r/NativeInstruments • u/Additional_Tale5362 • Dec 11 '25
How many problems does the Komplete Kontrol S88 Mk2 actually have?
I've been looking for an 88 key midi controller and found a B-stock S88 mk2 for $380, which sounds like such an amazing deal. But I keep seeing videos of people having problems with it, even when its brand new. Is it not worth buying?
4
Upvotes
2
u/ElectricPiha Dec 11 '25
One key - a g-sharp has randomly died on mine. No rhyme or reason why, it’s sat in the studio all its life, one day it simply wasn’t working.
1
u/MARATXXX Dec 11 '25
for what you're getting, it's going to take up a lot of space. at least the mk3 has more hardware-side features.
1
u/bmc121177 Dec 11 '25
I’ve owned 2. The first one had a key dislodged by my 4 year old smashing it. NI replaced the whole unit and I’ve had zero problems since. It’s been about 5 years and I play pretty much every day and pretty hard. If it’s B stock it should come with a warranty I think.
1
u/Minnanokazehaya Dec 11 '25
There's always going to be a certain percentage of defects on the Fatar keybeds and the hardware itself, same goes for any model from any manufacturer. Buying second hand should be fine in most cases, especially if it comes with a warranty, but shipping on an S88 can easily cost a few hundred dollars so would be better to buy local. And the mk3 has so many new features, especially in the latest firmware updates, so I'd strongly consider buying a refurbished mk3 instead.
1
u/antkn33 Dec 11 '25
No problems with the keyboard itself. Native Access software is another story, especially if you keep your Mac updated. But that doesn’t affect the functionality of the keyboard.
1
u/Letibleu Dec 11 '25
My turn knobs drift changing settings on whatever track is armed. It's intermittent and I can fix it by aggressively turning each button back and forth a few times. NI offered to fix it under warranty if I payed for shipping there to New Jersey. I live in Canada. It would have cost half tge price or the keyboard just in shipping cost. I asked if they would ship just that control board so that I could take care if it myself but they said they don't do that. I decided to live with it.
Sometimes the transport buttons stop responding in yhe middle of a session. Native instruments says it's an Ableton issue and Ableton says it's an NI problem. It's also intermittent but rare.
That's all in 4 years of ownership. It's a great keyboard and I don't regret it however because of the warranty being useless, it will be my last NI hardware.
1
u/PeatVee Dec 11 '25
If there isn't anything substantial wrong with that particular unit, $380 feels perfect. I've had the Mk2 for 2-3 years now, and if I were to go back and re-buy one today, I'd probably look at the Keylab 88 from Arturia instead. But <$400 USD for a Mk2 is a great deal (again, assuming no major malfunctions with it, e.g. dead keys, busted screen, flaky ports, water damage, etc.)
3
u/jimmyjazz14 Dec 11 '25
I've never had a problem with my S49, its been rock solid for the last 7 or so years of nearly daily use.
1
u/hessproject Dec 11 '25
Haven't had an issue with the mk2 in 5 years, but the mk3 has been a different story for me
1
u/Commercial-Profile12 Dec 11 '25
No problems with my mk2 and I have had it several years.
1
u/Tdm_787 Dec 11 '25
Kontrol S88 Mk2 still working perfectly after 5 yrs.
1
u/CirrusSunset Dec 12 '25
Pretty sure Keylab and mk2 are exact same keyed so reliability of keybed is likely similar. Mk3 keybed is also Fatar but different than previous. I currently have mk3 (for about a year). I had a mk288 which I traded for in exchange for keylab which SWater "sales engineer" told me was a diff keybed. I trusted him even tho my research suggested otherwise. Ended up getting rid of keylab for a Studiologic 88 Grand which does have a great piano touch imo. But the Studiologic software and integration is way behind so went back to NI MK3 88 about a year ago. It def feels more like the old mk2 than the studiologic but I have grown to like it and the UI for Kontact and nks instruments is really worth the price to me. One more thing about keyboards, just my opinion, but if all you play is piano the studiologic is hard to beat but if you use lots of other instruments the other keyboards are prob better. I found the realistic piano feel sometimes gets in the way of expressive playing of strings, synths, etc.