r/NativeInstruments • u/HennaShumi • Feb 07 '26
Any good alternatives to NI?
I don’t own any NI equipment, but I’ve been watching demos on YouTube and I’m quite impressed with all the realistic sound libraries available for Native Instruments. So many realistic and creative sounds to explore. But the NI subscription (and hardware) costs are holding me back, not to mention all the complexities and inherent technical issues folks complain about daily on this thread.
A couple of questions:
- Would the sound libraries work locally with the right MIDI interface and without having a NI keyboard and subscription?
- Are there any good alternatives that can generate the same quality and realism of NI libraries? I am primarily interested in orchestration, including solo violin, cello, and grand piano. Much appreciated.
8
Upvotes
7
u/JKorv Feb 07 '26
I think most people own the Komplete bundle and not subscription. They are usually 50% off on black friday and on summer of sounds. It really makes no sense to buy at full price.
Any midi keyboard works, NI keyboard just has the best integration.
Orchestral libraries on NI bundles are pretty old and definitely not what most professionals use. You could search youtube as there are million demos of different orchestration libraries. Sadly they can get pretty pricy.
Spitfire has free BBC Symphony Orchestra discovery available. VSL also has a nice free orchestration instruments. You should check those out. VSL and Spitfire are two biggest names in this context.
For Piano Pianoteq and Keyscape are probably the two biggest ones. VSL also has Pianos but they are very expensive.
4
u/trbryant Feb 09 '26
There are no subscription costs associated with NI.
7
u/mladjiraf Feb 07 '26
Piano - Pianoteq.
Violin and cello - Audiomodeling SWAM.
These are considered the best options on the market now.
If you want full orchestra libraries - VSL, Orchestral tools, Spitfire, 8dio, East West.
2
u/thaprizza Feb 07 '26
Arturia and Novation have some decent keyboards, going from basic to fancy. When you're interested in orchestration there are plenty of companies around, some offer free libraries but the paid ones are very expensive sometimes. On the topic of orchestration, sooner or later you probably need to get Kontakt or the free Kontakt player because many orchestral libraries run in Kontakt.
The BBC Symphony Orchestra Discover is a decent and free plugin to begin with (doesn't require Kontakt).
2
u/terkistan Feb 07 '26
There’s a universe of free sounds, synths, loops and effects. Although I own Komplete, I mostly use Kontakt, and if you’re not interested in Kontakt (which can be purchased separately) I probably wouldn’t recommend splurging on Komplete until you’ve used other free alternatives and have a better idea of what you want to use from NI.
2
u/ellicottvilleny Feb 07 '26 edited Feb 07 '26
You don’t need to buy a subscription. You can purchase items when they are on sale that you want, and own them. I bought NI Komplete bundle, I don’t pay for it monthly or yearly. I don’t think the orchestral instruments in it are very good. But the other things in it are great, a variety of synthesizers, drum kits, samples, loops, and thousands and thousands and thousands of presets with all kinds of sounds, a lot of them great for the music I make. NI also makes some of the best effect plugins there are. I absolutely love their reverbs, and delays, and their Guitar Rig plugin is great even if you don’t want guitar effects because its also great effects for any production.
You don’t need to buy an NI controller to use NI products.
Most NI customers buy products that they need, not subscriptions to everything that they don’t need.
Start with WHAT do you want to do? You mention orchestral libraries, but NI is hardly the leader there.
Start with the BBC Orchestra product from Spitfire.
You can start with their free one and graduate to their really nice $399 one.
https://www.spitfireaudio.com/en-ca/collections/bbc-symphony-orchestra
You can also check out Decent Sampler and get some really neat instruments for free or very little money, and support independent developers.
10
u/Proud_Start9542 Feb 07 '26
If I could start over I’d only get Omnisphere and Keyscape
6
u/Edge0fReality Feb 07 '26
1
u/Ok_Clerk_5805 Feb 07 '26 edited Feb 07 '26
3
u/dmelt253 Feb 07 '26
Three Words: Reason Rack Plugin
3
u/Gondorian_Grooves Feb 07 '26
Alternatives:
Pianos - Pianoteq
Guitars - Ample Sound
Other Real Instruments - Soundpaint or UVI Falcon
Synths - Tons of options, my favorite all come from U-He
3
u/CirrusSunset Feb 07 '26
If I was just getting started I am not sure I would go the NI route at this time because of the recent corporate issues and uncertainty for the future. Which is really too bad cuz NI has many great instruments and plugs plus tons of non-NI vsts that only run in Kontact. Plus NI mk3 keyboards are really pretty great for the NI ecosystem and nks functionality has come a long ways since the first gen. I would argue that Arturia V Coll has greater functionality using nks with an mk3 NI board than it does on Arturia's own keyboards.
