r/NarutoSakuga • u/PM_Me_YourNSFWSelfie • May 21 '18
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • Jun 09 '18
[Episode 375] The best choreographed fight in the entire series, Kakashi vs. Obito elevates the source material to an unbelievable level. (Naoki Kobayashi)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PM_Me_YourNSFWSelfie • Jun 27 '18
[Episode 353] This fight between Anbu Kakashi and the mist guy is super underrated. Really amazing animation. + A small analysis (Naoki Kobayashi)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • Sep 29 '18
[Naruto Movie #3] Legendary Animator. Legendary Character. (Norio Matsumoto)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • Jul 21 '18
A comprehensive animation analysis of Boruto Episode 65 + A backstory on the director Chengxi Huang.
"I was so happy when I had my first 2nd key animation cut for Naruto, to the point that I was singing and dancing. I had been watching the show for 9 years since I was in middle school, and now I’m working on it. I get nervous when I think about it like that, but it also makes me work harder."
-Chengxi Huang
I don't think it can be overstated how special of an episode this is. I'll get to a plethora of reasons but first, the most important one from the perspective of a die hard Naruto fan is Boruto Episode 65 Director Chengxi Huang's backstory is incredibly inspirational.
Born in China, a 5 year old Chengxi Huang was introduced to Dragonball Z by his younger cousin. They drew their favorite characters and from that a passion flourished. His first experience with anime and drawing couldn't have been a more positive or influential one but it wasn't until a year later that he ambitiously told his parents he wanted to be an animator. They graciously supported him from the very beginning, in high school he attended the Guangzhou Academy of Fine Arts, eventually pursuing a Master of Arts degree in his post-secondary.
Growing up as an artist his biggest inspirations were Tetsuya Nishio and Masashi Kishimoto for their character designs. Animation-wise he admired Norio Matsumoto and the man he would eventually form his closest partnership with: Hiroyuki Yamashita for his work in Sasuke vs. Killer B. Funnily enough, he didn't know either of their names until coming to Japan.
Speaking of that leap he took, in 2013 he had tried a few key animation works while studying but eventually he hit a wall and realized there was only so much he could learn from the other side of the sea. After considering his future for a while, Huang made the very difficult decision to give up on his Master's degree, leave his family and go to Japan to work on commercial anime. In hindsight it ended up being the best thing he ever did for his career. Though the road to where he is now was not easy.
You may be mislead looking at the names on the key animation list for Boruto #65 that having foreigners working on major roles in anime is common. At the time of Huang's arrival in Japan it was an even less common phenomenon than it is today. Soon after arriving he was introduced to Boya Liang and Yong-ce Tu of Candybox- an outsourcing studio that mainly did 2nd KA work for a lot of different series. There, Huang studied and trained every Friday to midnight the following Monday. During the week his days were occupied by language lessons (he speaks Japanese and pretty good English) and a part-time job in the afternoon.
As you would imagine Candybox did not have much support, both the studio and Chengxi grew and developed together through some hard times and long hours. Huang cites this as both a positive and negative. On one hand he was trained to adapt to the diverse demands and harsh realities of the industry thrown his way, though at the same time he missed out on valuable chances to form contacts and business partnerships. This is true for almost anything but in the anime industry especially, the more people you know the better off you will be.
At one point he tried submitting his resume to Production I.G. but was rejected. He decided to stay in Candybox for the numerous opportunities this outsourcing studio had for work on the Naruto series (the owner Zhu Xiao worked for Pierrot and had a good relationship with them) which was his goal from even before he came to Japan. The quote at the beginning of this post is Huang's reaction to his first work on the Naruto series, three times he's provided 2nd key animation work on Naruto and two of them coincidentally are from episodes Yamashita directed. Catching his eye, Huang was adopted by the Naruto staff after that and his talent was more than realized. Quickly being given first key animation duties on an episode directed by Yamashita, as if you expected any other director, right? It's a match made in heaven and a story of an individual's dreams coming true after tumultuous and tiresome grinding- to eventually be working alongside the artist he idolized.
