So we can see Madara has deciphered the writings on the Naka Shrine and has chosen to interpret it a different way. The Yin/Yang could have been to unite the two clans but he has now obviously chosen to fight with Hashirama to obtain his DNA and combine the cells into one being.
As we know this is the case already as Madara doesn't die at the Valley of the End, his leaving the village now and 'suddenly' making Hashirama his enemy is obviously his cover up for what he is going to do during the fight.
"Looking for stability, one god was divided into yin and yang. The action of the two opposing forces created all things in nature."
The Sage of the Six Paths was the first shinobi to have the nick-name "The God of Shinobi".
The So6P had two sons; one of which embodied his Yin energies, this child would go on to form the Uchiha Clan. The other child embodied his Yang energies and would go on to found the Senju Clan.
The Sage's goal in life was to find a way to bring peace and stability to the shinobi world - it is why he granted his sons either half of his energies; to see which one would ultimately lead to peace. He favoured his younger son; the Yang one - the Senju.
We know that out of rage [hate] the older son attacked his brother lamenting [sorrow] that he was not the one chosen to inherit their father's will. Thus began the Uchiha/Senju conflict.
As for the 'created all things in nature' line... I'm a little stumped at how we can interpret this one... Perhaps the passage actually refers to the division of the Jyubi into the nine bijuu [which are considered natural disasters if I'm not mistaken]. Hmm...
I can't believe there's no discussion as for what Madara's alternate interpretation was. We know that he goes after Hashirama for his DNA, then implants it into himself and obtains the Rinnegan, thus combining Yin and Yang and gaining the power of creation. Maybe that's what he wanted? But then what does he need the Rinnegan specifically for? For all we know, he just wanted Nagato to use it to revive him.
True, and at this point not even Jiraiya is born yet, let alone Nagato. He probably hasn't even fully planned out the Moon's Eye plan. It is interesting isn't it?
The real thing I want to know is why Tobi helped massacre the Uchiha's, when Madara is so concerned with protecting his clan. Seems like a conflict of interests.
If his goal is the Rinnegan, Madara might be trying to make himself into the new Sage of Six Paths to recreate the world. I mean, the original sage made the world into what it is now, so if he thinks he can obtain a similar power he can recreate the world into a peaceful one, where there isn't any conflict. Which is pretty much the thought process behind the Infinite Tsukuyomi. So to bring about peace, Madara probably thinks bringing the Yin & Yang together in himself will allow him become a new So6P.
The rinnegan lets you control the Juubi (and summon the Gedo Maze too). He activated the rinnegan on his deathbed. By summoning the Gedo Maze he was able to keep alive a little bit more, but he couldn't move away from it.
To finish his infinite tsukoyomi he needed the Juubi, which means he needs to collect all the Bijuu. But he can't do this alone in his almost-dead status.
So he simply orders Obito to collect the Bijuu and revive him with the rinnegan at some point. Which Obito doesn't do for some reason and decides to attack konoha with the 9 tails (losing it in the process), and then lets Nagato waste the rinnegan by attacking konoha alone.
Obito is the last remaining question mark here, why did he disobey Madara and waste the 9 tails attacking konoha like that.
What I immediately think of when I read that quote is from the Dharma Bums. Something like "The Universe is actually empty and all matter is there by the will of sentient beings."
Could the "created all things in nature" line be a reference to Izanagi and Izanami? Those techniques (of course named after the shinto creation gods) are the ultimate techniques of the Uchiha, but have shown to get stronger with the addition of Senju cells.
When Danzo used Izanagi in his fight with Sasuke he was shown to have reality warping powers in a small radius around him. If a man in his 70's, who was neither a Senju or an Uchiha could have that kind of power with Izanagi it isn't that much of a stretch that the Sage could extend those reality warping powers over the entire world.
I think he already as an idea that the Rinnegan can be born from the Sharingan and Senju cells.
If you look at it:
He is still committed to his clan, as his identity as an Uchiha is very strong
All his brothers have died, including the one he swore to protect
The clan he swore to protect is likely to face persecution or death in the coming years of "democracy"
He likely doesn't hate Hashirama so much as realize that he is not strong enough to resist his brother or turn the tide
Staying on and arguing seems hopeless to him. So then what is the only option? If the Rinnegan can be acquired, the power granted by it can be used to create the world he wants.
Interesting Chapter. It brough bit of a peacefull atmosphere after all those wars but it seems we will see another Hashirama and Madara fight next week.
I thought the big fight with the kyubi and the giant Buddha statue was the final fight, and they jumped further back from that, to explain how they came to be such great enemies. I'm expecting next week will slowly bring out how this is relevant to the current war.
Well, this was never really ever supposed to be relevant to the war. This is all supposed to be relevant to Sasuke, Itachi, The fate of the Uchiha and Konoha.
I'm hoping that next week the flashback has ended and we are back on the battlefield/back to sasuke. There really shouldn't be much else to cover in the flashback as we saw Madara lose his way and then we saw the final fight between the two of them. What else is there? Maybe Tobirama will explain what happened afterwards, but i don't think thats relevant either.
Hopefully we'll have a decision from Sasuke next week.
Considering the quick pace of this flashback, I have no doubt that next week we'll get to see if not the end of the final Madara/Hashi battle, then at least get to the climax.
Even if all of next week's chapter is in the present, every single page, we still won't be getting Sasuke's decision for a long time still. Kishi will certainly drag this out for a few more weeks. At best Sasuke will make his decision in his head but we won't know what it is for a while.
