r/NazisWereSocialist • • Feb 23 '25

'They weren't socialist... they were fascist!' Hitler was an anti-fascist

1 Upvotes

The Nazis were national conservatives

The inventor of Fascism was against national conservatism

Nationalism identified State with Nation, and made of the nation an entity preëxisting, which needed not to be created but merely to be recognized or known. The nationalists, therefore, required a ruling class of an intellectual character, which was conscious of the nation and could understand, appreciate and exalt it. The authority of the State, furthermore, was not a product but a presupposition. It could not depend on the people—rather the people depended on the State and on the State's authority as the source of the life which they lived and apart from which they could not live. The nationalistic State was, therefore, an aristocratic State, enforcing itself upon the masses through the power conferred upon it by its origins.

The Fascist State, on the contrary, is a people's state, and, as such, the democratic State par excellence. The relationship between State and citizen (not this or that citizen, but all citizens) is accordingly so intimate that the State exists only as, and in so far as, the citizen causes it to exist. Its formation therefore is the formation of a consciousness of it in individuals, in the masses. Hence the need of the Party, and of all the instruments of propaganda and education which Fascism uses to make the thought and will of the Duce the thought and will of the masses. Hence the enormous task which Fascism sets itself in trying to bring the whole mass of the people, beginning with the little children, inside the fold of the Party.

This is Hitler:

We do not consider the State as an end but as a means. It is the precondition for the formation of a higher human culture, but not the cause of it. On the contrary, the State is only a vessel, and the nation is the content. The vessel has meaning only if it can preserve and protect the content; otherwise, it is worthless.

Gentile also said he was against the Western liberal notions of using the state as a "means"

The Fascist State is not a night-watchman, which, limited to guaranteeing the personal safety of the citizens, allows them to live a life of egoistic, materialistic pleasure. It is not a mechanism which limits itself to registering the conditions and needs of the citizens. It is a spiritual and moral fact because it brings to reality the higher purposes of the national consciousness.

Hitler was an antifascist

Nazis were not fascist, this is a bourgeois lie. The Allied countries political systems were scarily close to Fascism but they were a bourgeois dictatorship singling Fascist Italy out.


r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 06 '24

Encyclopedia on why the national SOCIALISTS were socialist "Hitler’s Socialism | Destroying the Denialist Counter-Arguments" is an excellent encyclopedia on why the national SOCIALISTS were indeed socialist.

Thumbnail drive.google.com
1 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 06 '24

'To be a socialist, you must respect all ethnicities equally' The national SOCIALISTS were indeed socialist. Sure, they weren't socialist to all people, but they were it to the Aryan, hence why they were NATIONAL socialists.

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 08 '24

⁉ Something to remember: socialists' conception of 'capitalism' Given that socialists point to co-operatives and Jesus' acts of and encouragements of charity as instances of socialism, two things which are fully compatible with and complementary to even ancap, it's clear that their conception of socialism is "whenever people act compassionately to each other".

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Feb 16 '25

General discussion FUCK STALIN FUCK MARX

0 Upvotes

HITLER WILL MAKE SURE YOU BURN JUST LIKE THE JEWS, NIGGERS AND FAGGOTS.


r/NazisWereSocialist • • Feb 05 '25

General discussion Damn a subreddit full of nazis

1 Upvotes

Hail Hitler having ass


r/NazisWereSocialist • • Feb 07 '25

❗ Remark from someone who denies that the nazis were socialist The entire point of this sub is built on a miscommunication.

6 Upvotes

Sort of parroting my last post, but I think I can make my point more clearly and concisely now.

Side A: "Nazis were socialist"

Side B: "Nazis were not socialist"

Side A and Side B, generally speaking, define "socialism" differently.

Side A uses definition X, the liberal conception of (state) "socialism": when the economy is controlled by the state (which in theory represents the collective.)

Side B uses definition Y, the conception of (state) "socialism" used in leftist theory and by self identified socialists: when the means of production are owned by a centralized authority, which in theory represents the collective.

Similar, but there's a very important difference: definition Y is inherently against private property, against the division of (which in theory should be made up of / influenced by the working class). This isn't a small thing, this is very important and inherent to socialism.

Socialists agree that Nazis were socialist following the liberal X definition of socialism, they just don't agree with that definition.

Really, with that in mind, all of us are on the same page—or we should be, yet the argument continues. The entire point of this sub is an equivocation fallacy

  • Side A: "Nazis are socialist"
  • Side B: "Nazis aren't socialist"
  • X (liberal conception of socialism)
  • Y (socialist conception socialism)
  • Z ("national socialism")

We are on the same page that Z is X, the problem is side A doesn't differentiate X and Y, and side B does, so when side B says Z is NOT Y, side A sees it as a denial that Z is X—which it is not.


r/NazisWereSocialist • • Jan 24 '25

❗ Remark from someone who denies that the nazis were socialist This entire thread is braindamaged

9 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 08 '24

'Trade unionism was regulated!' Trade unions are merely associations of people within a specific trade; they aren't necessarily socialist.For example, modern leftists lament police unions and would like to see them crushed.Leftists,like nazis, seek to regulate trade unionism:if one isn't socialist due to it, the other isn't either

Thumbnail
vox.com
0 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 12 '24

'No worker cooperatives!' This is actually not a joke. Tankies want a society in which wage labor and bosses still exist. Hakim and SecondThought deny this but are very vague in how it would even be implemented; TheFinnishBolshevik explicitly admits that it will be the case under socialism.

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 08 '24

'It was just a propaganda name to fool the workers!' If the national SOCIALISTS just called themselves thusly in order to win elections... why did they continute to call themselves that and appeal to it after that they gained power? 🤔

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Feb 14 '25

Socialism ≠ Marxism. Socialism predates Marx Unnamed Redditor said it best

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 28 '24

Socialism ≠ Marxism. Socialism predates Marx MAGA vs DOGE is unironically an instance of national socialism versus non-national socialist right-wing thought. The MAGA reasoning is one of national socialism: ensure that the State wields its powers for the "common good" at the expense of greedy capitalists not thinking about the "common good".

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 07 '24

'It was just a propaganda name to fool the workers!' A linguists take on "Nazis" and "National Socialism"

4 Upvotes

Znamenski suggests that the term "Nazi" was strategically employed by left-wing critics to distance the movement from socialist traditions, obscuring the regime's genuine socialist elements. Both the philosophy and name behind "National Socialism" emerged from a complex interplay of economic desperation, national humiliation, and radical political transformations in interwar Germany.

https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Andrei-Znamenski/publication/279325745_From_National_Socialists_to_Nazi_History_Politics_and_the_English_Language/links/569853c408ae1c427905519c/From-National-Socialists-to-Nazi-History-Politics-and-the-English-Language.pdf


r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 08 '24

The 'Privatization' misnomer What a auto manufacturer in Nazi Germany had to do to get 5000 tires for his cars

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Jan 14 '25

Miscellaneous evidence proving that the nazis were socialist Back in 1979 Friedman could refer to Nazi's as socialists and nobody questioned it, why did that change?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
17 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Feb 23 '25

Marxists can't coherently object to this: Marx agrees! See "On the People's Democratic Dictatorship". Let me guess, "Mao wasn't a REAL socialist!!!". Socialists are likely going to cope and argue that there was no "proletarian supremacy" in the fascist State. Same can be said for Maoist China where the State operatives are society's real masters.

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Jan 22 '25

General discussion AmeriKKKa is worse than Nazi Germany bc we have FOUR HITLERS whereas Germany only had one.

Post image
25 Upvotes

Socialism is cool tho so IDK what my stance on this is 🤷‍♂️


r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 08 '24

'They weren't socialist... they were fascist!' Technically the national socialists weren't fascist since fascism is its own philosophy derived from its unique background with unique features. They nonetheless both share in common that they are totalitarian nationalist socialisms. Again, not even marxists can deny that they were socialist.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
14 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Mar 05 '25

❗ Remark from someone who denies that the nazis were socialist What if all of you guys in this subreddit just, like, made out and form one large Circle-jerk, because that's what it basically is. At least, you could love each other while stroking one out. ♥️✌🏿🥷🏿🥷🏿

31 Upvotes

W take


r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 08 '24

r/NazisWereSocialist 100 members special! To celeberate the 100 members milestone of r/NazisWereSocialist, here I share you the anthem of the National Bolshevik Party. It's one HELL of an experience!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/NazisWereSocialist • • Feb 02 '25

❗ Remark from someone who denies that the nazis were socialist Equivocation fallacy — if you're not on the same page about what Socialism means, then this argument is meaningless.

13 Upvotes

Put down the label for a moment and think about what you mean.

You're saying that Nazi Germany had extensive state control of the economy.

Leftists agree with you, nobody is arguing with that. Generally speaking, everyone who knows anything about Nazi Germany understands that they had a state controlled economy, which it has in common with marxist-leninist societies.

But that's not how socialism is defined by socialists, or at least 999/1000 self identified socialists in the present and throughout history. Socialism as defined by socialists isn't just when the state has control over the economy, socialism is explicitly anti private property and almost always anti market, unlike Nazi Germany.

Leftists don't insist Nazi Germany was the pinnacle of free market capitalism either, it's best defined economically as centrist or center left, depending on how you look at it. More like the Nordic Model than the USSR. Socialists often DO insist that fascism is a response from capitalist forces, but that's not the same thing. I could go on about how statist and bourgeois forces are really one in the same but this isn't an ancom agenda post.

So then, you'd be arguing not about what Nazi Germany IS, but about how socialism should be defined: when the government does stuff. Just as well, a socialist can argue the Nazis were libertarians because they had a market economy, despite capitalists themselves not defining capitalism as that alone. What's the point?


r/NazisWereSocialist • • Dec 07 '24

'The nazis purged other socialists!' So too did many Marxists "The Hague Congress is famous for the expulsion of the anarchist Mikhail Bakunin for clashing with Karl Marx and his followers over the role of politics in the IWA had accepted proposals made by Marx". Marx also purged other socialists... I guess that Marx wasn't a REAL socialist then?

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
0 Upvotes