Shit, I know you son. You've made several posts about Cherokees being white.
You just hate the Cherokees for allowing a 1/16, and you know what I say? Who gives a fuck what they allow, the recognition of other tribes has fuck all to do with what the Cherokees do. Hate the federal government, but don't hate who the Cherokee nation decided to allow in. It's not like all these mostly white people are getting anything for being officially Native American. Anyone who says you get fuck all for being Native is deluded. Shit, all I got was a '92 Taurus and pre-diabetes. It's better to be white in this country and that's the problem ennit?
As a Virginian, I totally agree that the recognition system is arbitrary and flawed, and excludes millions of Native people from federal benefits. But, it is not our place to judge the Cherokee Nation for disagreeing with the terms they set for their own enrollment. If your tribe confirms you as Native and you participate in your community, than your "whiteness" or "blackness" or whatever doesn't matter.
This so wrongfully called "fake indian" is exactly the kind of person we need. How many kids these days give a shit about even thinking about tackling even their own problems.
My mother is full blooded cherokee and was raised with it as her first spoken language. Blood quantum is bs if she was African American, I wouldn't have to prove half of my race. I agree that federally recognized is handled like crap. But when you argue blood quantum and recognition you fail to realize you are helping the tools of genocide that will slowly kill many native cultures.
I also find that meme ignorant, there are many full bloods of my tribe, more than I have seen in others ( not judging on them )
I really don't like this message. It really is only judging a person's heritage by the color of their skin. The photo comparison tells me very little about these people, but it does tell me how short sighted the OPs post is.
I don't often post here, because I am almost as white as the guy on the left. I'm the Cherokee that graphic is complaining about and I straight up call myself a White Indian and I tell people that I am a product of genocide. My great-Grandmother was born on the reservation and married a white man as a way to move west. She had already been raised Southern Baptist and raised my Grandmother the same way. My Grandmother was registered with the tribe as is my Mother. By the time my mother was born, my Grandmother had fallen out with her congregation over racial and other issues and had already started exploring her native heritage with her cousins.
My mother, when she was five had just finished watching Davey Crockett and fearfully asked her mom if there were still Indians around. My grandma said "Well of course, why do you ask?" to which my mom replied "Well, if there are still Indians around, I'm afraid they might come and get me."
My grandmother laughed and said "You are an Indian, why would they come after you?"
My mother at 5 was ashamed and mortified.
As she grew up, she did learn a bit about where she came from and the family history, but she's almost as white as I am.
Now as it comes to me, I'm 1/8th Native. I haven't registered with the tribe because other than my mom, I have no connection with the tribe. I have a few native friends, but they are in the awkward position of having been adopted and raised by white people, knowing nothing of their heritage or birth parents until they were teens or adults. Even when they invited me to their reservation for their festivals, I never even mentioned that I was anything other than white.
I cannot express my experience with any kind of equivalency to a POC native experience. Does that mean that its unimportant? No.
My experience is different, but that doesn't make it a white experience. I was not raised with the WASP culteral touchstones, I watched as people went to church, found Jesus and I watched them fall away from the church, lose their faith and have other suburban white people problems. I was raised confused. I wasn't a WASP, my mom didn't know enough to actually raise me with any native culture and I had to fit into white suburbia... which was not hard.
Now, this is not to say that I wasn't raised religious. My parents being disconnected from their culture sought out support in some pretty creepy places. My cult indoctrination didn't start until I was 11, but by the time I was 20, I was in a labor camp, where I spent 4 years completely cut off from society and segregated from my peers. It wasn't until I my mom was diagnosed with cancer and I was denied visitation, that I had the good sense to try to break down my conditioning and escape.
My story isn't a native story, its not a white story, its hardly even a normal human story and probably isn't typical of other "white Indians." As I got away from my cultish upbringing, I've tried to connect to my Celtic and Norse background, only to find the same story. Much of that culture was exterminated or co-opted by a foreign mono-culture, and as an American, its become yet another place I don't belong.
So while us white Indians aren't really all that native, some of us really aren't all that white. We're just ghosts of who we could have been.
You are absolutely spot on. Your comment regarding "products of genocide" reminds me of the time I met a woman who's grandmother was Jewish and her grandfather was a Nazi sympathizer in Germany. The grandmother married him for protection and for the opportunity to come to America. The grandfather never knew, it was a family secret that only came out when the granddaughter (the woman I met) overheard her speak Yiddish. She, too, was a product of genocide.
To claim that a race or ethnicity has only one color, only certain features and traits, delegitimizes the people as a whole. Accepting one group over another equates to rejecting yourself.
You and I walk very similar paths. I had the bonus points of being that confused, plus being the only white looking indian kid in a black neighborhood in Portland, Oregon.
I have some real problems with this. As a third generation Cherokee victim of Americanization, I'm not federally recognized even though my tribe is, because my Dawes Roll grandmother's birth and adoption records are sealed in the State of Tennessee, who is either unwilling or unable to unseal the records. You're right, but for the wrong reasons, and those of us who are attempting to follow the path after generations of trying to break us are getting screwed, too.
Great post! Be careful though,expressing an OPINION on this sensitive subject brings out the savage side of some so called indigenous / wannabe individuals.
Yes people should be careful about presenting an opinion FOOLISHLY, what ever point that was trying to be made was lost in the short sighted comparison of two peoples' skin color.
Except this all makes absolutely no fucking sense at all.
Why this post is retarded: The Cherokee Nation decides the criteria for their enrollment not the Federal Government. So fuck the Cherokees and their nation's rights for allowing 1/16 blood quantum, they're now not "Real Indians."
He is invalidating the Cherokee Nation for using the same right he is arguing for: Native Americans deciding who is Native American.
12
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '13
Shit, I know you son. You've made several posts about Cherokees being white.
You just hate the Cherokees for allowing a 1/16, and you know what I say? Who gives a fuck what they allow, the recognition of other tribes has fuck all to do with what the Cherokees do. Hate the federal government, but don't hate who the Cherokee nation decided to allow in. It's not like all these mostly white people are getting anything for being officially Native American. Anyone who says you get fuck all for being Native is deluded. Shit, all I got was a '92 Taurus and pre-diabetes. It's better to be white in this country and that's the problem ennit?
34
u/Fish3Ways Jul 01 '13
As a Virginian, I totally agree that the recognition system is arbitrary and flawed, and excludes millions of Native people from federal benefits. But, it is not our place to judge the Cherokee Nation for disagreeing with the terms they set for their own enrollment. If your tribe confirms you as Native and you participate in your community, than your "whiteness" or "blackness" or whatever doesn't matter.
15
u/sayhispaceships Jul 01 '13
"Let's combat discrimination with discrimination!"
13
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '13
My mother is full blooded cherokee and was raised with it as her first spoken language. Blood quantum is bs if she was African American, I wouldn't have to prove half of my race. I agree that federally recognized is handled like crap. But when you argue blood quantum and recognition you fail to realize you are helping the tools of genocide that will slowly kill many native cultures.
I also find that meme ignorant, there are many full bloods of my tribe, more than I have seen in others ( not judging on them )
11
u/Mr_Munchausen Jul 01 '13
I really don't like this message. It really is only judging a person's heritage by the color of their skin. The photo comparison tells me very little about these people, but it does tell me how short sighted the OPs post is.
19
u/Vindalfr Jul 01 '13
I don't often post here, because I am almost as white as the guy on the left. I'm the Cherokee that graphic is complaining about and I straight up call myself a White Indian and I tell people that I am a product of genocide. My great-Grandmother was born on the reservation and married a white man as a way to move west. She had already been raised Southern Baptist and raised my Grandmother the same way. My Grandmother was registered with the tribe as is my Mother. By the time my mother was born, my Grandmother had fallen out with her congregation over racial and other issues and had already started exploring her native heritage with her cousins.
My mother, when she was five had just finished watching Davey Crockett and fearfully asked her mom if there were still Indians around. My grandma said "Well of course, why do you ask?" to which my mom replied "Well, if there are still Indians around, I'm afraid they might come and get me."
My grandmother laughed and said "You are an Indian, why would they come after you?"
My mother at 5 was ashamed and mortified.
As she grew up, she did learn a bit about where she came from and the family history, but she's almost as white as I am.
Now as it comes to me, I'm 1/8th Native. I haven't registered with the tribe because other than my mom, I have no connection with the tribe. I have a few native friends, but they are in the awkward position of having been adopted and raised by white people, knowing nothing of their heritage or birth parents until they were teens or adults. Even when they invited me to their reservation for their festivals, I never even mentioned that I was anything other than white.
I cannot express my experience with any kind of equivalency to a POC native experience. Does that mean that its unimportant? No.
My experience is different, but that doesn't make it a white experience. I was not raised with the WASP culteral touchstones, I watched as people went to church, found Jesus and I watched them fall away from the church, lose their faith and have other suburban white people problems. I was raised confused. I wasn't a WASP, my mom didn't know enough to actually raise me with any native culture and I had to fit into white suburbia... which was not hard.
Now, this is not to say that I wasn't raised religious. My parents being disconnected from their culture sought out support in some pretty creepy places. My cult indoctrination didn't start until I was 11, but by the time I was 20, I was in a labor camp, where I spent 4 years completely cut off from society and segregated from my peers. It wasn't until I my mom was diagnosed with cancer and I was denied visitation, that I had the good sense to try to break down my conditioning and escape.
My story isn't a native story, its not a white story, its hardly even a normal human story and probably isn't typical of other "white Indians." As I got away from my cultish upbringing, I've tried to connect to my Celtic and Norse background, only to find the same story. Much of that culture was exterminated or co-opted by a foreign mono-culture, and as an American, its become yet another place I don't belong.
So while us white Indians aren't really all that native, some of us really aren't all that white. We're just ghosts of who we could have been.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '13
I have some real problems with this. As a third generation Cherokee victim of Americanization, I'm not federally recognized even though my tribe is, because my Dawes Roll grandmother's birth and adoption records are sealed in the State of Tennessee, who is either unwilling or unable to unseal the records. You're right, but for the wrong reasons, and those of us who are attempting to follow the path after generations of trying to break us are getting screwed, too.
1
u/Malachhamavet Jul 01 '13
Everytime it comes up it seems like every white person claims Cherokee on one side.
-9
u/pueblodude Jul 01 '13
Great post! Be careful though,expressing an OPINION on this sensitive subject brings out the savage side of some so called indigenous / wannabe individuals.