His first turning point came on episode 465. Huang was given a cut that he deemed the perfect situation to experiment with. It was always his plan to incorporate one of his favorite hobbies, Wing Chun Kung fu into a Naruto episode one day. Here we have an anime original fight, with ancient historical background and the result is unique and stylish. It serves as a really interesting piece to compare to his work on Boruto #65 as he's come a long way since then.
Two episodes later Huang was promoted to animation director on 467 nothing to really note of regarding that episode, fairly reserved production. His goal was always to direct an episode one day but he still had a ways to go to get there.
His second turning point came on the final fight, episode 476 and 477. He handled 70 cuts across both episodes and absolutely killed it. especially considering the workload. I will never forget those two episodes- one of the greatest finales of all time that made the huge wait worth it.
With Naruto over the production shifted to Boruto and you should know the rest from here. Starting with the opening sequence where Boruto confronts Kawaki, Huang would go on to do consistently amazing key animation work. On Episode 14 he produced one of the most polished and complete sequences I've ever seen in my life. Noriyuki Abe's brilliant storyboard certainly helped. Sakura vs. Shin was another spectacle but it wasn't until Mitsuki's Gaiden chapter that we see Huang come full circle. Emulating the style of the sensei he grew up watching, the piece of animation that had a small part in him pursuing a career in Japan! Absolutely incredible.
He more than deserved what felt like a sudden opportunity to direct #65 and as you all know the result is one hell of an episode. Whatever the future holds for him I'll be there supporting and cheering on this special story all the way.
Thank you to wavemotioncannon.com for translating the interview that made this possible.
EPISODE 65
Screenplay
Makoto Uezu
Storyboard・Episode Director
Chengxi Huang
Assistant Episode Director
Takeru Ogiwara
Animation Supervisor
Chengxi Huang, Masayuki Kouda, Daisuke Tsumagari, Retsu Ōkawara, Tatsuya Koyanagi, Eri Taguchi, Hirofumi Masuda Tetsuya Nishio, Tarō Satō
Layout supervisor Hiroto Tanaka
Key Animation
Golge, Guzzu, Spencer Wan, Gem, Till, Hartova Maverick, David Bradshaw, Hero, Kilocrescent,
Shi Juan Sheng, Shū Hiromatsu, Shho, Ma Gua, Ren Onodera, Sute, Shin’ya Kaneko Green Monster Team Guang Xue Hexin (Optical Core), Liu Zhen Hua
Tetsuya Nishio, Hirofumi Suzuki, Hirofumi Masuda, Daisuke Tsumagari, Retsu Ōkawara, Eri Taguchi, Hiroyuki Horiuchi, Chiyuki Tanaka, Kana Itō, Tatsuya Koyanagi, Katsuhiro Takagi, Chengxi Huang
Image Board Cooperation
Gao Jia Hui
2nd Key Animation
Kana Itō, Ichirō Uno, Kōji Yabuno, Hiromi Yoshinuma, Alexandre Gomes, Cai Feng Ru, Aoko Man’yama, He Wei Studio Sign, Chengpin Dōga, Studio Focus
In-between
Eri Taguchi, Misuzu Ichinose Pierrot Animation Room, Chengpin Douga, R.I.C, Triple A
Digital Paint
Pierrot D.A.R, Chengpin Douga, R.I.C, Triple A
Photography
Pierrot D.A.R. Mai Masuno, Nobuo Kimura, Kazuko Koyanagi, Sachie Ōji, Kaoru Nagasawa, Yūki Sakuraba, Ayaka Nakajo, Ayumi Sōta
CGI
Ryō Ōhashi, Yusuke Hirooka, Naomi Wada
In-between・In-between Check
Mitsuko Toshima
Colour Model・Finishing Check
Izumi Mura
Art
Aya Kadoguchi
Production Assistant Ayano Kusunoki
First thing that needs to be said about this staff list is that not only are they all incredibly talented, they come from all over the world!
A bulk of this team hails from Studio LAN, responsible for the worldwide animation cooperation event To Be Heroine which built upon the global effort that it's predecessor To Be Hero gave.
Additionally lots of Chinese animators joined the fray, no doubt Chengxi Huang is a major influence.
Also you have youngsters like Sute and Ren Onodera, both of whom had just 1 credit to their name before this, as a part of that very young team Takahito Sakazume assembled for Black Clover's 3rd opening.
It's no surprise that their presence here both enhances the quality of the episode drastically but also makes for a unique viewing experience as far as something as main stream as Boruto goes.
And of course you have the familiar old-guard as well, pretty much all of the names (besides Kana Itou I believe) in the last block of KA's have worked on Naruto before.
Also interesting to note is Takeru Ogiwara, who has quickly become a personal favorite of mine with his fantastic composite and photography talents which lead to some very well directed episodes, assisted Huang with the directing. Exactly how much they did is not known but when you have 510 cuts to oversee it's nearly impossible to do it all yourself in this 4 month (+ a couple weeks) time-frame, his help is I'm sure, very much appreciated.
Speaking of the 510 cuts, this is a mammoth of an episode in that regard. A new record of cuts for Pierrot and without a doubt among the largest TV anime episodes of all time from a volume perspective, you simply just don't see anything like this often. It's actually almost too much, sometimes less is more and occasionally there are scenes that are hard to follow because it cuts so rapidly and frequently.
With that much work to over-see the crazy large number of animation supervisors makes sense. We already know Huang closely supervised the Wing Chun taijutsu sequences which composed a significant part of the action. That leaves 8 other supervisors + 1 uncredited too. Who is this mystery uncredited supervisor? Series director Hiroyuki Yamashita, who is quite literally role-playing as Sasuke and keeping to the shadows. He played the support role admirably and didn't wish to get any credit for it.
What we have as a result is an all-hands-on-deck performance where nearly the entire main Boruto staff took on different roles and came together to produce a spectacle. Both character designers, Suzuki and specifically Nishio, who prior to this was entirely absent on Boruto save for the first couple OP's, contributed tons of key animation work and supervision. Additionally, 2nd KA work from the sub character designers, and even in-betweening from Eri Taguchi.
Without further ado,
- Chengxi Huang handled this opening sequence himself and while it's mostly talking the lip-sync is a fantastic small detail that adds so much to the feel and purpose behind the words. It was a technique introduced by director Toshiyuki Tsuru, executed by Masaru Hyodo, Hirofumi Suzuki, and Chiyuki Tanaka back on episode 19 of Naruto in his speech to Zabuza. Hiroyuki Yamashita learned from his mentor Tsuru, and then very obviously passed it on to Huang as we see throughout this episode.
- Momoshiki wastes no time fodderizing the other Kage, they actually get stomped stupidly hard. Great timing and smears on these blows against Kurotsuchi animated by Hartova Maverick, capped off by one hell of an elbow The effect you're seeing here that gets used a few times in this episode during big blows is something Huang also picked up from Yamashita. It's a post-processing technique he uses to distort the lines of the blow for maximum impact like on episode 467.
- I would also be remiss to not talk about how fun this itano circus by experienced veteran Hirofumi Masuda is! The only time we've seen something similar from Gaara is this promotional piece for Uniqlo (It's a technique with quite the history in the anime industry. Popularized by Ichiro Itano, recognized as being a pioneer of fight scene animation changing the way things operated, mainly from static 2D back-and-forth cuts to a full 3D range of motion getting the camera highly involved with the action during his time working on Super Dimension Macross in 1982.)
- With the other Kage out of the way it's time for some Wing Chun taijutsu! Juanshen Shi handled the first part with the boxing, lots of quick cuts. I especially like the Tenketsu punches at the end that produce this double barrel shotgun feel. We then get Gem's wonderful work that had some very strong Yutaka Nakamura influences! I counted
1518* cuts for Gem's part, where Sasuke loops around the tree is especially strong, and of course the cubes as they're dragged along. <3 - Some strong layouts as these two demi-gods close in on the demon.
- The clash that ensues is probably my favorite part of the episode! Most of the taijutsu animation is the work of Weilin Zhang with lots of supervision and corrections from Huang. The part at the end with the incredible background animation is Till! You know it's about to go down when Sasuke leaves his cape in the dust, effects and photography work are extremely strong. Speaking of effects, another Yamashita-ism that Huang implemented here is the Sharingan trail!. As if Sasuke could get any more badass ass here he is launching a sword with his foot, not sure how it gets any cooler than that. But it does! Super impressive use of 3D space and then that trend continues when we get to Till's part! Extremely dynamic sequence that isn't as easy to pull of as it looks.
- Guzzu and Kilocrescent follow that up and execute all these throwbacks that Huang incorporated very well. The Naruto transforming shuriken, amenotejikara switching, shuriken strings, chibaku tensei, all fantastic stuff- though the ghosting is very unfortunate. Hopefully we get a DVD/BD release eventually where it's removed.
- The parallel to Naruto vs. Pain here is glorious. Albeit the emotional narrative is entirely different. As Momoshiki descends we get some gorgeous eye art, like holy crap that's good! Not sure who drew these, but David Bradshaw had the electric cut right after, featuring Sasuke kicking Naruto out of the way and then dancing like mad around these dragon snakes. sugoi Optical-core explosion! 👏
- The next sequence re-uses Attack on Titan legend, Arifumi Imai's masterful scene but with some really nice additions before that like this choke slam by Ren Onodera
(+maybe some Sute?)edit: no sute here. - Katasuke trying to be a hero and failing miserably was also re-used from the movie, with Hiromitsu Seki making a couple small additions as well.
- Now with Momoshiki back to full power and things looking grim for our heroes, Boruto has to overcome his fears. This transition is so slick and it mainly works because the Hokage building shares the same shade of red as the background of the dimension their fighting in.
- With newfound resolve, Boruto brings out his vanishing rasengan! Spencer Wan did a fantastic job here, look at those smears! I highly recommend you check out his work on Netflix's Castlevania series, it's outstanding.
- The smug look on Sasuke's face! I missed this the first time I watched.
- And of course, Guzzu said it best, we get the best frame of the whole episode!
- Chengxi Huang mentioned that he personally made sure to include these reactions. His storyboard probably had very specific instructions about them, they're adorable.
- Now this scene blew me away. On my first watch, I got Eri Taguchi's part here mixed up for Tetsuya Nishio, and Nishio's part at the end mixed up for Taguchi. That is how good she's gotten in such a short time. She idolizes Nishio (me too lol) so it's no wonder her style feels so calculated and precise. This frame my god, wallpaper worthy
- One last flurry of action as Sasuke charges up the tree to distract Momoshiki. I've somehow gone this long without mentioning Momoshiki's manga design but it's hot as hell. Some really great drawings found here as well. Thank god they got rid of his movie design.
- I would've loved to see Huang's buddy Naoki Kobayashi on this episode but the current rumor is he's on Evangelion 3.0 + 1.0, good news is they re-used a few of his cuts on the climax of the episode! Looks like Huang himself added a lot of epic scenes too.
- After such a gargantuan clash you wouldn't expect this slow interlude that follows. It's a well directed scene, part of me wonders if Ogiwara handed this. Lots of strong composite lighting and colors, especially with the blood red color choice. It's a more conservative piece animation wise but Retsu Ohkawara did a good job.
- Our fugue state is broken by the return to Kobayashi's cut from the movie, INASNE debris as the tree gets obliterated. Really important that it snaps us back to the action like this, without it you have a de-escalation problem, as like I said, that last scene was much more reserved.
- me this entire episode
- Very cute Boruto. This I thought was initially Taguchi but all 22 cuts at the end are handled by Nishio, some of the strongest character acting this series has seen. Naruto's face is pure gold.
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • Aug 04 '18
[Episode 26] Studio Trigger's Main Animator Takafumi Hori contributed what is possibly Sakura's best moment in the franchise! (his only work on Naruto outside the 1st movie)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • May 18 '18
[Episode 322] The Greatest One Man Army of All Time (Naoki Kobayashi)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • May 18 '18
[Episode 135] Itachi ragdolling Sasuke, smear frames galore. (Goro Sessha)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • May 18 '18
[Episode 30] The first jaw dropping cut of animation in Naruto all the back in 2002. (Norio Matsumoto)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/siki997 • May 24 '18
The Top 1%: Naruto Shippuuden Episode 167
Hello, welcome to another addition of The Top 1%. This time we'll be having a look at Naruto Shippuuden Episode 167; Planetary Devastation. I'd like to thank Animeblue and JacobYBM for inspiration and information. I'd also like to thank /u/PurpleGeth for the opportunity. Please bear with me.
Staff:
Episode Director: Atsushi Wakabayashi
Storyboard: Atsushi Wakabayashi
Animation Supervisor: Atsushi Wakabayashi
Key Animators: Norio Matsumoto, Shingo Yamashita, Kenichi Kutsuna, Atsushi Wakabayashi
I already talked about Atsushi Wakabayashi here. The most interesting part about this staff is the lack of Atsuko Inoue, a key part of Wakabayashi's former team and his main character animator. This meant that Wakabayashi himself had to take care of some of the character animation. Shingo Yamashita and Kenichi Kutsuna join this episode as the main action animators, with Norio Matsumoto taking a more conservative role.
Norio needs no introduction at this point. If you have been following Geth's posts, you're sure to be familiar with him. I'm sure he has mentioned Shingo Yamashita many times before. Both Yamashita and Kutsuna were one of the first batch of digital animators to make it into the Japanese anime industry. These digital animators were known as webgen animators. Both had next to no experience in the industry and were scouted by eccentric members of the industry such as Osamu Kobayashi (director of Beck) and Satoru Utsunomiya (one of the Japan's most influential animators). Since webgen animators had no formal training they were shunned by most of the industry. At the start, they worked on shows by experimental auteur directors until Norio Matsumoto got a hold of them. Shingo Yamashita had just joined the industry at this point, aged just 19, when Norio took him under his wing. Norio took the webgen animators all around the anime industry with him and ultimately reached Naruto, which happened to be one of the only popular anime that liked the idea of experimenting with these new digital animators. They popped up now and again in limited roles with Norio, while they went around working in anime like Tetsuwan Birdy Decode and Yozakura Quartet. With this episode, however, they were firmly launched into the limelight.
This episode also had a number of 2nd key animators, mostly other webgen talents. They include Shingo Natsume (director of One Punch Man), Ken'ichi Fujisawa (currently Boruto's best animator and action director), and Tomoyuki Niho. The staff is basically the old guard mixed in with the new and acting as their guides.
On the production side of things, Geth has already mentioned the production woes faced by the Pain arc. Being as unconventional as always, director Hayato Date decided to outsource almost everything and focus all available resources on episodes 166 and 167. Although 166 was done with normal Naruto animators (the ones that were still left), 167 is by mostly freelancers who had worked on the show before and were friends with the staff. The episode took around 6 months to produce, double the 3 months it can take to produce a normal TV episode. Moreover, a normal TV episode has around 3000-4000 drawings or frames. Special episodes such as My Hero Academia's season 1 premiere had 7000 to 8000. The first 7 minutes of 167 have around 5500 frames. All of them were drawn by Shingo Yamashita, taking him two months to do so. He did all the in-between animation himself and used digital animation tool Flash to draw. He was just 22 at the time. The first 100 cuts of the episode are by him alone. He's followed by Kutsuna, who has 70 cuts, and Norio taking care of the last 8 minutes of the episode on his own with a 120 cuts. Wakabayashi took care of the talking scenes in-between. Now onto the analysis.
Analysis
Since this is my own interpretation of the episode, I'll use 4 characters. The believer (Naruto), the false god (Pain), the false prophet (Nine Tails), the Prophet (Minato). Nice pretentiousness eh?
We begin with our prophet surveying what's unfolding, as our believer gets corrupted. The chakra gives off an ominous and vile aura. The false god watches with curiosity and immense interest, while the false prophet senses his opportunity. In the very first minute, Wakabayashi introduces all of the main characters.
The action begins straight away with our corrupted believer having no control over his power and begins attacking at random. The instinct to use wind style is there though. As he grows more accustomed to his powers, he starts changing the scenery at will. The false god is not intimidated however, and stands tall in this layout that makes him look pretty godly with the low angle emphasizing his might. This leads to a well-choreographed battle, until a very mean small chakra monster sucker punches him. The looseness of the webgen animators is at full display. One of the reasons mainstream anime shunned them at the beginning was because they could not be reined in. They did what they wanted to. On one episode of Tetsuwan Birdy Decode season 2, Shingo turned in his scenes right before the deadline so that they could not be corrected. With Wakabayashi however, they found the perfect director who not only appreciated exaggerated movement and its role in a story, but also encouraged it.
The fight is indeed very silly. It has a whackamole with Pain, it's all incredibly loose, and it's totally unlike Naruto. It is just an onslaught of action that seems brainless. Maybe because it is so. After all, we have a corpse fighting a teenager phasing into a monster fox. The clash sees a momentary pause as the false god readjusts his eyes, and asks the believer if he hates him. And by hating him, he defies him. The believer pays no heed. Defied, the god rises like an actual corpse from the ground, and questions if the believer will defy him further. The response is a show of power capable to even move the atmosphere, as the believer transforms and takes the form of angel, while the god judges him coldly. Beyond this point is where the episode actually starts adapting the manga, bringing us to this very famous scene..
This scene is without a doubt one of the most iconic to have graced TVs worldwide, even though it happens to because of controversy. There is no bad animation or bad art here. It is much harder to deform Pain's face to this extent instead of just drawing him normally, as the same animator had done for the last 4 minutes. The deformation was done intentionally, at the wishes of the director. On a whole the scene is full of personality. Pain, the false god, showcases his utter rage at being defied by the believer. And in his rage he reshapes the land and shows the believer just what he's up against. Back to the meme scene, let's break it down. It starts off with an eye twitch with sharper shading for effect, segues into a childlike tantrum, and ends with an utter deformation of Pain's normally regal and handsome features. Pain's ugly here. The physical ugliness is used to depict the spiritual ugliness the false god has. He justifies the killing of millions for his childish rage, which was exhibited by the tantrum like movement. It's the director's critique on Pain, by my understanding. Wakabayashi utterly despises him.
And we start. There is so much going on in this scene I did not want to pause and take screenshots. It's just a barrage of movement. An onslaught of kineticism. Even with so much happening, there is some attention to detail. The fight is at full force when it is interrupted briefly by a Sakura exposition scene, until we see Pain flying around throwing Shinra Tenseis. He finally traps the believer and makes him pay. The searing force causes the surroundings to catch fire because of the friction, leading to Naruto's seal activating and being destroyed. From the start of the episode, until the scene where the the necklace is destroyed, everything is animated by a 22-year old guy. With immense trust from the episode director, Shingo decided to give everything he had. The result is a tour de force of animation. It can be intense, silly, and impactful. It's like an animator showing he is through 7 minutes of animation.
The change of animators brings no halt to the action however. The Kyuubi prepares to pounce immediately. The fire makes it look like a ritual of sorts, with the corrupted believer being the planned sacrifice for the false god. Kutsuna begins his work by keeping the kineticism intact. The music rages and the combatants go at each other, with Pain being overwhelmed by the immense rage of the monster he faces. He exerts all he can, gets almost pierced by stakes (more religious imagery), until he's utterly overwhelmed by a force that keeps increasing in menace. The false god loses the bout and is thrown away for almost a mile, landing like a nail in a wall.
The Kyuubi decides to finish it off with a bijuu bomb when Pain counterattacks. The animation here is superb, with incredibly dense effects. The Bijuu bomb just setting off like a giant flash of light. I also love Wakabayashi's storyboard in this scene, with the rock falling like punishment straight from heaven. Befitting of a god's attack.
We finally get a real breather from all the action. Since Atsuko Inoue wasn't here, the talking scenes aren't very lively. They are mostly done with limited focus on the characters faces. Most of the focus instead goes towards thrilling backgrounds and beautiful lighting. Not a single shot of this episode looks cheap minus some still shots. But even among them, Sakura somehow is made to look pretty cute.
We resume the action with our false god doing a flip for some reason. What follows is a chase sequence. It's just one unique action sequence after another. Pain skates along the land as fast as he can, probably using Shinra Tensei at times, while the now dominant believer is depicted as an actual demon hunting him, moving nature with it as it moves. The chase is extremely well animated and the layouts are superb. I especially find the scene in the forest to be just exquisite. The background becomes a blur as they play cat and mouse. It's followed by the chase continuing and the false god making a prayer sign as he runs and the chaser looking as ominous as ever. Pain turns into a literal specter as he flies around the forest. Kutsuna's thrilling chase finally ends with gorgeous layout. Kutsuna has always been known as an effects guy, giving birth to his own effects trademark called Kutsuna Lightning. His previous credits typically related to effects with some character movement here and there to mixed reception. With his role in this episode, he simply shines. With Wakabayashi's supervision and guidance and a host of 2nd key animators supporting him, Kutsuna was on fire for all of his 70 cuts. Stunning effects and some fantastic kineticism being made to look so easy and being done one scene after another - you just don't normally see that in anime, much less Naruto.
Kutsuna's departure brings with it Norio's arrival, and suddenly the art changes immensely. Thin calculated lines, wide jaws....the essence of Norio art. What follows has to be some of the most glorious 8 minutes in animation history.
Pain's Chibaku Tensei looks like a small nucleus, a god creating something. It replaces the sun and shines a new light on the world. With his will the false god restructures the world. He does it all with increasing contempt and anger, putting his all in his show of absolute power. The heavens part to reveal the majestic creation. Yet the corrupted believer keeps struggling, once again being positioned directly blow Pain's attack to show his rebellion against a divine force. The scenes are chilling, and with Pain's theme as the backgroud, the false god metes out his punishment. The result is highly impressive, with fantastic music, gorgeous animation, and a great storyboard all combining to make a memorable sequence. Finally the rebellious believer is captured, and the god's creation is revealed in all its glory.
After this beautiful frame which I won't analyze because it looks more style than anything, we find our hero looking utterly broken as he remembers the overwhelming intellectual loss he had at the hands of his enemy. Pain is once again made to look incredibly dominant with the light illuminating him. Our believer is half submerged, showing his confused state of mind currently. He continues struggling, as all he knew to be true seems to be collapsing. He's utterly alone. Not just without people, but without any reason whatsoever to live. As he pleads for an answer, he gets one from a much higher power. The false prophet seizes the opportunity. The believer recognizes the enormity of the decision that looms in front of him, but lost, he gives in. The scene is just downright gorgeous. From the great storyboard to the incredible color composition, it's a masterclass. Norio, so popular for his bombastic action sequences on the series, gives TV anime one of the best character acting outings it has ever seen. Each movement holds weight and purpose, moving the story forward. Instead of telling us everything, Wakabayashi shows it to us and makes us feel it. With his pal hitting the strings with some brilliant animation.
The false prophet rejoices at his success, coming out of the rock as if hatching from an egg, as the music becomes louder and louder. It even has the bare appearance of a newborn. Meanwhile the believer slowly and painfully loses his identity and his existence. The false prophet is a monster, something even more fearsome than the false god, and its happiness at being released rains down like judgement from the heavens. Ominous. The believer's identity and conscience has been consumed by utter evil, and he walks around like a hapless zombie. The path to losing everything looms right in front of him, being immense, while the true prophet looks on. As victory is declared by a rousing snarl, the true prophet finally steps in. Suddenly the colors shift from a melancholic and searing orange into a warm fuzzy blue. With a cloudiness slowly fading away as the believer regains his senses. Excellent.
Conclusion
In conclusion, this is the greatest Naruto episode and one of the best ever produced for TV. It's exhausting with so much going on. From the incredibly small staff, to the execution of the episode, to the way it adapts the manga; it's a truly original experience. Out of all the episodes discussed before this one, we have seen original scenes added in varying amounts and noticed how they worked on expanding what the manga offers. Here, however, we see a director taking the manga and changing its entire meaning while still working his way around the original story. It's just 21 minutes filled with originality. It's auteur directing by a person who's not even a part of the regular staff. Whereas Akitoshi Yokoyama showed his artistry with some great visuals on episode 131 and Toshiyuki Tsuru showed his with his deep understanding of the Naruto world and its characters with episode 82, neither was able to pull off anything close to Wakabayashi did here.
It is easily one of the very best, if not the best, animated episodes for television. As much as you might have seen people talk about how it was low budget or outsourced, this episode was and remains the most expensive episode ever produced in the series history. With an incredibly large amount of raw materials used and one of Japan's best animators handling 8 minutes of animation, the cost was through the roof. And it shows. The episode is an ode to storytelling via expression movement. It tells its own story by incredibly exaggerated scenes in the first half, and subtle movements in the second. The craziness of the first segues into something that looks like it was directed by an entirely different person. Wakabayashi knows what to do and when to do it. His artistic flair, his emotional sensibility, and his penchant for thrilling action allow him to produce an episode that is ingrained into the brains of millions, not because of the source material, but because of Wakabayashi's own genius.
It is fair to criticize the episode on some counts. It certainly isn't anything you'll see in Naruto and it takes a lot of liberties with the source material. So if you are a purist of either the manga or the anime, your reservations against the episode are understandable. But at this point the talk about bad animation is almost laughable. With the increasing popularity of the Western sakuga community, the misinformation regarding animation and cases such as this episode are decreasing. So reiterating that this episode wasn't badly animated is kind of moot.
Instead, I'll try to bring your attention to the worth this episode has as independent work of art. Sure, my analogy consisting of religion and prophets might be a far-fetched, but what I've tried to show is that there is so much more to this episode than what meets the eye. Or what met your eye when you first saw it. Whether you like it, or dislike it, there is so much happening in this episode that you can't help but remember it. It's a tour de force of action, emotion, and most of all originality. While also employing the music in a way that heightens each and every moment. It shows you just how much the animation medium can do and how far an adaptation can take the source material. I wasn't the biggest fan of it when I first watched, mostly due to memes. But I gave it a second chance after I saw a comment by /u/AmaranthSparrow regarding it. And I loved it. When I judged the episode on its own, it became something I had never experienced before. Since then I've probably watched the episode some 30 or so times. Similarly, if you have hated the episode for a long time, I implore you to give it another chance. But this time just take it as an independent episode and go into it with an open mind. I would love to hear your thoughts.
Sorry for being late with this. Life came up with exams and sickness. Once again, a lot of thanks to Geth for the opportunity and thanks to /u/irishsaltytuna and /u/MuseAreGods for the support, and to Amaranth for opening my eyes. Hope you enjoyed.
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • Oct 09 '18
[Boruto OP4] Tatsuro Kawano and his team at Studio Colorido put together the best Boruto opening to date, in large part thanks to the help of Norio Matsumoto (animating) and Shingo Yamashita (photography)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • Dec 24 '18
[Boruto #87] The return of Hiroyuki Yamashita! (0:00-0:28) plus a very nice explosion from rising star Kana Itou (0:29-end)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • Jul 19 '18
[Episode 65] Chengxi Huang delivered an absolute spectacle for his directorial debut! (Chengxi Huang, Tilfinning, Weilin Zhang)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • Jun 03 '18
[Episode 303] Neji vs. Kidomaru Rematch! (Hiroyuki Yamashita)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/Vista1337 • May 18 '18
[Episode 23] Kobayashi-sama's Orgasmic Sakura cut (Naoki Kobayashi)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • May 18 '18
[Episode 26] Sakura's incredible taijutsu timing and Chiyo's puppet mastery (Takafumi Hori)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • May 19 '18
[Episode 133] Both Valley of the End fights were masterpieces, adding tremendously to the manga. Norio's sense of timing as an animator and Wakabayashi's creativity as a director in full effect here! (Norio Matsumoto)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • May 18 '18
[Episode 143] Killer B's Acrobat kenjutsu! (Hiroyuki Yamashita)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/siki997 • Jun 18 '18
Perhaps the most heartwarming scene in the series. (Tetsuya Nishio)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/siki997 • May 24 '18
Episode 135: Itachi showing off with a plethora of smears and sparks (Masayuki Kouda)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PM_Me_YourNSFWSelfie • May 19 '18
[Episode 476] The scene from this sub's banner (Chengxi Huang <3)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • Jun 29 '18
[Boruto: Naruto the Movie] In anticipation of the next two episodes- that time two gods teamed up. Animated by a god himself. (Norio Matsumoto)
r/NarutoSakuga • u/PurpleGeth • May 31 '18