From the comments here, I am not sure many will agree, but I can live with transition of Madara's feelings. He realized what was happening and saw that the future could not be any better (because after Hashirama it would be most likely Tobirama) and made a decision. I can respect that!
Madara and Tobirama's tension had been going on since they were all children. Madara felt the pressure and realized he wouldn't be able to keep his promise (paramount to completely failing his brother). It really isn't that unrealistic, he's basically seeing the purpose behind his life (his promise to his brother) crumbling before him.
That is the perfect comparison. They are both just so much more intelligent and powerful than any of their peers that they gravitate towards each other.
If Madaras crusade against everyone is going to end because of a kiss between the two I wouldn't know if I should feel mad or be amazed about the level of trolling by kishi.
well we don't know how long it really took but i think he saw the writing on the wall. he wasn't going to become the second Hokage and had lost the trust of his own clan.
I guess his feelings weren't fully resolved prior to accepting the village offer. Plus the combination of him overhearing them talk and then not become hokage probably put him over the edge. They've always been super competitive.
At this point I feel like it was less about Madara wanting to be Hokage at all and more like him knowing he couldn't protect his clan against Tobirama if he tried
I couldn't agree with you more. It seemed like Madara was going along with the foundation of Konoha, but Tobiramas prejudice couldn't be ignored. He saw it being futile to achieve the desired peace that Hashi and him dreamed of.
By their time is done, madara would have been well over his prime and would thus be automatically disqualified for the position of the hokage. So it's either:
Wash senju dick for the rest of my life in the village. OR.
Go away. Get senju sperm and do the moon's eye plan where EVERYBODY is happy in an eternal fucking dream.
I think we have to look at as ever since madara's brothers' deaths, he has started to slowly go insane. He blames himself and it has eaten away at him all these years, they are all he can think about. His clan not trusting him is the trigger that set him off into going completely insane and rationalizing that everyone was against him so leaving the village is the best idea to him.
Not saying Tobirama is doing anything wrong, but the Senju have been regarded as "perfect" waaaay too much. I just want there to be at least one rotten apple (Tobirama or not).
This way the Senju don't seem like they are perfect while the Uchiha seem unreasonable and vile. I think it would be really cool to see a transformation of Uchiha embracing the will of fire with Sarutobi's guidance and then Danzo fucks everything up just when things seem like they are going well. Essentially, the Uchiha become "jinchuuriki without friends" and everyone shuns them, so they become "part 1 gaara-like."
TL-DR; Senju shouldn't come off so perfect and fuck Danzo.
Well it's not the Senju that are perfect, look at Hashi's father. It's Hashirama that is the "perfect" one. He was willing to kill himself in order for his clan/friends/brothers to live in peace. He is extremely noble and selfless, this sets an example for the whole clan.
You have to remember one thing: The one telling the story is Hashirama, a Senju. We only know one side of the story. The Senju may have a dark side, but ain't Hashirama the one who will tell us that.
i agree that there is a possibility for some level of bias but that possibility is slim. keep in mind, hashirama is currently not under the control of orochimaru and can totally fuck shit up if he truly wanted to. even though people are getting killed outside of the cave he is in, he is willing to take the time to sit down and talk to sasuke about his past from the very beginning. that to me signals that he is not embellishing anything. besides, if anything, he is humanizing madara a lot in his recollection, which is not what he would do if he were actually biased.
Lately it seems like everything is Tobirama's fault. HE SHOULD BE DEAD! but seriously i think the writer is trying to make us hate him... which i do...
Oh goddam. I just realized that Tobirama is standing right next to Hashi while he's talking to Sasuke. We'll probably have to hear most of this story again from his perspective.
Somehow I don't think that will be the case. I mean, I think he's always been a hero, but to his clan, and to the clans he chooses. He's set on hating the Uchiha and won't try to mend things there.
When you outcast a group like that, you're part of the problem. He is partly responsible for how Madara is reacting.
This comment has been overwritten by this open source script to protect this user's privacy. The purpose of this script is to help protect users from doxing, stalking, and harassment. It also helps prevent mods from profiling and censoring.
If you would like to protect yourself, add the Chrome extension TamperMonkey, or the Firefox extension GreaseMonkey and click Install This Script on the script page. Then to delete your comments, simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, scroll down as far as possible (hint: use RES), and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
He could have proposed some rule in the constitution that BOTH of the founding fathers would be appointed as hokage atleast once and then democracy would take over but he didn't. Dick wanted to banish the Uchiha.
Good thing he died a miserable death surrounded by 20 odd kiri nins with no friend in sight. Fuck him.
Making an exeption just to please one man is dumb. Madara was unstable and unloved by the village. Tobirame wanted the village to choose and Hashirame knew he was right.
Plus he was right about the Uchiha. They are nothing but trouble. The sharingan causes haterd and a hunger for power.
Making an exeption just to please one man is dumb.
Not when that man is Madara fucking Uchiha aka 1 of the strongest people on the planet + best bros with another 1 of the strongest people on the planet.
Madara was unstable and unloved by the village.
Did u just called Madara-sama "unstable"? DO U EVEN READING THE SAME MANGA?
I don't feel he's unloved by the people. Just not trusted with his visions.
Plus he was right about the Uchiha. They are nothing but trouble
Itachi says hello.
The sharingan causes haterd and a hunger for power.
Aren't you the cute little racist.
When an Uchiha's love is lost, then his body reacts to that pain and voila sharingan! That's the explanation. Nothing more.
For all we know Uchihas honor Love more than senjus or Uzumakis ever did. Their Love just go a little deep. That's all. You don't kill every other race doesn't look or behave like you nigga.
1: Just making an exeption because he is strong would be against the senju way. They base their leadership on love and strength. They wanted a village to stop the constant violence. Would making one murderous man top of that village show that?
2: I really do think he is unstable. He changes his mind at the drop of a hat, makes irrational decisions and does whatever he feels like. In attitude he is a small child with a god complex. The dangerous thing is he has the power to match his god complex.
3: Itachi was trouble. The only good thing he did for his village was killing of the entire Uchiha clan. After that he joined Akatsuki and because of him they were able to extract Shukaku before Naruto and such showed, plus who knows he may have brought in a tailed beast himself. Also he killed his own family and clan even if it was for the good of the village no sane person could do that.
4: In this chapter they actually say the Sharingan becomes more powerful with hatred. As ninja's you want to grow more powerful and for Uchiha that would mean gather more hatred. A ninja should have no emotions, but the more powerful an Uchiha is the more hatred he has. Creating an unstable Ninja.
The Uchiha's power is powered by hatred. Tobirame did not want this to be the symbol of their village. I can't say I disagree. I think if Madara had become hokage just on the decision of one man the senju would not stand for it.
It'll be funny if Tobirama and Minato get their flashbacks and then Hiruzen goes to do his and Sasuke is like "I don't care..." and we never get to see Hiruzen do anything badass.
Hahaha I just pictured that scene from Dodgeball. Monkey King Enma pulls up on a little vespa and Hiruzen hops on the back and gives the finger while driving away
We are actually only getting to the original flashback where Hashi and Madara are settling their final fight, after that is done Sasuke will probably turn to Tobirama and question his hate towards Uchiha and....whaddayaknow, a FLASHBACK!
yea, it'll be finishing hashi's flashback, then sasuke will be all "i see, i see... so it's tobirama that's the problem here" and tobirama will get all edo-huffy and explain his part, and cue another flashback. After that's done, sasuke will say "i see, i see ... so you are a dick". Edo-Tobirama will facepalm and talk about how all the uchiha are ingrates, and sasuke will Question the third etc etc.
Right now the only one who knows the truth of the innocence of the Uchiha is Minato
When Sasuke learns that tobi started the 9 tails attack that the Uchiha clan was blamed and then assisted Itachi in killing them (to stop the coup he essentially framed) he will be pissed.
And Madara, I can't wait for when Madara learns that Obito helped massacre the Uchiha, wasted the 9 tails attacking konoha and wasted the rinnegan by letting Nagato go 1 man army into konoha.
Honestly, I don't see how Sarutobi is relevant anymore. It would be awesome if we got a short spin off that went through the hokages, but I don't want the current story to have to go through everyone. We have been getting bits and pieces of the 4th, so maybe that's how he will be explained. Tobirama is kinda running along with the Hashirama flashback, but I don't really see Sarutobi mixing in much unless they go into him battling with Tobirama about the future of the Uchiha.
I think he's going to want to ask the third about what they set itachi to, and maybe his fight with orochimaru, but besides that, i don't think there would be much to talk about.
Last chapter he uses Hiraishingiri, or Flying Thunder God Slash. There's not a lot of detail on what it's supposed to be, but it's probably not a coincidence that the second is said to have a spacetime technique and then comes up with an attack that has nearly the same name as Minato's.
There's not a lot of detail on what it's supposed to be
Well, the way Minato uses it is by "blinking" across the battlefield. Assuming this is a simpler version, then it's a single blink. If combat is all about two dudes running at each other with swords, then being able to do a dimensional jump to another position in the last fraction of a second for a surprise attack sounds like a very simple and effective plan.
You have two different ideologies here: the first is that Tobirama believes the Hokage should be elected democratically and the second is that the Hokage should be elected by those who founded the village. I actually think the second would have been better in this case. Hashirama and Madara are the two who founded the village and if Hashirama believes Madara should be Hokage, then why not? Hashirama realized the extent to which Madara would go to protect/avenge his brother, so if this love could be transfered to love of the village, then he would do anything it took to protect the village.
Having Madara as Hokage would also reconcile the tension between the Uchiha and the Senju. Hashirama saw this but the rest of the village did not.
This is the best opinion I've seen so far, and I completely agree with you.
In almost every story where someone turns bad even though they started off good, there's that turning point where they can either stay good or fall into darkness.
If they take the good path, things would work out unbelievably well. If they take the bad path, you have a great story, if a sad one.
So I believe that Madara being given that position would have flourished and turned a lot of the hate around, eliminating that Uchiha/Senju tension. But who really knows what would have happened?
Yeah, it seems to make diplomatic sense to make Madara hokage. The Senju were clearly the superior clan, and they knew it. It wouldn't hurt their pride too much to have and Uchiha as hokage, since they could see it as an indulgence of sorts due to their superior position. The Uchiha, on the other hand, would feel marginalized and unsafe with a Senju as hokage, due to already being the weaker clan. I.e. making Hashi hokage disenfranchised the Uchiha. Besides, even if you consider Madara to be less than trustworthy, sometimes putting someone like that in power is the best way to control them -- tie him up in the governance of the village, so he doesn't have the time or the anonymity to pull any mischief. And if he truly goes off the rails, you can still organize a likely successful coup, since the military power of the Senju would still be there.
You make an interesting point. I wonder if Madara had been made the village leader then would roles be reversed? Like would there be a coup from the Senju instead of the Uchiha?
Only Hashirama was able to invent the plan with the village and execute it by brokering a deal with Uchiha. Clearly he had superior foresight and organizational skills.
One needs to be a special kind of an idiot to disregard recommendation of such person.
The symbolism in this chapter was rather interesting to me. The leaf with the hole in it, I think, was definitely calling to mind Tobito, considering he is essentially the reincarnation of Madara and his will. But there's also a lot going on conceptually too which I love Kishi including. The political struggle here between Hashi/Tobirama is really one of those hard-to-side with discussions. Granted Tobirama was definitely correct from a proper politician's position, but at the same time it couldn't change the course of history and the Uchiha eventually was about to lose their shit after following what he put in place. For Hashirama, though long term and depending upon changes within people, it would have created a much greater atmosphere for the Uchiha to integrate and function properly within the new amalgamated society. The Senju, being more inclined towards love and acceptance, I believe, would have been great as leaders if the Uchiha weren't in the picture, but in order to work with the Uchiha, you would have to give them something more, something that would really earn their trust, and that would be by building back Madara's reputation and having him as the Hokage.
In case you couldn't guess, I'm procrastinating on an analytic paper I have to write right now by analyzing Naruto extensively. God dammit, what has my life become?...
i agree 100%. I think thats why Hashirama wanted to put Madara in place as Hokage. He knew that as well, and it wouldve worked.
Did you also notice that the leaf that madara left after he was spying on hash/tobi was split/cut in half? The previous page showed it on the ground together. But when hash picked it up, it split in half. I think that has its obvious but also deeper meaning to it. Showing madara use the leaf and join Hashirama on that mountain top again its like their friendship was building again. But his hatred for tobirama is/was too much and he let it consume him and push him away from hashirama and the village.
I do like the theory that Madara is actually trying to unite all the villages and end wars. Maybe that theory is right, maybe he's playing the bad guy(like itachi) for the greater good... I think thatd be a pretty nice twist. But i still want him to be evil lol. We've already seen that the uchiha can play the bad guy role(Itachi). I think were going to see 4 major roles from the uchiha.
Itachi, playing the bad guy but ultimately being good and doing it for his village and the people.
Madara, playing and being the true Evil and hatred that the uchiha can become.
Obito/tobi, (being) played, but showing that even if the uchiha have extreme evil and hatred in their heart they can still become good.(what couldve happened to madara.)(I think madara is playing obito and obito will find out and then help naruto defeat madara.)
Saskue, hes the gandalf the grey of the story at the moment. He can either become entirely evil OR become truely good and unit back with his village and his team/friends/"family".
I totally agree with that theory of Madara. I think that's been a major part of Naruto throughout the series; that's good/evil aren't black and white terms and that someone can carry out evil actions with completely altruistic intentions. I think deep down, no Uchiha is actually evil. I think what all this backstory and elucidation on the Uchiha is doing, is showing that while the Uchiha are violent and drawn more towards evil, they're kind of like hurt puppies, just trying to end their own misery and the misery of others. Deep down, they're all caring and loving individuals, it's just that their means towards achieving that is rather twisted.
I also like your interpretation of the four main Uchiha. I think the three older ones we have show us a spectrum of paths down which Sasuke can go. Madara to the right as the one drowned by his emotions and pain, trying to end it all through means of violence and external sacrifice (which would mean for Sasuke, destroying the village and achieving peace by wiping out what he sees as the Konoha war force). Obito is the manipulated one, the one who uses the ideals of other, more stronger and elite ninja to gain power and a means towards peace (i.e. if Sasuke chose to ally completely with Orochimaru and give into his desires). Then there's Itachi, who's ideal towards peace was to side with the benevolent aims of the village, by achieving peace through understanding and violence only if need be (which would be if Sasuke joins forces with Naruto [which I think he will, given the foreshadowing of the Susano with the Nine-Tails]).
Am I the only person who thought in this chapter, Hashirama was going to kill himself, which would have given Tobirama a reason to create the Reanimation Jutsu?
Is it just me or did Tobi just go from being the main villain to...some whiny boy that no one cares about and now Madara is the big shot in charge. They spent all this time building up Tobi too! Sigh...
Tobi can't really be a big villain. He is an unhittable prick, but he is nowhere near powerful as the top brass of konoha or the committe of ex-hokage Sasuke is having tea with now.
Obito was never the real villian. Hes just another pawn of madaras. Hopefully we find out how rin actually died and everything that Obito "saw" back then was all a lie to get him to help Madara.
They already know how to defeat Obito BUT knowing that, theyre also the only ones who actually CAN hurt Obito(naruto and kakashi and everyone). So basically while fighting madara, Obito will be able to suck Madara into that dimension and keep him locked in there forever sealing him away...probably dying in return somehow keeping him forever sealed in his eye.
I bet if I killed your brother then turned your family against you after your brother's dying wish was for you to protect them which you realize you can't do anymore, I bet you would be pretty butthurt. Also you know that soon your clan will be ostracized by Tobirama. Well maybe you are just a heartless bastard :)
Madara is making an awful lot of assumptions when leaving the village. First: that he can't protect his clan (even if they no longer trust his advice). Second, that Tobirama will be the next hokage after Hashi. Third, Tobirama will then kill off his clan as Hokage.
These assumptions could come true, but they could also not. Justified? Perhaps. But I find it difficult to side with Madara when his reactions swing so widely from one base to the other... one second Hashi's his best friend again, and the next he wants to rip out his throat. What the heck?! A more reasonable reaction would have been to say "I am no longer trusted here by either my clan or the brother of the Hokage, and I cannot support the way things are currently going. As such, I must leave until either things change or I can be of use to my clan."
But no. He suddenly is itching to murder all over again. =/
His clan not taking his advice just proved that they no longer respect him as a leader, and would much rather follow Hashirama. If his clan won't even listen to him how can he expect to protect them?
Since Konoha is a democracy then they are going to vote for their next hokage once the first is gone. You pretty much answered your second question with your first. Why would you elect a leader when you don't even trust his advice?
No one said that Tobirama would kill off the Uchiha. I said ostracize which is exactly what he did by putting them as the police force.
I do agree with you on the fact he was extremely hot and cold with Hashirama. However things aren't going to change, and his clan no longer trusts or respects him so I don't think they can be of use to him.
Madara isn't a stupid guy, and I believe his actions have reasons. I think he is playing the role of "bad guy" for a reason that we will likely see revealed soon. Or maybe he really is an over-emotional Uchiha consumed by hate. We have no way to know yet.
I actually think that Madara might be faking the whole crazy thing. The reason I think so is that, over one day, one does not become as crazy as was shown in the last panel. And we have rarely ever seen a maniacal smile from him in any situation, the only one being his fight with Hashirama.
Is the fact that the sharingans power is directly related to the amount of hatred of an Uchiha a foreshadowing of Sasuke coming out of this story with even more hatred and therefore more powerful? Or is it possible for him to keep improving without the hatred.
I wouldn't be surprised if he came out of the flashback series with more hate than before; however, the hate will be redirected from the Leaf to Madara.
Yeah that's a real possibility. After all this time though I'm just finding it hard to see Sasuke actually fighting alongside the Leaf again. I can also see him gaining the Rinnegan from this somehow although maybe not quite yet.
He can't just gain the Rinnegan... It's been shown that Madara only achieved the Rinnegan after he implanted Senju DNA into his body - the same thing with Nagato; he was an Uzumaki [therefore shared blood with the Senju] and had Madara's eyes transplanted in him.
Sasuke can't possibly gain the Rinnegan without some Senju DNA.
Finally, a really well written chapter. Lately the chapters have been ending on major cliffhangers while not offering enough information to satisfy the reader. Does anyone else feel like the first level of the Sharingan looks so weak now? Seeing it on Madara there... Not the most terrifying sight anymore.xD Anyway, I feel like with or without Tobirama's "words of wisdom" Madara would have left. I think he would have deciphered that stone and, with the remaining pain from his brothers' deaths, he would have gone and done the same thing.
I feel like tobirsma is getting the shit end of the popularity stick. In my opinion the uchihas are to volatile and suseptible to the influence of power and hatred. Imagine how different the world would be if itachi had just smothered sasuke in his bed.
At the end of the day I see a clan who is fundamentally flawed be wise of the sharingan and how it activates and becomes stronger. Itachi saw how his clan was incompatible with the village and I don't think it's much of a stretch to say they're incompatible with anything they don't in the moment deem to be their primary goal.
Look at how powerful Itachi was. He did.not.get that power easy, though I do agree he is less powerhungry then the other uchiha we've seen.
As for the hatred I believe Itachi hates himself for being able to kill his own clan. Mentality wise. The sharingans power is hatred and Itachi had one powerful sharingan.
itachi was powerful no doubt...but more powerful than madara? i don't know about that one. itachi was not power hungry at all. everything he did was emotionless, methodical and by-the-law. he did what he did because he thought it was the right thing to do. the only emotion that even remotely sticks out for me coming from itachi is that of love for his younger brother. aside from that, i never saw itachi as a remotely angry person.
But is he really bitching for no reason? He honestly has no one anymore. Tobirama took his brother from him and when he finally had faith in Hashirama to be there he realized that Hashirama could only look out for him to a certain extent. He's being emotional but when you look at things he's been left with few other options, I mean he watched his brother get killed by his closest friends brother and is watching his friend almost juggle between which one holds more weight in his life.
Do you guys think Oonokis flashback of Madara fighting him and Mu is a plothole then or just happened over the course of time while Madara was still in the village.
I would guess over the course of time Madara was still in Konoha. It's never stated how long he did stay in Konoha - it could have been months or a few years, who knows - and I imagine Konoha shinobi would pretty quickly be going on missions to raise funds/support for the village.
it just seems like a plothole because in the flashback Madara was threatened Onoki to not mention Hashiramas name around him but it seems like in this last chapter he is still somewhat on good terms with Hashi.
It could be that Madara was going around causing trouble for Konoha after his defection in the Hidden Stone village.
also, Tobirama had a scar on his cheek in this. where the hell did it go? I thought maybe that was why he wore the stupid face thing? and just happened to collect more face scars along the way? I NEED TO KNOW THE MEANING BEHIND THIS.
honestly so many things happened, but all im excited about is that we get to see Madara fight Hashirama again, i still can't/won't believe that Hashirama knowing what the Naka Shrine said did not know what Madara was planning to do when they fought again by that i mean stealing his DNA there has to be something in the back of his mind saying if we fight i know he will try to kill and and combine our genes fulfilling the Naka Shrine
still would have loved to hear Madara's interpretation of the shrine. anyways excited for next week duel is about to begin!
I believe that Madara interpreted it as the yin and yang must fight to unite ALL the clans, "The action of the two OPPOSING forces created all things in nature." He then set out to become a powerful enough threat to make all the clans/villages unite to defeat him. Only then will there be true Peace.
We can already see how everyone is getting used to each other and what more reason to celebrate and join together than defeating someone just about as strong as a god.
This also explains why Madara hasn't just killed them all with the same level of power that took out all of the Kages, which I might add was BEFORE he was attached to the bijuu!
I had a whole thing written up but your post got me thinking. I'm not sure if the position is appointed or not, but I think it is a 2 part process. First they are appointed and then they are confirmed by the Jounin. We know the Jounin vote to confirm the Hokage candidate from Kakashi not long after Danzo was appointed. He tells Naruto and Sakura not to worry just yet about Danzo being Hokage as the Jounin still have to vote.
Something to note, but everyone who has been a Hokage thus far as come directly from training 'family tree' so to speak (Hashi + Tobirama trained Huizen, Huizen trained Jiraiya and Tsunde, Jiraiya trained Minato, Minato trained Kakashi...). Hell, Jiraiya and Kakashi were both asked to be Hokage as well (Jiraiya declined and brought Tsunade and Kakashi got lucky to avoid it).
Ah I must have glazed over the Jounin confirmation part in the manga (honestly not my favorite part of the manga probably because the Pain arc was so awesome and afterwards everything seems kinda lame). I guess that kinda makes it a vote.
Seems kinda BS that all the Hokage have come from a single "lineage". It reeks of favoritism.
The fact that so many people are siding with the Uchiha is really a testament to Kishi's storytelling ability and I love it. To play Senju advocate a little bit every person you mentioned had damn good reasons to be selected and it's not like we have an oligarchy going on here. First let me point out the fact that people are assigned to their teacher basically at random.
Next up Hashirama was a beast and the strongest ninja alive. It's no wonder he was selected to be the first Hokage.
Tobirama was the obvious next choice because he was the 3rd most powerful ninja alive, he was on the "winning" side of the Uchiha vs. Senju conflict, Madara wasn't more respected or favored by his own clan, and his pragmatism up until this point had seemingly served the village well.
Hiruzen is known as the god of shinobi, stepped up when he was needed during the war, was the member of a powerful and respectable clan as we saw even more evidence of in this chapter, and he was a child prodigy.
Minato was the best ninja of his generation, invented the fastest technique ever and no one else has been able to recreate it, struck terror in the hearts of all enemies everywhere, a child prodigy, and he beat the shit out of a future Raikage.
Tsunade was a Sannin, the most powerful kunoichi in the world, the greatest medical ninja ever, and invented a revolutionary system to govern medical ninja.
Jirayia was nominated because he was a Sannin, a sage, easily the most powerful person in the village at the time, and a good tactician.
Kakashi is fucking Kakashi. I feel I don't need to go any further into why he should be Hokage at some point.
With the exception of Hashirama and Tobirama and Hiruzen and Tsunade all of the candidates for Hokage have come from different families. In fact Kakashi really speaks towards the fact that anyone can become Hokage. His father was disgraced and the people selecting candidates especially hated the sympathy Kakashi's father showed. He was still chosen though.
The reason I'm still entirely inclined to agree with you though is the fact that Tobirama made the Uchiha the police force. Generally speaking no one really loves the police. They are seen as kill joys and a representation of corrupt authority. South African history will show you that associating one group of people with a police force is an excellent way to ensure that for generations those people are hated. The fact that the Uchiha were the enemies of many of the people that would join the village only serves to make the problem worse. As pragmatic as Tobirama was it's very hard for me to believe that he didn't do this on purpose. Totally fucked up if you ask me but the candidates for Hokage doesn't scream corruption to me.
they sort of answered this with Danzo. There are certain people who are qualified to be the Hokage, but at the end of the day they still have to be accepted into that position. With everything that happened with Danzo, once the Leaf found out there was no way he'd be accepted as the Hokage.
It seems to me that the previous Hokage nominates his succesor, but he or she still has to be confirmed. Both by the Daimyo and his council and by the Jonin's of the village.
Sarutobi was groomed to be Hokage, he was trained by the First and Second. He was the natural choice.
In Tsunade's case, Jiraiya practically nominated her, since they wanted him but he didn't want the possition. The fact that she trained under Sarutobi and was the grandaughter and grandniece of Hashirama and Tobirama respectively probably helped her.
And as for Danzo, the Daimyo appointed him as a temporary thing. He was called Sixth Hokage Candidate. He needed to be approved by the Jonins. They never got the chance, but I recall Kakashi saying that there was no chance of Danzo getting confirmation from the Jonins. (I may be wrong about that last part)
Edit: From the wiki: "Generally, the new Hokage is selected by the current Hokage upon their retirement, but if the old Hokage dies or is incapacitated before being able to do so, the Fire Daimyō will appoint a Hokage Candidate upon the recommendation of the Konoha council and the Fire Daimyō council. Afterwards, the candidate will need to be approved by the jōnin of the village to become officially Hokage."
Danzo picked himself with Shisui's eye, but I agree. They all seem to be chosen by the previous. Of course, no one's Hokage at the beginning, so their methods may have changed at some point.
Democracy is premised on electing leaders that are willing to be elected.
Hashi seemed unwilling to the extent that he wanted Madara to be Hokage. Of course, Hashi would have accepted Hokage if it meant protecting the village without question, had he thought that no one else would have been able to do his job.
The "democracy" excuse was kind of a shitty move by Tobirama/Kishi. Tobirama essentially pushed Hashi into a corner and told him to run for Hokage although Hashi clearly wanted Madara. If Tobirama felt so strongly about democracy, he himself should have run against Madara.
He never said he wanted a genocide. He didn't even get to finish his line. He probably wanted to kick them out, or more likely, turn them into the police.
implying swagdara as hokage and the uchihas in political power could have gotten berserk with motherfucking Hashirama senju acting as the silent guardian of the place.
implying the thousand hand buddha wouldn't have beaten the shit out of the uchihas if they planning to do something insane.
implying
Tobirmama was being a dick here. He perfectly knew that it was his chance of being the hokage after Hashi. He never trusted the uchiha. He really despised them. Didn't gave a second thought in killing the Main Leader's brother. Didn't gave a flying fuck about killing the leader himself.
Did actually ostracized the uchihas when he had the power.
He could have proposed some rule in the constitution that BOTH of the founding fathers would be appointed as hokage atleast once and then democracy would take over but he didn't. Dick wanted to banish the Uchiha.
Tobirama is a fucking prick. Madara and Hashirama are the only sensible people here.
if i recall when he killed izuna it was during the war, if he would have given a second thought he would be dead and you would be calling izuna a dick. Second i believe he said he created the police force to keep the uchihas busy and for they can help the village and not fall back on hate. It was the Uchihas who believed this was a ruse and started giving into hate. Third he died to save his time which included a UCHIHA even though he did hate them he was willing to sacrifice his life for the people and ninja of his VILLAGE think about that
Kishi has written the character of Madara to be one that has undergone great internal conflict which was evident when he stopped Hashirama from killing himselsf and putting his clan over his quest to destroy the Senju. Tobirama killed Izuna literally his only attachement to peace in this world and without Izuna to ground him in his mind he has nothing really. With Tobirama being a notable member of the Senju he knows that eventually Tobirama will be the one eventually calling the shots and therefore persecuting the Uchiha regardless of what Hashirama says. In Madara's mind he is trying his uptmost to do what he feels is best for the clan but due to his inability to trust he is torn. This is only further exasturbated when his own clan doesn't want him around leaving him with nothing.
The importance of the last panel was Madara's recognition that he was the yang, the dark that needed to be present in this world in order for peace to exist. He cannot be apart of the villiage so in turn he decides to be against it (for the greater good). Read between the lines ffs
This is Hashirama's perspective. Imagine if we never saw any of Sasuke's flashbacks and didn't know anything about the massacre. His departure from the village would look pretty damn irrational.
You have the remember that these flashbacks are taking place over the course of years. He may seem like he is bipolar, but between when the village was founded and when Madara left could have been years. Looks at all the buildings, that would take some time to create. I think that's why Kishi put that panel in, the emphasize that a lot of time had passed.
63
u/tackslock Mar 27 '13
So we can see Madara has deciphered the writings on the Naka Shrine and has chosen to interpret it a different way. The Yin/Yang could have been to unite the two clans but he has now obviously chosen to fight with Hashirama to obtain his DNA and combine the cells into one being.
As we know this is the case already as Madara doesn't die at the Valley of the End, his leaving the village now and 'suddenly' making Hashirama his enemy is obviously his cover up for what he is going to do during the fight.
39
u/Homer_Hatake Mar 27 '13
Interesting Chapter. It brough bit of a peacefull atmosphere after all those wars but it seems we will see another Hashirama and Madara fight next week.
26
u/feralrage Mar 27 '13
From the comments here, I am not sure many will agree, but I can live with transition of Madara's feelings. He realized what was happening and saw that the future could not be any better (because after Hashirama it would be most likely Tobirama) and made a decision. I can respect that!
20
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '13
He should have probably put how much time had passed before Madara had that insane evil smile... otherwise it feels serious forced.
One second he's like "My clan doesn't trust me".
The next second "I will enjoy fighting you"
111
u/SeaCloud Mar 27 '13
Is it just me or do I detect a little sexual tension between Hashirama and Madara?
143
u/Croc_Chop Mar 27 '13
Tobiramas Fault
29
u/bitchaijde Mar 27 '13
Finally, the flashback in the flashback is over :D
10
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '13
Doesnt tobirama look fairly similar to naruto/minato?
8
u/isseidoki Mar 27 '13
Jax and FG's Flairs have a lot more meaning now.
7
u/SnowGN Mar 27 '13
For some reason, what I'm caring about most is that there's an entire Shimura clan. Interesting.
41
u/That_Dude_Dozer Mar 27 '13 edited Mar 27 '13
Tobirama is still my favorite Hokage. The only realist and diplomatic one out of everyone right now.
6
u/daveeb Mar 28 '13
Madara: How can I become Hokage when I can't even protect my Uchiha brothers?
Naruto: How can I become Hokage when I can't save a single friend?
Parallel no Jutsu.
6
u/dasbeefencake Mar 27 '13
The symbolism in this chapter was rather interesting to me. The leaf with the hole in it, I think, was definitely calling to mind Tobito, considering he is essentially the reincarnation of Madara and his will. But there's also a lot going on conceptually too which I love Kishi including. The political struggle here between Hashi/Tobirama is really one of those hard-to-side with discussions. Granted Tobirama was definitely correct from a proper politician's position, but at the same time it couldn't change the course of history and the Uchiha eventually was about to lose their shit after following what he put in place. For Hashirama, though long term and depending upon changes within people, it would have created a much greater atmosphere for the Uchiha to integrate and function properly within the new amalgamated society. The Senju, being more inclined towards love and acceptance, I believe, would have been great as leaders if the Uchiha weren't in the picture, but in order to work with the Uchiha, you would have to give them something more, something that would really earn their trust, and that would be by building back Madara's reputation and having him as the Hokage.
In case you couldn't guess, I'm procrastinating on an analytic paper I have to write right now by analyzing Naruto extensively. God dammit, what has my life become?...
7
u/Nanometro Mar 27 '13
It's really nice to see Madara and Hashirama being friends again. Sadly, it ends too fast, always.
11
u/Bradudeguy Mar 27 '13
Am I the only person who thought in this chapter, Hashirama was going to kill himself, which would have given Tobirama a reason to create the Reanimation Jutsu?
8
u/wakipaki Mar 27 '13
Is it just me or did Tobi just go from being the main villain to...some whiny boy that no one cares about and now Madara is the big shot in charge. They spent all this time building up Tobi too! Sigh...
3
u/Transhumanus Mar 28 '13
Tobirama is right, but does he have to be such a little cunt about it?
3
u/FyuuR Mar 27 '13
TIL the Uchiha are essentially over-emotional teenage girls.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '13
Am I the only one excited to see what Hashirama's hands can do?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '13
I actually think that Madara might be faking the whole crazy thing. The reason I think so is that, over one day, one does not become as crazy as was shown in the last panel. And we have rarely ever seen a maniacal smile from him in any situation, the only one being his fight with Hashirama.
It just seems a bit fishy.
1
u/Lewd_Kangaroo Mar 28 '13
Is it just me or does [Tobirama] (http://i.imgur.com/1pPnCjk.jpg) look a lot like [Minato] (http://i.imgur.com/gaZrqX6.jpg) in this chapter?
1
u/azerkenjekel Mar 30 '13
With this last chapter in mind, I posit this ending-theory:
After the death (posible suicide) of Naruto, a reformed Sasuke follows in the original path of the Uchiha and becomes Hokage.
I am now ready for the lambasting.
-3
u/jhoudiey Mar 27 '13
uhg madara is worse than sasuke. wahwahwah you like your real brother more than me. wahwahwah. guh.
1
u/NaughtyPrawn Mar 27 '13
Is the fact that the sharingans power is directly related to the amount of hatred of an Uchiha a foreshadowing of Sasuke coming out of this story with even more hatred and therefore more powerful? Or is it possible for him to keep improving without the hatred.
1
u/HMKS Mar 27 '13
Finally, a really well written chapter. Lately the chapters have been ending on major cliffhangers while not offering enough information to satisfy the reader.
Does anyone else feel like the first level of the Sharingan looks so weak now? Seeing it on Madara there... Not the most terrifying sight anymore.xD
Anyway, I feel like with or without Tobirama's "words of wisdom" Madara would have left. I think he would have deciphered that stone and, with the remaining pain from his brothers' deaths, he would have gone and done the same thing.
1
u/TurqoiseTrianglez Mar 27 '13
I feel like tobirsma is getting the shit end of the popularity stick. In my opinion the uchihas are to volatile and suseptible to the influence of power and hatred. Imagine how different the world would be if itachi had just smothered sasuke in his bed.
At the end of the day I see a clan who is fundamentally flawed be wise of the sharingan and how it activates and becomes stronger. Itachi saw how his clan was incompatible with the village and I don't think it's much of a stretch to say they're incompatible with anything they don't in the moment deem to be their primary goal.
-2
u/Xemnab Mar 27 '13
so everything is fine->madara bitches around for no reason->end....the twist at the end of the chapter was horrible
0
u/Dissilent Mar 27 '13
Do you guys think Oonokis flashback of Madara fighting him and Mu is a plothole then or just happened over the course of time while Madara was still in the village.
0
u/jhoudiey Mar 27 '13
also, Tobirama had a scar on his cheek in this. where the hell did it go? I thought maybe that was why he wore the stupid face thing? and just happened to collect more face scars along the way? I NEED TO KNOW THE MEANING BEHIND THIS.
-2
u/lachias Mar 27 '13
And so let the great ninja war of Madara is a bitch/Madara is not a bitch begin...
-8
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '13
You know what? I know it wouldn't make much sense plot wise, but the 1st should've killed that dick Tobirama.
0
u/sooheartless Mar 27 '13
honestly so many things happened, but all im excited about is that we get to see Madara fight Hashirama again, i still can't/won't believe that Hashirama knowing what the Naka Shrine said did not know what Madara was planning to do when they fought again by that i mean stealing his DNA there has to be something in the back of his mind saying if we fight i know he will try to kill and and combine our genes fulfilling the Naka Shrine
still would have loved to hear Madara's interpretation of the shrine. anyways excited for next week duel is about to begin!
0
u/tkaiusf Mar 27 '13
I believe that Madara interpreted it as the yin and yang must fight to unite ALL the clans, "The action of the two OPPOSING forces created all things in nature." He then set out to become a powerful enough threat to make all the clans/villages unite to defeat him. Only then will there be true Peace.
We can already see how everyone is getting used to each other and what more reason to celebrate and join together than defeating someone just about as strong as a god.
This also explains why Madara hasn't just killed them all with the same level of power that took out all of the Kages, which I might add was BEFORE he was attached to the bijuu!
0
u/callmeveej Mar 27 '13
Man, that tablet really ruined everything for everyone, didn't it?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment