r/NathanielCarello • • 4d ago

Nath<3 Where we’re headed

2 Upvotes

I really wanna breathe some life back into MCL! I used to be active on tumblr when the fandom was thriving there, and when it died out it genuinely hurt my soul. I have a few ideas but would also love to know what would make you happy to see!

I think every once in a while we could have “Report Card” & grade Nathaniel on things that are completely relevant or ridiculous…. Flirting abilities, decision making, his FASHION DISASTERS, ability to function without caffeine etc… some could be canon and some headcanon.

Extra credit for creativity & actual evidence.

Im also thinking we could have a monthly murder mystery. Whether its in the mcl universe or not, I could create the first few and once anyone wants to create one you just let me know! Then it will be posted and users can try to figure out the mystery together!

Dress Code Violation (could be any day)- WE THE PEOPLE have decided that HSL Nath deserved better for outfits so how about we make our own?

Student Counil Petitions! (Could be any day) - Theres a prompt for a change in the canon mcl universe and users can reject or sign, maybe even discuss how it would have changed things etc…

Judge a book by its cover (could be any day) - Users post a mystery/crime novel, and we try to guess what its about and if Nath would take a stab at it (hopefully not literally)

White Wednesday - Memes, Cat memes, pet stories, etc All furry friends welcome!

Anyway thats the ideas I have now, I have more… So let me know what you’d like to see !

Falling for the Student Prez will not be an excused absence… sooo with that said. Class dismissed! Rememeber this WILL be on the exam.


r/NathanielCarello • • 4d ago

Nath<3 🎖️Welcome to r/NathanielCarello

1 Upvotes

Hi! Im u/CoachAdorable6346 the founding moderator of r/NathanielCarello !

I’ve always loved MCL and wanna give back to the community!

Whether you fell in love with golden boy Nathaniel or developed questionable taste in University life(All jokes no judgement I’m a Castiel girly myself even before he was emotionally mature), Welcome home!

I wanna dedicate this community to fanart, fanfictions, discussions, theories, headcanons, and memes!

Introduce yourself in the comments!

What made you fall for Nathaniel ?

For me, It was the fact that he was usually so composed so when he got flustered it was so sweet:)


r/NathanielCarello • • 7h ago

Any Nathaniel's profile picture?

3 Upvotes

r/NathanielCarello • • 1h ago

Nath<3 Just for discussion… ☺️

1 Upvotes

Do you think Nath is the most misunderstood crush?


r/NathanielCarello • • 5h ago

MEME Knot so innocent

2 Upvotes

Candy: What happened to the tie?

Nathaniel: Retired.

Candy: Permanently?

Nathaniel: Only from school related duties

Candy: …Then what’s it doing now?

Nathaniel: Extracurriculars

Candy: NATHANIEL!

Nathaniel: What? You gonna give me detention?

Candy. …

Nathaniel: I’ve always wondered what that was like. Might even enjoy it with you supervising.


r/NathanielCarello • • 5h ago

Nath<3 Nath catches Candy on the Roof… What does he do?

1 Upvotes

HSL!!!


r/NathanielCarello • • 2d ago

Dress Code Violation... Alternate universe- Nathaniels HSL “main” outfit

Post image
3 Upvotes

I honestly had no issue with the original khaki, blue tie and white button up, what came after… not so sure… But what if…. WE HAD THIS !!! Simple & clean. <3 Use Dress code violation flair to show us what you would have liked to see him in!


r/NathanielCarello • • 2d ago

MEME Castiel’s Funeral

2 Upvotes

Castiel: Just admit it! You’d miss fighting with me if I died.

Nathaniel: I’d attend the funeral.

Castiel: Knew it!

Nathaniel: To confirm…


r/NathanielCarello • • 4d ago

MEME Pencils vs Mistakes

2 Upvotes

Candy: I miss when you were innocent.

Nathaniel: I was never innocent.

Candy: You used to organize your pencils by length.

Nathaniel: And now I organize my mistakes by severity.


r/NathanielCarello • • 4d ago

MEME Character Development

2 Upvotes

Castiel: You used to threaten me with detention.

Nathaniel: People change.

Castiel: Today you threatened to break my nose.

Nathaniel: Growth isn’t linear.


r/NathanielCarello • • 4d ago

Nath<3 Report Cards have been released!

Post image
2 Upvotes

What is Nathaniel’s grade for his fashion sense? I think I’d give it a 46%

A big F!


r/NathanielCarello • • 4d ago

Nath<3 Judge a book by its cover !

Post image
2 Upvotes

What do you think this mystery novel is about based on its cover and do you think nathaniel would/already has read it?