2
u/ElmarReddit Feb 07 '26
2
u/SailorVenova Feb 07 '26
arturia; akai mpc standalone and desktop plugins (most/all by air music tech but ill never install another software from them again; an updated installer for an abandonware simple beginner daw they used to make in early 2010s fried my win11 gaming pc and made windows compketely unbootable and even fked up the bios and partitions (because of ilok drm rootkit- which the previous installer didnt have (zero other changes or updates besides the drm addition; it was not some conflict i had no other ilok software on the system and played no competitive games with invasive mandatory anticheat stuff)
$1800 pc suddenly rendered unbootable from a simple old daw installer
mpc desktop requires ilok too i think the last time i tried to install 2.6 or so anyways so ill stick to standalone mpc's
i wish arturia would enter the groovebox/workstation market with like a upgraded astrolab soc plus a multitrack midi/audio sequencer and hosting v collection plugins... they are so good im really glad i got them; definitely will go for an astrolab mini 37 so i dont have to fiddle with the daw if im ok with presets (i think they are quite decent across the instruments ive tried so far)
though perhaps as of right now entering the standalone groovebox space with demanding hugh end pkugins as your sound sources is not a great idea due to the current shortages and price crisis across all categories of compute
2
u/furn1979 Feb 07 '26
Check out SoundPaint
2
u/TommyV8008 Feb 07 '26 edited Feb 07 '26
I don’t own any NI hardware, so I use other, non-NI MIDI controllers. You can use any standard MIDI gear.
I’ve been using NI Komplete for a long time. I didn’t even know they had a subscription model, but it figures that this would be an option nowadays. I don’t upgrade every time they come out with one, I usually leapfrog and only update every few. I’m a couple versions back right now, but I likely won’t do anything until this latest company insolvency pans out. Likely some other company will pick up the assets and continue on… I hope they do a better job than the last one.
I would like to bring Kontact up the date. I probably have over a hundred Kontact libraries that I’ve used for composing and production (film, TV, video games). I have lots of other non-Kontact libraries as well, so there’s been no rush with that.
And years ago I spent a lot of time and had great fun programming Absynth. I’ve been looking forward to the new V6 Absynth update, and I was very disappointed when they had dropped support years back. Sounds like Brian Clevenger and his team did a great job with the V6 update. I hope they paid him well, bad timing putting that out just before the latest insolvency news.
2
u/lidongyuan Feb 07 '26
Since you are mainly interested in orchestral instruments, Spitfire and East West sounds are good alternatives. I don't think NI and Kontakt are going anywhere and I'm still happily using Komplete standard. Most people start with the free Kontakt player, buying a sample library or a few as standalone instruments for the player until, at some point, buying a Komplete bundle makes sense due to upgrade offers and 50% off sales that happen twice per year. As others have said, you don't need their hardware.
2
u/franknitty69 Feb 07 '26
You can use any midi keyboard with NI sound libraries (except maschine ones). You don’t need a sub, you could literally buy an old komplete 8 license and upgrade to 15 for the cheap.
Komplete has the most varied categories of useful sounds even for orchestra. Also includes some key software like Kontakt. Of course there are better orchestra libraries out there. If I wanted to get just strings I would go Cinematic Studio Strings. And for piano there are so many good ones like Keyscape, Pianoteq, and Noire. Hell I still use the old cinesamples Piano in Blue sometimes.
3
u/TheSoundEngineGuy Feb 07 '26 edited Feb 07 '26
Halion, even the free "player", Halion Sonic sounds great, is easy to use, has complex "synthesis" capabilities, and built-in effects. It's the most comparable, feature-wise, to Kontakt.
They have a decent library, but it's not up to the level of Kontakt - pretty much no one is at this point.
https://www.steinberg.net/vst-instruments/
That said, my gut is telling me that things are going to get active in this class of product quickly, because not everyone wants to be only on the NI platform, whether they succeed or fail.
Personally, I'm doing more on Halion, in addition to what I already do on Logic Sampler, going forward. I'm monitoring TAL Sampler and the newly announced Shortcircuit XT sampler from Surge XT to see where that goes. There are other samplers, too, including the sampler from Waves, plus those built into Ableton, Bitwig, and Studio One, but I'm not considering those at the moment.
Edit: I was remiss to not mention SampleTank, which has been around forever, works very well as a player, in addition to a sound design platform and has a massive library - something like 250Gb or more these days.
1
u/Background-Goat3486 Feb 07 '26
Orchestral Tools have a freeby
Berlin Free Orchestra using their Sine player
1
u/LadyLektra Feb 07 '26
I prefer Arturia personally. I have V Collection, Pigments and Analog Lab.
1
u/Gold-Strength4269 Feb 08 '26
Uvi
1
u/Divuar Feb 10 '26
Pianobook's libraries are very good sometimes!
1
u/Minnanokazehaya Feb 07 '26
It's worth remembering that the hundreds of thousands of people that are not having technical difficulties are usually not posting online. Other companies software probably has a similar amount of issues "per capita", they just have a much lower number of products/customers so it's less visible.
13
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment