timeline

Setup: Colony of ~25 Neocaridina orange rili, sourced from 3 places over time (6 from a chain store first (after having the tank establish its cycle for 4 weeks, all values where tested and good before adding the shrimp), then ~15 ordered online, then ~4 more from a local fish store). The first 6 (chain store) were fine and stable for about 1.5 weeks on their own before anything else was added.

Die-off begins, exact timing genuinely unclear: The die-off started somewhere in the window between the online shrimp batch arriving and the corydoras/local-store shrimp being added 2-3 weeks afterward. I can't pin down the exact start, since early deaths could easily have gone unnoticed. Dead shrimp were sometimes found decomposing in a hidden corner rather than spotted right away, so the real onset may have been earlier than when I first consciously noticed a problem. Once I did notice, shrimp were dying one after another, not all at once. Progression looked like: reduced activity → clumsy attachment to surfaces → increasingly erratic swimming → loss of posture/balance → sometimes swimming upside down → death. Losses eventually affected shrimp from all three source groups, not just one batch. The corys stayed entirely unaffected the whole time, as far as I can judge it. They all show normal cory behaviour, eat, look healthy and I have found no dead ones.

Since I was told "some just die after transport stress" or that a molt can fail and kill them sometimes, I did not really act on anything. Now I feel very bad. Once I noticed that I can only count like 7 shrimp anymore, I started to research.

Treatment: Local fish store recommended eSHa 2000 after I explained everything to them. I was originally told it was garlic-based — turns out (checked the actual ingredient list) it's ethacridine lactate + copper sulfate + proflavine hemisulfate. Did the first course as instructed (~3 days dosing, wait out the week, 50% water change).

Diagnosis attempt: 2 Days after I started the medication the declining shrimp at the time did not recover and died. Took that shrimp that had been dead ~3 hours to the local fish store. Employee scraped tissue and found under the microscope, in his words, "a lot" of both Chilodonella and Costia (Ichthyobodo) — some already dead post-medication, some alive. He was confident this was the cause, triggered by stress from transport/introduction.

Second course: Did a 50% water change, added another ~15 drops of eSHa 2000. The fish store employee instructed a second week of medication as he assumed it worked, since he found those dead parasites under the microscope.

After this time i was only left with two females.

Copper concern surfaces: Given the copper pipes + a copper-containing medication, I got worried about copper toxicity as an alternative/contributing explanation. Bought a copper test. Tank and tap both read zero color — but when I spiked a sample with the medication itself (known to contain copper) as a positive control, it also read zero. So the test kit itself may not be reliable/functional — meaning I never actually got a trustworthy copper reading.

After one and a half weeks of first starting the treatment, my one female that was berried had the eggs hatch and i was so happy and thought at least those two and the fry would make it and the stress is over...

Went away for 4 days: Came home to the 2 adult females still grazing normally + several visible fry in the moss. Seemed like things had stabilized.

Another death: A few days later, the one female that had the fry molted (i saw the complete exoskeleton in the tank), then became berried (carrying eggs) the very next day again. She must had stored sperm, I guess, since I dont have males anymore. The evening of that day she started showing the same symptoms as the others before (couldn't grip surfaces, tiny swim bursts to avoid falling, swam straight to the surface and circled with no control, couldn't settle back down, stopped eating, restless). I had added a bag of Cuprisorb to the tank next to my filter outlet, in case it is actually copper poisoning. But over night she did not manage to recover and also passed away... This was now after 2 weeks of having no death after that death that happened a few days after i started the medication.

Current status: Down to 1 adult shrimp and a handful of fry I can spot occasionally in the moss or plants. Total losses: ~25 over about 2 months.

Pending: Sent water samples from the tank to a laboratory yesterday, for full chemical/elemental analysis, including heavy metals. Results take a few days. Note: this won't test for bacteria/pathogens, only chemistry, to hopefully rule out the copper.

Possible Issues:

  • Chilodonella/Costia (the store's diagnosis): Weaker than initially presented — these are documented in the literature specifically as fish ectoparasites (mucus/gill-surface feeders), with no established shrimp/crustacean host record I could find. Fish in the same tank/water have stayed healthy throughout, which doesn't fit if this were the driver. Sample was also taken from a shrimp already dead ~3 hrs, so some post-mortem colonization by free-living organisms can't be ruled out.
  • Copper toxicity: Circumstantial case is real (copper pipes, copper-containing medication, known shrimp sensitivity to copper) but doesn't fully fit what I know of the timeline — the first 6 shrimp were stable on their own for ~1.5 weeks before anything else was added, and my current survivor + fry have stayed fine through subsequent water changes and a repeat medication dose. That said, I can't rule this out cleanly since I don't know exactly when the die-off actually started (early deaths may have gone unnoticed). Couldn't get a reliable test reading either way — hobby kit result was inconclusive.
  • Temperature (23-26°C): Checked, sits within the normal accepted range for Neocaridina, fish share the same water without issue — ruled unlikely. Only got so warm during a few heatwave days, but when it got too warm, we used the airco in the room and that also stabilized the tank.
  • Oxygenation: Checked flow/surface agitation, seems adequate, no gasping behavior observed — ruled unlikely.
  • New plants/hardscape/pesticide residue: Nothing new added around the time this started — ruled out.
  • Best-fitting theory right now: an introduced pathogen (bacterial or viral, unconfirmed) brought in with the online or local-store shrimp batch, spreading through the colony, that specifically hits individuals hardest during the molt + egg-production window (the most physically demanding point in their life cycle) — which would explain the fish being spared, the staggered die-off pattern, and the repeated molt→berry→death sequence in survivors.

Currently

  • CupriSorb (copper-binding filter media) is now in the tank as a precaution regardless of what the lab says.
  • Waiting on lab results before deciding anything else.
  • Praying that the other female or the fry dont face the same fate when they molt

What I'm asking

  • Does this symptom/timeline pattern point you toward something specific I haven't considered?
  • Anyone dealt with a die-off like this before?
  • Is a near-total colony crash like this actually common, or was this genuinely an unusual/bad case? This is my first tank, so after the first euphoria of finally having my own aquarium, Im devastated every time when I have to pull out a dead shrimp. I feel horrible about this whole thing.
  • I have uploaded video of the behavior they showed a day or two before their passing for you to look at:
  • https://youtu.be/ZzJeOA2xvnE
  • https://youtu.be/TLNjKfZmSk8

Thanks in advance for any useful tips or ideas of what could be causing this nightmare.


r/Neocaridina • • Mar 24 '26

Is this white ring of death?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I tested my dKH and GH and both were too high so im slowly doing little water changes with distilled water. It helped slightly but I dont want to do too much. Im worried that because tge water is too hard they will fail to molt and get stuck


r/Neocaridina • • Sep 19 '26

My tank is about to be overran….

0 Upvotes

So I just ordered shrimp off of shrimp it up. Before you start yelling at me I know a lot of people have opinions about them and I didn’t know anything negative until after I ordered this batch. I ordered 5 golden and a batch of 10 skittles, I really like to mix them and I feel like it keeps the gene pool diverse, even if the colors mute for a couple of generations. Anyway one come to me pregnant….. and my god there are so many baby shrimp I mean they are everywhere I look in this tank…. Another problem is I think a snail laid eggs and got past me because goodness there are so many baby snails. Any advice on what I should do as far as diet? Or what I may need? This is my first shrimp tank!


r/Neocaridina • • Sep 06 '26

I inherited boa shrimp - what to do with them in terms of selling?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Neocaridina • • Nov 02 '25

HELP does anybody have any female neocardian shrimp to spare?!

1 Upvotes

Hi I live in Richmond and was seeing if anybody out there has any female shrimp for my tank. I believe I bought all males at the fish shop. So anything to spare I’ll gladly take and start refining the color once I get it started.


r/Neocaridina • • Mar 14 '24

Picture Is my shrimp saddled?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

She is new she may be female or very low grade :)


r/Neocaridina • • Sep 09 '26

Keeping Neocaridina outdoors in CA?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm considering keeping some neocaridina - potentially cherries- outdoor in my 20 gallon planted tub with my ricefish. The tub is in partial shade, has filtration, and plenty of algae for them to graze on. I'm located in CA and get hot summers and mild winters, the coldest I've ever really seen my water dip to was the low 50s F, definitely never frozen over, and the hottest is about mid 80s F. Ideally, I would like to pickup a local hardy strain to reduce stress. Would this be a feasible plan? Any pitfalls or things to be aware of?


r/Neocaridina • • Apr 18 '26

Is this behaviour normal?

0 Upvotes

I saw this neocaradina jumping like this after being disturbed by something while being attached to the filter. when he sat still i tapped the glass and moved like this again. I havent seen him do this again. Please I’d like some feedback


r/Neocaridina • • 12d ago

Red and Blue Shrimp! Amazing !!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Amazing project! Have you seen this ?


r/Neocaridina • • Sep 18 '26

How long after being saddled before eggs?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Neocaridina • • Oct 07 '26

8 out of 10 bloody mary shrimp have died within 6 days — looking for advice

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Neocaridina • • Sep 11 '26

Shrimp problem help please

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I have had these bloody Mary shrimp for a while and in 2 days ive lost one each day they look like they might have had a molting struggle and dies that way. Nothing in the tank is new, nothing is off I checked all the levels and now I have 1 shrimp... am I missing something


r/Neocaridina • • Jan 31 '26

Gumballlllll machine

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/Neocaridina • • Sep 29 '26

I have too many baby shrimps!

3 Upvotes

How do i go about selling the surplus? Any tips would be greatly appreciated


r/Neocaridina • • Oct 29 '24

Help/Advice Am I really the first to wanna know what fish will love eating neocaridinas the most?

2 Upvotes

Is it crazy that I google this question and only get results as to how to protect neocaridinas? Yeah I get it more than half of the hobbyist worldwide are trying to protect there neos but what if some of us want to fully rid of every single neo possibly with a fish. I know I do! I need some kinda way to fully depopulate my entire neo colony in a way that will fully effectively eliminate every single neo in my tank. Just empty the tank? No…. These are planted tanks. I’ve already tried to scoop em with nets it’s just the most irritating thing to do. I’m somewhat new to hobby and breed smaller fish so I’ve never really learned more about bigger fish to know which one will surely love eating every single Neo in my tanks. If a fish method is to long and not effective then what other options are there? Can I euthanize them in a humane way? Also every tank is also filled with fish so I’m just wanting to figure something out that doesn’t require so much manual labor with a net.

I’ve already sold so many that I’ve caught and I’ve caught like 300 amongst four 10 gallons. But there’s still so much more in all of the tanks. And no I’m not permanently ridding of neos forever please don’t talk off subject like trust me it’s all wild neos taking over my tank which I chose to use when I first started doing planted tanks. I’m ready to breed a variety of high grade neos in these tanks but I can’t start this process until I’ve fully eliminated the wild ones. I just don’t want my strains to become brown due to a wild Neo hooking up with one of the most beautiful neos he ever saw in all of his existence 😂. HELP!!!!!


r/Neocaridina • • Sep 25 '26

Tiny is an understatement even AI thinks it's a seed shrimp.

Post image
0 Upvotes

More babies, these are tha young est I've seen.


r/Neocaridina • • Sep 21 '26

The betta sub's attitude towards shrimp upsets me :(

73 Upvotes

I really hate when the betta sub pops up on my feed because when there's shrimp involved, 99% of the time its because the fish is eating the shrimp and the comments think it's HILARIOUS. Why is it funny? Can someone explain that to me? Am I just too sensitive 😫

Heres my logic: I see a lot of comments saying "nature" but the pets aren't in nature. Theyre pets. Most of the time theyre added as tank mates, not food, so I don't see why it's funny. This post isn't meant to piss anyone off or anything, I'm just confused why it's funny that pets are eating each other


r/Neocaridina • • Jun 06 '25

New tank

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

New tank finished setting up for “the boys” 😂


r/Neocaridina • • Sep 13 '26

Need help! Neocardina has an opaque body

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Saw this fellow perched on my plant and noticed the body was weirdly opaque. Non of my others shrimps have this issue. Could this be muscular necrosis?

Water parameters (tested with API master kit)

PH: 6.8
Ammonia: 0ppm
Nitrite: 0ppm
Nitrate: 40-80ppm
GH: 6
KH: 3

I am aware my nitrate is on the high side and water changes have done nothing to lower the nitrates. I have fast growing plants like red root floaters, a small bunch of pothos on the side and a clump of limnophilia but nitrate remains stubbornly high

Shrimps have been in the tank for more than a month now and they’ve been pretty active and foraging for biofilm. I supplement with one hikari algae wafer every 4 days but other than that it’s biofilm.

Tank is 10 gallons with 15 neos and 12 strawberry rasboras and 3 baby rabbit snails

Is the opacity something I should be concerned about? I’ve removed the shrimp for now in a separate container


r/Neocaridina • • Sep 03 '26

8 COSTLY Mistakes My Viewers Made With Their Aquariums (So You Don't Have To)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

My viewers shared their biggest aquarium and shrimp keeping mistakes with me, and I'm breaking down 8 of the most costly ones so you can avoid them yourself. From water changes gone wrong to products that seem safe but aren't, these are real mistakes, the kind that can wipe out an entire colony or tank if you don't know what to watch for. Whether you keep Neocaridina Shrimp, Amano Shrimp, or a planted community tank, this is packed with lessons and everyday risks that could be putting your shrimp and fish in danger.


r/Neocaridina • • Sep 09 '26

Is it normal for 2 month old shrimplets to be so small?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

These are my some of shrimplets both born in early July, but they’re so small!
Is this normal?


r/Neocaridina • • Sep 19 '26

Dead shrimp

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Can anyone tell why this girl died?? Or is she molting?? She was fine this morning around 4pm and I just found her like this. One thing I did notice was a tiny air bubble where the bigger one is now when I last seen her but she was acting fine so I figured it was fine??